Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was I rude/wrong in this situation?

457 replies

clankist · 16/10/2022 16:20

Was out walking my two seven month chihuahuas today. I have treated them like dogs from day one and they are very well trained. They walk off lead absolutely fine and don't bother other dogs at all, however if a dog comes running over to them they will bolt.

Today I was walking them off lead and there were two big golden retriever with two women who were chatting. We were quite a distance away but one of the retrievers started barking and running towards me/my dogs. I put my hand out in a 'stop' motion as it got closer. I said, 'stop' and when that didn't work I said 'no'. That didn't work either and my dogs started to run away.

I moved away from the dogs and began to call for my dogs but the retriever kept following me so my dogs were standing watching at a distance but wouldn't come over due to the dog being next to me. I shouted across to the woman, 'can you please get your dog?' No reply and she continued talking.

I moved away again, calling my dogs and the dog followed me again. I looked at the lady and shouted, 'can you get your dog?' She didn't move.

I moved away again and the dog followed once again, at this point I was exasperated and said a little sternly, 'will You move your dog!?'

She came over and said, 'my dog isn't anywhere near your dogs' rudely.

I said, 'yeah because they ran away terrified due to your dog coming up to them. If your dog is off lead it shouldn't be running up to my dogs'

She went to say something but I just held up my hand and said, 'thank you'.

I then continued my walk with my dogs and the lady met another dog walker who then started pointing to me and shaking their head.

Did I do the right thing to deal with this situation or was I too sensitive? I just think you shouldn't have your dog off the lead unless you know they will not approach any other dogs without permission.

OP posts:
Brigante9 · 16/10/2022 16:37

Putting up your hand was extremely impolite. As everyone has said, if your dogs are a flight risk, they ought to be on the lead. If a dog is off lead, I expect it to be non-aggressive and able to cope with other dogs off lead coming up to it. One of mine is worried about bigger dogs but he’ll just stand to the side, there’s no running away.

RebelliousStarrChild · 16/10/2022 16:37

I would say you shouldn't have your dog off lead in a public place at all unless they return when called immediately. Which means technically you were both in the wrong. She wasn't paying attention to her dog and therefore her dog wasn't under her control and equally you are aware that in certain situations your dogs will run away when approached by larger dogs, so I would think it's unsafe for them to also be off lead in a place where there will likely be other dogs around. Situations happen and we learn from them going forward, be glad that nothing bad happened to any of the dogs and in future do what you can to prevent your dogs from being able to run too far away from you, like using a retractable lead for example

PotteringAlonggotkickedoutandhadtoreregister · 16/10/2022 16:37

Yes you were rude
yes you were wrong to have your dogs off the lead without full control.

Randomness12 · 16/10/2022 16:36

Both sets of dogs off lead, so you should be expecting interaction - which is what happened.

Your dogs being by nervous of others means they should be on a lead im
afraid. What happens if your dogs run into a road? Other dogs likely take the running away as part of playing so they are likely to be chased.

IMO you were in the wrong, not her. yes, she could have called her dogs when you asked but she wasn’t unreasonable to assume they wanted to play because they weren’t on a lead. This is your issue.

fruitstick · 16/10/2022 16:35

You were rude and unreasonable.

My dog is very friendly and often goes up to other dogs when he is off lead.

If another dog is on lead, then I will put him back on his lead or recall him. That's the signal to other dog owners that they don't want to be approached.

I don't know of any dog trained not to approach another off lead dog without permission.

If your dogs are anxious and bolt when other dogs go near them, they should be on a lead.

No stranger's dog is going to understand stop if they haven't been trained to understand that word. And stop what?

If the dogs were nowhere near your dog, it would have been difficult to understand what you were expecting.

Putting your hand up to someone is incredibly rude and disrespectful.

PugInTheHouse · 16/10/2022 16:35

Sorry I thought I had added in my first post that the other owner doesn't sound like she had control either as even if her dog had approached yours she should have beenable to recall it straight away also.

Bettyboop3 · 16/10/2022 16:34

I totally agree with you OP, your dogs were minding their own business and should not have to tolerate unwelcome dogs off lead and in their faces. This absolutely infuriates me and i would have been a lot ruder!!

dadumdedum · 16/10/2022 16:34

If you don't want other dogs to come up to them, you need to keep them on a lead.

She should've got her dog though when you asked

You shouldn't have put your hand up in front of her face.

Malfi · 16/10/2022 16:34

YABU. Your dogs shouldn’t be off lead if they might bolt -they aren’t well trained. And it’s rude to put your hand up to someone. But the other dog wasn’t under control either.

PugInTheHouse · 16/10/2022 16:33

Oh and yes you were really rude.

Skatewing · 16/10/2022 16:33

Dogs should be on leads unless they are in an area that caters for them such as a dog park or that the owner can 100% guarantee their dogs recall.
I say this as a dog owner.
Too many people allow their dogs to pester other dogs and humans.

Im restricted to where I can walk my dogs as they are constantly pestered by other dogs and ignorant owners telling me they are only saying their unwanted hello. I have a blind and partially deaf dog that finds this worrying.

PugInTheHouse · 16/10/2022 16:33

Surely the etiquette is if your dogs are on lead then you wouldn't expect off lead dogs to approach at all, if they are off lead then I would expect that other off lead dogs approaching them wouldn't be a particular issue. Personally do train my dogs to wait till I tell them to go over regardless of on or off lead but it certainly wouldn't be a huge concern to me if another off lead dog approached them.

As yours don't have reliable recall and run off then I don't think they are trained enough to be off lead TBH.

Johnnysgirl · 16/10/2022 16:33

You don't have full control of your dogs, so they shouldn't be off lead.
Yes, you were rude, both in the way you spoke to the woman, and for expecting her to solve your problem for you.

Remagirl · 16/10/2022 16:33

Context required. If you were in a field, park or country setting I would have just walked a different way. If you were on a pavement or close to a hazard you should have your dogs on a lead as should the other dog owner.

Oysterbabe · 16/10/2022 16:32

Your dogs should not be off lead if they will bolt. Off lead dogs play or are recalled if another dog approaches.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 16/10/2022 16:32

Your dogs shouldn't be off if they bolt op. That's dangerous.

But no, other people's dogs shouldn't approach either without the ok from you

Ponderingwindow · 16/10/2022 16:30

Dogs should only be off lead if you have 100% control.

the woman should not be letting her dog approach you. She didn’t have her dog under control by either lead or voice command.

SerenaTee · 16/10/2022 16:30

Sounds like your dogs need to be on a lead if there are limits to their ability to be recalled by you! I don’t think you sound rude though, I can’t abide dog owners who need a prompt (or multiple prompts) to get their dog back under their control.

Hoppinggreen · 16/10/2022 16:29

If they run away when approached then you need to have them on a lead

Midnights · 16/10/2022 16:29

I think you were both BU.

I'm not sure why you thought telling a strange dog "stop" "no" would work, and putting your hand up to someone talking is rude.

Your dogs shouldn't be off lead if they don't have great recall, and if their recall is impacted by other dogs being present then they should be on the lead. When the golden retriever started to approach, instead of holding up your hand and then resorting to saying "stop" you should have immediately put your dogs back on the lead.

Off lead dogs around here are assumed to be okay to interact, if your dogs aren't happy with that they should be on the lead.

midsomermurderess · 16/10/2022 16:29

People so often minimise their own involvement in these sorts of confrontations and exaggerate the poor behaviour of others. I think that that you are here, asking for people to validate your behaviour, you are already uncomfortable with how you acted.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 16/10/2022 16:28

Yeah I mean it seems unnecessarily risky to not use a lead when you know they will bolt when approached.

JorisBonson · 16/10/2022 16:28

clankist · 16/10/2022 16:26

Completely disagree. The only situation they run is when a random dog approaches them by running up and barking. I don't think it's much to ask dog owners to not allow that.

But you can't 100% guarantee that won't happen, and that your dogs won't bolt. So they should be on a lead.

And yes, putting your hand up at someone's face is rude.

Youcancallmeirrelevant · 16/10/2022 16:28

Both sets of dogs were off lead so i would expect them to interact, and as an owner i would be confused by your reaction, as your dogs were off the lead and also weren't responding. I wouldn't have acted how the woman did but you were very rude!
If your dogs were on lead then this would be a different story.

ilovesooty · 16/10/2022 16:27

I don't think your dogs should be off lead if they might run off. You can't legislate for the behaviour of other people and their dogs.