Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I being unreasonable for wanting another child

169 replies

Wiluli · 16/10/2022 18:13

I’m almost 40 , I have 2 kids from a previous relationship and one with my partner and my partner has a teen daughter that we love .
I love him to bits and we have a great relationship been together 3 years . One of my oldest daughters has severe autism so she will always be in my care. prior to being with my current partner I was single for a long time , I always been in charge of rent my home ,car etc , I paid and pay my own bills my whole life .
Anyway my youngest is now 1 year old , I’m hitting my 40s and I feel like I found the love of my life so late that certain options where taken from us .
I had a pregnancy scare , I thought I was pregnant as I’m late 3 days ( I’m never late ) but the test was negative .
I feel both of us should be relieved , home is to small to add another kid ( only have 3ans half bedrooms ) and we rent so would mean a move , I just got a big promotion , I have enough on my plate , we are old etc etc etc , all the logical reasons !
But as soon as I his face I could see the disappointment and to be honest I was too .
Am I being completely irrational for wanting another child ?
I wish I had more time to decide but I know I won’t die to my age .

OP posts:
Wiluli · 18/10/2022 13:52

Theroad · 18/10/2022 10:41

Terrible idea. It's natural to feel disappointed when seeing a negative pregnancy test. I absolutely knew I didn't want a third child yet I still felt irrationally disappointed when I had a negative result following a pregnancy scare a few months ago.

it sounds like you're acutely aware of the ticking clock and your animal instincts are urging you to throw caution to the wind and keep repopulating the species! Don't do it. It's madness in your circumstances. There's four existing children to think about and also complex additional needs in the mix. I imagine things are already stretched for your DC in terms of time, attention, opportunities. Don't make life harder for them. Enough.

My children get plenty of attention , including individual attention and a few holiday and days out a year . I’m always amazed on how ableist people can be ( even if unintentionally so please don’t be offended it’s not towards you only but for a few replies here ) as soon as someone mentions special needs . Just because one of my children has autism doesn’t mean life is horrendous or that others don’t get attention or that we don’t do lots of things due to it .People really need to get away from the preconceived idea that special needs mean less quality of life , just because she is different doesn’t mean anyone around her is suffering .

OP posts:
Wiluli · 18/10/2022 13:46

mamabear715 · 18/10/2022 06:58

@Wiluli I have seven in total!
(Kind of like Hob Nobs, once you have one, you just keep on..) ;-)
My last one was with my then new DH, we waited for him for four years. DH died when 'baby' was six, so I feel so blessed to watch him growing up & see his Daddy in him. :-)
Everyone was against me having a baby at my age, but some things are meant to be. Utterly blessed!
Good luck, whatever you decide - let us know! Hugs x

I’m so sorry for your loss . That must have been so hard . Thank you for your kind words .

OP posts:
Theroad · 18/10/2022 10:41

Terrible idea. It's natural to feel disappointed when seeing a negative pregnancy test. I absolutely knew I didn't want a third child yet I still felt irrationally disappointed when I had a negative result following a pregnancy scare a few months ago.

it sounds like you're acutely aware of the ticking clock and your animal instincts are urging you to throw caution to the wind and keep repopulating the species! Don't do it. It's madness in your circumstances. There's four existing children to think about and also complex additional needs in the mix. I imagine things are already stretched for your DC in terms of time, attention, opportunities. Don't make life harder for them. Enough.

MrsSkylerWhite · 18/10/2022 10:34

You and the partner you’re very happy with have a family of 4 already. Count your blessings. Another would be a bad idea.

JorisBonson · 18/10/2022 10:32

What does your partner want?

Loachworks · 18/10/2022 10:27

I'd just imagine that in 20 year's time (twins are more likely post 40) you could potentially have two teenagers and an adult child reliant on you at sixty. I'm 50 and shattered now parenting two teens who are pretty much physically independent.
You can make amazing plans for the not inconsiderable family you already have. Concentrate on giving them a wonderful present and future. Perhaps if you didn't share a child with your partner now or your partner didn't have children then fair enough but the risks are too high to jeopardise your family dynamic especially if your child isn't born healthy.

Lcb123 · 18/10/2022 10:19

you're not unreasonable to want another, but do think about all the practical reasons you mentioned especially your older DD and her needs.

boredOf · 18/10/2022 10:12

No way terrible idea. Enjoy your family

mamabear715 · 18/10/2022 10:09

@Luredbyapomegranate They were spread out, yes, I'd like to be superhuman but am sadly not! ;-) Did have twins though.. :-0

Luredbyapomegranate · 18/10/2022 10:07

mamabear715 · 18/10/2022 06:58

@Wiluli I have seven in total!
(Kind of like Hob Nobs, once you have one, you just keep on..) ;-)
My last one was with my then new DH, we waited for him for four years. DH died when 'baby' was six, so I feel so blessed to watch him growing up & see his Daddy in him. :-)
Everyone was against me having a baby at my age, but some things are meant to be. Utterly blessed!
Good luck, whatever you decide - let us know! Hugs x

Few people could effectively parent 7 children though, unless they were literally spread across 30 years.

I’m not suggesting you can’t, but most people couldn’t.

Luredbyapomegranate · 18/10/2022 10:05

I don’t think you have the capacity for another child. It wouldn’t be fair to the kids you have.

Lots of people get these feelings at the end of their fertile life and after a pregnancy scare - it will pass. (Get a puppy.)

SleeplessInEngland · 18/10/2022 10:02

Obviously you shouldn't have another.

Wiluli · 18/10/2022 10:01

user1471457751 · 18/10/2022 05:57

But before your partner moved in was when you only had 2 kids and before the cost of living crisis. So if you had a fourth and separated then it wouldn't be like it was before your partner moved in. You could potentially be looking at full-time childcare for two pre-schoolers - would you really be able to afford that?

Yes I could , none of mine go to nursery full time as I work mostly from home . It’s exhausting but doable if I needed it , I had to do it with my now 5 year old . I also earned considerably less when I had 2 children ( 16 k a year less ) .

OP posts:
mamabear715 · 18/10/2022 06:58

@Wiluli I have seven in total!
(Kind of like Hob Nobs, once you have one, you just keep on..) ;-)
My last one was with my then new DH, we waited for him for four years. DH died when 'baby' was six, so I feel so blessed to watch him growing up & see his Daddy in him. :-)
Everyone was against me having a baby at my age, but some things are meant to be. Utterly blessed!
Good luck, whatever you decide - let us know! Hugs x

user1471457751 · 18/10/2022 05:57

But before your partner moved in was when you only had 2 kids and before the cost of living crisis. So if you had a fourth and separated then it wouldn't be like it was before your partner moved in. You could potentially be looking at full-time childcare for two pre-schoolers - would you really be able to afford that?

Wiluli · 18/10/2022 00:26

mamabear715 · 17/10/2022 19:34

Up to you! It sounds to me like your hearts are telling you to go for it? :-)
My last baby was born when I was 45. :-) Not a MOMENT'S regret.

Awww congratulations. How many other kids do you have , if it’s ok to ask ?

OP posts:
Wiluli · 18/10/2022 00:25

NCFT0922 · 17/10/2022 17:00

Already paid for what home? You rent? And how do 3 children have their own rooms in a 3 bed house? Do you not have a bedroom? if you didn’t want opinions then why post on mumsnet? Not wanting a mortgage at 40 is a silly reason to rent all your life; yes all your life including past retirement. You may still be supporting a child through university in your 60s too. A cinema / bar isn’t a good bedroom for a teen, though of course they love it. Where would a new baby sleep?

I said 3 and half bedrooms , I will explain the whole top floor of the house are 2 double bedrooms with a bathroom at the end , so you must go through the first one to get to the second but still with a door completely separate large bedrooms . Then 2 other double bedrooms .
I rent because I moved country within the U.K. and didn’t want to buy yet , I can afford to build?, it’s been out on hold due to partner moving in 3 years ago and then covid .
And the teen is fine that way for now , it’s his choice ( the bar is locked I should add when he is here ) . The way you speak is if we live in deep poverty ! I said in my post I’ve always paid my own things even without my partner , so people could understand financially we are ok . We are not rich but money is not into consideration for this decision . And yes off course you are entitled to your opinion . But you are making it sound like I will somehow be taking from what our children physically need to have another and it’s not the case at all . I would never jeopardise the children we have .

OP posts:
mamabear715 · 17/10/2022 19:34

Up to you! It sounds to me like your hearts are telling you to go for it? :-)
My last baby was born when I was 45. :-) Not a MOMENT'S regret.

inheritanceshiteagain · 17/10/2022 19:13

Wiluli · 17/10/2022 10:56

Ok I m thankful for all replies .
But just want to say , I have no idea where people got the idea I can’t afford another child or that we are struggling. We are not . Not rich but comfortable . So a financia reason is not really existent.

Maybe you should read you own post. You rent. Hardly financial stability for a 40 something family wanting another child.

Figgygal · 17/10/2022 17:57

God no
Bad idea for so many reasons
You have one together already put all the existing children first

Popgoestheweaselagain · 17/10/2022 17:48

If your partner was also disappointed, I think that makes all the difference. Maybe you should talk to him about it and see how he really feels? If you both want to go for it and think you can make it work, that's what matters. I know couples who had another child for exactly this reason - they miscarried an unplanned and were so disappointed that tried again.

I would really like to have another, but my husband is sure he can't cope. If he felt we could make it work together, that would make all the difference for me.

ChagSameachDoreen · 17/10/2022 17:39

YABVU.

LimpBiskit · 17/10/2022 17:26

Completely your call but if I had your set of circumstances, I'd not want another child. I'd be enjoying the family I'd already got without the added pressure of another child.

NCFT0922 · 17/10/2022 17:00

Already paid for what home? You rent? And how do 3 children have their own rooms in a 3 bed house? Do you not have a bedroom? if you didn’t want opinions then why post on mumsnet? Not wanting a mortgage at 40 is a silly reason to rent all your life; yes all your life including past retirement. You may still be supporting a child through university in your 60s too. A cinema / bar isn’t a good bedroom for a teen, though of course they love it. Where would a new baby sleep?

Wiluli · 17/10/2022 16:17

NCFT0922 · 17/10/2022 14:07

Of course the financial reason is existent; you rent!
YABU to want another child. There are already 4 children, big age gaps, who have to share rooms and what sounds like a cramped, unsecure house.
what if you have to move and the only ones available are even smaller? What if it’s a flat and you’ve no outdoor space for 5 children?
I would focus on your existing children and I say this as a mother of 4 but in admittedly very different circs.

Im sorry you are of course entitled to your opinion but you are being a bit creative with interpretation. we rent because we both sold previous homes ( well he is still selling ) and don’t what a mortgage starting at 40 ! We talked about building our own in the future mortgage free, but still we live in a long term rental , why dobrou see that as us being financially unstable is beyond me , over 35% of the U.K. population rents . Also none of our children share rooms . Only 3 live with us full time and they all have their own bedrooms and when the step child visits they have the converted garage currently a cinema /bar room as he prefers it that way .
We live in a detached farm and we would never move to a flat I should add , the house is not massive but by no means cramped either . I already paid for this home when my partner moved so if we whereby separate ( which I’m in no way expecting ) I’m absolutely fine paying for all bills alone as I’ve done it before, I have a very secure career .

OP posts: