Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have woken DS up to walk the dog?

112 replies

artemo4kak · 16/10/2022 12:07

DS is 17, for his birthday we got him a dog as he’d been asking for one for years, one of the conditions of getting him was that he'd walk the dog and take care of it as it's his dog. He agreed.

Last night, his gf stayed over and I reminded DS he still needed to walk the dog. This morning, I woke him up at about 10 and told him to get ready to walk the dog, as we have plans for the rest of the day. He started arguing with me and called me embarrassing for waking him up when his gf is here. DP is on his side and has said I shouldn't have

WIBU?

OP posts:
Mummyoflittledragon · 16/10/2022 17:44

thelobsterquadrille · 16/10/2022 17:02

But if he goes to university, he won't be able to take the dog. Dogs (except for genuine assistance dogs) can't live in university halls or accommodation, and even if they could, a university lifestyle isn't compatible with dog ownership.

I mea - who's going to care for the dog when he's out all night? Or at lectures all day? He can hardly take the dog clubbing or to the library while he studies. He's hardly going to stay home in the evenings to walk the dog, or pay for a dog walker or doggy daycare at eighteen years old.

I said in a previous post that it would be more difficult to find suitable university accommodation these days. But I managed it with a lot of help from my ex, parents then with my current dh. We all chose to do it as the dog was being neglected and I wasn’t a party animal.

Americano75 · 16/10/2022 17:28

He's 17, not 7.
If he's old enough to have his girlfriend stay over then he's old enough to drag his backside out of bed to walk the dog he was so desperate to have.

2bazookas · 16/10/2022 17:26

Of course the lazy little boy should get up and walk his dog.

GF 's embarrassment is easily solved by not staying over at your house.

Suzi888 · 16/10/2022 17:10

Firstly, the dog is yours.

Secondly YANBU to have woken him, as whilst the dog is yours, HE wanted it! Life choices eh?!

liveforsummer · 16/10/2022 17:07

Some parents buy their almost adult a horse on the understanding they will tend to it twice a day. A parent buying a horse may not even be able to ride or handle it! And why the hell should they muck it out, turn it out etc?

Most horses bought for dc with non horsey parents would be on some sort of assisted livery and would likely be sold on once the dc leave school to move on to the next chapter in life. People tend not to do that with dogs

thelobsterquadrille · 16/10/2022 17:02

Mummyoflittledragon · 16/10/2022 16:24

In a few months time, ownership can be transferred to the 17 yo as he will be 18. An adult. I don’t see any difference to this from having a job to go to even if it’s a morning paper round before school or college. A lot of 17 yos are already working alongside college either as part of their course or for money. Some colleges send students, who arrive and haven’t done their homework home, because they are expected to study and complete the work as part of the course. That’s age 16 plus.

Some parents buy their almost adult a horse on the understanding they will tend to it twice a day. A parent buying a horse may not even be able to ride or handle it! And why the hell should they muck it out, turn it out etc?

Then let’s talk about single parents. A lot of 17 yo teens seem to manage to be perfectly good parents. I am all for looking after our children and being more cared for than I was. But really, the level of responsibility expected from some parents is woeful.

I said before I ended up taking care of a dog. I was a couple of years older. Funnily enough I managed to walk, feed and take care of the dog, even went to the vet when required!

But if he goes to university, he won't be able to take the dog. Dogs (except for genuine assistance dogs) can't live in university halls or accommodation, and even if they could, a university lifestyle isn't compatible with dog ownership.

I mea - who's going to care for the dog when he's out all night? Or at lectures all day? He can hardly take the dog clubbing or to the library while he studies. He's hardly going to stay home in the evenings to walk the dog, or pay for a dog walker or doggy daycare at eighteen years old.

MervynPumpkinhead · 16/10/2022 17:00

YABU for buying s child a dog in the 1st place and then refusing to care for it when that child can't be bothered. What happens if he goes to Uni, he can't take it with him, or when he moves out and rents somewhere and can't take it with him. Dogs live about 15 years or more. This is your dog a d you should never have bought it in the 1st place. Start looking after the dog you bought.

Beees · 16/10/2022 16:44

In a few months time, ownership can be transferred to the 17 yo as he will be 18. An adult. I don’t see any difference to this from having a job to go to even if it’s a morning paper round before school or college.

He's not going to want sole ownership of the dog when he turns 18 though no matter how much he may actually love the dog as itwon't suit the practicalities of a student/young adult lifestyle.

It's not even remotely comparable with a paper round which can be given up with no recourse if he wants to move away to uni. The dog will either be the responsibility of his parents or be rehomed a situation which was ridiculously predicable.

thelobsterquadrille · 16/10/2022 16:35

I'm with everyone else - why on earth did you buy a dog for a 17yo in the first place?

cushioncovers · 16/10/2022 16:29

It's your dog op your 17 year old will be moving out one day. Kids rarely ever look after animals properly it always becomes the parent's responsibility.

Mummyoflittledragon · 16/10/2022 16:24

Beees · 16/10/2022 13:55

Honestly, he’s 17 and I’m shocked at just how little we expect of our teens. Taking the dog to the vet, ensuring there is food, flea treatment etc, absolutely the parents‘ responsibility. But walking it, keeping it clean and ensuring there is food and water in the bowls, absolutely the responsibility of the 17 year old… unless his leg has fallen off.

It's not his responsibility though, it really isn't because no matter how much anyone would like to pretend the fact is it's not his dog.

No 17 year old gets a dog after never owning one before and fully understands what a life changing, consuming, repetitive and often restrictive decision it is. Heck most adult first time dog owners don't fully comprehend this. Of course the 17 year old should pull his weight by walking it and feeding it but this is a family pet and anyone thinking otherwise is exceptionally naive.

The simple fact is no matter how its dressed up this dog belongs to the OP and her husband. In a few short years the son will have left home and they will be responsible for the care and costs of the dog.

In a few months time, ownership can be transferred to the 17 yo as he will be 18. An adult. I don’t see any difference to this from having a job to go to even if it’s a morning paper round before school or college. A lot of 17 yos are already working alongside college either as part of their course or for money. Some colleges send students, who arrive and haven’t done their homework home, because they are expected to study and complete the work as part of the course. That’s age 16 plus.

Some parents buy their almost adult a horse on the understanding they will tend to it twice a day. A parent buying a horse may not even be able to ride or handle it! And why the hell should they muck it out, turn it out etc?

Then let’s talk about single parents. A lot of 17 yo teens seem to manage to be perfectly good parents. I am all for looking after our children and being more cared for than I was. But really, the level of responsibility expected from some parents is woeful.

I said before I ended up taking care of a dog. I was a couple of years older. Funnily enough I managed to walk, feed and take care of the dog, even went to the vet when required!

TheHauntedPencilCase · 16/10/2022 15:40

YABU you don't buy a child a dog, it's a family dog so you can't expect a teen to do all the walking. However, if it's his turn or responsibility that day and he's been told I don't think YABU to wake him at 10 to do the walk.

PhillySub · 16/10/2022 15:26

You were generous, I would have woken him at 7.

WillPowerLite · 16/10/2022 15:16

Whether the dog is his or not... if it's his job to walk the dog at 10am, he needs to get out of bed and walk the dog at 10am. YANBU.

liveforsummer · 16/10/2022 15:13

Bluetrews25 · 16/10/2022 15:10

If my (sadly, late) doggo could understand 'where's DC?' said in a really excited voice, followed by 'go get him!' and would have belted upstairs and swatted at his door enough to open it, surely yours can be trained to, OP?
Mine would also have jumped on the bed....

Ah mine does this. We use 'go see (child's name)' and she belts off to pester

Bluetrews25 · 16/10/2022 15:10

If my (sadly, late) doggo could understand 'where's DC?' said in a really excited voice, followed by 'go get him!' and would have belted upstairs and swatted at his door enough to open it, surely yours can be trained to, OP?
Mine would also have jumped on the bed....

Floralnomad · 16/10/2022 14:58

YABU , totally irresponsible to get a 17yo a dog and frankly if you consider your 17 yo to be mature enough to have overnight guests I think they are probably mature enough to know when they want to get up .

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 16/10/2022 14:37

I'm old-fashioned so the gf wouldn't have been there in the first place. Nor probably the dog.

SnarkyBag · 16/10/2022 14:21

Congratulations on your new dog! Yeah honestly you may as well get used to walking it cause your ds isn’t going to be fully responsible and will in all likelihood move out one day and not take the dog so you’ve got another 10 to 15 years to cover.

if you don’t want a dog rehome it now. My 17 year old has asked for a kitten. I laughed a lot then went about my day!

LondonWolf · 16/10/2022 14:15

If he's usually pretty good about walking the dog then no I wouldn't have gone into his room while his GF was there to wake him up and make a point in front of her. I'd have helped him out and taken it myself.

donttellmehesalive · 16/10/2022 14:08

I don't take my dog out that early on a Sunday, although I do let him into the garden for a wee. I do think it's odd that you woke him to do that. What time were you all going out? Presumably he could walk it at any time before then? Were you cross that his gf stayed over?

Scalottia · 16/10/2022 14:07

Branster · 16/10/2022 12:16

You do realise this is the family dog not DS's dog, right?

He'll very likely move out in 1, maximum 2 years if university is on the cards. He's likely to be living on his own and with a job in maximum 5 years. Ni chance of taking the dog with him.

Dog likely to live 8-16 years.

It's your dog now and this has always been your dog.

If you don't want the responsibility, it's best to re-home the dog.

A bit unkind to wake DS up for this today.

Unkind? Bloody hell.

Beees · 16/10/2022 13:55

Honestly, he’s 17 and I’m shocked at just how little we expect of our teens. Taking the dog to the vet, ensuring there is food, flea treatment etc, absolutely the parents‘ responsibility. But walking it, keeping it clean and ensuring there is food and water in the bowls, absolutely the responsibility of the 17 year old… unless his leg has fallen off.

It's not his responsibility though, it really isn't because no matter how much anyone would like to pretend the fact is it's not his dog.

No 17 year old gets a dog after never owning one before and fully understands what a life changing, consuming, repetitive and often restrictive decision it is. Heck most adult first time dog owners don't fully comprehend this. Of course the 17 year old should pull his weight by walking it and feeding it but this is a family pet and anyone thinking otherwise is exceptionally naive.

The simple fact is no matter how its dressed up this dog belongs to the OP and her husband. In a few short years the son will have left home and they will be responsible for the care and costs of the dog.

Brigante9 · 16/10/2022 13:43

liveforsummer · 16/10/2022 13:40

On the other hand my dog is still curled up in bed now after a quick toilet break earlier. She likes a lie in on a Sunday as much as your average teen! She has free access to the house though. Wouldn't be so happy if shut away. Plenty dogs can manage as break from their normal walking schedule

I have springers. They’re used to going out by about 10.30. One pulled all the stuffing out of his mattress, his brother will happily stay in his bed. The older dog wouldn’t dream of being destructive.

liveforsummer · 16/10/2022 13:40

Brigante9 · 16/10/2022 13:37

I fed the dogs at 6, let them out for toileting, then went back to bed at 6.30 til 9. Big mistake. One ruined dog bed. Yabu to get a 17 yea old a dog, but he is bu to prefer staying in bed to walking the dog HE wanted.

On the other hand my dog is still curled up in bed now after a quick toilet break earlier. She likes a lie in on a Sunday as much as your average teen! She has free access to the house though. Wouldn't be so happy if shut away. Plenty dogs can manage as break from their normal walking schedule

Swipe left for the next trending thread