Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Phone anxiety..... is this a thing

160 replies

Firefightress1 · 16/10/2022 17:46

I'm prepared to be educated but I've been helping a friend recruit for a job in a hotel. She created a job advert and we posted it online and on social media.

It gave details about the job and she had put her phone number to call to apply or for further info. She wanted to talk to candidates as its the way she has always recruited. It might be old school, I don't know.

Anyway, She had a lot of responses on Facebook and through private messages but no calls.
I replied on the post just to say to call the phone number as its quicker and she might not monitor replies and I was met with a barrage of unkind comments.

A majority saying they cannot phone as they have phone anxiety, this is a recognised trait and I should be more understanding. The job involves answering the phone in occasion and making outgoing calls to suppliers.

I'm so confused, I've never heard of it!
Everyone has a mobile phone but does no one actually make calls anymore?
I'm only 40 so not ancient but I'm no spring chicken either.
Just wondering if I'm totally unreasonable? How can they do the a job if they can't even call to apply. I'm 😕

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TorviShieldMaiden · 17/10/2022 10:41

Yep, as I said above- I've worked in a contact centre and on a switch board/reception. Totally different to calling someone off the hoof, to talk about myself etc. I won't pone for takeaways or anything, but fine using teh phone at work.

At work I have a professional mask. I have an opener that I always say, I am relatively confident I will know how to deal with the conversation/questions. Even at work I'm much better at answering calls, than making them.

Pinkdelight3 · 17/10/2022 08:46

Just to say - it doesn't automatically make someone incompatible with a job involving phonecalls. I hate using the phone 'as myself' and avoid it at all costs, but in a job I can make and take calls because I'm in that role. The 'mask' or perhaps empowerment of the positions means I can cope with it much better. So I wouldn't want to call for more info as would correspond much better in writing, but I'd be fine to do the job, which may well be the case with many applicants.

RampantIvy · 17/10/2022 08:39

If people who are incapable of using a phone are put off applying for a job that involves using the phone then that's a good thing as it wastes neither person's time

Exactly.

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 17/10/2022 08:15

spiderlight · 17/10/2022 08:09

I would absolutely never ever ever apply! I used to have a job that involved a lot of phone calls and I hated it.

You're saying that like there's a failing in the process

If people who are incapable of using a phone are put off applying for a job that involves using the phone then that's a good thing as it wastes neither person's time

spiderlight · 17/10/2022 08:09

Firefightress1 · 16/10/2022 18:22

Thanks for your input, would you apply for a job that requires you to talk on the phone or would you avoid it like the plague

I would absolutely never ever ever apply! I used to have a job that involved a lot of phone calls and I hated it.

iamnotacatt · 17/10/2022 07:33

Those people need to get over themselves, and I say that as someone who has 'phone anxiety'

JustDanceAddict · 17/10/2022 06:53

I’m in my 50s and have always had it to some extent.
Never answered phone as a child. As a teen I did but it was usually for me!
Love mobiles as you know it’s for you and:or who it is.
i manage at work but it’s definitely my least favoured communication method. I always email if I can.

BooksAndHooks · 17/10/2022 06:48

GuyMontag · 16/10/2022 19:04

It's become a thing since texting apps/customer service portals got more widespread. People have got out of the habit of talking on the phone and now experience feelings of discomfort when they do it, because it's an unusual activity for them, and those feelings are labelled as anxiety. There's also an element (ironically) of social contagion as there is with much self diagnosis.

No it has always been an issue before internet and become mobile phones. Previously you would have dealt with things by post or in person to avoid the phone. Think just more people are open about it now.

strawberrytilda · 16/10/2022 21:13

I am a similar age to you and I absolutely hate it. It's weird because when I was a child I would have over two hour phone calls with my best friends most nights! Of course I can do it if I have to but I would always prefer email or text message. In fact, I'm just booking my dd's birthday party entertainer and ruled one out because she only had a phone number rather than an email option. If I really wanted the job I would phone though but it might sway me to not pursue the job.

PinkArt · 16/10/2022 21:06

All the more reason to get as many applications as possible then if the employee pool is small, surely.
A lot of people on the thread have said similar, but personally I've found coping strategies for when I'm in jobs that involve more calls. I've even worked on reception desks in my time so it's not a case of literally never being able to speak on the phone ever. More that I hate it and it massively raises my anxiety levels. But for it to be the first hurdle to a job, I think I'd just avoid that one and apply for something else instead as I know I'd be so far from my best in a phone application.

TheHateIsNotGood · 16/10/2022 21:01

Call me old-fashioned but if I could just make a call as part of the 'first sift' then I'm fine with that. Even a bit handy if an essential job requirement includes "good telephone manner".

But it's probably down to location - where I live (north Devon, but not Barnstaple) decent jobs are so scarce it's a rare thing to phone for a job - normally there's several hideous layers of 'sifting' first.

No idea telephone anxiety was a thing, but then I could aver that FB, Insta and Pintoboring gave me anxiety instead of admitting I just think they're fluffy-stupid and don't use them.

LondonQueen · 16/10/2022 20:56

If they have to use the phone as part of the job then it's clearly unsuitable for them if they have phone anxiety. I don't like making phone calls but needs must!

Firefightress1 · 16/10/2022 20:52

PinkArt · 16/10/2022 20:43

I'm a couple of years older than you, OP and have had phone anxiety for years. Since I was a kid. I will always avoid making a call if there is any other option - thank god for Deliveroo, Uber etc!
Are phone applications an old fashioned thing though or are they a local thing? I've never heard of that as a process. I was first applying for jobs in the late 90s by dropping my Saturday job paper CV into local shops and then in the early 00s posting it to potential employers, progressing to email with a couple of years.
I work in TV, which recruitments at very short notice and can't remotely see the benefit of phone applications. I've had to do similar once, when I needed several people to start in about 12 hours time but still got CVs emailed in for me to then to a 5 min phone interview with. It's massively more time consuming for both the employer and the potential employees to start the process with a call. Not to mention opening the company up to potential discrimination charges.
Aside from all of that though, your friend desperately needs staff and the overwhelming feedback she's getting from people job hunting in the area is that this process doesn't really appeal to them. Isn't it worth amending it to something that does, if she really needs to get those applications in fast, in big numbers?

Unfortunately it will never be big numbers due to the area, but if its phone anxiety that's an issue then surely its more of a waste of time if people can't or won't answer the phone. I've passed everyone's advice on.

OP posts:
PinkArt · 16/10/2022 20:43

I'm a couple of years older than you, OP and have had phone anxiety for years. Since I was a kid. I will always avoid making a call if there is any other option - thank god for Deliveroo, Uber etc!
Are phone applications an old fashioned thing though or are they a local thing? I've never heard of that as a process. I was first applying for jobs in the late 90s by dropping my Saturday job paper CV into local shops and then in the early 00s posting it to potential employers, progressing to email with a couple of years.
I work in TV, which recruitments at very short notice and can't remotely see the benefit of phone applications. I've had to do similar once, when I needed several people to start in about 12 hours time but still got CVs emailed in for me to then to a 5 min phone interview with. It's massively more time consuming for both the employer and the potential employees to start the process with a call. Not to mention opening the company up to potential discrimination charges.
Aside from all of that though, your friend desperately needs staff and the overwhelming feedback she's getting from people job hunting in the area is that this process doesn't really appeal to them. Isn't it worth amending it to something that does, if she really needs to get those applications in fast, in big numbers?

girlfriend44 · 16/10/2022 20:43

It's because everyone's into messaging and emailing now. Shame.

RampantIvy · 16/10/2022 20:43

So many weird experiences trying to phone friends on their landlines only for random family members to answer and pretend the person didn't exist or have to have excruciating conversations with them.

I think your friends had weird family members. I remember chatting for hours with my school friends back in the 1970s. I never had any of their family members doing this.

Firefightress1 · 16/10/2022 20:38

silverclock222 · 16/10/2022 20:25

"she didn't provide an email or ask for private messages. It clearly says call in to the hotel to apply or call the number" In that case she won't have received any of the emails or messages then will she :)

The advert is on the business Facebook which has a private message and email option.

OP posts:
Ccoffee · 16/10/2022 20:35

'Phone anxiety' is nothing new, I started work in the 80s and remember my manager forcing me to make calls to try and make me get over it.

In my 50s now and still hate it - I zone out and lose the thread of the conversation, talk over people, there are awkward silences, I'm always asking people to repeat themselves as I haven't taken in the info quickly enough.

Thankfully my current job is no phone calls, just pre-arranged zooms (I'm fine if I can see the person's face and body language) and lots of emails (I write far more quickly and articulately than I speak).

KhaleesiOfChaos · 16/10/2022 20:31

Firefightress1 · 16/10/2022 18:15

Where has it come from though, before smart phones and laptops we only had the phone. My mum n dad used to go ballistic because I spent to long talking on the phone. It's amazing that this is now a real issue

That's exactly where the fear came from! So many weird experiences trying to phone friends on their landlines only for random family members to answer and pretend the person didn't exist or have to have excruciating conversations with them. It instilled a massive dislike / fear of phones for me as a teenager.

I got over it when I started working in offices etc as I had no choice.

RampantIvy · 16/10/2022 20:31

If someone literally can't phone, I would wonder why they are applying for a job that involves using the phone.

I agree. My job is internet based, but we have regular Teams calls, and the odd telephone call.

KhaleesiOfChaos · 16/10/2022 20:28

I'm 41 so the same age as you and phone fear was definitely a thing for me and several others when I was younger. But it also doesn't help that your friend is approaching this in an unusual way.

Did she not give an email address in the ad at all? She wanted to waste her time speaking to 100% of all applicants? If so, that's an odd way to approach it, so I'm not surprised she hasn't had much interest.

Surely the logical thing to do is get applicants to email in their CV then arrange to phone the shortlisted people at a convenient time, ie how job searches are usually carried out. She still gets to speak to people but in a more controlled way.

silverclock222 · 16/10/2022 20:25

"she didn't provide an email or ask for private messages. It clearly says call in to the hotel to apply or call the number" In that case she won't have received any of the emails or messages then will she :)

user1745 · 16/10/2022 20:16

Phone anxiety is a thing, especially among the young who are used to communicating by text or email.

Personally I prefer to communicate via text-based means rather than the phone where possible. It's just easier, less stressful, more time to consider your answer rather than being put on the spot. However that doesn't mean I can't phone. If a job advert asked for calls rather than any other contact method I would phone. If someone literally can't phone, I would wonder why they are applying for a job that involves using the phone.

BaileySharp · 16/10/2022 20:07

I hate phone calls, but I do sometimes have to make them. If I wanted a job and was told the only way to apply was to call then i would (or wouldnt apply for the job) I think candidates unwilling to phone are making it easier for recruitment as they won't be suitable for the job

BadNomad · 16/10/2022 20:05

"Answering and making phone calls" as part of a job is different, though. That will be about specific things which follow a "script". People with social anxiety/ASH/ADHD might be able to handle that.

Spontaneous calls, calls to people they don't know, calls about themselves, calls where they will be required to listen or respond while panicking are the ones that are avoided.