Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think forgiveness is not always necessary in order to fully heal?

108 replies

CoachGary · 16/10/2022 20:33

I'm getting a litte tired of seeing this narrative that you have to forgive in order to move on and heal.

Some things can't be forgiven, and that's OK too IMO.

OP posts:
SnoozyLucy7 · 17/10/2022 10:15

Fromthedarkside · 17/10/2022 08:55

@FayeGovan Forgiveness is a load of shite. Where did that notion come from, the bible?
Some people misunderstand Christian forgiveness.

If we wrong a person, or commit a Sin against God the first thing we must do is own that. We put our hand up and take responsibility for our less-than-perfect behaviour. Then we try and make amends.
If we are genuinely remorseful then God will certainly forgive us. The person may or may not and that is their choice.

Consider Luke 17:3–4, where Jesus tells us, “If your brother sins, rebuke him, and if he repents, forgive him; and if he sins against you seven times in the day, and turns to you seven times, and says, ‘I repent,’ you must forgive him.”
Notice that Jesus says to forgive him if he repents, not regardless of whether he does so. Jesus also envisions the person coming back to you and admitting his wrong.
The upshot? If someone isn’t repentant, you don’t have to forgive them.

Hang on a moment. If a person has wronged me they first seek “forgiveness” from god, and not from me? And if this god says that person is forgiven, even though I was the person who was badly wronged, then all is good because god said so? Can you see how this leads to abuse, especially among religious people, because if they repent and are forgiven by god, through a priest say,? It’s a complete cop out and great big slap in the face of the victim.

Fromthedarkside · 17/10/2022 10:12

@daisychain01 Realistically, why should @magma32 have the onus of teaching some lowlife they shouldn't be an AH to others.

I don't see that it's anyone's responsibility to teach any adult how they should behave. What we should do is just not tolerate their sh!££y behaviour.

I would say that people who have been AH's to @magma32 have been AH's to other people as well. And these other people, if they have any sense, will have also removed them from their life.

therubbiliser · 17/10/2022 10:10

*So what if a person doesn’t repent when all is said and done?
At some point we need to let our feeling of anger fade, not for their sake but for ours. It isn’t good for us to stay angry, and it spoils us. Ultimately, we have to let go of the feeling of anger and move on with life.

With regret, for the person himself we recognize that it is appropriate that they get what they chose, even if that was Hell. This is, after all, the attitude taken by God*

I completely agree with the above. Forgiveness is an internal process. It doesn’t say that what happened is right, it doesn’t suggest we don’t learn from the experience, it doesn’t suggest inappropriate reconciliation. It is about returning to your own state of a peaceful compassionate mind knowing what you know and understanding that another persons failings are for them to deal with and for you to just accept.

Fromthedarkside · 17/10/2022 10:03

@daisychain01 unfortunately religion fails to adequately address the unpalatable perspective of the perpetrator not being willing to be the seeker of forgiveness from the victim of their crime. Very often they have "done a runner" and left their victim high and dry. The chances of them seeking forgiveness is zilch and often they refuse to even recognise they've done anything wrong.
instead it is left to the victim to be the "bigger person" and forgive the perpetrator. That's a bitter pill to swallow, and to your point, if trust is broken, it's madness to be the one to make efforts to repair the damage. It can give the perpetrator even more power that they don't deserve .

So what if a person doesn’t repent when all is said and done?
At some point we need to let our feeling of anger fade, not for their sake but for ours. It isn’t good for us to stay angry, and it spoils us. Ultimately, we have to let go of the feeling of anger and move on with life.

With regret, for the person himself we recognize that it is appropriate that they get what they chose, even if that was Hell. This is, after all, the attitude taken by God.

instead it is left to the victim to be the "bigger person" and forgive the perpetrator.
**
That's not correct - if someone chooses not to take responsibility and apologise, then we are not required to forgive them.

daisychain01 · 17/10/2022 09:59

Anger is righteous—in keeping with justice—if it is still fundamentally directed toward the good. So you may wish that a person experience the consequences of his offenses to sufficiently understand how he has hurt others, and teach him to not commit them in the future.

Realistically, why should @magma32 have the onus of teaching some lowlife they shouldn't be an AH to others. That's why I said in my post that religion doesn't adequately address the reality of the perpetrator's role and the fact they aren't going to have some Road to Damascus moment. If only!

therubbiliser · 17/10/2022 09:57

Yep @Fromthedarkside that is very true. Forgiveness does not require us not to understand or learn from past experiences in fact it requires the opposite from us. To absolutely know the other person and how they have failed but to have compassion for their weaknesses.

Fromthedarkside · 17/10/2022 09:51

@magma32 Forgiveness isn’t some magic bullet that heals everything.
True

It’s a religious concept which is very triggering for me as it puts the onus on the victim to fix their shit,

Not true

which often means somehow trying to minimise it to allow the forgiveness to happen and the perpetrator getting treated better because of it

Certainly not true.

If someone is a terrorist or a child molester then—no matter how penitent he may be—he simply cannot be treated as if he had never committed his crimes.
Forgiveness does not mean treating someone as if they had never wronged us. That would require us to let go of our reason as well as our anger.

Anger is righteous—in keeping with justice—if it is still fundamentally directed toward the good. So you may wish that a person experience the consequences of his offenses to sufficiently understand how he has hurt others, and teach him to not commit them in the future.

daisychain01 · 17/10/2022 09:48

@Fromthedarkside unfortunately religion fails to adequately address the unpalatable perspective of the perpetrator not being willing to be the seeker of forgiveness from the victim of their crime. Very often they have "done a runner" and left their victim high and dry. The chances of them seeking forgiveness is zilch and often they refuse to even recognise they've done anything wrong.

instead it is left to the victim to be the "bigger person" and forgive the perpetrator. That's a bitter pill to swallow, and to your point, if trust is broken, it's madness to be the one to make efforts to repair the damage. It can give the perpetrator even more power that they don't deserve .

magma32 · 17/10/2022 09:41

I agree forgiveness is over rated. The only way for many of us to heal is to seek therapy. Forgiveness isn’t some magic bullet that heals everything. It’s a religious concept which is very triggering for me as it puts the onus on the victim
to fix their shit, which often means somehow trying to minimise it to allow the forgiveness to happen and the perpetrator getting treated better because of it. It is not one that is based on research from what I’ve gathered. Far more effective ways to heal imo.

Lordofmyflies · 17/10/2022 09:36

I think RudsyFarmer has hit the nail on the head. Acceptance is more important than forgiveness. I was assaulted by a friend's DH. I will never forgive them but I now accept that they are dysfunctional and toxic. This acceptance has validated my decisions going forward.

daisychain01 · 17/10/2022 09:36

IrisVersicolor · 16/10/2022 23:29

Forgiveness is a Christian concept. I say get mad, get even, then get over the whole thing.

Just to put the record straight, all World religions teach the concept of forgiveness not just Christianity. Yom Kippur, the Jewish period of Atonement, centres on recognition of our own mistakes and the opportunity to seek forgiveness.

RudsyFarmer · 17/10/2022 09:27

I think acceptance of a situation is a better way of describing it. Forgiveness suggests there is no longer blame, for some that’s impossible to ascribe to.

I now accept many situations that hurt me because enough time has passed and it’s not as painful as it once was. I know I can’t change the past. I can forgive myself once I understand the part I had to play and I can accept the behaviour of the other party.

Fromthedarkside · 17/10/2022 09:22

@therubbiliser To forgive an abuser, for example, doesn’t include reconciliation.

This ^

Forgiving someone doesn't mean pressing the reset button and going back to 'as you were'.
If someone breaks our trust, we'd be an idiot to trust them again until they had earned our trust back. That could be next month, next year or never.

Fromthedarkside · 17/10/2022 08:55

@FayeGovan Forgiveness is a load of shite. Where did that notion come from, the bible?
Some people misunderstand Christian forgiveness.

If we wrong a person, or commit a Sin against God the first thing we must do is own that. We put our hand up and take responsibility for our less-than-perfect behaviour. Then we try and make amends.
If we are genuinely remorseful then God will certainly forgive us. The person may or may not and that is their choice.

Consider Luke 17:3–4, where Jesus tells us, “If your brother sins, rebuke him, and if he repents, forgive him; and if he sins against you seven times in the day, and turns to you seven times, and says, ‘I repent,’ you must forgive him.”
Notice that Jesus says to forgive him if he repents, not regardless of whether he does so. Jesus also envisions the person coming back to you and admitting his wrong.
The upshot? If someone isn’t repentant, you don’t have to forgive them.

silentpool · 17/10/2022 08:42

Some people don't deserve forgiveness and I don't see why the injured party is expected to offer it. Instead, I've moved to a point of indifference.

therubbiliser · 17/10/2022 08:38

NeverDropYourMooncup · 17/10/2022 08:09

That is NOT forgiveness.

You are talking about acceptance there. Acceptance that it happened.

That is exactly what forgiveness looks like in many circumstances @NeverDropYourMooncup.

To forgive an abuser, for example, doesn’t include reconciliation.

Happylittlethoughts · 17/10/2022 08:26

Absolutely right !
The narrative of "forgiveness " puts responsibility back onto the person who has been hurt . They don't need to be made to feel bad because they can't forgive!
Toxic idea

NeverDropYourMooncup · 17/10/2022 08:09

SaintDominic · 16/10/2022 23:23

@Babdoc I like your answer. To forgive someone there has to be genuine repentance.

However forgiving is not forgetting or putting yourself in harms way or having anything to do with a person and/or situation that caused you harm.

Forgiveness doesn’t mean having to see anyone you have forgiven or not maintaining boundaries or physical distance. Forgiving doesn’t mean going back to the way things were in the past.

Its also not about anyone who caused problems or committed crimes not experiencing the natural and lawful consequences of their actions. Forgiveness doesn’t mean that justice should not be served.

It’s about letting go of the pain so you yourself can be free.

Noone is required to forgive anyone else, and nobody else should tell us how we should feel or respond to what has happened in the past.

Forgiving is not about having warm emotions or positive thoughts toward anyone, it’s going through a process so that you can emerge healthier and move on.

Its accepting that we cannot change anything about the past and not being consumed with anger because of it.

Forgiveness is not a requirement, it has to be freely given. Forgiveness can also be a long process over a long period of time.

That is NOT forgiveness.

You are talking about acceptance there. Acceptance that it happened.

IrisVersicolor · 16/10/2022 23:29

Forgiveness is a Christian concept. I say get mad, get even, then get over the whole thing.

Whiskeypowers · 16/10/2022 23:27

Babdoc · 16/10/2022 22:54

Repentance (genuine, not insincere apology) has to come before forgiveness. If your offender is unrepentant, then there is no reason to forgive them. As a PP commented, even God does not forgive the unrepentant sinner, though He immediately welcomes those who really are sorry.

What their version of repentance is and mine are and always will be poles apart. Perhaps in another lifetime I might have been more open to such concepts but not now.

SaintDominic · 16/10/2022 23:23

@Babdoc I like your answer. To forgive someone there has to be genuine repentance.

However forgiving is not forgetting or putting yourself in harms way or having anything to do with a person and/or situation that caused you harm.

Forgiveness doesn’t mean having to see anyone you have forgiven or not maintaining boundaries or physical distance. Forgiving doesn’t mean going back to the way things were in the past.

Its also not about anyone who caused problems or committed crimes not experiencing the natural and lawful consequences of their actions. Forgiveness doesn’t mean that justice should not be served.

It’s about letting go of the pain so you yourself can be free.

Noone is required to forgive anyone else, and nobody else should tell us how we should feel or respond to what has happened in the past.

Forgiving is not about having warm emotions or positive thoughts toward anyone, it’s going through a process so that you can emerge healthier and move on.

Its accepting that we cannot change anything about the past and not being consumed with anger because of it.

Forgiveness is not a requirement, it has to be freely given. Forgiveness can also be a long process over a long period of time.

Whiskeypowers · 16/10/2022 23:23

TheHighlandMoo · 16/10/2022 23:05

I hate when people say you need to forgive to fully heal. Such a load of bollox.
i forgive myself for the blame I attributed incorrectly. I forgive myself for the punishments I put myself through. I forgive myself for the shame I felt and still feel. I forgive myself for all of the ways I wasn’t there for me in the aftermath.
forgive the person who caused it? Not in a million lifetimes

a million times over
What you have written here resonates so deeply with me.
thank you for sharing it.

Snugglemonkey · 16/10/2022 23:07

CoachGary · 16/10/2022 22:28

For some reason I wasn't expecting these types of replies, it's very encouraging actually. But I'm so sorry to hear about what you've all been through. People really do suck.

I've been told my whole life that forgiveness is good for the soul, that you can't truly ever move on of you don't forgive and all that bullshit but I've never bought it.

My ex SA'd me for years and isn't sorry about it so fuck forgiveness 🖕

Fuck forgiveness indeed. How can you forgive when someone is not sorry? Some things are not forgivable. You absolutely can move on with no forgiveness.

The only forgiving I think is necessary is that to yourself, if you are giving yourself a hard time. Especially if the hard time is about choices you made that went wrong. We lack crystal balls and it is inevitable that some choices will not work. We also need to remember the position of the us that made the choice. They were doing it with less information than the us now judging ourselves. Self compassion is essential, but forgiveness for abusive fuckers, no way.

TheHighlandMoo · 16/10/2022 23:05

I hate when people say you need to forgive to fully heal. Such a load of bollox.
i forgive myself for the blame I attributed incorrectly. I forgive myself for the punishments I put myself through. I forgive myself for the shame I felt and still feel. I forgive myself for all of the ways I wasn’t there for me in the aftermath.
forgive the person who caused it? Not in a million lifetimes

therubbiliser · 16/10/2022 23:05

I don’t forgive my brother who sexually abused me. I rarely think about him at all, he is a person from my past. I focus on trying to forgive the rest of my family for their absolutely shit reactions to finding out about the abuse. Much better use of my time even though I won’t be having a relationship with any of them ever again I know they have goodness in them unlike the paedophile who is rotten to the core. I want to forgive them because it will be freeing for me. They couldn’t give a shit whether I forgive them or not. They don’t believe their have done anything that would warrant forgiveness so it is completely for myself that I want to allow them their failings and move on.