Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Smacking DD 5

237 replies

FluffyFluffMonster · 16/10/2022 11:43

My DD who is 5 has been hit today while I was in the shower. Her grandmother (not related) hit her leaving a red mark, GM said dd was wrapping curtains around herself and she was scared she would hang herself so hit her! GM is actually my eldest DD grandmother but is amazing with youngest and treats her like her own. DD has an amazing relationship with her, adores her. We are only a little family with not much support or involvement from other family. This isn't about me I would stop contact in an instant but because my dd adores GM I don't know what to do? I'm 100% against hitting! I told GM we don't hit in this house and she did say sorry and she was scared which is why she did it! I'm actually ill currently and not thinking clearly!

OP posts:
Tansytea · 16/10/2022 16:29

You just can't what?

HouseBook · 16/10/2022 16:29

She is an older generation and reacted out of fear for your daughter's safety.

I just can't with this. How stupid.

Nobody who has concerns for the safety of a child hits the child. That's the exact opposite of keeping them safe.

The older generation? Not an excuse.

People who hot children are horrible, not old.

Sunflowerkeep · 16/10/2022 16:21

SenseiOfDuty · 16/10/2022 11:47

Bullshit that she was worried that dd would hang herself, in front of her, twirling in curtains. GM was irritated and lashed out. Hitting a kid that hard, that it left a red mark? She'd not be seeing either of mine for a long time.

My nan did that to me when I was a child, a hard smack too for messing with curtains. Get forward 45 years later and she has since passed but my love for her has never gone. She was wonderful, it was probably normal than too. I'm not saying it's right but today it doesn't take much to break a family. A simple chat should do but never see her again is harsh.

MinnieMountain · 16/10/2022 16:12

Presumably smacking being made illegal in Wales was publicised. So the “older generation” comments wouldn’t wash for me.

Mummyoflittledragon · 16/10/2022 13:21

I would take the apology and move on. I wouldn’t leave your dd in her care for a while and take the time to discuss better strategies with her.

Tansytea · 16/10/2022 13:19

She is an older generation and reacted out of fear for your daughter's safety. Yes, it's wrong, but lots of adults who were smacked as children are not traumatised. Personally I would move on, she is sorry and reacted because she was scared. You have to consider what the alternative is, and I personally think it sounds more traumatic.

HouseBook · 16/10/2022 13:04

This isn't about me I would stop contact in an instant but because my dd adores GM I don't know what to do?

She won't adore her for long if she keeps assaulting her.

I'm confused at the idea this woman was scared for your child so decided to hit her. It makes no sense. It would be unforgivable for me.

Badgirlriri · 16/10/2022 13:01

Some people are so dramatic.

She panicked, she’s apologised, move on.

Copasetic · 16/10/2022 12:58

I used to smack my eldest. I was smacked as a child and it was an automatic reaction that I didn't realise was wrong. This was in the early 1990s and more people did it. One day the penny dropped and I realised how horrible it was and never smacked from that day on. In the GMs defence, it was no doubt something she did with her kids and had never thought it through, like I hadn't. People who say that your job is to protect your children are absolutely right. I don't know know how I ever smacked one of them now.

Upnorthen · 16/10/2022 12:57

For me this would be a not allowed alone with my child again.
Sure it might be nice to have a break but not at that expense.
Perfectly normal behaviour for a child to be twirling in curtains and not listening, not normal behaviour to hit someone for being their age. There are other far more appropriate and rational ways. Sounds to me like she lost her temper. It's illegal where you live as well.
I wouldn't cut her out completely as she sounds a well loved grandma but I wouldn't let my DD out of my sight in her company from now on, which is the price she'll have to pay.

Kindofcrunchy · 16/10/2022 12:57

Avidreader69 · 16/10/2022 12:25

No, smacking when children are small does not lead to traumatized adults. If it did there would be whole generations of damaged adults around, which is clearly not the case. I am not advocating beating children, which is totally different from giving an occasional smack.
Why do you think there are so many teachers leaving the profession because they and other children, are being terrorized by five year olds throwing things, kicking and hitting?

Utter rubbish. Smacking your kids in childhood affects them into adulthood. There is a big difference between a 5 year old hitting because they can't control their big emotions, and an adult hitting because they're too ignorant to improve their parenting skills. Smacking is illegal end of story.

KitchiHuritAngeni · 16/10/2022 12:54

She hit your child.

She is no longer a safe person to be around her.

As well as the lesson your dd will learn that if you love someone it's OK to be hit by them sometimes.

If you did something she deemed as dangerous would she hit you?

She may be lovely in some ways but she lashed out and marked your kid, I would never see her again (and probably report her to the police, so dd sees the appropriate action to take).

Eupraxia · 16/10/2022 12:53

Oh, and my money is on Gran worried the curtains were about to be pulled down was the trigger.

RudsyFarmer · 16/10/2022 12:53

I’d want that mark on her skin to be gone in minutes. Has that happened?

Eupraxia · 16/10/2022 12:52

It's not acceptable for anyone to hit a young child. That this grandparent thought she could/should bothers me a lot.

Where on your daughter is the red mark?

FictionalCharacter · 16/10/2022 12:51

SenseiOfDuty · 16/10/2022 11:47

Bullshit that she was worried that dd would hang herself, in front of her, twirling in curtains. GM was irritated and lashed out. Hitting a kid that hard, that it left a red mark? She'd not be seeing either of mine for a long time.

I agree. Scared she’d hang herself?! All she had to do was remove the child from the curtains if she thought it was looking like an imminent fatal accident (which is nonsense), not hit her. And she hit hard enough to leave a mark.

urbanbuddha · 16/10/2022 12:49

Smacking children became illegal in Wales in March 2022.
It's been illegal in Scotland since November 2020.
If an adult can't explain to a child why the child's behaviour is dangerous/unacceptable there's something wrong with the adult, not the child.

SheWoreYellow · 16/10/2022 12:48

I would wonder why she didn’t hold the child still or hold the curtains still above her, rather than hitting her. Did she just lose her temper with her or alternatively did she panic?
I don’t think either is great, so I definitely wouldn’t leave her alone with her again.

FluffyFluffMonster · 16/10/2022 12:43

I'm in Wales.

OP posts:
urbanbuddha · 16/10/2022 12:42

If you're in Scotland or Wales she'd be breaking the law. A criminal. Explain that to her.

FluffyFluffMonster · 16/10/2022 12:39

But there are a lot of adults with trauma? Granted not all because they have been smacked but smacking and hitting a defenceless child is wrong.
My mother actually works in a school and as far as I can tell it's the bullying between staff that is the problem rather than naughty children throwing things and hitting adults. This is just her school and I don't know a lot about teaching except what she tells me however she does work in a really deprived area and she loves the children.

OP posts:
Avidreader69 · 16/10/2022 12:25

FluffyFluffMonster · 16/10/2022 12:12

Thank you everyone! I've taken on board the advice. @Avidreader69 I really don't think smacking anyone is helpful! There are other ways to discipline without resorting to anger and losing control. And surely smacking/hitting a child will lead to trauma as an adult?

No, smacking when children are small does not lead to traumatized adults. If it did there would be whole generations of damaged adults around, which is clearly not the case. I am not advocating beating children, which is totally different from giving an occasional smack.
Why do you think there are so many teachers leaving the profession because they and other children, are being terrorized by five year olds throwing things, kicking and hitting?

CornishTin · 16/10/2022 12:17

My child wouldn’t go back. If GM can only respond to danger by hitting then your DD is not safe.

I don’t believe her about the fear of hanging either. She just thinks it’s okay to hit children but has had to explain it because this time she left a mark.

YellowTreeHouse · 16/10/2022 12:14

She would never be left alone with my children ever again.

Swipe left for the next trending thread