Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I being unreasonable for wanting another child

169 replies

Wiluli · 16/10/2022 18:13

I’m almost 40 , I have 2 kids from a previous relationship and one with my partner and my partner has a teen daughter that we love .
I love him to bits and we have a great relationship been together 3 years . One of my oldest daughters has severe autism so she will always be in my care. prior to being with my current partner I was single for a long time , I always been in charge of rent my home ,car etc , I paid and pay my own bills my whole life .
Anyway my youngest is now 1 year old , I’m hitting my 40s and I feel like I found the love of my life so late that certain options where taken from us .
I had a pregnancy scare , I thought I was pregnant as I’m late 3 days ( I’m never late ) but the test was negative .
I feel both of us should be relieved , home is to small to add another kid ( only have 3ans half bedrooms ) and we rent so would mean a move , I just got a big promotion , I have enough on my plate , we are old etc etc etc , all the logical reasons !
But as soon as I his face I could see the disappointment and to be honest I was too .
Am I being completely irrational for wanting another child ?
I wish I had more time to decide but I know I won’t die to my age .

OP posts:
MilkToastHoney · 20/10/2022 16:12

If you had another baby now, you’d have a 6 and 2 year old plus baby, is that right?

That’s similar to age gaps I have and 2 young ones plus baby is HARD. 3 growing up with those age gals is really hard.
I’d completely underestimated what adding one more would mean in terms of time, balancing everyone’s needs etc.

I’m not saying don’t do it, only you know what’s right for you. Just don’t underestimate how difficult it can be emotionally having 3 young ones. The constant demands can be relentless, managing giving them all enough quality time plus time for yourself so you aren’t burnt out is so much harder than I’d ever anticipated.
Plus financially, I know you are not struggling in this area and fortunately we don’t either but the cost of one more in terms of holidays, days out, meals out is noticeable, especially as they get older. The cost of their activities etc is also very noticeable with one more.

I definitely do not want any more but I’ve felt very upset when had a scare/negative pregnancy test. I do think how lovely another baby would be, wouldn’t it be amazing for them to have another sibling. I think that is a normal biological feeling when we get into our 40’s. It’s about separating what that biological pull of ‘one more baby’ is and what you actually want and could give practically to another child.

Best of luck whatever you decide.

Wiluli · 20/10/2022 15:23

washingbasketqueen · 20/10/2022 12:43

Genuine question- what do you think another child will give you that you don't already get from your current dc? 4 children between you two to support is a lot. Your children have siblings, you have a dc with your current partner, you have a busy life, why do you want to add to that? I'd enjoy the children you have.

Why does anyone have siblings then, shouldn’t we all just have one or 2 children, tops ? Because I would like the youngest ones to have closer siblings in age . I see the benefits the 5 year old has from the 1 year old and I believe another child would be as beneficial. Not the single reason of course . I have more time now , that I did nit until this last baby too so that is something I’m taking in account too

OP posts:
Wiluli · 20/10/2022 15:17

BeanieTeen · 20/10/2022 07:56

I guess the one thing I’ve learned is people seem to really dislike large families and to think children suffer with each sibling . Maybe because I only had 1 sibling and think I would have loved more , I can’t quite grasp why would be unfair on the siblings to have a brother or sister ?

Not always, for sure. But often there is suffering. People who work with children from large families - teachers, social workers for example - have a lot of experience with this. You seem very naive in thinking children lose nothing - money and time is not infinite for anyone, and for many children another sibling means less time from parents, less care, less help with homework, less emotional support, less toys, less clothes, less experiences and sadly more responsibility as they help to look after younger siblings. You might be fine OP, that’s for you to decide - but your reasons for wanting another child really don’t sound rational or sensible, you sound like an immature girl who wants to cement her relationship with a baby but you are nearing forty and should know better quite frankly. There is good reason why people aren’t encouraging you to go for it.

oh please !! Sound like a child ? I already have a child with my current partner , even if I had none I would not need to cement anything . I’ve been a single mum for 14 years prior to this relationship , I do not need children to cement a relationship , why would I ? If anything children put strain on relationships not the opposite . And honestly you are being plain rude ! I questioned why people have an issue with big families , that was a simple question .

OP posts:
NCFT0922 · 20/10/2022 13:23

@Univalve no, you’re not reading it right.

washingbasketqueen · 20/10/2022 12:43

Genuine question- what do you think another child will give you that you don't already get from your current dc? 4 children between you two to support is a lot. Your children have siblings, you have a dc with your current partner, you have a busy life, why do you want to add to that? I'd enjoy the children you have.

Univalve · 20/10/2022 12:27

OP shouldn’t have a baby because she rents?! Am I actually reading this right? Should we just sterilise everyone below a certain income bracket and get it over with then?

OP have a baby if you want one! I’m sure he or she would be wanted and loved, and I’m certainly sure they wouldn’t care if you owned your own house or not!

AloysiusBear · 20/10/2022 12:16

You are bonkers tbh op. Don't do it.

vivainsomnia · 20/10/2022 12:13

Thank you all . I guess the one thing I’ve learned is people seem to really dislike large families and to think children suffer with each sibling
I think it's because there are so many threads by women with disabled children or who have three kids or more who post about difficult situations they find themselves in when at the time of conception, everything was fine.

Be it a change in finances, housing, relationship, family or health and don't accept that part of the reason they are in a mess is the decision they made at the time.

At 40, I felt I could cope with 3 more children, 5 years later and in the mist of a very bad premenopause, I struggle to cope with my life with my two older children and thanked destiny that I hadn't had another. Things can change very quickly and sometimes accepting how fortunate we already are is the best move forward for all.

Aria2015 · 20/10/2022 12:03

Regards your last post, I'm 1 of 4 and I love my siblings BUT growing up my parents just couldn't give me the attention I wanted (deserved). It's naive to think that adding an extra person to a household won't take anything away from existing children. It takes away physical space, it takes away time and attention, it takes away money.

I have spoken to others from similar size families and most have felt the same as me. It's no issue as an adult, but as a child (when you need attention the most) parents were just too stretched. Since I can remember I've always said i’d never have more than 2 for that reason. I have definitely wanted more (especially approaching 40!) but giving the 2 I have as much as attention as I can manage trumps that desire every time.

NCFT0922 · 20/10/2022 10:56

You can’t of read my posts properly; I pointed out I have 4 children. I have absolutely nothing against large families and am from one myself; I have 3 siblings and a foster sibling and absolutely adore being part of a big family. I just pointed out that I personally don’t feel your circumstances are ideal for having another child.

Popgoestheweaselagain · 20/10/2022 09:24

Wiluli · 19/10/2022 22:57

Thank you all . I guess the one thing I’ve learned is people seem to really dislike large families and to think children suffer with each sibling . Maybe because I only had 1 sibling and think I would have loved more , I can’t quite grasp why would be unfair on the siblings to have a brother or sister ? It’s not like they would loose anything . I respect everyone’s opinions ( apart from the person who constantly attacked me and called me a liar ) but I do wonder why people feel siblings loose by having other siblings ? Is it attention people worry or materialistic reasons ?

I'm a bit surprised by that too. I had an accidental sibling and thought it was the best thing ever. Only my parents worried we would suffer. Mind you, I never missed out on school trips or anything really important. There was still money for music lessons. I didn't have loads of stuff or new clothes or expensive holidays, but it never occurred to me that my sibling was depriving me if that- we didn't have it because we didn't need it. Many of my friends were much worse off than me and had to share rooms with siblings, but I'm not sure I would define that as suffering.

BeanieTeen · 20/10/2022 07:56

I guess the one thing I’ve learned is people seem to really dislike large families and to think children suffer with each sibling . Maybe because I only had 1 sibling and think I would have loved more , I can’t quite grasp why would be unfair on the siblings to have a brother or sister ?

Not always, for sure. But often there is suffering. People who work with children from large families - teachers, social workers for example - have a lot of experience with this. You seem very naive in thinking children lose nothing - money and time is not infinite for anyone, and for many children another sibling means less time from parents, less care, less help with homework, less emotional support, less toys, less clothes, less experiences and sadly more responsibility as they help to look after younger siblings. You might be fine OP, that’s for you to decide - but your reasons for wanting another child really don’t sound rational or sensible, you sound like an immature girl who wants to cement her relationship with a baby but you are nearing forty and should know better quite frankly. There is good reason why people aren’t encouraging you to go for it.

Meili04 · 19/10/2022 23:07

Why do people feel the need to procreate in every relationship they have? You have 4 children between you already it's enough.

cuju2407 · 19/10/2022 23:04

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 19/10/2022 23:01

Well, they’ll lose space, time and money being spent on them. And frankly, just because you as a child idly considered having another sibling would have been nice doesn’t mean any of your children feel the same.

Ultimately, you’re trying to justify something you can’t - because having kids is the ultimate in selfish endeavours. I don’t mean that in a mean way, just that the only reason people have children is because they want to. There’s nothing wrong with that, but you have to accept that other people are not going to agree with your choices. Especially when you already have a large family.

Completely ridiculous! Nothing wrong with having a larger family nor does it make her selfish for wanting one 🙄

toomuchlaundry · 19/10/2022 23:04

Quite a few people on MN post how they didn’t like being part of a large family. Not all children like a busy noisy environment, some like their own space. Having more and more siblings added to the mix is not always a blessing to some.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 19/10/2022 23:01

Well, they’ll lose space, time and money being spent on them. And frankly, just because you as a child idly considered having another sibling would have been nice doesn’t mean any of your children feel the same.

Ultimately, you’re trying to justify something you can’t - because having kids is the ultimate in selfish endeavours. I don’t mean that in a mean way, just that the only reason people have children is because they want to. There’s nothing wrong with that, but you have to accept that other people are not going to agree with your choices. Especially when you already have a large family.

Wiluli · 19/10/2022 22:57

Thank you all . I guess the one thing I’ve learned is people seem to really dislike large families and to think children suffer with each sibling . Maybe because I only had 1 sibling and think I would have loved more , I can’t quite grasp why would be unfair on the siblings to have a brother or sister ? It’s not like they would loose anything . I respect everyone’s opinions ( apart from the person who constantly attacked me and called me a liar ) but I do wonder why people feel siblings loose by having other siblings ? Is it attention people worry or materialistic reasons ?

OP posts:
Realityloom · 19/10/2022 18:53

cuju2407 · 19/10/2022 18:42

@Realityloom no didn't miss it. Plenty of people have at least a 2 year age gap between their kids! I am pretty sure she is aware of that too.

Yes they do. But OP circumstances are not what you are describing though. Not arguing with you it's not fair on her other kids and she has one with additional needs. The youngest is only 1 and she doesn't know what the future holds. What about the eldest child also? Each to their own and all that.

cuju2407 · 19/10/2022 18:42

@Realityloom no didn't miss it. Plenty of people have at least a 2 year age gap between their kids! I am pretty sure she is aware of that too.

BeanieTeen · 19/10/2022 18:34

No. It would be really selfish of you all things considered, especially the children you already have.

Realityloom · 19/10/2022 18:32

cuju2407 · 19/10/2022 17:10

Some of these comments are unbelievable! Op has 3 children already including the fact she's raised a child with additional support needs. I am pretty sure she knows what is ahead of her if she has another child. I think she has already proved she's quite capable

Did you miss her youngest is only 1 years old?

Realityloom · 19/10/2022 18:27

@Wiluli there's no snobbery from me about renting. I rent also however we are living in testing times and recently I have started to save for my child and worry about how he would afford to leave home.... there's no way my Son would get a Council house like how I did when I was 20 once he turns 20.

I don't think anybody has suggested you wouldn't love another potential child.

Wiluli · 19/10/2022 17:51

Realityloom · 19/10/2022 17:23

Your youngest is only 1 years old. The rental market is crazy. Its not fair on the kids you already have and its not as though you don't have a baby with your current partner. Count your blessings! Think, you will still be doing the school run in your late 40s. Utter madness in the nicest way

Thanks for your input . We won’t be renting forever or even long term . I have land , the reason we are yet to build is when I moved to Scotland from England I decided the planning permission on the house that was in place was not what I wanted so we started a new one but covid hit so I withdrew the applications just a couple of weeks after it was logged so it wouldn’t lapse . Since then partner moved in and obviously the family changed so the drawings and plans need to be redone and all that and building takes time .
I know for a fact I would love another child and that we have enough time an solve for one , ideally that would have been in my forever home but at almost 40 I do t have the luxury of time to wait until all is “ perfect “

OP posts:
Realityloom · 19/10/2022 17:23

Wiluli · 17/10/2022 10:56

Ok I m thankful for all replies .
But just want to say , I have no idea where people got the idea I can’t afford another child or that we are struggling. We are not . Not rich but comfortable . So a financia reason is not really existent.

Your youngest is only 1 years old. The rental market is crazy. Its not fair on the kids you already have and its not as though you don't have a baby with your current partner. Count your blessings! Think, you will still be doing the school run in your late 40s. Utter madness in the nicest way

cuju2407 · 19/10/2022 17:10

Some of these comments are unbelievable! Op has 3 children already including the fact she's raised a child with additional support needs. I am pretty sure she knows what is ahead of her if she has another child. I think she has already proved she's quite capable