Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be bloody pissed off that school are annoyed that my son can't breathe?

239 replies

Mrsweasleysclock · 17/10/2022 15:25

DS suffers from asthma. It has been a struggle to get it under control and this time of year always comes with a flare up. He has been breathless and coughing with chest tightness for a week now, hasn't been in school in this time. We've had to take him to the hospital twice, once by ambulance as he couldn't catch his breath for an hour so called 999. I have kept in touch with the school everyday giving them updates.

This morning I get a letter about his poor attendance and threatening further action if his attendance doesn't improve.

I am fuming. I understand they have attendance standards to keep but surely if you were concerned you could have had a chat with me any time when I was in dropping/collecting DD. Or even act like you care about his health rather than making it seem like I just haven't bloody bothered to bring him to school.

So mumsnet, talk me down because I feel like going to war over this with the school.

Yabu: the school have procedures to follow

Yanbu: they could have discussed his health/attendance informally first before going down the formal route of sending a letter threatening action.

OP posts:
Schulte · 17/10/2022 19:02

Mrsweasleysclock · 17/10/2022 18:59

Thank you for all the well wishes. I feel so sad for him. He asks me all the time "why do I have to have asthma, mummy?" It honestly breaks my heart. He's such a sweet boy, and he really likes school.

💐

Basilandparsleyandmint · 17/10/2022 19:01

Yes of course with our monthly attendance meetings or the school admin looks who k ow the children very well.

Schulte · 17/10/2022 19:01

I’ve been in exactly the same position so I feel for you. I have a feeling these letters may get sent out automatically. What I did was phone the office (who were very understanding) and they simply asked me to bring in something from the GP confirming DD’s asthma flare ups. GP printed off two pages that showed all our trips to out of hours, A&E etc. No more questions asked.

Her class then made her a very sweet get well soon card.

I hope your DS improves very soon. It’s so hard.

Mrsweasleysclock · 17/10/2022 18:59

Thank you for all the well wishes. I feel so sad for him. He asks me all the time "why do I have to have asthma, mummy?" It honestly breaks my heart. He's such a sweet boy, and he really likes school.

OP posts:
CurlyhairedAssassin · 17/10/2022 18:59

Basilandparsleyandmint · 17/10/2022 18:57

Schools just can’t win can they. As someone who works in a school we have to monitor why a child isn’t it. Safeguarding and all that. Yes generally a head teacher gets to see letters of attendance concerns and pull out the historic children of long term health issues. However occasionally they get missed.
we have a job to do, parent have a role to play. Let’s not get too aggy about this. If it’s a mistake, school will generally acknowledge that.

Wow, really - your head has time to sit and do that?

CurlyhairedAssassin · 17/10/2022 18:58

Is there any evidence that confrontational letters sent indiscriminately have an impact on attendance?

Well in my own school, then, yes, in some cases where a parent tends to keep the child off at the drop of a hat, the letters seem to have resulted in an improvement to that child's attendance. Local authorities can and will, quite rightly, fine if there is no good reason for persistent absence. Schools will let them know the people in this category, and those parents know that without medical evidence they are are risk of a fine, so in some families, yes, the letters do have an effect. I mean, if your child has a genuine illness or medical condition there is usually some evidence for this, and if you are engaging in dialogue with the school regularly about it, there is nothing to worry about.

Basilandparsleyandmint · 17/10/2022 18:57

Schools just can’t win can they. As someone who works in a school we have to monitor why a child isn’t it. Safeguarding and all that. Yes generally a head teacher gets to see letters of attendance concerns and pull out the historic children of long term health issues. However occasionally they get missed.
we have a job to do, parent have a role to play. Let’s not get too aggy about this. If it’s a mistake, school will generally acknowledge that.

FourTeaFallOut · 17/10/2022 18:56

I hate this system that forces the hand of schools to behave like this. It unnecessarily engenders an adversarial relationship between the school and the parents who actually care deeply about both the health and education of their children and resent the accusation that they are failing their kids.

Who is winning with this - in the history of all these crappy letters has even one of the shitty parents -who they supposedly address - actually changed their behaviour and attendance of their children as a result of it?

ilovesushi · 17/10/2022 18:54

For everyone saying there is no time to look at factors behind attendance in schools, I can't believe that to be true! So rather than look at individual cases and offer support where needed and strategies to get the kids back in school, better to send out a one-size fits none letter. It is box ticking and nothing more. I work in HE where attendance is not mandatory, but I can assure you we monitor every single student and reach out when we don't see them. We have a lot of students!

Mooshroo · 17/10/2022 18:54

I’m mid 30s now but remember my Mum having the same problem

EmmaDilemma5 · 17/10/2022 18:54

Small schools tend to be the most understaffed due to less funding. Managing attendance is hard work so it will likely just be a template letter you received.

If I was you, I would email the head, asking if there's anything beyond what you're already doing that she'd like. She'll likely apologise and say it's a template.

YANBU though, I can imagine it feels pretty crap to receive that when you're already anxious and worrying. I hope your son recovers soon.

JassyRadlett · 17/10/2022 18:51

Blahdeebla · 17/10/2022 17:19

This doesn't matter. They have to notify parents when their child's attendance hits a certain level. As he isn't better yet you won't have had the chance to show any medical evidence yet either (another thing they have to ask for). In our school an attendance officer comes in once every few weeks and does these letters and no she doesn't read why the children are off, she looks at their attendance data and that's it.

Which is a terrible, thoughtless process.

Is there any evidence that confrontational letters sent indiscriminately have an impact on attendance?

CurlyhairedAssassin · 17/10/2022 18:49

threegoodthings · 17/10/2022 16:50

Sending those kind of letters to a parent in the OP's situation is the very opposite of hardworking and caring. It's lazy and thoughtless.

Ah unforunately it's most probably nothing to do with being "lazy and thoughtless". It will simply be down to lack of time and resources to dedicate to doing it as it should be done. How wonderful it would be if the people in charge of attendance in schools could sit down and go thorough every case of a low percentage attendance. They would love to allocate the proper time to that if they had it, for the receptionist to sit down with the SLT attendance lead and discuss individual cases. But as much as they'd like to be able to do that, school staff just fly through the day, doing things ultra fast, and while they may be able to quickly take out the pupils they know who have longterm illness or health conditions, they won't always catch everyone before the letter is sent out.

Prescottdanni123 · 17/10/2022 18:47

It may well be automated, but parents that are genuinely ill should not be bothered by snotty letters about attendance at this time, especially in OP's case where her child was so poorly he ended up going to hospital via ambulance. Attendance needs to be monitored but the system needs changing.

Isaidnoalready · 17/10/2022 18:40

I had a congratulations your child is currently on 100% attendance then it went into all the details of discipline and the knock on effect of absence with education and all the steps they would take for unauthorised absence....can I just point out again my son has 100% attendance? What's the noise for ffs this is probably his first 100% just move on to people actually skiving school

happy66 · 17/10/2022 18:37

CurlyhairedAssassin · 17/10/2022 18:33

But the DfE DOES expect schools to monitor attendance, and act on persistent absenteeism, and be able to prove to them that they are doing something about it.
What do you expect schools to do?
I work in an infant school so it's an age group that is often genuinely sick.
But national and local guidelines means that we have to send out these bloody letters anyway.
You can read for yourself, and by the way this is just a short summary, the actual document is huge this year:

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1073619/Summary_table_of_responsibilities_for_school_attendance.pdf

Page 9 and 11 will be of particular interest.

Schools are stuck between a rock and a hard place. They have to be seen to be doing something about low attendance, because they are told they must. They have to be seen as having the same expectations of attendance for those with medical conditions as with other pupils, which seems ludicrous to me. No LA would fine for absence due to a genuine medical condition but the expectation is that they should all have the same opportunities to attend school as a person without any health conditions yadda yadda. It's all very worthy, but in practice? Hmmmm...

You'll notice that through that document is an expectation that parents must work with the school, and if they have a medical condition or SEN to help them understand the barriers to their child's attendance. It's better all round if, rather than getting all uppity and defensive, you simply work with the school and have genuine dialogue with them. They don't want your child attending when they're genuinely ill any more than you do. Sometimes these letters almost feel accusatory, but try not to see them that way, particularly this time of year when all it takes is one or two days or illness and your child is already in danger of becoming a persistent absentee, simply because of the way percentages work over a short space of time!

For every parent who does their best to follow the guidelines and send their "a bit under the weather but will manage" child into school dosed up on Calpol, there is another who lets their child stay off at the drop of a hat, with no good reason. The latter are who schools are trying to pick up with these policies.
If you engage with the school, have proper dialogue with them, keep them up to date on any health issues and GP visits/medication etc, state that you're worried about getting an attendance letter but you're unsure what approach to take etc etc, then school will see that as doing your best to comply with the policy. They can make suggestions on how to improve the attendance eg suggest you send them in anyway, and if they are miserable and unable to concentrate or are very sleepy etc they will call you to collect them. Or maybe if they have a sleep in the morning and seem better for the afternoon session, send them in for the afternoon, as that will be one session marked in. It's all about compromise. Meet them half way and they'll do the same with you. Ask THEM for advice on what you can do.

I can not see on this document where it says specifically that: schools must write to parents of children who have explained absences due to a health condition.

I personally would a write a complaint letter to the headteacher. And I would expect never to receive one of those letters again!

SquashesPumpkinsAutumnBliss · 17/10/2022 18:36

The worst was a child who got knocked down on the way to school - they got an absence letter despite the fact they were in hospital and needed major surgery, then part-time hours due to physical injuries sustained!!

SquashesPumpkinsAutumnBliss · 17/10/2022 18:35

It is beyond infuriating.

one of children had such a letter. However, he had multiple hospital appointments, due to a medical issue which also kept him off school at his worst, which they counted as absence as he did not get in until 10.30 - so they counted it as a half-day absence. I felt like asking the school to fund private medical care so it could be in the school holidays - as NHS never were!! Plus he had to have surgery - necessary, but still an absence. Then post the letter there was a sickness bug going round the school and they were phoning parents to collect children. I asked them if they really wanted me to get him, as they were very keen to send letters about improving absence and I was happy for them to keep him ( said very much tongue in cheek!!!) Then they would not let him back for 48 hours, despite the fact he was only sick on day 1.

thankfully the surgery did the job and they no longer have poor absences.

Mrsweasleysclock · 17/10/2022 18:33

CentralLondonLife · 17/10/2022 18:29

That’s a larger than average primary school

45 students is 1 and a half classes per year group. The average where I am is 3 classes per year group.

OP posts:
CurlyhairedAssassin · 17/10/2022 18:33

But the DfE DOES expect schools to monitor attendance, and act on persistent absenteeism, and be able to prove to them that they are doing something about it.
What do you expect schools to do?
I work in an infant school so it's an age group that is often genuinely sick.
But national and local guidelines means that we have to send out these bloody letters anyway.
You can read for yourself, and by the way this is just a short summary, the actual document is huge this year:

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1073619/Summary_table_of_responsibilities_for_school_attendance.pdf

Page 9 and 11 will be of particular interest.

Schools are stuck between a rock and a hard place. They have to be seen to be doing something about low attendance, because they are told they must. They have to be seen as having the same expectations of attendance for those with medical conditions as with other pupils, which seems ludicrous to me. No LA would fine for absence due to a genuine medical condition but the expectation is that they should all have the same opportunities to attend school as a person without any health conditions yadda yadda. It's all very worthy, but in practice? Hmmmm...

You'll notice that through that document is an expectation that parents must work with the school, and if they have a medical condition or SEN to help them understand the barriers to their child's attendance. It's better all round if, rather than getting all uppity and defensive, you simply work with the school and have genuine dialogue with them. They don't want your child attending when they're genuinely ill any more than you do. Sometimes these letters almost feel accusatory, but try not to see them that way, particularly this time of year when all it takes is one or two days or illness and your child is already in danger of becoming a persistent absentee, simply because of the way percentages work over a short space of time!

For every parent who does their best to follow the guidelines and send their "a bit under the weather but will manage" child into school dosed up on Calpol, there is another who lets their child stay off at the drop of a hat, with no good reason. The latter are who schools are trying to pick up with these policies.
If you engage with the school, have proper dialogue with them, keep them up to date on any health issues and GP visits/medication etc, state that you're worried about getting an attendance letter but you're unsure what approach to take etc etc, then school will see that as doing your best to comply with the policy. They can make suggestions on how to improve the attendance eg suggest you send them in anyway, and if they are miserable and unable to concentrate or are very sleepy etc they will call you to collect them. Or maybe if they have a sleep in the morning and seem better for the afternoon session, send them in for the afternoon, as that will be one session marked in. It's all about compromise. Meet them half way and they'll do the same with you. Ask THEM for advice on what you can do.

happy66 · 17/10/2022 18:31

YANBU. I would write a complaint letter to the head teacher if it was me to get it off my chest.

CentralLondonLife · 17/10/2022 18:29

Mrsweasleysclock · 17/10/2022 17:58

It wasn't the teacher, however the letter is signed off in the head teachers name. It's a very small primary school, 45 students per year.

Once again I understand that it's policy. I just don't think this policy is particularly helpful or the correct way to deal with things. I think it's a horrible way to pile on to parents who are already going through enough with their children.

If I do have a meeting I will be pointing out that as the letter was sent out on behalf of the head teacher, perhaps she might like to discuss rewording it.

That’s a larger than average primary school

KeepOutingMyselfAnotherNameChange · 17/10/2022 18:26

I got one of those letters when my son had major surgery which had a 6 week recovery. I was fuming too. Told them it was insulting as they 'urged me to get him to improve his attendance'

Ginqueen456 · 17/10/2022 18:23

I hate these letters they are pointless when it comes to cases like yours. My daughter received 2 last year (never had one previously)because she had 2 periods of sickness which lasted a week and then a few half days where she was sent home by the school for non existent temperatures, no word of a lie they would send her home with a temperature of 37.2!! I hit the roof when I got the letters.

poormanspombears · 17/10/2022 18:22

The schools absence system should have certain letters for a variety of reasons; ours for example uses M for medical and as long as it can be evidenced- text, letter, admittance paperwork- it counts as authorised absence.

Your school attendance officer sounds like they could have stopped that letter.

I would raise it with the head and if not, via governors.

Swipe left for the next trending thread