Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No first aiders at train station

129 replies

Mushroomlady · 16/10/2022 18:58

An older woman tripped and fell in front of me on the station platform while running for a train today. She was very badly injured. I've been first aid trained for work so was able to help - removed her broken glasses, laid her down on her side, stemmed the bleeding (quite heavy), bandaged her up, shaded her from the sun, talked to her, etc. I asked if any of the station staff were first aiders and the answer was no! There was about 4 of them. I had to shout at them to call an ambulance, but it was another passenger that called as the staff were dithering and seemed quite clueless.

Aibu to be absolutely shocked about this? They are dealing with hundreds of passengers per day. How is it not essential that they have a certified first aider on site at all times?
Should I complain? Assume they would need to log it in accident book?

OP posts:
Badbadbunny · 16/10/2022 20:25

Alopeciabop · 16/10/2022 20:22

I’m with you OP. Like you say, put an event on for the public and you need first aiders. So why would a business which deals with the public in large numbers with, as you say, the risks of tracks/trains/etc, not need to?

Dont even get me started on schools not needing to have everyone be first aid trained.

No you don't "need" first aiders if you put on an event. You have to do a risk assessment, which may, or may not, determine that first aiders are in attendance, dependant upon risks etc.

Even then, an "event" is a relatively short duration, maybe just a few hours, so your first aid "provision" could be as simple as getting the local St John ambulance to send a couple of volunteers for a few hours. That's completely different to some people who seem to think that a 24/7 attendance everywhere is appropriate (and ruinously expensive!).

Mushroomlady · 16/10/2022 20:25

She didn't fall on her knees. She fell flat on her face and was wearing glasses so they smashed into her face . At least one tooth was on the floor. She has a very deep cut on her hand which I assume would need stitches. She was visibly shaken and I thought she was going to properly pass out. I was worried about concussion or shock.

It scares me that we keep hearing that ambulance waiting times are getting longer and longer and yet in busy public places there are few people able to help - only random passerbys. Thank goodness the paramedics did actually arrive relatively quickly.

OP posts:
Chesneyhawkes1 · 16/10/2022 20:23

@JennieTheZebra if you are trained that's all well and good.

I'm often in a situation where it's just me and sometimes in excess of 500 people.

I had a half day first aid course almost 19 years ago when I started my job. Since then nothing. Of course I would try to help - but I don't have much confidence in what I'd be able to do beyond common sense stuff.

Alopeciabop · 16/10/2022 20:22

I’m with you OP. Like you say, put an event on for the public and you need first aiders. So why would a business which deals with the public in large numbers with, as you say, the risks of tracks/trains/etc, not need to?

Dont even get me started on schools not needing to have everyone be first aid trained.

Kite22 · 16/10/2022 20:17

I am surprised you are shocked by it.
I wouldn't expect all train staff to be First Aid trained, no.
I mean, don't get me wrong, it would be great if more people were first aid trained, but I don't expect there to be an officially trained person wherever I go, on the off chance someone needs First Aid.

Badbadbunny · 16/10/2022 20:16

Intelligenthair · 16/10/2022 20:10

There are some right dickheads on this thread. I hope they encounter kinder strangers than they frankly deserve if they ever have an accident.

OP well done for helping, hope you’ve had a gin and the lady is ok. The state of first aid in this country is depressing, I think it should be mandatory in all public places.

Even public places where there are no staff on duty?

If so, does that public place have to close if there is no qualified first aider staff, i.e. if they call in sick that day?

As mentioned above, re railway stations, what about unmanned stations - are should we close them all?

What about council owned parks - sometimes there are no staff at all, other times, there'll just be gardeners - should one of them be first aid trained?

JennieTheZebra · 16/10/2022 20:15

I’m a student nurse and, as such, first aid trained and then some. If someone has an accident in front of us we’re obligated, by our Code, to offer help, regardless of who it is, as long as it’s safe to do so, and I think that’s how it should be.

Changingmynameyetagain · 16/10/2022 20:13

I work in a major supermarket and I’m 1st aid trained.
Officially I only have to respond to a staff 1st aid call but we also attend customers if they are injured because they are more likely to sue.

Intelligenthair · 16/10/2022 20:10

There are some right dickheads on this thread. I hope they encounter kinder strangers than they frankly deserve if they ever have an accident.

OP well done for helping, hope you’ve had a gin and the lady is ok. The state of first aid in this country is depressing, I think it should be mandatory in all public places.

GarlicCrackers · 16/10/2022 20:09

Mushroomlady · 16/10/2022 20:05

Thanks for the responses. This has been a bit of an eye opener! I'm now wondering about other places where I had always assumed staff were first aid trained, like shopping centres and football stadiums. Especially given various tragedies and terror attacks that have happened in the past, it surprises me to hear that the companies/organisations involved are not obligated or expected to provide first aid to the public.

Which station was it?

Mushroomlady · 16/10/2022 20:05

Thanks for the responses. This has been a bit of an eye opener! I'm now wondering about other places where I had always assumed staff were first aid trained, like shopping centres and football stadiums. Especially given various tragedies and terror attacks that have happened in the past, it surprises me to hear that the companies/organisations involved are not obligated or expected to provide first aid to the public.

OP posts:
hesbeingabitofadick · 16/10/2022 19:59

LittleScottieDog · 16/10/2022 19:02

As I understand it, there is no legal duty to provide first aiders for non-employees.

^this.

Public Sector first aiders are only "insured" to give aid to a colleague, and not the general public, unfortunately.

99problemsandaballisone · 16/10/2022 19:56

Well done OP and thank you for helping. I'm not great in a crisis but so grateful to people who are (yes I'm working on this!)

TulipCat · 16/10/2022 19:56

I think it's a nice-to-have from a bygone era when things weren't so tight in the budgets sadly. I don't think you can expect that any more.

Flapjacker48 · 16/10/2022 19:55

@Mushroomlady might surprise you but the vast majority of station/platform staff don't have the training to go on the track either.

SirGawain · 16/10/2022 19:51

AnotherDelphinium · 16/10/2022 19:14

YABU. The FAAW act covers employees, why would they want to administer first aid for a deliberately self-inflicted and avoidable injury? Yes, it should have gone in the accident book.

I imagine the station staff were pissed off frustrated with yet another member of the public who couldn’t be bothered to “waste their precious time” waiting for the next train, and instead ran or tried to stick their arms/belongings into closing doors.

There is something wrong with the public psyche that when they hear the “doors closing, STAND CLEAR” warning, they interpret it as “RUN FORREST RUN”.

This has to be the stupidest comment I've seen on Mumsnet in quite a while, and that's saying something! let's let it fall by the weight it's own folly.

Mushroomlady · 16/10/2022 19:50

namechange3394 · 16/10/2022 19:44

You understand that some stations don't have any staff at all, right?

Yes I am aware of that, thank you I obviously don't expect non-existent staff to be first aid trained 🙄

I just would have thought that at a busy staffed mainline train station there would be someone on duty that has been trained to deal with an emergency situation like an injured passenger. This is not some rural station, it has multiple platforms, a ticket office, lifts, shops, etc.

OP posts:
SmallPrawnEnergy · 16/10/2022 19:47

Tickledtrout · 16/10/2022 19:30

Of course yanbu OP. Posters pretending we're all cool with nobody having any duty of care for anyone else. It may we'll be permitted in law but it doesn't make for a decent or humane society.

OP asked if she should complain. People are responding with facts. You can be as morally outraged as you like but the facts are it’s pointless reporting it or complaining because the train station hasn’t done anything incorrect here. Surely you’re intelligent enough to understand that advising OP on the legalities of the situation doesn’t mean you can’t be annoyed by it.

Brefugee · 16/10/2022 19:46

I imagine the station staff were pissed off frustrated with yet another member of the public who couldn’t be bothered to “waste their precious time” waiting for the next train, and instead ran or tried to stick their arms/belongings into closing doors.

bollocks. Given that we sometimes don't even know when the next train is coming, and often have a ticket that is valid for that exact train and no other, or may be trying to make a flight etc etc, it is not beyond the bounds of possiblity that people might run for trains.

What the bigger problem is, imo, is the general lack of a) first aid knowledge and b) willingness to help among the general public.

On Look North the other night they were showing how (I think) Emergency crews went into hundreds of schools across Yorkshire to teach the children how to do CPR. And an interview with a woman who needed CPR when she collapsed while out with her children - luckily 2 passers by knew how to do it and called an ambulance.

thelobsterquadrille · 16/10/2022 19:45

Mushroomlady · 16/10/2022 19:43

To be clear, it is a mainline train station with hundreds of trains passing through every day. Trains arriving every 5-10 mins. At any one time it seems like there are at least 5 staff visibly on duty.

Five staff is nowhere near the recommended limit for having a first-aider on duty, though. It's a very small number in the grand scheme of things.

sausagepastapot · 16/10/2022 19:44

I'm more intrigued as to why you put her on her side if her knee was bleeding?

namechange3394 · 16/10/2022 19:44

Mushroomlady · 16/10/2022 19:06

Really? Whenever we run an event at work for the public we have to do a risk assessment and make sure there is a first aider on duty. And we're not dealing with live railway tracks!

You understand that some stations don't have any staff at all, right?

thelobsterquadrille · 16/10/2022 19:43

Cw112 · 16/10/2022 19:41

Surely if there's employees there then there should be a first aider amongst them though. We have a really small staff team so I'm first aid trained but the rest of the team aren't (one is being trained shortly because it does leave a gap if I have leave. I understand if it's an unmanned station though?

No - only if there's a certain number of employees and/or the workplace is considered dangerous.

I worked in a small shop with a team of 10 people. Nobody on site was first-aid trained. All we had to do was provide a basic first-aid kit that was checked every six months or so.

However when I worked in a large supermarket, there did have to be trained first-aiders on site, I believe because there were more than 25 employees and the risk of injury was greater (fires, burning on hot ovens etc).

Mushroomlady · 16/10/2022 19:43

To be clear, it is a mainline train station with hundreds of trains passing through every day. Trains arriving every 5-10 mins. At any one time it seems like there are at least 5 staff visibly on duty.

OP posts:
IncessantNameChanger · 16/10/2022 19:43

It seems for the previous posters that you should steped over her as it was all her own fault.

There's no staff at our station. I did first aid training at school for the pupils when I worked in a school. I guess that's why so many people don't know to do cpr? Not my problem, not my legal responsibility view? When my kids have hurt themselves in shops for example no one has ever said sorry your kids not staff.

Did the staff come over when you said call an ambulance? Maybe they are also of the mn mindset that only near death requires a hospital trip?

Swipe left for the next trending thread