Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Smacking DD 5

237 replies

FluffyFluffMonster · 16/10/2022 11:43

My DD who is 5 has been hit today while I was in the shower. Her grandmother (not related) hit her leaving a red mark, GM said dd was wrapping curtains around herself and she was scared she would hang herself so hit her! GM is actually my eldest DD grandmother but is amazing with youngest and treats her like her own. DD has an amazing relationship with her, adores her. We are only a little family with not much support or involvement from other family. This isn't about me I would stop contact in an instant but because my dd adores GM I don't know what to do? I'm 100% against hitting! I told GM we don't hit in this house and she did say sorry and she was scared which is why she did it! I'm actually ill currently and not thinking clearly!

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 09:20

Being forced to listen or forced to sit somewhere else. Both are unacceptable for me, an adult, in the context of an interpersonal relationship. You can disagree but you can't explain the material difference.

I don’t understand what you mean by this. You can’t force a kid to listen. You can force them (by lifting them up/holding them) to sit somewhere else.

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 09:19

Miffee · 17/10/2022 09:17

It's using your power over them to stop them doing what they want and force them to stop doing what they want and make them do what you want.

Being forced to listen or forced to sit somewhere else. Both are unacceptable for me, an adult, in the context of an interpersonal relationship. You can disagree but you can't explain the material difference.

FYI in my experience (which mainly comes from TV) the naughty step/time out thing is usually 1-2 minutes rather than 15.

I don’t think there’s a circumstance where they’re allowed to do whatever they like at all times, no. It’s how you deal with their behaviour - you either punish it or you don’t. And punishments don’t work.

I thought the naughty step was one minute per year of life? What other punishments did you use?

Yupbutnobut · 17/10/2022 09:18

MbatataOwl · 16/10/2022 11:47

It was wrong but I can understand her reaction. She must have had a fright.

If she's sorry and won't do it again then I would forget about it.

This

Miffee · 17/10/2022 09:17

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 09:10

Except the naughty step is essentially solitary confinement. You and I will have to agree to disagree that talking to them calmly is the same as using your weight or authority to force compliance.

It's using your power over them to stop them doing what they want and force them to stop doing what they want and make them do what you want.

Being forced to listen or forced to sit somewhere else. Both are unacceptable for me, an adult, in the context of an interpersonal relationship. You can disagree but you can't explain the material difference.

FYI in my experience (which mainly comes from TV) the naughty step/time out thing is usually 1-2 minutes rather than 15.

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 09:17

Miffee · 17/10/2022 09:13

I never sent my kids to sit on the stairs for 15 mins at any point.

I thought you "talking to them while they're angry" wasn't a punishment? Are you saying it is? And that when they are teens it will change?

Why would talking to them be a punishment? No, I still spoke to them when they became teenagers.

How did you punish your children?

Miffee · 17/10/2022 09:13

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 09:11

And did you use the same punishments for your teenagers as you did for your young children? Did you sent them to sit alone on the stairs for fifteen minutes?

I never sent my kids to sit on the stairs for 15 mins at any point.

I thought you "talking to them while they're angry" wasn't a punishment? Are you saying it is? And that when they are teens it will change?

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 09:11

Miffee · 17/10/2022 08:59

Your post history indicates your children are young. I checked before my post as I was going to ask about teens but wanted to see if you had dealt with it.

I think you are probably right that you could exert control a young child's environment and to an extent were you could probably eschew discipline. I don't know of that's a desirable option but I think it's achievable. It all goes out the window when you and the things you choose stop being the centre of their life. Maybe you could still get away with it but I think you'd just be changing one set of problems for another.

And did you use the same punishments for your teenagers as you did for your young children? Did you sent them to sit alone on the stairs for fifteen minutes?

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 09:10

Miffee · 17/10/2022 09:04

I'm not sure your approach is any different to be honest. Being forced to listen while you are "angry" still sounds like discipline to me. Just changing the naughty step for talking. They are still being forced to stopped from doing what they want to.

Except the naughty step is essentially solitary confinement. You and I will have to agree to disagree that talking to them calmly is the same as using your weight or authority to force compliance.

LeningradSymphony · 17/10/2022 09:09

Kellie45 · 17/10/2022 08:55

So you would give the kid the trauma of never seeing the grandma she loves again? Great! Scar her emotionally for life. How wonderful you guys are with your daft psychology!

Yes. OP hasn't put her daughter in this position, but it's where she is now due to the grandmother's actions. Thanks to grandma the choices are now 'keep my child in contact with someone who physically assaulted her' or 'protect my daughter by keeping her away from someone who physically assaulted her'. I'd rather support my child emotionally through the loss of a loved one and processing what happened with grandma than continue to expose her to the adult she loves and thought she could trust who betryaed that and hurt her.

There is no happy outcome here unfortunately where daughter gets to continue having a loving close relationship with a grandma who is safe to be around. Grandma took that possibility away when she chose to hit a five year old.

I'd be furious with grandma that she'd done this and put us in this awful position and caused not only physical but emotional harm to my child.

Colderthanever · 17/10/2022 09:09

What bullshit. She was scared so assaulted her? Fuck me that’s her excuse?and what she did was ilegal. Who the fuck physically assaults a five year old when scared. She chose violence. End of.

has she apologised to your daughter and told her it will never happen again, have you spoken to your child?

Miffee · 17/10/2022 09:04

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 08:53

Although actually, you might want to AS me, I’ve spoken a lot on here about what a waste of time punishments are, because some people on mumsnet are always so aghast at the idea you can parent your kids like actual humans instead of little soldiers who must obey.

I'm not sure your approach is any different to be honest. Being forced to listen while you are "angry" still sounds like discipline to me. Just changing the naughty step for talking. They are still being forced to stopped from doing what they want to.

HouseBook · 17/10/2022 09:01

What reactions have you had when you've been scared?

This is a really weird way to justify what happened.

The majority of people, who were scared of someone getting hurt, would not deliberately hurt them. It makes zero sense.

Miffee · 17/10/2022 08:59

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 08:52

What post history? The small angry child but was in response to the idea you have to punish a kid for compliance. You don’t, it doesn’t work.

Your post history indicates your children are young. I checked before my post as I was going to ask about teens but wanted to see if you had dealt with it.

I think you are probably right that you could exert control a young child's environment and to an extent were you could probably eschew discipline. I don't know of that's a desirable option but I think it's achievable. It all goes out the window when you and the things you choose stop being the centre of their life. Maybe you could still get away with it but I think you'd just be changing one set of problems for another.

Kellie45 · 17/10/2022 08:55

LeningradSymphony · 17/10/2022 08:52

I mean, if I saw a child in imminent danger I'd be trying to remove the danger/them from the danger rather than jump to assaulting them. How does hitting her change the situation? Why didn't she grab the curtains, or move DD away, or shout for help or literally anything else?

Also: hitting is an appalling thing to do to a child. But to SOMEONE ELSE'S CHILD? I can't even begin to explain the lines that that crosses!

I wonder what else has happened that you don't know about.

If anyone hit my child they would never see us again, full stop. Absolutely your first job as a parent is to protect your child. An older, grown adult assaulted your child, YABU to be even contemplating not going zero contact with this person.

So you would give the kid the trauma of never seeing the grandma she loves again? Great! Scar her emotionally for life. How wonderful you guys are with your daft psychology!

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 08:53

Miffee · 17/10/2022 08:51

That wasn't what you post history implied but sure.

Although actually, you might want to AS me, I’ve spoken a lot on here about what a waste of time punishments are, because some people on mumsnet are always so aghast at the idea you can parent your kids like actual humans instead of little soldiers who must obey.

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 08:52

Miffee · 17/10/2022 08:51

That wasn't what you post history implied but sure.

What post history? The small angry child but was in response to the idea you have to punish a kid for compliance. You don’t, it doesn’t work.

LeningradSymphony · 17/10/2022 08:52

I mean, if I saw a child in imminent danger I'd be trying to remove the danger/them from the danger rather than jump to assaulting them. How does hitting her change the situation? Why didn't she grab the curtains, or move DD away, or shout for help or literally anything else?

Also: hitting is an appalling thing to do to a child. But to SOMEONE ELSE'S CHILD? I can't even begin to explain the lines that that crosses!

I wonder what else has happened that you don't know about.

If anyone hit my child they would never see us again, full stop. Absolutely your first job as a parent is to protect your child. An older, grown adult assaulted your child, YABU to be even contemplating not going zero contact with this person.

Miffee · 17/10/2022 08:51

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 08:49

Mine are all older now.

That wasn't what you post history implied but sure.

feministqueen · 17/10/2022 08:50

MbatataOwl · 16/10/2022 11:47

It was wrong but I can understand her reaction. She must have had a fright.

If she's sorry and won't do it again then I would forget about it.

This^^

What reactions have you had when you've been scared? She apologised when you said not to do that. What more can she do?

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 08:49

Miffee · 17/10/2022 08:49

Wait until its a large moody teen. You're in for a treat.

Mine are all older now.

Miffee · 17/10/2022 08:49

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 08:45

No, of course it doesn’t work every time. It’s boring and time consuming trying to negotiate with a small angry child. But it’s a happier life than one with violence or aggression.

Wait until its a large moody teen. You're in for a treat.

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 08:47

Untitledsquatboulder · 17/10/2022 08:39

And if they don't stop? Or if they are at it again 5 min later? What if its one child constantly picking at the other?

What if one of your children was being racially abused or bullied at school. Would he school just telling the bully to stop it be OK?

Maybe none of that happens w your kids but I'm sure you have the imagination to understand that not all kids are like yours.

I talk to them again, and again and again.

If my child was being racially abused at school I would want the racist child to receive help. That doesn’t seem a happy, well adjusted way for a happy, well adjusted kid to behave.

It doesn’t just happen with my kids. I’m a teacher who also doesn’t punish the kids I teach.

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 08:45

Miffee · 17/10/2022 08:39

Does this work every time? Would it work on all children? All ages? If they are that compliant why are they misbehaving in the first place?

No, of course it doesn’t work every time. It’s boring and time consuming trying to negotiate with a small angry child. But it’s a happier life than one with violence or aggression.

Miffee · 17/10/2022 08:39

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 08:30

I ask them to stop.

Does this work every time? Would it work on all children? All ages? If they are that compliant why are they misbehaving in the first place?

Untitledsquatboulder · 17/10/2022 08:39

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 08:30

I ask them to stop.

And if they don't stop? Or if they are at it again 5 min later? What if its one child constantly picking at the other?

What if one of your children was being racially abused or bullied at school. Would he school just telling the bully to stop it be OK?

Maybe none of that happens w your kids but I'm sure you have the imagination to understand that not all kids are like yours.

Swipe left for the next trending thread