Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Smacking DD 5

237 replies

FluffyFluffMonster · 16/10/2022 11:43

My DD who is 5 has been hit today while I was in the shower. Her grandmother (not related) hit her leaving a red mark, GM said dd was wrapping curtains around herself and she was scared she would hang herself so hit her! GM is actually my eldest DD grandmother but is amazing with youngest and treats her like her own. DD has an amazing relationship with her, adores her. We are only a little family with not much support or involvement from other family. This isn't about me I would stop contact in an instant but because my dd adores GM I don't know what to do? I'm 100% against hitting! I told GM we don't hit in this house and she did say sorry and she was scared which is why she did it! I'm actually ill currently and not thinking clearly!

OP posts:
Dumbledormer · 17/10/2022 08:34

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 08:31

Why is it always a run onto the road?

No idea. Apparently all three of us were little sods for bolting. By the time my brother came along reins were firmly established.

LemonsAndCherries · 17/10/2022 08:32

I would never leave them alone again but I wouldn't cut contact.

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 08:31

Dumbledormer · 17/10/2022 08:26

My parents were not ‘smackers’ but on occasion it did happen and one time I remember I’d run into the road, my mum pulled me back and gave me a hard smack for it. She was terrified and acted on instinct. I don’t blame her at all and I’m certainly not traumatised as an adult.

She made a mistake and acted without thinking. It’s clear she feels terrible about it and I would definitely forgive and move on in this case.

Why is it always a run onto the road?

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 08:30

Miffee · 17/10/2022 08:15

So what do you do? For example when siblings torment each other. How do you handle it?

I ask them to stop.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 17/10/2022 08:30

Pumperthepumper · 16/10/2022 20:00

It’s illegal in Wales too.

I believe that the reddening of the skin makes it common assault in England too.

Dumbledormer · 17/10/2022 08:26

My parents were not ‘smackers’ but on occasion it did happen and one time I remember I’d run into the road, my mum pulled me back and gave me a hard smack for it. She was terrified and acted on instinct. I don’t blame her at all and I’m certainly not traumatised as an adult.

She made a mistake and acted without thinking. It’s clear she feels terrible about it and I would definitely forgive and move on in this case.

Miffee · 17/10/2022 08:24

Kellie45 · 17/10/2022 08:21

You know everything apparently!

What the fuck are you taking about? What have I said that would imply this?

My first response to you was me saying that your post was interesting as it challenged my previous view.

Are you mistaking me for somebody else?

Kellie45 · 17/10/2022 08:21

Miffee · 17/10/2022 08:09

I am not saying anything of the sort.

I am saying I see where YOU are coming from. Christ.

You know everything apparently!

Miffee · 17/10/2022 08:15

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 08:11

Disciplining then changes nothing though. It doesn’t work.

So what do you do? For example when siblings torment each other. How do you handle it?

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 08:11

Kellie45 · 17/10/2022 08:04

How do you know? I’ve seen kids dragged away and traumatised by it. What you are saying is that discipline never should be applied. That’s why we have kids who can’t behave themselves. Everyone has to find their own way of disciplining their kids but people with views like you make life very difficult. Why so many kids have problems because people complicate life so much

Disciplining then changes nothing though. It doesn’t work.

Miffee · 17/10/2022 08:09

Kellie45 · 17/10/2022 08:04

How do you know? I’ve seen kids dragged away and traumatised by it. What you are saying is that discipline never should be applied. That’s why we have kids who can’t behave themselves. Everyone has to find their own way of disciplining their kids but people with views like you make life very difficult. Why so many kids have problems because people complicate life so much

I am not saying anything of the sort.

I am saying I see where YOU are coming from. Christ.

Kellie45 · 17/10/2022 08:04

Miffee · 17/10/2022 07:54

Smacking children models aggressive behaviour, which teaches children to solve problems with violence. There's a really good chance that this guy was subjected to physical discipline as a child

Okay but is aggressive behaviour is more about the way in which something is done than the act itself? I'm thinking here about physically removing a child to another area as discipline. Is that less aggressive? I suppose you could argue the difference is to remove rather than hurt/shock but, again, I'm not sure that a time out is inherently "better" than a smack. If I think about it as an adult a time out seems horrific too.

How do you know? I’ve seen kids dragged away and traumatised by it. What you are saying is that discipline never should be applied. That’s why we have kids who can’t behave themselves. Everyone has to find their own way of disciplining their kids but people with views like you make life very difficult. Why so many kids have problems because people complicate life so much

Redqueenheart · 17/10/2022 08:02

It does not make sense that she would hit her because she was worried about the fact she was getting tangled in the shower curtain..how was that going to help?

If she had said she might have grabbed her and squeezed too hard out of fear as she was trying to entangled her and it would make some sense but smack her so hard it left a red mark? That's nonsense.

Hitting a child like this is never acceptable.

She has also shown you that she is not able to care for your daughter while under pressure/stress, so I would not leave her with the child on her own ever again.

Miffee · 17/10/2022 07:54

Smacking children models aggressive behaviour, which teaches children to solve problems with violence. There's a really good chance that this guy was subjected to physical discipline as a child

Okay but is aggressive behaviour is more about the way in which something is done than the act itself? I'm thinking here about physically removing a child to another area as discipline. Is that less aggressive? I suppose you could argue the difference is to remove rather than hurt/shock but, again, I'm not sure that a time out is inherently "better" than a smack. If I think about it as an adult a time out seems horrific too.

HouseBook · 17/10/2022 07:54

I certainly hope you don’t work with battered women as you appear to follow a formula and assumptions. Obviously individuality doesn’t come into it in your case

So you didn't read the second part of my post then.

FWIW I haven't claimed to work with any women.

I follow no formula or assumptions and I have no idea why you have taken that from my posts which clearly say the opposite.

Now perhaps stop making ridiculous claims about other people to try and justify your own lack of understanding. If you spent half as much time doing a bit of research as you have coming back at me you might have learned something positive.

Kellie45 · 17/10/2022 07:51

HouseBook · 17/10/2022 07:38

Actually when you have worked with battered women you will find out that is not necessarily the case. Every case is different. To make these assumptions is just the work of people who want to make the figures fit their own theories.

Did you read the second part where is acknowledged this?

I sincerely hope you don't work with 'battered women' - your lack of understanding and awareness of violence is shocking for someone who would hold such a position.

I certainly hope you don’t work with battered women as you appear to follow a formula and assumptions. Obviously individuality doesn’t come into it in your case

Miffee · 17/10/2022 07:50

Kellie45 · 17/10/2022 06:38

Do you discipline people now? In any sort of way? Do you make people go to bed early? Do you ground people? Does it traumatise them?

That's interesting. I was am against smacking, one reason is that if it not acceptable between adults it's not acceptable for children. But actually all forms of discipline we use on our kids is totally unacceptable between adults. Also it's all predicated on the fact that we are physically more powerful than them.

The more I read on the thread the more I am struggling to establish why smacking is inherently worse than the naughty step. I think I would prefer a light slap to being forced to sit somewhere I didn't want to be.

Darbs76 · 17/10/2022 07:42

If she was genuinely afraid she was going to hurt herself then I think it’s a bit different than lashing out for no reason. I’d hope it wouldn’t happen again, I’d have another chat with her in a few days to remind her that you don’t want her to ever lay a finger on your DD again

HouseBook · 17/10/2022 07:38

Actually when you have worked with battered women you will find out that is not necessarily the case. Every case is different. To make these assumptions is just the work of people who want to make the figures fit their own theories.

Did you read the second part where is acknowledged this?

I sincerely hope you don't work with 'battered women' - your lack of understanding and awareness of violence is shocking for someone who would hold such a position.

urbanbuddha · 17/10/2022 07:37

I would have reserved that for the guy who beat his wife up.

Smacking children models aggressive behaviour, which teaches children to solve problems with violence. There's a really good chance that this guy was subjected to physical discipline as a child.

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 07:34

Kellie45 · 17/10/2022 06:38

Do you discipline people now? In any sort of way? Do you make people go to bed early? Do you ground people? Does it traumatise them?

I don’t, no. I don’t punish.

Did you know physical violence is known as ‘justifiable assault’ in law?

Kellie45 · 17/10/2022 07:32

HouseBook · 17/10/2022 07:23

it’s interesting the way you people use words ‘Physical violence’ is not words I would have used when my mum smacked my bum. I would have reserved that for the guy who beat his wife up.

And the wife getting beat? She is the one who was brought up being hit. She is the one who thinks it is normal. She is the one who thinks people who love her hit her. And yes, it's all physical violence.

Actually when you have worked with battered women you will find out that is not necessarily the case. Every case is different. To make these assumptions is just the work of people who want to make the figures fit their own theories.

HouseBook · 17/10/2022 07:24

Every woman

HouseBook · 17/10/2022 07:24

*Disclaimer - not always, not every watch man who is living with physical violence, but it certainly follows for some that if the violence is normalised it can be harder to break the cycle.

HouseBook · 17/10/2022 07:23

it’s interesting the way you people use words ‘Physical violence’ is not words I would have used when my mum smacked my bum. I would have reserved that for the guy who beat his wife up.

And the wife getting beat? She is the one who was brought up being hit. She is the one who thinks it is normal. She is the one who thinks people who love her hit her. And yes, it's all physical violence.

Swipe left for the next trending thread