Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

4 year old travelling - dummy

134 replies

AmySma1i · 17/10/2022 16:03

Hi all,

Hope you're all well!

My 4 year old DD hates travelling and gets super upset when in the back of the car, we've tried many different distractions, but the only thing that reasonably calms her is her dummy ( she has it for bedtime as well). We visited grandparents this weekend and they immediately berated me for letting her have it in the car, but she'd be distraught travelling without. Should I be ditching this for car journeys or will she feel calmer over time or am I being unreasonable in seeing no issue with this as it makes her happier?

Currently it isn't damaging her teeth or speech otherwise I'd definitely consider

OP posts:
Ohwellwhateverthen · 17/10/2022 20:09

AmySma1i · 17/10/2022 19:59

I was surprised by this, she's growing up but she's still in that delicate age where she really needs all the support at times. She is a total daddy's girl though

I think needing a dummy or to hold someone's hand in the car is indicative of some sort of issue. What's the problem with driving? Is she anxious, has she been in the car while there was an accident?

AmySma1i · 17/10/2022 19:59

NCHammer2022 · 17/10/2022 19:35

What the heck is wrong with holding her dad’s hand in the car? I often hold DH’s hand if we’re on the bus or something and I’m 36!

I was surprised by this, she's growing up but she's still in that delicate age where she really needs all the support at times. She is a total daddy's girl though

OP posts:
AmySma1i · 17/10/2022 19:47

miltonj · 17/10/2022 19:44

I don't think it's too old if it's just for comfort situations and at night. Not great for running round the park etc but I'm guessing she's not doing that!

Thank you, did you have kids who used them at this age?

OP posts:
AmySma1i · 17/10/2022 19:46

luckylavender · 17/10/2022 19:40

This is another one of these threads. Everyone - dummies shouldn't be used at 4.5 (honestly this is very well known). OP - every comment - doesn't really agree. Why ask a question if you don't like the answer?

I think I've been quite agreeable? On balance I think we'll be doing the dummy fairy in the next few weeks, but there's been quite a few comments of other parents with 4yo in dummies. I'm trying to make a balanced opinion based on the wide range of experiences and views and it seems that although quite a few 4yo have them I should be getting rid soon .

I think the only thing I've disagreed on were the oral hygiene, I'm aware the issues dummies can cause and I'm being vigilant of it, I'm not giving my daughter a life with improper speech or crooked teeth

OP posts:
miltonj · 17/10/2022 19:44

I don't think it's too old if it's just for comfort situations and at night. Not great for running round the park etc but I'm guessing she's not doing that!

luckylavender · 17/10/2022 19:40

This is another one of these threads. Everyone - dummies shouldn't be used at 4.5 (honestly this is very well known). OP - every comment - doesn't really agree. Why ask a question if you don't like the answer?

Simonjt · 17/10/2022 19:38

MakeWayMoana · 17/10/2022 19:32

@Simonjt no judgement from me because he’s not sucking it, but doesn’t it concern you how his peers will view his holding a dummy at sleepovers etc? My son’s 6 and went on his first beaver camp last weekend - all the children took a teddy, there was even advice sent out about how they would discreetly manage children still in pull-ups, but there wasn’t any children with a dummy and I think my son would’ve thought it weird if there was.

He’s only seven, so he doesn’t go to sleepovers, and no, if he did I wouldn’t be worried, we do things we like, not things other people want us to do.

NCHammer2022 · 17/10/2022 19:35

What the heck is wrong with holding her dad’s hand in the car? I often hold DH’s hand if we’re on the bus or something and I’m 36!

MakeWayMoana · 17/10/2022 19:32

@Simonjt no judgement from me because he’s not sucking it, but doesn’t it concern you how his peers will view his holding a dummy at sleepovers etc? My son’s 6 and went on his first beaver camp last weekend - all the children took a teddy, there was even advice sent out about how they would discreetly manage children still in pull-ups, but there wasn’t any children with a dummy and I think my son would’ve thought it weird if there was.

Simonjt · 17/10/2022 19:30

AmySma1i · 17/10/2022 19:28

Bless him, did he still have it at bedtime when he was four or does he still have it at bedtime now great to hear it doesn't affect him

Hes never really used it at bedtime, even as a toddler, he prefers going to sleep holding something.

MakeWayMoana · 17/10/2022 19:28

She’s definitely old enough for understanding. Just tell her that she’s too big for a dummy now because it will hurt her teeth as she gets bigger, so shall we throw them away and go to Smyths and choose and nice new bedtime teddy.

My daughter who’s 3 got a scruffalove for Christmas last year which she has been attached to at bedtime ever since - it’s a good one to get because it’s an activity, can go in the bath etc too.

Also you’ve said you don’t allow the dummy to cause issues with teeth because of oral hygiene - it’s not about cleanliness, it’s about the alignment of her teeth being affected by the constant sucking motion.

AmySma1i · 17/10/2022 19:28

Simonjt · 17/10/2022 19:26

He’s seven

Bless him, did he still have it at bedtime when he was four or does he still have it at bedtime now great to hear it doesn't affect him

OP posts:
Simonjt · 17/10/2022 19:26

AmySma1i · 17/10/2022 19:25

How old is he? Is he the same age as my daughter?

He’s seven

AmySma1i · 17/10/2022 19:25

Simonjt · 17/10/2022 19:23

Mine son still has a dummy, he uses it as a dummy when hes unwell, otherwise he tends to hold it like you would a teddy bear. His teeth, palate etc are fine, as is his speech.

How old is he? Is he the same age as my daughter?

OP posts:
Simonjt · 17/10/2022 19:23

Mine son still has a dummy, he uses it as a dummy when hes unwell, otherwise he tends to hold it like you would a teddy bear. His teeth, palate etc are fine, as is his speech.

AmySma1i · 17/10/2022 19:12

CheezePleeze · 17/10/2022 19:09

How long did you try for?

We did three days but she was getting so tired from crying and staying up as we tried not to over comfort and chance the dependency to us. it was affecting learning and other areas just for the dummy at bedtime and sleep so we gave it back, ideally knowing this we should've done it over summer

OP posts:
CheezePleeze · 17/10/2022 19:09

AmySma1i · 17/10/2022 18:55

I'm definitely anxious to do it in case she wasn't ready, but when we tried first time it was constant quiet crying and not performative and it told us she wasn't ready, but maybe should have tried longer

How long did you try for?

AmySma1i · 17/10/2022 19:08

OperaStation · 17/10/2022 18:58

That’s really not ideal. It will be damaging her teeth.

We're very careful to make sure this doesn't happen and give her good dental hygiene at all times, we're very aware and careful for her

OP posts:
asdasult · 17/10/2022 19:03

@Lucyccfc68 speech was never impaired, nor were teeth damaged.

It was the only comfort item they ever had.

Sibling had a cuddly teddy and sucked thumb when tired well into big school. They might still. I don't know, they're an adult now.

How do you stop a child sucking their thumb?

As I explained, my child had medical issues and the dummy was their only comfort. Perhaps you missed that.

Riapia · 17/10/2022 19:01

“Berated me “ = “Oh. does she still have her dummy.”

Lucyccfc68 · 17/10/2022 19:01

asdasult · 17/10/2022 18:46

All those saying no dummy past 1 - did you take away comfort toys and teddies at 1 too? My child literally never had a cuddly toy - the dummy was their comfort item.

Comfort toys and teddy’s don’t damage teeth or impede speech.

OperaStation · 17/10/2022 18:58

AmySma1i · 17/10/2022 16:38

We currently give it to her after bathtime and she settles with it during story time and snuggles, and she had it in her mouth throughout the night, we take it off of her about 20 mins after she wakes up.

Should we try to take it out when she's asleep?

That’s really not ideal. It will be damaging her teeth.

AmySma1i · 17/10/2022 18:55

CheezePleeze · 17/10/2022 18:50

But you know there's every chance it could, so why not prevent it?

Honestly, sometimes the parents are more nervous of this sort of thing than the children.

I'm definitely anxious to do it in case she wasn't ready, but when we tried first time it was constant quiet crying and not performative and it told us she wasn't ready, but maybe should have tried longer

OP posts:
AmySma1i · 17/10/2022 18:53

BeanieTeen · 17/10/2022 18:49

At age four - with no SEN or logical reasons for this behaviour - I’d either set up a reward for sitting in the car nicely, and also set a clear consequence for causing such a nuisance. Dummies and handholding?? Sounds like you’re being played for a fool here OP.

I hadn't considered it like that I'm surprised it would just be for the car if she was playing us... generally she's quite independent

OP posts:
CheezePleeze · 17/10/2022 18:50

AmySma1i · 17/10/2022 18:47

If it ever showed any signs of affecting speech or the mouth we'd have got rid 100%

But you know there's every chance it could, so why not prevent it?

Honestly, sometimes the parents are more nervous of this sort of thing than the children.

Swipe left for the next trending thread