Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Driving my car if 'Psych says not insured' ?

35 replies

medianewbie · 17/10/2022 14:50

ExH lives 8m away. We're rural. 2 disabled kids so (try to!) co-operate re transport. He's still on my insurance policy so he can use my small car when needed re kids (ages 18 & 15)
Now, ExH suffers from Depression. Currently signed off (last 6+wks) & on 200mcg Sertraline. Not his fault obvs.

He's arranged to use the car tonight (inc giving a lift to15 y/it's friend). Only he's just said that his Psychiatrist says he isn't insured to drive atm due to 'concentration issues'. So, I've said NO.

Apparently I'm 'being unreasonable'.
Apart from not having kids in car, I don't want him using it alone. Surely that's correct in the circumstances?? (obvs I
only have his word on Psych comment)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Beautiful3 · 17/10/2022 19:32

If there's an accident, his insurance won't be valid and won't pay out. Its not worth it.

IWillBeWaxingAnOwl · 17/10/2022 19:12

If his psychiatrist has told him he cannot drive, his insurance would be invalidated if he did and had an accident. As they prescribed medicine, they will be a psychiatrist not psychologist.

NumberTheory · 17/10/2022 19:04

Jalepenojello · 17/10/2022 18:36

Technically I think if you drove against the advice of your doctor your insurance can be void but I’ve never heard of this occurring for depression with ssri’s before as this is extremely common scenario/medication. I think he need clarification from his doctor.

SSRIs being common is irrelevant, they aren’t the problem. Severe depression is a known cause of concentration and memory problems that can make someone unfit to drive. If the drugs aren’t working to alleviate the depression enough, then the concentration problems can still be too severe for driving to be safe.

It’s one of the more common mental health issues that impact people’s ability to drive and is specifically covered on MIND’s website section on the right to drive with mental health issues:
www.mind.org.uk/information-support/legal-rights/fitness-to-drive/my-right-to-drive/

OP’s ex may or may not need clarification, he doesn’t have to give OP all the details his doctor gives him, he can be vague if he wants a bit of privacy around it or if he’s finding it hard to accept. OP still needs to make the best decisions she can with the information she has.

NumberTheory · 17/10/2022 18:44

medianewbie · 17/10/2022 17:25

Thanks, this is helpful.
I've texted him to ask bluntly (we had an argument yesterday about it) & he says 'it's because his concentration is poor' so it sounds as though he definitely wouldn't be covered legally temporarily even though he's not 'lost his licence'.

What I'm not clear about is whether I'd be legally exposed if he had an accident in his own car (I'd hope he's not daft enough to drive it anyway, but..) if he is still named on MY policy (sorry if being dense, its been a long day already today)

Check your insurance, it may say you have to inform them if a named driver is told they musn’t drive for health reasons. But generally, if your insurance only covers him in your car and you aren’t letting him drive that, you wont be liable as there is nothing you can control.

CanopusMind · 17/10/2022 18:38

@Jalepenojello It's common - I suspect there's more to the story, but it does commonly happen. Anyone under the Crisis Team for instance should not be allowed to drive (it's a bit hit and miss which Crisis Teams tell you and which don't though)...

Jalepenojello · 17/10/2022 18:36

Technically I think if you drove against the advice of your doctor your insurance can be void but I’ve never heard of this occurring for depression with ssri’s before as this is extremely common scenario/medication. I think he need clarification from his doctor.

forrestgreen · 17/10/2022 18:33

Why is he on your policy?

CanopusMind · 17/10/2022 17:41

Does your policy cover his car?

If so, then yes you would have an issue.

If not, then you won't have an issue - as he he would be driving on his own insurance. If he doesn't have his own insurance you need to cancel him on your policy immediately. And notify him in writing you have done so.

x2boys · 17/10/2022 17:31

I used to be a mental health nurse, obviously the Psychiatrist can't cancel your ex ,s insurance ,but i have known some write to rhe DVLA to inform them they don't feel a particular patient is fit to drive ,because of they have had a breakdown in their mental health.for a period of time

medianewbie · 17/10/2022 17:25

Thanks, this is helpful.
I've texted him to ask bluntly (we had an argument yesterday about it) & he says 'it's because his concentration is poor' so it sounds as though he definitely wouldn't be covered legally temporarily even though he's not 'lost his licence'.

What I'm not clear about is whether I'd be legally exposed if he had an accident in his own car (I'd hope he's not daft enough to drive it anyway, but..) if he is still named on MY policy (sorry if being dense, its been a long day already today)

OP posts:
Shanksponyorbust · 17/10/2022 16:55

I mean if he took the car and had an accident your insurance would be invalid.

Shanksponyorbust · 17/10/2022 16:54

The dvla website gives guidance for anxiety & depression and driving. www.gov.uk/guidance/psychiatric-disorders-assessing-fitness-to-drive

Basically without concentration issues he’s ok to drive but with concentration issues he cannot drive and must notify dvla. Your insurance would be invalid as it means there’s an increased risk of accident. Stick to your “no” decision, it’s the right one,

WiddlinDiddlin · 17/10/2022 16:52

It is more likely, like this.

His medical records now show he has been advised not to drive - his work have been told he's advised not to drive hence, off work.

So if there's an accident when he is driving, the insurance company might well discover this and then he wouldn't be covered.

But being told not to drive for a while and your medical records reflecting you've been advised not to drive does not mean the DVLA have been informed and you have to return your licence (it is usually on you to do this unless a HCP believes theres a strong chance you will not do so AND will drive whilst advised not to). So he wouldn't flag up on a police system as uninsured automatically.

CanopusMind · 17/10/2022 16:40

He may have also expressed risk related to driving ie. "I feel like I want to drive the car into a wall", this is the other situation that this happens in. Or it could just be that he is cognitively not functioning well enough to drive.

What he does in his own car and his own insurance is his decisions, but do not let your kids get into a car with him, and I would report him if you know he is driving.

medianewbie · 17/10/2022 16:37

@OneTC. Probably yes ?
Hes been signed off with Depression frequently through our marriage. Bus driver all that time but always driven socially even when signed off as only ever been on antidepressants so I've never formally taken him off my insurance.
Now he's suddenly saying he's seeing a Psychiatrist (poss a Psychologist, he's 'not sure') & been told not to drive (some weeks back apparently ...
but still only on antidepressants)
As for 'what do I want from this thread'- I think i'm just trying to puzzle it out?

We're Divorcing (it's taken ages but he now has the Draft to sign which isn't happening so far). I'm sympathetic but it all seems a bit odd, esp being aggro when I made perfectly sensible comments about not using my car.

I assume if he chooses to drive his own car then the fact he's on my insurance isn't a problem too ?

OP posts:
CanopusMind · 17/10/2022 16:34

If he's been told he cannot drive then it would actually be illegal for him to do so.

It's likely his psychiatrist will have notified the DVLA already that this is the case.

Unfortunately it can be quite rough (understandably) when people have freedom's removed from them but it's really important you stick to your guns on this.

OneTC · 17/10/2022 16:28

Maybe the psychiatrist said something more like "as you're medically disqualified, if you drove, you'd be uninsured"

BerryShots · 17/10/2022 15:37

medianewbie · 17/10/2022 15:19

Yes, just to be clear : he's not driving my kids. Anyone else's kids. Or my car.
I'd just wondered about the way he phrased it. And why he was quite so aggro about my stance when informed.

I imagine if he's under the care of a psychiatrist and has been signed off work, his behaviour might be unusual for him. As you say, it's not his fault he is suffering from depression so maybe, and since you say he's not driving then maybe give him some slack.

I'm not sure what you want from this thread.

Quveas · 17/10/2022 15:32

Aprilx · 17/10/2022 15:11

What you are saying doesn’t make sense. He cannot have his insurance cancelled for health reasons, although he might have a temporary ban on driving for health reasons, which would of course invalidate insurance. But the doctor saying his insurance is cancelled is a very strange way of putting it.

I don't think that's what the psychiatrist said - and it isn't what the OP said either. A doctor can tell you that you are not fit to drive, and advise you how long that impediment may last if they are able to determine that. If you then choose to drive you are likely to find that any insurance you have isn't valid because they will take the view that your were told not to drive. It's very common that this happens - it isn't "cancelling insurance" at all. When I had hip surgery I was told that I wasn't fit to drive for 8 weeks. In actualy fact I was fine and recovered really quickly, but the 8 weeks would have stood except for the fact that the surgeon revised his advice after 4. Had I driven without that happening though, and had an accident, my insurance would have found out that I was advised not to drive and I would have been royally screwed!

BerryShots · 17/10/2022 15:30

Driving under the influence of drink or drugs (prescription or otherwise) is illegal so there's that, and there may also be a clause in your insurance invalidating it if you sit behind the wheel while taking certain drugs.

Was your ex hoping you'd just laugh it off? I am wondering why he told you?

DysmalRadius · 17/10/2022 15:26

It all sounds very weird, but why did he even tell you if he wasn't expecting you to say he couldn't take your car?! Did he think you'd be fine with it?!

WizardOfUK · 17/10/2022 15:22

Ring your insurance company and ask for advice.

medianewbie · 17/10/2022 15:19

Yes, just to be clear : he's not driving my kids. Anyone else's kids. Or my car.
I'd just wondered about the way he phrased it. And why he was quite so aggro about my stance when informed.

OP posts:
uncomfortablydumb53 · 17/10/2022 15:17

Psychiatrist wouldn't have said he's not insured.
They can report to the DVLA if for example a patient is sectioned
They likely told him his judgement/ concentration may be impaired whilst the medication takes effect
It even says on the dispensary label
Do not drive or operate machinery
( speaking as a psychiatrists patient!)

VoiceaFromUranus · 17/10/2022 15:12

Get him off the insurance now. And hope he doesn't have a serious RTC in the meantime because in your car, it's on you.