Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Prisoner morality TW

59 replies

scorpiogirly · 16/10/2022 23:41

I've come across this a lot and given some thought to it.

When it comes to a paedophile going to prison, they're always at very high risk from other prisoners.

These prisoners could be the most violent murders etc yet they will Jo stand for sexual offences against children.

To me, crimes against children are the absolute worst.

AIBU to somewhat admire these prisoners for their intolerance to this sort of thing?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Nolongera · 17/10/2022 13:17

I have worked in a number of forensic settings, mainly mental health but prisons too.

Criminals will always try to form some kind of hierarchy based on what you are in for, peados at the bottom, serious armed robbers type at the top.

It's a crock of shit designed to make criminals feel better about their crimes. They always deflect and minimise their crimes.

High profile inmates like Huntley will always get targeted, but there are loads under the radar. Prisoners often change their name so it's harder for the rest of the prison population to find out what they are in for.

If you are soft the other prisoners will identify it and target you, hard nuts don't get picked on much no matter what they are in for.

Most sex offenders stand out a mile. Mind some of the most vociferous with their hatred of peados were in for that very same crime, just trying to hide and deflect.

silverclock222 · 17/10/2022 11:23

Meh anyone who gets sent to prison for a violent or sexual offence is just scum. Its sad if its because of some childhood trauma but that's not their victims fault, there is always a choice.

ThatGirlInACountrySong · 17/10/2022 11:11

Wing not ring!

ThatGirlInACountrySong · 17/10/2022 11:11

If you worked in that prison and had to prevent this behaviour you may well think twice!!

Awful attitude. A home made weapon on the ring could as easily be coming for you as it could the sec offender

In the hands of a volatile inmate everyone is in danger

OooohAhhhh · 17/10/2022 10:58

A child sex offender is easy prey. Nobody likes a child sex offender, so they all group together and target them. I'd say it's more collectively following the actions of other inmates. Plus sex offenders are probably part of the minority population in prisons, so are seen as 'not one of them' and will stand out - as you say most other offenders will have done murders or shared other similar crimes, so they won't target other inmates similar to them.

DontSpeakLatinInFrontOfTheBooks · 17/10/2022 10:57

AIBU to somewhat admire these prisoners for their intolerance to this sort of thing?

Think about what you’re saying. You admire murderers, for being violent no less. That’s twisted.

YABU. And weird.

dogsod · 17/10/2022 10:49

ToooMuchToDo · 17/10/2022 09:37

To those who say sex offenders deserve to die - do you think these people were born evil? In my more than 20 years experience working with offenders, I can tell you now that every single sex offender I have ever worked with (and that's many hundred) has a history which explains their actions. They have been subject to circumstances which shaped them to be the person they became. Society allowed that to happen.

Yes, be sickened and shocked by the crimes. Yes, hate the crimes. But, remember that the person who committed those heinous crimes was once a small child themself, and society needs to start taking responsibility for allowing those children to endure and be shaped into the kind of people that commit those crimes.

We are all responsible for not doing enough to support children, protect them and prevent them ending up as the adults that commit horrendous crimes (of all kinds).

And how did society let that happen?
by letting sex offenders go free or get a slap on the wrist?

mavismorpoth · 17/10/2022 10:42

I don't admire them no because any decent person would not tolerate them. What you have with inmates (and I used to know one very well and heard a lot about this) is oftentimes prison doesn't phase them at all. The ones who are in and out, so know people in them, and the ones who are in there long-term, moved around, so again know many people inside, they know the system and the threat of more time seldom phases them either because they expect to either be in there a long time anyway or be back at some point. So they use this unique position (I can't go around bashing up paedophiles because I don't want to go to prison) to kick the crap of “wronguns” including rapists but yes, paedophiles will get the worst treatment. But it's not some altruistic love of children, it's the fact that they want to have fights wherever they can, they enjoy it. They're angry bitter people who want to take their anger out. Great that they take it out on those people (although I'm still an idealist and believe all prisoners should be treated with respect, otherwise we aren't a civilised society) but at the same time if a paedophile gets his head kicked in I can't feel much besides joy.

So yes I'm glad they get this treatment but no I don't admire inmates for doing what they would do anyway just directed at the right people.

dogsod · 17/10/2022 10:37

I don't think you're wrong for wanting justice to be served for paedophiles. We have always had public executions and other executions. We are only baby steps away from them. It's completely normal to want the man who raped you or your child to be violently beaten to death. If you were physically able to (but you're not because you're a vulnerable child, that's why they picked you) you would have been able to do that yourself, enough to run away or defend yourself.

I think the prisoners who do kill paedophiles are using their special ability (I know, I know) to serve the justice that society won't serve.

If you fucking hurt children like that yoh deserve all you can get. Wasn't Jeffrey Dahmer killed in prison? Wasn't Jon venebles given a series of different identities because he keeps commiting crimes and outing himself? Would it be better of he had been killed too? what about the potential victims?

Also rapists and paedoohiles get such fucking short sentences, or they are let go. let them die I say.

therubbiliser · 17/10/2022 10:33

Plingston · 17/10/2022 10:29

therubbiliser, sorry, I'm not sure what you mean. I don't think I explained myself very well. I was actually trying to disagree with the idea that men just can't help themselves. I'm not trying to rationalise the idea - I am disturbed and frightened by it.

Oh no sorry I didn’t think you were trying to rationalise it. I think others try to rationalise it using what you said.

bloodyeverlastinghell · 17/10/2022 10:32

ToooMuchToDo · 17/10/2022 09:37

To those who say sex offenders deserve to die - do you think these people were born evil? In my more than 20 years experience working with offenders, I can tell you now that every single sex offender I have ever worked with (and that's many hundred) has a history which explains their actions. They have been subject to circumstances which shaped them to be the person they became. Society allowed that to happen.

Yes, be sickened and shocked by the crimes. Yes, hate the crimes. But, remember that the person who committed those heinous crimes was once a small child themself, and society needs to start taking responsibility for allowing those children to endure and be shaped into the kind of people that commit those crimes.

We are all responsible for not doing enough to support children, protect them and prevent them ending up as the adults that commit horrendous crimes (of all kinds).

Given that girls and women are much more likely to be the victims of sexual assault/ sex abuse I find it strange that men are much more likely to be abusers.

If I was caught doing something heinous I’d be looking for an excuse too. I would agree that children need to be protected much better than they are today.

Plingston · 17/10/2022 10:29

therubbiliser, sorry, I'm not sure what you mean. I don't think I explained myself very well. I was actually trying to disagree with the idea that men just can't help themselves. I'm not trying to rationalise the idea - I am disturbed and frightened by it.

Discovereads · 17/10/2022 10:23

@GlistersisnotGold
Regardless of childhood trauma the issue is almost always men,

While it is true vast majority of child sex abuse is perpetrated by boys/men, it is really more evenly split when you look at all childhood trauma between male/female perpetrators.

(By childhood trauma I am presuming you mean all types of child abuse. )

EmeraldShamrock1 · 17/10/2022 10:21

I think hormone blockers and castration is the best option.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 17/10/2022 10:20

I'd imagine a lot of the time they find new friends in prison they recognise the likeness that unfortunately encourages them.

Plingston · 17/10/2022 10:19

Sorry, I know that was slightly off topic, but related to a few previous posts.

I don't think that it's right to think of paedophiles as people who 'can't help' their attraction to children. I suppose that is exactly what the word means, but a 'convicted paedophile' is surely not actually convicted of being a paedophile. They've been convicted of raping or assaulting a child. I don't tend to think of rape and assault as being linked to attraction at all. They are acts of extreme violence.

I wouldn't say that I'd be happy for another prisoner to kill a paedophile. I think that if an imprisoned paedophile was known to me because they had abused a child I know, I'd be glad they'd been killed and not give any thought to the prisoner doing the killing. But then I guess that's why we don't allow the friends and family of victims to decide their fate.

therubbiliser · 17/10/2022 10:16

I am attracted to men. If no men ever wanted to have sex with me ever again, I'd just never have sex again. I wouldn't rape a man. Why would somebody being attracted to children mean that they have to fight the urge to rape them? It's really disturbing. I have never had to fight the urge to rape somebody. Are we suggesting that all straight men who haven't had sex for a while are fighting the urge to rape women they are attracted to?

Abuse against women and children is rationalised persistently in every human culture. Your example is one of a billion rationalisations out there from victim blaming, to denial, to minimisation etc etc We have an enormous amount of growing up to do around accepting to tendencies of particularly males to sexually abuse more vulnerable people in society.

SirCharlesRainier · 17/10/2022 10:14

PetraBP · 17/10/2022 09:03

It’s just a pity the state won’t do it.

Anyone can kill if the circumstances were there (self defence, loss of temper, mental breakdown etc).

It takes a particular kind of evil to rape a child.

I’d be more likely to support the death penalty for child rape than I would for murder.

Well that would incentivise them to kill their victims and so result in more children being murdered. But at least it would make you feel better I guess.

Plingston · 17/10/2022 10:09

The bit I don't understand is saying that people are born as paedophiles and therefore cannot help their attraction to children but can choose not to act on it and set up support groups for people similar to themselves. I almost hear admiration because they 'choose' not to act on it or to help others fight the urge and sympathy for how difficult that must be.

Isn't every single person in the same situation?

I am attracted to men. If no men ever wanted to have sex with me ever again, I'd just never have sex again. I wouldn't rape a man. Why would somebody being attracted to children mean that they have to fight the urge to rape them? It's really disturbing. I have never had to fight the urge to rape somebody. Are we suggesting that all straight men who haven't had sex for a while are fighting the urge to rape women they are attracted to?

ToooMuchToDo · 17/10/2022 10:08

GlistersisnotGold · 17/10/2022 09:58

@ToooMuchToDo my friend used to work as a psychotherapist in prisons and then on a programme to rehabilitate sex offenders. I don’t know how she did it but she did talk in depth about childhood trauma being the root cause. I was sexually abused as a child and have not become an abuser, I am a woman by the way.

Not all abused children become abusers so what do you think is the trigger for some to go down that route but more importantly what stops abused children not becoming abusers. Plus let’s be honest it is mainly a problem with men because almost all sex offenders are men and of the few women that are is it true that many have been groomed by men in to supporting them.

Regardless of childhood trauma the issue is almost always men, why is their wiring just so different from low level misogynists right up to these very worst examples of human beings.

I'm sorry you experienced abuse Glisters...

You are right that not all those abused go on to abuse (I've also been abused and haven't become an abuser), but pretty much every abuser has been abused.

The differences between those that go on to abuse and those that don't are multiple and complex. Often it is about the protective factors around at the time. People who grow up not to abuse have often received messages growing up that it is wrong to abuse. They may also have had some positive relationships with a parent/Guardian/schoolteacher/parents friend, they may have had a good education experience. There are so many possible protective factors or different paths people could have taken.

Often with those who go on to abuse they may not have had protective factors, they may have been repeatedly told they are bad and believed it to the point they then own this belief as true and grow up to be 'bad' as they've always been told they are. Or maybe they were told as kids 'you want it, you are asking for it, kids are so desperate for it' etc.. with no counter messages, so they grow up to believe children want sex and are sexual beings and enjoy it. Or maybe they had severe exposure to porn as kids, witnessed and experience ed sexual abuse and had no alternative messages growing up to believe it's normal and everyone has sexual contact with kids they just don't 'admit it'.

There are so so many factors which influence the directions we take in life, the examples above are based on real stories. We need to help the child victims of crime (abuse, sexual abuse, neglect, domestic violence, trafficking, emotional abuse), provide them with protective factors and guide them in positive directions if we want to prevent future crime and/or mental health problems further down the line.

middleofthelittle · 17/10/2022 10:04

@girlfriend44
I said rarely, Ian Huntley is an extreme example, whoever harmed him would have gained great status in doing so.

The are thousands of men who've committed sexual offences in prisons. I believe in human rights and part of that is being free from harm, that includes people who've committed the worst offences.
Although I think the world would be better off if several people dropped dead, I don't think vigilantism is right.

It's well studied that trying to understand the motive and treat these men is far more preventative of reoffending then surrounding them in shame and violence.

Sexual offending is complex and them being beaten in prison does nothing to stop offending.

Societies attitudes towards women and sex needs to change and with that a reduction in sexual offending. Courts needs to improve conviction rates and massive increases in budgets to social care services are needed.

But that's just my two pence on the subject.

ToooMuchToDo · 17/10/2022 10:00

You can't just say rape is worse than murder. There are so many different kinds of rape and murder. The chopping up, torture and dismembering of a live body before it finally dies is a much more serious murder than Joe thumping Fred at the pub causing him to fall and knock his head and die. A stranger grabbing, attacking and raping a 6 year old child on the street at knife point, is very different from 18year old having sex with a 14/15 year old in the context of a 'relationship'. You can't just box all crimes together as 'rape' or 'murder'.

To be honest, I'd rather be a 14 year old having what I though was consensual sex with my 18 year old 'boyfriend', than be chopped up, tortured and killed by some random. Obviously neither are good, but, if both were sentenced to custody, the 18 year old would be called a sex offender, placed on the vulnerable prisoner wing and hated by the main wing prisoners. The 'murderer' would not be seen as, as bad. That is prion life. It's mad.

Let's not all jump on the band wagon and make sweeping statements about killing all paedophiles or raposts. Life is so much more complex than putting people in boxes like that.

Jumperoo56370000 · 17/10/2022 09:59

scorpiogirly · 16/10/2022 23:58

Yes maybe admire was the wrong word.

I agree, personally I'd have no qualms with whatever fate a paedophile might face.

I suppose I just always thought that was crossing a line even for the most violent of society and just felt in agreement with it. Not that I agree with any other heinous crime.

This literally makes no sense. Unfortunately crimes against children are committed throughout society, and usually by family members.

GlistersisnotGold · 17/10/2022 09:58

@ToooMuchToDo my friend used to work as a psychotherapist in prisons and then on a programme to rehabilitate sex offenders. I don’t know how she did it but she did talk in depth about childhood trauma being the root cause. I was sexually abused as a child and have not become an abuser, I am a woman by the way.

Not all abused children become abusers so what do you think is the trigger for some to go down that route but more importantly what stops abused children not becoming abusers. Plus let’s be honest it is mainly a problem with men because almost all sex offenders are men and of the few women that are is it true that many have been groomed by men in to supporting them.

Regardless of childhood trauma the issue is almost always men, why is their wiring just so different from low level misogynists right up to these very worst examples of human beings.

KettrickenSmiled · 17/10/2022 09:46

I’d be more likely to support the death penalty for child rape than I would for murder.

Nobody's asking you to make a choice from two evils @PetraBP.
Murder is murder, whether state sanctioned or not. And once you open those floodgates, where do you think a bloodthirsty press & a populist government would take it next?