Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to feel like we are being used/tested for money?

117 replies

FailingMum81 · 17/10/2022 10:33

Strap in, I'll try my best to keep it brief but I really want you to see full picture for advice. DD13, makes new friend at school (DD has had lots of friend issues historically and pretty lonely, has wide group of "friends" but more they are a group than actual friends if that makes sense!) anyway, new friend comes along, also had similar issues - great I thought, two girls very similar this could be the new proper friend DD has been looking for. New friend (lets say NF) invites DD to tea and sleepover, yey great start! She then tells her she must bring £10 because her mum has said so.... lots of toing and froing and basically they are having McDs for tea. I tell DD that hers only comes to £3 and so if I send £5 that will be plenty - mum tells NF to say no, she MUST bring £10 to pay for Just Eat delivery charge...ok gets my back up a little but I go with it. We move on to next invite - come to a day out - there are fair rides at this place (couple of pounds each). NF tells DD 'my mum says she doesnt mind taking you but she definitely is not paying for you' followed by 'I have a £15 allowance for the day so she says you have to bring the same'...now Im starting to get a little irked - I cant afford another £15 on top of last weeks £10 and DD not a big ride fan so maybe would only do one or two. I then arrange a halloween gathering for the group including NF - parents told I will provide all food, entertainment, treats and decorations if they bring their own drinks as I have had issues in the past with some not allowed fizzy, some intolerance, colours etc etc - NF comes back with the response 'my mum wants to know why your mum cant provide the drinks too'. I am really struggling with how to keep responding to these demands. I ALWAYS supply everything when DD has sleepovers, parties, friends for tea etc (that doesnt mean I expect everyone to be the same and have no issue at all in DD paying her way - in fact I insist on it) but really not too sure about the attitude and the way this is coming across or how to tackle it. Dont want DD to miss out, and also NF as I dont think its coming from her but I cannot fund these types of extravagance every weekend. From the outset they appear to be a family similar to ours, both working but possibly close to the bone due to cost of living etc - but AIBU to think that they shouldnt be demanding set amounts and DD definitely shouldnt be having to pay delivery charge for their takeaways?

OP posts:
MeridianB · 17/10/2022 12:34

So these ‘host’ parents charged your DD three times the price of her junk food meal, and she had to wait until after 11pm to eat? Surely you know the answer here, OP.

Yupbutnobut · 17/10/2022 12:32

FailingMum81 · 17/10/2022 12:31

Yep exactly that! She literally has hamburger, small fries, small coke - occasionally switches it up to an iced drink/smoothie but very rarely over £3ish mark. She not a huge eater at such as meal times (that being said, McDonalds wasnt ordered until 11pm so she was pretty peckish by then!)

They had dinner at 11pm??? No way would I let my daughter go back there. Weirdos.

Yupbutnobut · 17/10/2022 12:31

FailingMum81 · 17/10/2022 12:29

Thank you all so much for replies so far - just to answer a couple of questions - I have seen all messages exchanged so definitely not DD, she does have her own financial allowance from us for doing little jobs but in these types of scenarios we would give her a little extra but absolutely 100% sure its not her. In regard to handing over the money, she was asked for it on arrival at NFs by parent so know that it went straight to her. NF did tell DD that 'if there is any left over she could have some change' but when DD asked for the change she told her that there wasnt any from her meal. I havent gone straight to NF mum as they are nearing 14 rather than early 13 so I try and let her sort as much as possible herself but they do live a bit of a drive apart so we have to be involved to some extent.

Wtf. Just stop it. A play date should never involve money changing hands unless it's it's day out at a theme park etc and has been agreed by parents discussing it in advance. I would have declined the invitation on your daughters behalf once the cheeky fucker mum had demanded 10 quid for a mcds at their house. Grow a back bone, this is not a good friendship.

FailingMum81 · 17/10/2022 12:31

DidYouFindYourCrumpetHoles · 17/10/2022 12:13

What is your daughter getting from McDonalds that’s only costing £3? Fair enough if she’s ordering a happy meal but you said she’s 13? Or is she ordering a hamburger, small fries and a drink from the saver menu? Not judging at all, just curious as my DS is 10 and his order would come to more than £3 Blush Totally agree you did not need to send £10 Shock I think some people are just tight OP, and usually try to subsidise themselves using others money where possible.

Yep exactly that! She literally has hamburger, small fries, small coke - occasionally switches it up to an iced drink/smoothie but very rarely over £3ish mark. She not a huge eater at such as meal times (that being said, McDonalds wasnt ordered until 11pm so she was pretty peckish by then!)

OP posts:
FailingMum81 · 17/10/2022 12:29

Thank you all so much for replies so far - just to answer a couple of questions - I have seen all messages exchanged so definitely not DD, she does have her own financial allowance from us for doing little jobs but in these types of scenarios we would give her a little extra but absolutely 100% sure its not her. In regard to handing over the money, she was asked for it on arrival at NFs by parent so know that it went straight to her. NF did tell DD that 'if there is any left over she could have some change' but when DD asked for the change she told her that there wasnt any from her meal. I havent gone straight to NF mum as they are nearing 14 rather than early 13 so I try and let her sort as much as possible herself but they do live a bit of a drive apart so we have to be involved to some extent.

OP posts:
MeridianB · 17/10/2022 12:17

Who invites a child for tea and then charges them? No more messages from children - you need to speak to a parent.

Better still, stop op sending DD there - there is something very weird going on.

Aposterhasnoname · 17/10/2022 12:16

I’d be speaking to the mother. It’s years ago but I had similar with my DD, turned out she was making it up to get extra spend out of me

DidYouFindYourCrumpetHoles · 17/10/2022 12:14

@ThrowingSomeCrumbs Cross posted!

DidYouFindYourCrumpetHoles · 17/10/2022 12:13

What is your daughter getting from McDonalds that’s only costing £3? Fair enough if she’s ordering a happy meal but you said she’s 13? Or is she ordering a hamburger, small fries and a drink from the saver menu? Not judging at all, just curious as my DS is 10 and his order would come to more than £3 Blush Totally agree you did not need to send £10 Shock I think some people are just tight OP, and usually try to subsidise themselves using others money where possible.

ThrowingSomeCrumbs · 17/10/2022 12:12

I'm still stuck at the fact you can feed a 13 year old a meal for £3 from McDonalds!!

littleducks · 17/10/2022 12:09

I'm surprised the adults are so involved at 13, do you live very rural or something? I would expect the girls to be making and budgeting for their own plans at that age.

Discovereads · 17/10/2022 12:06

I would try and talk to a NF parent directly.
I don’t think anyone is deliberately being a CF.
I think lots of families are struggling and this sort of counting pennies on both sides and is new territory for some and it’s difficult to navigate especially when using children as messengers.
I think both you and NFs parents are trying to keep a bit of fun in their lives. Nothing wrong with that.

magicscares · 17/10/2022 12:03

Very weird. If the family are finding finances that tricky then I doubt they’d be rushing to order in Take aways & days out 🤷‍♀️.

I wonder if it is NF pulling the strings & taking the dosh for herself?! Definitely sounds like strange behaviour from an adult. Not that money is tight, but the way they are asking for money comes across as grabby.

I can understand why you want to foster new friendships for Dd, however this doesn’t sound like it’s working IMHO.

Caiti19 · 17/10/2022 11:58

This is so crass, and what horrible etiquette for the NF to be learning, assuming the Mother is genuinely making these demands. I wouldn't respond to the drinks question and just give everyone water. Water is nice with salty snacks. I would also only allow your daughter to accept invites that don't come with a price attached. What's that? 10 pound charge? No, tell her thanks, but you can't make it this time. Continue to invite NF over, let them just hang out and do cost-free activities. Serve tea if she's there at tea-time, but something simple and inexpensive. The important thing is that the two girls spend time together. Nuke all this talk of money entirely! This woman is obviously fairly advanced on the cheeky f*ckery scale (you're invited to tea at my house - actually, I want you to pay for a McD's for your daughter and also to subsidies ours), that any communication on this topic needs to leave zero room for response from her. It needs to be a statement "It's so lovely that the girls have developed a great bond. Just wanted to let you know that we won't be able to accept invites to your house anymore that are accompanied by requests for payment. It's just not something I want my daughter exposed to as a social norm. We love having X here, and she is always welcome. Thanks"

Hankunamatata · 17/10/2022 11:51

Well you have the reason why NF has friendship issues

Confusion101 · 17/10/2022 11:44

Next time dropping DD off could you speak with the mum and request her number? Then deal with all communications yourselves instead of through the girls. That way u will quickly figure out if its the DD or the mam and can nip it in the bud.
Also just throwing out all possibilities jot accusing at all, have u seen the msgs? Could your DD be keeping the extra money?

silverclock222 · 17/10/2022 11:25

I think its NF that's taking the money.

britneyisfree · 17/10/2022 11:12

Stop sending your DD there and tell her to invite NF to yours?

RebeccaRose92 · 17/10/2022 11:06

There’s a reason why that girl has issues making friends..

sheepdogdelight · 17/10/2022 11:05

By 13, I'd expect the DC to be more organising this among themselves. If they were having takeaway, I'd expect them to agree what they have and how they split the bill. Similarly, if they are going to the fair they take their own money (as much as they want/can afford).

So I'd personally suggest staying out of this, and letting the girls sort it out between themselves.

Obki · 17/10/2022 11:01

On the McDonalds delivery, I would have given dd £5, £3 for her food and £2 for her contribution to delivery (even thought they're very tight to ask for that).

Bonus points if DD asks them how much is delivery and pays exactly her share. They profited from you and your dd which is terrible.

What happened on the fairground trip? Did dd go?

My tip would be to go to the bank and stock up on £1 coins so that you can give dd however much you want and she can manage her money without giving them a tenner or fiver.

It sounds like these people see you and dd as a soft target and expect more from you than they are willing to give, so start being assertive and help build you dd to be assertive.

OgdensGoneNutFlake · 17/10/2022 10:59

I'd contact the mum, play dumb and say "I'm sure that there's been a miscommunication, I just wanted to check- surely this isn't right?"
Call her out on the cheeky fuckery and embarrass her.

But I'm not very nice!

Pixiedust1234 · 17/10/2022 10:59

Both you and your dd are being taken for a ride. Protect your dd by backing away. If your dd can maintain their friendship without her giving things it will be a miracle, and proves it wasn't a friendship to begin with.

Your poor daughter to find out about cfs this early in life 😥

YouWereGr8InLittleMenstruators · 17/10/2022 10:59

I always communicate directly with DD's friend's parents, she's the same age as yours. Get her friend's mum's number. Next time they decide to do something, say, "Great, I'll just message her mum to confirm." That way neither child needs to be implicated as messengers in what is essentially adult decisions.

Chdjdn · 17/10/2022 10:58

I’d ask for the mums number and speak direct to her; that issue about the fayre could have been solved that way. Personally I’d never invite a child over and expect them to pay for a takeaway; if i couldn’t afford their takeaway then it’d be something like oven pizza which is very cheap.
I understand that with your DDs issues right friendships you don’t want to discourage this one but personally I think I would as it’s not sounding good

Swipe left for the next trending thread