Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How often do you have fights with your other half?

186 replies

bookworm1982 · 17/10/2022 13:40

I'm talking like shouting in each other's faces. My husband and I have been together for twenty years. We seem to do it a few times a year. Otherwise we get on well. He thinks it's normal. Is it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Miffee · 24/10/2022 10:52

@5foot5

I strongly disagree with this but I guess it does depend on the type of person you are and if it works for you. When it comes to conflict it seems you are either the type of person who agrees with the good blow out theory or you are the type of person who absolutely hates it. If you try to force someone who hates it in to a shouty row then it won't solve anything, just make it worse

After reading the rest of OPs posts and thinking a little bit more about how she phrased the first one I wouldn't have posted that.

You're are right. I don't think blanket statements work. I am comfortable with open conflict and dont have an issue if it turns shouty as is DH. If one of us didn't like it (beyond the normal way nobody likes conflict) it wouldn't be okay.

VickerishAllsort · 20/10/2022 19:01

Together nearly 40 years, and the answer to your question is never.
Why would you want a partner, or why would you want to be the sort of partner, who can't talk reasonably about differences of opinion, compromise where necessary or walk away to cool down if things look like getting heated?

Watsername · 20/10/2022 17:44

Never. Not even raised voices with each other in 22 years. Passive aggressive comments do happen occasionally, though.

Bofthebang · 20/10/2022 16:23

I’ve been with my husband over twenty years and only once in that time have we had a “shouting in each other’s faces” stand up row.

We genuinely rarely argue. Maybe once or twice a year we’ll have a disagreement but that’s honestly it. One of our strengths, I feel, is that we always take each other into consideration, neither of us “needs” to win any disagreements, we’re champions of compromise and, frankly, we love each other too much to want to make the other unhappy!

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 20/10/2022 15:49

Never. We get cross and snappy and argue. But I don't see why people can't get their point across without shouting, it isnt a case of the more someone shouts, the more likely they are to win an argument

Topgub · 20/10/2022 15:46

@ComtesseDeSpair

No they weren't.

Plenty said they never argued and that it wasn't normal to argue

At least 1 suggested no one should ever settle for a relationship with any disagreement

ComtesseDeSpair · 20/10/2022 15:06

Topgub · 20/10/2022 15:03

@SleepingStandingUp

Its devoid of reality to think its the norm to never ever ever disagree or argue.

The vast majority of relationships end in break ups/divorce.

of course people fight.

Of course its not unhealthy to argue in a relationship

That wasn’t what the OP was asking though, was it. She asked how often, and whether it was normal, other people had fights with their OH which involved shouting in each other’s faces. The responses here are answering that specific question, not whether they never ever disagree.

Topgub · 20/10/2022 15:03

@SleepingStandingUp

Its devoid of reality to think its the norm to never ever ever disagree or argue.

The vast majority of relationships end in break ups/divorce.

of course people fight.

Of course its not unhealthy to argue in a relationship

SleepingStandingUp · 20/10/2022 14:48

Topgub · 19/10/2022 10:41

This is the equivalent of a what do you eat thread where everyone eats less that 1500 calories and only quinoa

Utterly devoid of any relation to realty.

It's devoid of reality to think people don't scream in each others faces??

Topgub · 19/10/2022 10:41

This is the equivalent of a what do you eat thread where everyone eats less that 1500 calories and only quinoa

Utterly devoid of any relation to realty.

RedRobyn2021 · 19/10/2022 10:28

To be honest, I can get really mad and have definitely raised my voice/shouted. Not in his face no.

He definitely argues but he's more of a sulky type of angry. I get really mad, then I calm down.

I actually don't like this about myself. It's the thing I like least. I do feel grateful that I am extremely patient with my DD though, I do not shout at her ever.

I'm not sure how often we argue, I do think a lot of our arguments are down to misunderstanding and my having problems controlling how I feel.

Like last night, my DD was ripping my hair out of my head, I asked my DP to please help and it was very painful. He just stood there. I was on the floor trying to pick up some of her toys. And on the third time she grabbed my hair she got the little baby hairs and it really hurt so I shouted "oooowwww" and he said to me "don't be so loud, she right next to you"

And I just got really annoyed. I do so much for him and for her, I always put myself last and to criticise me for shouting out in pain when he wasn't even helping. He just stood there.

Anyway, some people I'm sure that wouldn't have phased them but I was really upset and told him to "f off and not to speak to me unless it was to apologise" then I got up and carried on making us all dinner. Eventually I calmed down and let it go.

housemaus · 19/10/2022 10:15

Couple of times a year, maybe? Not 'in each other's faces' like, getting up close and shouting - that sounds aggressive. But the occasional row where we'll end up yelling. They're always about little things and a sign that we need to (when we're calmer) sit and have a proper heart to heart because there's something else going on underneath.

For example, last week we had a proper row over measuring the space for wardrobes in our bedroom. I said it was one way, he said it was the other, we ended up raising voices and shouting "You don't fucking listen!" / "Fine I won't measure the alcoves then we'll just leave all our clothes on the floor forever" / "Now you're just being childish" etc. I stomped off to the kitchen, he stomped off to the garage.

An hour later when we'd both chilled out we spent a few hours talking about how we're stressed about money at the moment and it's making us both have lower tolerance, how to address things, and to apologise to each other for shouting. I've been worried because of my health and he's been worried about work and we'd been letting it simmer away. It wasn't nice and I don't by any means consider it the best way to communicate - usually we're good at resolving disagreements/concerns calmly - but we're human and sometimes we get communication wrong when we're stressed. What matters to us is recognising when we fuck it up, acknowledging what we did wrong and finding a solution.

TheNoodlesIncident · 19/10/2022 10:06

There's a massive difference between having an argument and having a shouting match or one person shouting into the other's face though. The latter is really unacceptably aggressive.

We'll have differences of opinion where the debate might get a little heated, but still not shouting and never any insults or swearing. I've known DH for over twenty years and have never heard him swear angrily or act aggressively, and I don't either. That would be very disrespectful.

FWIW I don't believe that people should be excused for saying awful things just because they were angry either. Of course they meant it, they wouldn't have said it otherwise...

Haybo26 · 19/10/2022 10:00

Just 2 arguments in 4 years...both his fault obviously

1stTimeMama · 19/10/2022 09:57

We've been together 15 years and have never done this. What on earth are you arguing about that causes this much intimidation on both parts? I'd be reconsidering my choice of husband if he was screaming in my face, or causing me to scream in his.

CoalCraft · 19/10/2022 09:49

Shouting in each other's faces, never. Been together nine years and we've never done this.

I can think of perhaps three or four occasions where one has snapped at the other and then quickly apologised. Otherwise the closest we get is a hard look and a sigh if one is being annoying!

xogossipgirlxo · 19/10/2022 09:44

None now, we had our fair share while we moved in together. Now it works like well-oiled machine, I guess we just talked through all serious stuff and small things don't make us yell at each other.

5foot5 · 19/10/2022 09:25

Been married 35 years and we have never rowed like that. The worst it might ever get is if one of us feels a bit huffy and makes a few irritated comments but even that hardly ever happens and soon blows over.

I honestly couldn't live like that. Neither of us are shouty people and we would both hate that.

Probably the same as you. Its good to have a blow put every once in a while. It's almost always over something trivial, clears the air.
I'm from a very emotional family with lots of loud rowing followed by even louder reconciliation.

I strongly disagree with this but I guess it does depend on the type of person you are and if it works for you. When it comes to conflict it seems you are either the type of person who agrees with the good blow out theory or you are the type of person who absolutely hates it. If you try to force someone who hates it in to a shouty row then it won't solve anything, just make it worse.

Had an ex-SIL who came from a family who believed in a good row to clear the air. PILs on the other hand are the type who are horrified at any type of scene. It didn't end well - note the ex - and they are still NC with their DS after 30+ years as a result.

Fromthedarkside · 19/10/2022 07:43

I can remember dating three particular guys when I was single.

On one occasion with each of them we disagreed about something and they started shouting at me.
Each time I got up and walked away saying "I don't take abuse" and I refused to see them again.
To me shouting is abuse.

LizzieSiddal · 17/10/2022 22:37

ALongHardWinter · Today 21:26
Just waiting for someone to come along and say that if you EVER argue with your partner,then you are in the minority!

Just waiting fir someone to come along and said that if you EVER argue with your partner, you are abusive and should leave the family home immediately.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 17/10/2022 22:09

Never.

Tbf it's down to him, he doesn't like arguing with anyone. He hates conflict.

I am a bit scrappy.

i have had blazing rows in a different relationship but not this one, you can't argue with silence and I know that it effects him whereas I was used to it growing up with 3 sisters, arguing was normalised.

We're together 17 years so doing well.

Slimjimtobe · 17/10/2022 22:05

About once a year. Not in the face but bad enough that it’s painful ( to the heart. )

Hamster1111 · 17/10/2022 22:01

Same as you, a couple of times a year or so I reckon. I'm in particular a 'passionate' person shall we say. It's calmed as we've got older, we've been together 20 years and got together at 20. I find it interesting that some couples never shout. I can't imagine living my life so calmly all the time

Cameleongirl · 17/10/2022 21:57

NumberTheory · 17/10/2022 21:43

I’ve been with my DH for over 30 years and we’ve never shouted at each other. We’re both opinionated (me more so) we’re both a bit stubborn and we have plenty of disagreements. But we’ve never shouted at each other.

I don’t think shouting is necessarily the sign of a bad relationship, though. I grew up in a shouty household. It’s how we were. I don’t think it was a particularly bad way to communicate, providing it doesn’t make anyone scared and it doesn’t drag on. There are worse things I’ve seen in non-shouty households.

I agree, @NumberTheory . Shouty households aren’t necessarily unhappy or abusive , some people find it cathartic to have a rant and then it’s all over.

Tbh, I’d prefer to grow up in an occasionally shouty home than in my DH’s repressed family, where emotions were never shown and anything awkward or unpleasant was ignored/everyone pretended it wasn’t happening. I’d rather have an good argument than be so repressed!

middleofthelittle · 17/10/2022 21:54

@ComtesseDeSpair

I don't shout in my other half's face and we certainly don't scream at each other.
We do argue occasionally as I mentioned in my reply which is resolved quickly.

My question was not snipey in anyway just general curiosity. My mother is in a relationship where she puts up with a lot of crap, mainly because she's become passive.

She would be the first person to state they don't argue so therefore have a great relationship when that clearly isn't the case. She just accepts his shitty behaviour.

She won't be the only woman who is like that, or man. Hence my question about if anyone feels they are passive.