Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think sending your child to nursery, ill is selfish

273 replies

Anon778833 · 16/10/2022 19:29

If my toddler is ill, I do not send her into nursery - it’s as simple as that. If I have to not go into work, that’s just how it is.

There has been an outbreak of slapped cheek at my daughter’s nursery which she caught and now I also have caught too. And it’s a really horrible virus. My poor dd hasn’t eaten for nearly a week. And she is STILL spiking temperature.

Nursery sent out a message to say that thanks to people bringing ill children to nursery, they now have staff shortages. And that people must not bring ill kids to nursery.

I thought this was common sense.

OP posts:
Dahlietta · 17/10/2022 10:00

My child's primary school seems to be having an attendance drive and there's a sign outside listing the things you should keep them off with and the things you don't need to keep them off with. Slapped cheek is on the list of things you should send them in with - I was pretty shocked by that!

dandelionthistle · 17/10/2022 09:47

LokiDokiArtichoki · 17/10/2022 09:27

It’s sometimes hard to make a judgement call.
I’ve kept my 3yo home today as she is snotty and was coughing in the night. She’s absolutely fine in herself though and is running about, dancing and singing. She probably would have been fine to go in today and tbh if it was a day I worked I would have sent her in, and to the childminder later.

where is the line? All common illnesses are contagious and are part and parcel of life. It’s unfortunate that some people are more susceptible to complications (myself included) but we can’t lockdown for every sniffle

This is it.

There are of course always a very small number of parents deliberately sending in sick children, hoping the morning's calpol will tide them over, hoping they'll perk up, hoping they won't actually vomit again even though they've definitely not had their 48 hours so will still be sharing germs either way - and perhaps also knowing that if they can just get through til lunchtime before the nursery calls, the logistics of keeping their child at home for the rest of the day will be easier.
In some cases it'll be absolute financial desperation, in many cases it'll be insecurity re employment, and presumably yes in some cases it'll be fucked up parents.

But in most cases it's not about breaking the rules, it's about what happens in the grey area. Whether to send a snotty tired child in or not. Whether it's just a cold or not. I've kept a child at home before assuming she'd mostly nap on the sofa while I worked as she seemed so exhausted and groggy, but actually by 9am she was right as rain and would have had a great day at school. They bounce back very quickly and they become unwell from nowhere very quickly. Pre-rash slapped cheek is absolutely in this category - it might present as a nasty fever or a mild cold, and they're contagious (with occasionally tragic consequences) either way.

The fact that the nursery are sending letters home is 'proof' of very little. Institutional childcare is unfortunately a recipe for germ-sharing even if everyone did religiously keep their child at home at the first sign of a fever and for 48 hours after D&V.

Working parenthood can be very precarious. The overwhelming majority are trying their best.

Biscuits1011 · 17/10/2022 09:46

Depends. If it’s a cold and the child feels ok, I’d send them in. Slapped cheek, chicken pox any thing like that no I wouldn’t… we can’t all afford to take time off every time kids have a coke or sniffle… I would never work!

Elsamit · 17/10/2022 09:44

@Tumbleweed101

We are there to educate not provide a nursing service for unwell children.

Absolutely this! Well said!

Snowpaw · 17/10/2022 09:33

Thing is, if they are shielded from catching anything at nursery, they will only catch bugs when they HAVE to mix with others at school age. We can't keep everyone apart forever. That would only weaken everyones immune systems. I'd rather they get the bugs out of the way earlier on than when they are missing out on their formal school education.

LokiDokiArtichoki · 17/10/2022 09:27

It’s sometimes hard to make a judgement call.
I’ve kept my 3yo home today as she is snotty and was coughing in the night. She’s absolutely fine in herself though and is running about, dancing and singing. She probably would have been fine to go in today and tbh if it was a day I worked I would have sent her in, and to the childminder later.

where is the line? All common illnesses are contagious and are part and parcel of life. It’s unfortunate that some people are more susceptible to complications (myself included) but we can’t lockdown for every sniffle

Kanaloa · 17/10/2022 09:18

This is why it bugs me on mumsnet when I see threads innocently asking why it’s so hard for nurseries to get staff. You’re paid more to work at Tesco and don’t need to contend with the attitude of total entitlement that it’s your job to care for other people’s sick children at risk to your own health.

Kanaloa · 17/10/2022 09:17

Givenuptotally · 17/10/2022 07:01

You’re right, OP, it’s wrong and ultimately the knock on effect affects everyone. However your lack of empathy with those who are working zero hour contracts, working for minimum wage paid by the hour rather than a salary, who have multiple children and are off so regularly it becomes problematic regardless of the job, of those in jobs where others are reliant on them turning up ( anything with a waiting list in the NHS..). Are single parenting with no support etc etc etc is problematic. Not everyone feels able to just stay home.

Those of us who work at nurseries are also working NMW paid by the hour, and the grand majority of my colleagues have multiple children. And due to ratios etc there is also a huge huge amount of pressure on us not to take sick days for our children.

And more to the point it isn’t part of our job to care for sick children.

Anon778833 · 17/10/2022 07:52

Givenuptotally · 17/10/2022 07:01

You’re right, OP, it’s wrong and ultimately the knock on effect affects everyone. However your lack of empathy with those who are working zero hour contracts, working for minimum wage paid by the hour rather than a salary, who have multiple children and are off so regularly it becomes problematic regardless of the job, of those in jobs where others are reliant on them turning up ( anything with a waiting list in the NHS..). Are single parenting with no support etc etc etc is problematic. Not everyone feels able to just stay home.

What do you mean lack of empathy? What do you suggest is a solution? Nursery provisions aren’t designed to be a drop off sick bay for children with high temperatures and vomiting bugs. And people trying to argue that it’s ok to do that should be ashamed of themselves. I am paid by the hour myself and if I have to take time off I lose commission.

OP posts:
Givenuptotally · 17/10/2022 07:01

You’re right, OP, it’s wrong and ultimately the knock on effect affects everyone. However your lack of empathy with those who are working zero hour contracts, working for minimum wage paid by the hour rather than a salary, who have multiple children and are off so regularly it becomes problematic regardless of the job, of those in jobs where others are reliant on them turning up ( anything with a waiting list in the NHS..). Are single parenting with no support etc etc etc is problematic. Not everyone feels able to just stay home.

loulouljh · 17/10/2022 06:59

Anon778833 · 16/10/2022 20:46

So you are saying that your child isn’t your responsibility? Do you ask social services to step in? 🤯

What a silly thing to say! Of course your child is your responsibility. The harsh reality is thought that for parents that work, when a child is ill, it can put you in a very difficult position. Kids get sick alot...especially at nursery age. Employers cannot always be understanding. That will be why some kids are at nursery when you think they should be at home.

Tumbleweed101 · 17/10/2022 06:59

We just had an outbreak that saw several members of staff off. If it hadn't been that so many children were also off we would have had to close a room. Despite asking parents to keep children off until they were not showing a temperature they would be sent home and be back still obviously unwell the next day.

Ultimately it means more parents have to take time off work because more children become unwell. If too many staff catch it the option of us opening might not even be there so parents would have to be off or find alternate care. All because parents won't keep them home til they are through the infectious phase.

We are there to educate not provide a nursing service for unwell children. Our ratio means the children can't have one to one care. A nursery is noisy and busy and not where sick children want to be. We will call for children to go home but by that time their friends have been infected too.

DoubleBuggyDriver · 17/10/2022 06:49

I really don’t understand the comments where people are saying, ‘well we have to work to keep a roof over our heads’ or ‘I can’t just take days off work for X reason.’ Well sorry, if your child is ill why do you think it’s okay to take them to nursery/school and possibly spread it to other people.

Not just that, but so many kids with fevers and other illnesses (not just a common cold), need actual rest and time to recover. If your job doesn’t accommodate that then unfortunately that’s not the nursery or schools fault…

Rosebel · 17/10/2022 06:43

Safer · 16/10/2022 22:11

So why did the nursery accept the child in if it was so obvious that the child was poorly?

You're initial complaint was slapped cheek, so what happened at handover when an evidently ill child with slapped cheek was allowed in?

And if parents are handing children over with fevers, again why isn't your nursery handing them straight back?

It does work both ways. Nurseries have policies, parents are expected to follow the policies, but, for example last weekend my daughter was fine all morning - we went out, having a lovely day then in the afternoon she went downhill with a fever fast. It happened over the course of an hour. It was a weekend so no issue, but had it been a nursery day I would have had no reason to believe she wasn't well at drop off because 11am that morning she was stuffing her face with pancakes and running around soft play. So I give parents the benefit of the doubt in these circumstances that a child can become unwell over the course of the day as I would hope the nursery would too.

But had that happened during a nursery day I would expect the nursery to call me if my DD became unwell and I would collect her.
I'd be really annoyed if my nursery during handover took in a child who is clearly unwell, with a fever and slapped cheek syndrome.

Why aren't you more upset with the nursery? An angry email to parents is really passive aggressive, why don't you want nursery to be stringent about enforcing their policy on the door?

Loads of parents mask their children's fevers by dosing them with Calpol before drop off. So even if nursery staff were to take temperatures at the door (which we did when Covid first hit) the child would appear well. It's only when the effects of Calpol wear off that you realise the child is ill.
Obviously yoou then call the parents but usually too late by then, they've already infected children and staff.

StarfishBrain · 17/10/2022 00:00

Oh and everyone gets the 15 hours, that's universal. So OP, one would think, know this because anybody with internet access can discover it in 10 seconds. HTH.

StarfishBrain · 16/10/2022 23:52

EmeraldShamrock1 · 16/10/2022 23:08

If open FT how would you know they only offer 15 hours? Are you that nosey you've asked?
How do you know parents are receiving 15 hours? Do you have access to their personal life, financial details?

Just hire a Nanny.

Their policies will state this.

StarfishBrain · 16/10/2022 23:51

EmeraldShamrock1 · 16/10/2022 23:04

The nursery has repeatedly sent me messages saying thank you for not sending her in and being sensible

Awh I bet you feel chuffed hearing that. 🙄
I don’t have to explain myself but I will anyway. As it happens, the nursery my daughter goes to is attached to a private school that doesn’t even offer more than 15 funded hours a week.

So it is a preschool not a private nursery?

Which means that the majority of parents dumping ill kids are likely to be high earners. Otherwise they’d be offering 30 hours a week for eligible children.

This doesn't make sense.

Why would high earners working FT use a nursery that only opened 3 hours per day.

I think this is BS.

Obviously she isn't talking about their opening hours. She's talking about the discounted, additional partly funded extra 15 hours to make it up to 30 hours that is means tested.

Chessie678 · 16/10/2022 23:47

My nursery doesn't actually try to send children home for every illness. If children get a slight temperature at nursery they tend to give it an hour or so to see if it comes down (unless they're presenting as very unwell). Their policy on (e.g.) hand foot and mouth is to send them in if they seem well enough in line with NHS advice. So when my DS had hand foot and mouth I kept him off for 4 days as he was uncomfortable and under the weather and then sent him in even though the spots hadn't completely healed. If I had kept him off until the last spot had disappeared I would have had to take three weeks off and then another two weeks when he got it again despite him being his normal self after the first week or so. He probably was somewhat infectious but then hand foot and mouth is infectious before symptoms appear in any case and most toddlers will get it at some point.

I keep DS off when I think he's unwell enough that he wouldn't enjoy nursery or for D&V etc. and probably took 15 days off for him in his first year at nursery but I don't keep him at home for every cold or minor illness. He has a seemingly perpetual cold from September through to April and I don't think that's uncommon.

In regards to covid I doubt many parents of nursery age children now know whether or not they have it because in my experience very few are now testing their toddlers. Covid usually presents as a cold for this age group (if it has symptoms at all) so I've no idea if I've sent my DS in with it recently. I suspect a few of the children at DS's nursery have covid at any one time.

StarfishBrain · 16/10/2022 23:40

EmeraldShamrock1 · 16/10/2022 22:35

And you have no empathy either it seems for people who might have a miscarriage because you think it’s your god given right to dump a sick child in a provision?
That's extreme.

Not really, when a poster on this thread had this happen to her, 😔

LikeAStar1994 · 16/10/2022 23:40

Ohwellwhateverthen · 16/10/2022 19:32

You're very lucky that you can afford to take the day off whenever your child is sick. That's a privilege not many people I know have these days.

Well said.

Ilovemycatalot · 16/10/2022 23:40

@TescoCustomerService you are disgusting.

Ilovemycatalot · 16/10/2022 23:32

Well it probably won’t surprise you but nursery staff don’t get sick pay either so when we catch something from your sick child we have to take time of unpaid. Not great for us either especially as we are on shit pay already and can not afford it. Oh and when the calpol wears of you will get a call to collect your sick child anyway and any sickness normally means they are not allowed in for 48 hours after so parents really don’t gain anything by still sending them in.

Vecna · 16/10/2022 23:32

Besides the selfishness of it all, it is beyond me how a parent can send their sick child anywhere. I'd want to look after them myself and make sure they're as comfortable as possible.

Illnesses do take time to manifest though, so kids will catch illnesses at nursery even with the best of intentions.

Shayisgreat · 16/10/2022 23:29

It's not fair to send a miserably sick child into nursery but sometimes you don't know if them having a slightly snotty nose will develop into them being miserable or if it is just a run of the mill cold that they'll have on and off for the winter. If my DS has D&V or is clearly unwell I don't send him in and when he had the chicken pox and hand foot and mouth I kept him home as soon as I noticed a spot/rash on him. However, he probably gave it to his friends the 3\4 days in the lead up to the spots/rash appearing and there was no way of me knowing about that. Likewise, he clearly got it from another child whose symptoms showed up after the damage was done.

Your child is going to get sick at nursery and it's pointless to blame "selfish parents" because nobody in the world stays away from all others when they're feeling slightly unwell so these things are always going to go around.

StarfishBrain · 16/10/2022 23:28

Plus I've never known a school/nursery close for a bug.

It's happened several times at ours.

Swipe left for the next trending thread