Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Smacking DD 5

237 replies

FluffyFluffMonster · 16/10/2022 11:43

My DD who is 5 has been hit today while I was in the shower. Her grandmother (not related) hit her leaving a red mark, GM said dd was wrapping curtains around herself and she was scared she would hang herself so hit her! GM is actually my eldest DD grandmother but is amazing with youngest and treats her like her own. DD has an amazing relationship with her, adores her. We are only a little family with not much support or involvement from other family. This isn't about me I would stop contact in an instant but because my dd adores GM I don't know what to do? I'm 100% against hitting! I told GM we don't hit in this house and she did say sorry and she was scared which is why she did it! I'm actually ill currently and not thinking clearly!

OP posts:
jane1956 · 16/10/2022 17:07

won't lead to adult trauma, am 66 and have no trauma from the leg/bottom slaps my mother gave me. One slap will not damage the child, may stop her doing the wrapping curtain thing so it has achieved what Gm wanted.

Avidreader69 · 16/10/2022 17:06

She won't adore her for long if she keeps assaulting her

Ffs, the child wasn't assaulted, she got one smack.

Anydaynowonewouldhope · 16/10/2022 17:06

@Avidreader69 there ARE whole generations of traumatised adults walking around…

Schulte · 16/10/2022 17:04

Exactly @bellac11 .

Avidreader69 · 16/10/2022 17:03

TheLightSideOfTheMoon · 16/10/2022 16:33

What would you do off a random adult hit you?

Or an duly in the street hit your child?

Would you ignore it? Or report it to the police? There’s your answer.

Your child NEEDS to feel safe in her own home. And she NEEDS to rely on you to protect her from danger.

Don't be so ridiculous. An adult hitting another adult is totally different from a parent, or grandparent, smacking a child who has been naughty.
Children need to feel secure, of course. They also need to know that adults are in charge. It's a parent's job to bring up their child to be ready for the outside world, where not everyone will be pandering to their whims and letting them behave as they wish. Discipline is part of the process, and if it's done with a smack, by loving parents, that's a lot better than letting the child think they can do as they like.

bellac11 · 16/10/2022 17:02

For people thinkng that the grandmother should be removed from the child's life, if this was a parent who did this do you think the child should be removed into care after one occasion of this, with the parent showing remorse and shock that they did it?

Because that isnt what happens, parents are given support and opportunities to learn how to respond differently at times of stress.

Obviously if that doesnt work, the parent continues to be unsafe around the child, the parent doesnt see a problem and doesnt want to address it then those are issues for later down the line but in the first instance of such a situation, its right that people are given the skills to re learn

Ponderingwindow · 16/10/2022 17:01

I wouldn’t cut her out of your lives, but I would no longer leave her with the children unsupervised. It’s a pain to do that, but it can be done. you don’t have to share with her that it is now a rule, you just change your own routine.

mavismorpoth · 16/10/2022 17:00

Not just not in this house, not ever. If she accepts that it's never to happen again then a second chance is fine. A third chance would not happen with me. I can't imagine my child still loving someone if they hit her.

Has she hit her before?

HouseBook · 16/10/2022 16:57

Because removing the grandmother out of your DDs’ lives may do more damage. DD may even somehow feel that it’s her fault. Of course it isn’t but children can think that way.

Adults can ensure that they don't feel that way. Adults can take control and say 'we are not seeing X anymore because they hit you'. Adults are allowed to stand up for their children and teach them to do so for themselves. Nobody is suggesting they cut contact without having age appropriate conversation with the child about how it is absolutely not their fault.

Cactuslove · 16/10/2022 16:55

MbatataOwl · 16/10/2022 11:47

It was wrong but I can understand her reaction. She must have had a fright.

If she's sorry and won't do it again then I would forget about it.

100% this.

Schulte · 16/10/2022 16:55

I would not stop contact. Unless it happens again. Because removing the grandmother out of your DDs’ lives may do more damage. DD may even somehow feel that it’s her fault. Of course it isn’t but children can think that way.

Let it go but explain to DD that grandma was in the wrong and it won’t happen again.

neverbeenskiing · 16/10/2022 16:54

I wouldn't end a otherwise good relationship over a single smack.

Would you say this to a woman whose DP had slapped her hard enough to leave a red mark? Why do people think small, defenceless children shouldn't be afforded the same rights and protections we expect as adults.

Stompythedinosaur · 16/10/2022 16:54

You don't have to cut off contact, you just need to not allow unsupervised contact.

You also need to be clear that she must not ever hit either dc under any circumstances.

You need to talk to your dc about how it was wrong and you will make sure it never happens again.

HouseBook · 16/10/2022 16:53

I didn't say that.

You said exactly that (reacted, not acted as I misquoted - same thing anyhow)...

She is an older generation and reacted out of fear for your daughter's safety.

Tansytea · 16/10/2022 16:52

HouseBook · 16/10/2022 16:50

@Tansytea

You said she is older and scared out of fear.

I struggle to match 'fearing for a child safety' and 'hitting child'

I didn't say that.

HouseBook · 16/10/2022 16:50

Oh and she isn't even the kids grandmother.

HouseBook · 16/10/2022 16:50

*acted out of fear

HouseBook · 16/10/2022 16:50

@Tansytea

You said she is older and scared out of fear.

I struggle to match 'fearing for a child safety' and 'hitting child'

Tansytea · 16/10/2022 16:48

HouseBook · 16/10/2022 16:31

You just can't what?

Can't believe the stupidity.

Thinking someone who cares about the safety is f a child would hit them, and giving a free pass because of their age. Come on now.

Well I didn't say that it was out of concern for the child's safety, did I? The grandmother told the OP that she was scared. Not that it was out of concern for the child's safety, that's when you ring social services, @HouseBook She had a fright and reacted really badly, it's a different generation it was probably an old reflex. Never in a million years would anybody with the slightest bit of sense say that was ok that the grandmother hit the child. That's not even up for debate. But the question is do you stop contact. But I actually think reframing it as "the grandmother hit the child because she was concerned for her safety" is a pretty big rewrite compared to what is written in the OP.

Please remember that an explanation is NOT an excuse. It's important to differentiate.

Cantthinkofanewnameatm · 16/10/2022 16:42

I can’t imagine any way in which hitting a child would untangle them from a curtain. Surely you’d just say, “that’s not safe, twirl the other way” til she was out of the curtain?

Gottagetthruthissss · 16/10/2022 16:38

I had a similar situation. To make things 'fair', I mtold my son that he can hit grandma. She never did it again...

bellac11 · 16/10/2022 16:35

I think I would want to know what actions grandmother is going to take to ensure that she doesnt react that way instantly, whether she thought the child was at risk or whether she thought the curtains would be damaged is somewhat immaterial (no pun), its what other techniques is she going to ensure she applies at times like that? How does she get the support she needs to ensure that happens. Where does she go to reframe or re learn her responses?

Leaving a mark is considered abusive but if parents (grandparent in this case) are willing to work through to learn new strategies that is whats important. particularly in this case where as you say you have little support, the support around you needs to be safe and she needs to have the tools and skills to empower her at difficult times too.

TheLightSideOfTheMoon · 16/10/2022 16:33

What would you do off a random adult hit you?

Or an duly in the street hit your child?

Would you ignore it? Or report it to the police? There’s your answer.

Your child NEEDS to feel safe in her own home. And she NEEDS to rely on you to protect her from danger.

HouseBook · 16/10/2022 16:32

I did go in to say so I'm not sure why you asked though.

HouseBook · 16/10/2022 16:31

You just can't what?

Can't believe the stupidity.

Thinking someone who cares about the safety is f a child would hit them, and giving a free pass because of their age. Come on now.