Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think forgiveness is not always necessary in order to fully heal?

108 replies

CoachGary · 16/10/2022 20:33

I'm getting a litte tired of seeing this narrative that you have to forgive in order to move on and heal.

Some things can't be forgiven, and that's OK too IMO.

OP posts:
CoachGary · 17/10/2022 17:48

@Fromthedarkside
Because I don't think an eye for an eye is morally correct, like I've said. But according to your beliefs, if they asked for God's forgiveness, then it would send them to heaven a lot faster, not hell.

This isn't a discussion on the death penalty, it's about forgiveness and how it can be toxic in certain situations to push on the victim.

OP posts:
therubbiliser · 17/10/2022 14:36

NeverDropYourMooncup · 17/10/2022 13:11

You're using the wrong word. It isn't forgiveness. It's never forgiveness.

I could use the word Dog to describe my cat if it suited me to do so - but it doesn't make him a small canine. You're using forgiveness to mean acceptance/acknowledgement. That doesn't mean it's forgiving.

@NeverDropYourMooncup you are not the gatekeeper of what constitutes forgiveness. Why do you keep calling people on this thread wrong for their differing beliefs? I completely 100% accept that your definition of what constitutes forgiveness is different to mine but it would be really nice if we could agree to disagree.

Fromthedarkside · 17/10/2022 14:29

@CoachGary I don't think that people like child molesters deserve an opportunity for redemption, religiously or otherwise.

OK, then why not give them the 'long drop' before they have a chance to mend their ways, and send them to Hell a lot faster?

I'm curious to know what you think should happen to them?

CoachGary · 17/10/2022 14:20

@Fromthedarkside I don't really stand one way or the other on the death penalty to be honest. Morally I don't think "an eye for an eye" is the right way to go about things, however I don't think that people like child molesters deserve an opportunity for redemption, religiously or otherwise.

OP posts:
Fromthedarkside · 17/10/2022 14:04

@CoachGary It doesn't matter if you keep doing it or not. Someone who molested a child could still technically get into heaven by being sorry and asking God for forgiveness. I personally think that's a sick thing to be taught.

I take it that if you think these people are incapable of redemption you'd vote to bring back the Death Penalty?

magma32 · 17/10/2022 13:40

daisychain01 · 17/10/2022 13:33

Power to you @magma32 Flowers I'm nodding away here, reading your words.

my maxim in life is "never let another person live inside your head rent-free". There is an awful lot to be said for placing distance and living a happy life.

I cannot get the "forgiveness" thing, it feels too much like an action that the other person doesn't deserve!

Same it’s seeing the impact and pressure of forgiving and forgetting, often women in my community are told you forgive and be patient. Men who are wronged can wage a war! I’ve had people (men) commit murder in my community and the community gets together to pray for the murderer because it’s so important they get forgiven by god.
No thought for the actual victim and their family and seeking forgiveness from them and no idea if the actual murderer feels bad.
Usually lots of excuses are given.
Then you get lots of ‘reformed’ men in the community walking around with their held held high because y’know they’ve repented.
They don’t seem to have the same tolerance for women doing ‘wrong’ though.
You never hear of reformed women.
They often leave the community as they’ve been ostracised for doing much lesser ‘crimes’ than the men.
So yep I don’t really care what the theory behind forgiveness is, what matters to me is how it’s promoted and practiced on the ground and the unnecessary pressure it puts on victims. Like I said there are better ways to heal without thinking about whether you’ve forgiven someone who has harmed you. No matter what they say, you can be completely healthy and happy without needing to forgive someone.

daisychain01 · 17/10/2022 13:33

magma32 · 17/10/2022 11:08

Exactly not my job, have enough to deal with than to sort out the perpetrator. I go nc with people like that so I’d rather not think about them but they definitely are not ‘forgiven’ in my books. And who decides what forgiveness really is, different religions have different versions of it and they seem to add little bits to it. Forgiveness is just another job for a victim to do, adds to a mental load, great if it comes naturally but all the bs people in religious communities spout is you’re a bigger person if you’re forgiving, nope I’m a bigger person already. That forgiveness makes you closer to god etc. non forgiving people become bitter etc nah I’m the same caring and loving person, just not towards those who wronged and no I’m not out to seek revenge etc. I’m quite happy just having cut these people out, I don’t need to forgive them, I don’t need to do them any favours but people will tell me I’m hurting myself by not forgiving. Gimme a break.

Power to you @magma32 Flowers I'm nodding away here, reading your words.

my maxim in life is "never let another person live inside your head rent-free". There is an awful lot to be said for placing distance and living a happy life.

I cannot get the "forgiveness" thing, it feels too much like an action that the other person doesn't deserve!

NeverDropYourMooncup · 17/10/2022 13:11

therubbiliser · 17/10/2022 08:38

That is exactly what forgiveness looks like in many circumstances @NeverDropYourMooncup.

To forgive an abuser, for example, doesn’t include reconciliation.

You're using the wrong word. It isn't forgiveness. It's never forgiveness.

I could use the word Dog to describe my cat if it suited me to do so - but it doesn't make him a small canine. You're using forgiveness to mean acceptance/acknowledgement. That doesn't mean it's forgiving.

CoachGary · 17/10/2022 13:06

@Fromthedarkside It doesn't matter if you keep doing it or not. Someone who molested a child could still technically get into heaven by being sorry and asking God for forgiveness. I personally think that's a sick thing to be taught.

OP posts:
Fromthedarkside · 17/10/2022 12:45

@therubbiliser Priests are still humans, they will still have the same human frailties as everyone else when it comes down to it.

Absolutely, and they will have to account for their actions the same as anyone else, either by man's laws or God's laws or both

@CoachGary For example it teaches that no matter what, as long as you're really sorry, God will forgive you.
But not if you keep on doing whatever it was.
That doesn't fly with me.
OK, you're free to have your view.

Mommabear20 · 17/10/2022 11:56

100% agree! I can't forgive a sibling for something they did, but they will never be sorry or even apologise, but it doesn't mean I have to stop living my life

therubbiliser · 17/10/2022 11:53

Whiskeypowers · 17/10/2022 11:28

I’m sorry
I was unintentionally hostile but as you can see it this is a huge trigger for me. I forgave someone so many times and tried so hard it was all for nothing but more abuse in the end.

it is interesting though how we individually process and break down these things or not as the case may be. I cannot fall down any more rabbit holes with the person who did what they did to me. I have to adopt a dearth policy That’s how I survive. In every other aspect and relationship in my life I am not that person it it is like night and day.

I am sorry for what you have had to navigate your way through.

I 100% get you and I’m so sorry for what you have experienced and Fwiw I completely agree with the original premise of the thread you definitely don’t have to forgive to heal.

Whiskeypowers · 17/10/2022 11:28

therubbiliser · 17/10/2022 11:12

@Whiskeypowers i genuinely actually do get what you are saying but yes I have found that coping with my incestuous abuse and my family betrayal after that abuse coming out I have definitely found that making peace with the fact that my family have failed in being good people and having compassion for their failure has helped me to walk the balance for being able to hold very strong permanent boundaries against my family members while trying to be a good compassionate person at the same time and not getting eaten alive by how their failings affected me. I don’t expect it to make sense to everyone. God fucking knows I struggle with it myself sometimes.

I’m sorry
I was unintentionally hostile but as you can see it this is a huge trigger for me. I forgave someone so many times and tried so hard it was all for nothing but more abuse in the end.

it is interesting though how we individually process and break down these things or not as the case may be. I cannot fall down any more rabbit holes with the person who did what they did to me. I have to adopt a dearth policy That’s how I survive. In every other aspect and relationship in my life I am not that person it it is like night and day.

I am sorry for what you have had to navigate your way through.

RudsyFarmer · 17/10/2022 11:24

I’ve put in so much work to get to the point of acceptance so I’m so pleased it’s resonated with a few people ♥️

Fluckle · 17/10/2022 11:20

RudsyFarmer · 17/10/2022 09:27

I think acceptance of a situation is a better way of describing it. Forgiveness suggests there is no longer blame, for some that’s impossible to ascribe to.

I now accept many situations that hurt me because enough time has passed and it’s not as painful as it once was. I know I can’t change the past. I can forgive myself once I understand the part I had to play and I can accept the behaviour of the other party.

I was going to say exactly this, but @RudsyFarmer beat me to it.

Forgiveness isn't always possible, let alone healthy, especially when the other party continues to act without remorse. But acceptance is a huge, massive, healing step forward that leaves you in a better, wiser place that centres upon compassion for yourself and what you experienced. It doesn't mean you've forgotten, it means that it no longer affects your behaviour and thoughts in a negative way. That's a worthwhile goal to try and achieve, but it's fucking hard and grueling work, as I know only too well.

BackOnTheBandWagon · 17/10/2022 11:17

Yep, I will never forgive my ex for the abusive shit he put me through. But I also don't allow him any power in my life any more. Thankfully, I never have to see the wanker, so he doesn't impede my life now. I forgive myself for what happened, that's more important.

therubbiliser · 17/10/2022 11:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

@Whiskeypowers i genuinely actually do get what you are saying but yes I have found that coping with my incestuous abuse and my family betrayal after that abuse coming out I have definitely found that making peace with the fact that my family have failed in being good people and having compassion for their failure has helped me to walk the balance for being able to hold very strong permanent boundaries against my family members while trying to be a good compassionate person at the same time and not getting eaten alive by how their failings affected me. I don’t expect it to make sense to everyone. God fucking knows I struggle with it myself sometimes.

magma32 · 17/10/2022 11:08

daisychain01 · 17/10/2022 09:59

Anger is righteous—in keeping with justice—if it is still fundamentally directed toward the good. So you may wish that a person experience the consequences of his offenses to sufficiently understand how he has hurt others, and teach him to not commit them in the future.

Realistically, why should @magma32 have the onus of teaching some lowlife they shouldn't be an AH to others. That's why I said in my post that religion doesn't adequately address the reality of the perpetrator's role and the fact they aren't going to have some Road to Damascus moment. If only!

Exactly not my job, have enough to deal with than to sort out the perpetrator. I go nc with people like that so I’d rather not think about them but they definitely are not ‘forgiven’ in my books. And who decides what forgiveness really is, different religions have different versions of it and they seem to add little bits to it. Forgiveness is just another job for a victim to do, adds to a mental load, great if it comes naturally but all the bs people in religious communities spout is you’re a bigger person if you’re forgiving, nope I’m a bigger person already. That forgiveness makes you closer to god etc. non forgiving people become bitter etc nah I’m the same caring and loving person, just not towards those who wronged and no I’m not out to seek revenge etc. I’m quite happy just having cut these people out, I don’t need to forgive them, I don’t need to do them any favours but people will tell me I’m hurting myself by not forgiving. Gimme a break.

Whiskeypowers · 17/10/2022 11:06

CoachGary · 17/10/2022 10:47

@Fromthedarkside I take issue with religion in general, because IMO it has made the world a worse place to be overall. For example it teaches that no matter what, as long as you're really sorry, God will forgive you.

That doesn't fly with me.

Completely agree

Whiskeypowers · 17/10/2022 11:05

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

WizardOfUK · 17/10/2022 10:53

I think you can move on without forgiving. My ex was a selfish and abusive tear. We're now divorced and co parent pretty well. I've moved on, feel little animosity towards him, but will never forgive him for the things he put me through.

Kennykenkencat · 17/10/2022 10:48

To me forgiving someone is easing their conscience and giving them permission to do the same again.

I won’t forgive someone and I never forget and I always curse them. Then I will move on and it doesn’t eat away at me. I probably won’t ever think of that person again if I never saw them again.

CoachGary · 17/10/2022 10:47

@Fromthedarkside I take issue with religion in general, because IMO it has made the world a worse place to be overall. For example it teaches that no matter what, as long as you're really sorry, God will forgive you.

That doesn't fly with me.

OP posts:
therubbiliser · 17/10/2022 10:41

Fromthedarkside · 17/10/2022 10:34

@SnoozyLucy7 I'm sorry if I wasn't clear.

If we sin against God, then we apologise to God and ask for forgiveness.
If we hurt, wrong or treat another human being badly, we apologise to them and ask forgiveness.
We need to do both.

And if this god says that person is forgiven, even though I was the person who was badly wronged, then all is good because god said so?

No. Forgiveness does not mean treating someone as if they had never behaved badly. That would require us to let go of our reason as well as our anger

Can you see how this leads to abuse, especially among religious people, because if they repent and are forgiven by god, through a priest say,?

Priests are trained counsellors. Before they give a Penitent absolution they will have to satisfy themselves that the Penitent is truly remorseful. If they doubt the Penitent is genuine then they will suggest a course of action the Penitent can take, and to come back when they have time to learn greater understanding.

It’s a complete cop out and great big slap in the face of the victim.

No. Because forgiveness isn't automatic either via a priest or by God.

I don’t think I’d necessarily be looking to religious people to address some of this with regards to forgiveness.

My uncle, a priest, has chosen to be part of the problem in our family around the incestuous abuse in the family. The advice he has given to others who sought his counsel has amounted to sweeping sexual abuse of children under the rug so my own parents (his sister) won’t have to address their own emotionally and psychologically abusive behaviours towards their daughters. Priests are still humans, they will still have the same human frailties as everyone else when it comes down to it.

Fromthedarkside · 17/10/2022 10:34

@SnoozyLucy7 I'm sorry if I wasn't clear.

If we sin against God, then we apologise to God and ask for forgiveness.
If we hurt, wrong or treat another human being badly, we apologise to them and ask forgiveness.
We need to do both.

And if this god says that person is forgiven, even though I was the person who was badly wronged, then all is good because god said so?

No. Forgiveness does not mean treating someone as if they had never behaved badly. That would require us to let go of our reason as well as our anger

Can you see how this leads to abuse, especially among religious people, because if they repent and are forgiven by god, through a priest say,?

Priests are trained counsellors. Before they give a Penitent absolution they will have to satisfy themselves that the Penitent is truly remorseful. If they doubt the Penitent is genuine then they will suggest a course of action the Penitent can take, and to come back when they have time to learn greater understanding.

It’s a complete cop out and great big slap in the face of the victim.

No. Because forgiveness isn't automatic either via a priest or by God.

Swipe left for the next trending thread