Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Smacking DD 5

237 replies

FluffyFluffMonster · 16/10/2022 11:43

My DD who is 5 has been hit today while I was in the shower. Her grandmother (not related) hit her leaving a red mark, GM said dd was wrapping curtains around herself and she was scared she would hang herself so hit her! GM is actually my eldest DD grandmother but is amazing with youngest and treats her like her own. DD has an amazing relationship with her, adores her. We are only a little family with not much support or involvement from other family. This isn't about me I would stop contact in an instant but because my dd adores GM I don't know what to do? I'm 100% against hitting! I told GM we don't hit in this house and she did say sorry and she was scared which is why she did it! I'm actually ill currently and not thinking clearly!

OP posts:
Avidreader69 · 17/10/2022 11:01

@OriginalUsername3

A person advocating hitting defenceless children saying "my parents hit me and turned out alright" did, in fact not turn out alright

Can you explain what you mean by 'did not turn out alright?' Do you have any evidence to prove that this is the case?

My children were smacked when they were toddlers. Both have grown up to be resilient, motivated and well balanced adults. Both have families of their own, and one runs his own highly successful company. In what possible sense did they 'not turn out alright? Or is it just because you say so?

CPL593H · 17/10/2022 10:31

60s child. We were smacked by our parents but they had an absolute rule no one else did. We spent a huge amount of time with actual Victorian grandparents and they never, ever hit us. Not once.

I've actually had a memory of "twirling" myself up in full length curtains at a similar age and my grandmother laughing as she extricated me and saying "Don't do that, you'll bring them down". Slapping a small child hard enough to leave a mark is wrong (I don't actually think smacking is right full stop) but also utterly disproportionate to what happened and I have doubts that it was actually a fear reaction. OK, she's apologised, which is something, but I would be making it totally clear that it must never happen again and keeping a close eye on for the foreseeable.

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 10:22

Miffee · 17/10/2022 10:07

I think you see it more with teens. All that "Take this off them" "ground them". Like... it just doesn't work with most. Plus do people not remember being a teen?

Exactly.

Miffee · 17/10/2022 10:07

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 10:00

It isn’t. It’s treating them like they’re actual human beings. But you’re not alone, as I said - loads of people on mumsnet have that same knee jerk reaction.

I think you see it more with teens. All that "Take this off them" "ground them". Like... it just doesn't work with most. Plus do people not remember being a teen?

pinkycatmum · 17/10/2022 10:06

Hm. I would be really upset if someone hit my child, especially hard enough for a red mark to show. I agree, that I wouldn't cut contact with her. Especially if your DD adores her. But definitely be firm with her and tell her if this happens again, she will not be allowed to be around your children.

I was smacked as a child and don't feel (too) traumatised by it but I don't slap my children at all. A lot of the time it seems to me that when children are slapped it's either because the adults have run out of patience or have let the child's behaviour get them to a point where they feel so angry they have to use physical violence. That's the adults problem, not the child's. There are many other ways to discipline.

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 10:00

It isn’t. It’s treating them like they’re actual human beings. But you’re not alone, as I said - loads of people on mumsnet have that same knee jerk reaction.

Miffee · 17/10/2022 09:54

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 09:39

So you’d talk to them or distract them? Same as I would? What’s the issue then?

I liked to let them tantrum. You know, physically stop them doing it then while they were angry just leave them to tantrum and when they were done just move on or address the thing depending on what it was.

When my kids were little I used a lot of just moving them but not naughty steps or time outs. I did try time outs with one but the reaction.... Jesus. The level of frustration and anger. They hated it so much it seemed like a nuclear option.

From what you said I envisioned you talking to them while they were still in tantrum mode.

To be honest my response is probably a knee jerk reaction to somebody saying you shouldn't discipline kids. It just seems so crazy but, you know, maybe it isn't.

LeningradSymphony · 17/10/2022 09:49

Suzi888 · 17/10/2022 09:32

“Except the naughty step is essentially solitary confinement.”🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣oh my god.

Thank you for THE best laugh this morning- I’m in the office and you have made 30 people cry with laughter.

It is though.

The very nature of this specific punishment is that it removes the child from social support and isolates them either as punishment or to enforce space to 'think about what they've done', whether or not they're capable of that yet.

Imagine if you had a horrible day, came home, were really upset and got into an argument with your partner, and they told you that your raised voice was unacceptable and you now must go sit in the bedroom alone for a period of time decided by them. Off you go, come on. Sit there and think about what you did, until the timer runs out.

Just imagine. You might find the idea hilarious but thankfully plenty of people have realised it's an outdated, ineffective and frankly cruel parenting tactic. There are worse things out there of course, it's preferable to assault or being starved, but it's still not helpful or appropriate.

I suspect quite a few of the people laughing along in your imaginary office recognise this and don't do it with their own kids/remember it being done to them, but feel unable to speak up against the tide of adults all laughing at someone pointing out why the naughty step is cruel. Doesn't sound like a very safe or supportive imaginary environment.

F4chrissakes · 17/10/2022 09:49

The discipline of choice when I was a kid was smack, and I smacked my own children. Looking back! I wouldn't do it now, nor I think would my parents, but it is interesting to note how well behaved I was, and my kids too.
In this case, I doubt that one smacked bottom will traumatise the child, but the mother's over reaction might. How about just explaining to Grandma that these days we don't smack, and to the kid that Grandma made a mistake, that's how she was disciplined, but that it won't happen again. Then move on.

OriginalUsername3 · 17/10/2022 09:46

Avidreader69 · 16/10/2022 12:25

No, smacking when children are small does not lead to traumatized adults. If it did there would be whole generations of damaged adults around, which is clearly not the case. I am not advocating beating children, which is totally different from giving an occasional smack.
Why do you think there are so many teachers leaving the profession because they and other children, are being terrorized by five year olds throwing things, kicking and hitting?

Well actually yeah, our adult population is rather fucked in the head. Lots of depression, anxiety, self loathing, low self esteem, lack of self control, alcohol and drug dependency.

Children may seem worse behaved than previous generations, but we're not raising children, we're raising adults. Perhaps these future generations will grow into more mentally-healthy well-rounded people who respect themselves and others.

A person advocating hitting defenceless children saying "my parents hit me and turned out alright" did, in fact not turn out alright.

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 09:43

There’s more than one type of trauma. I can’t imagine what it’s like to go into school every day and know that you might be hit for any reason at all. I’d certainly find that traumatic.

ancientgran · 17/10/2022 09:40

Thinking about it I'm not sure but I think it might be more traumatic to have someone you love suddenly disappear from your life than to have a smack so I wouldn't stop her seeing your DD.

I was slapped plenty as a child, at home and school which wasn't unusual in the 50s, I don't feel traumatised by that at all but my uncle dying suddenly when I was five was very traumatic and I have always had a fear of people just disappearing which I think dates from that. I know this is crazy but when my kids hit their teens I told all of them that if they wanted to cut me off to tell me but don't just go off as I wouldn't be able to cope with them disappearing. I think that is trauma.

Talkwhilstyouwalk · 17/10/2022 09:39

FluffyFluffMonster · 16/10/2022 12:12

Thank you everyone! I've taken on board the advice. @Avidreader69 I really don't think smacking anyone is helpful! There are other ways to discipline without resorting to anger and losing control. And surely smacking/hitting a child will lead to trauma as an adult?

I agree with you but she is from a different era where smacking was commonplace and acceptable so I would move on from this and make it clear that it must not happen again.

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 09:39

Miffee · 17/10/2022 09:38

Depends on their age. Physically intervene with cat and sibling. Ask them to stop with cake.

FYI unlike the poster above I agree with you assessment of the naughty step. Indeed my interest in the thread stemmed from the fact I don't really see the difference between that and a light smack.

So you’d talk to them or distract them? Same as I would? What’s the issue then?

Miffee · 17/10/2022 09:38

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 09:32

I don’t think I’m the perfect parent either. I think I did what I thought was best.

How would you deal with the situation you posted above?

Depends on their age. Physically intervene with cat and sibling. Ask them to stop with cake.

FYI unlike the poster above I agree with you assessment of the naughty step. Indeed my interest in the thread stemmed from the fact I don't really see the difference between that and a light smack.

ancientgran · 17/10/2022 09:34

FluffyFluffMonster · 16/10/2022 12:12

Thank you everyone! I've taken on board the advice. @Avidreader69 I really don't think smacking anyone is helpful! There are other ways to discipline without resorting to anger and losing control. And surely smacking/hitting a child will lead to trauma as an adult?

Well pretty well everyone in my age group would have trauma. Being hit isn't nice but a one off smack isn't likely to cause trauma.

She's apologised so if child is happy to see her I'd follow her lead.

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 09:32

Suzi888 · 17/10/2022 09:32

“Except the naughty step is essentially solitary confinement.”🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣oh my god.

Thank you for THE best laugh this morning- I’m in the office and you have made 30 people cry with laughter.

Ah you’re welcome! Your office sounds amazing 😻

Suzi888 · 17/10/2022 09:32

“Except the naughty step is essentially solitary confinement.”🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣oh my god.

Thank you for THE best laugh this morning- I’m in the office and you have made 30 people cry with laughter.

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 09:32

Miffee · 17/10/2022 09:29

Why are you so reluctant to say how you punished your children?

Because its irrelevant. The only reason you are asking is so you can build a strawman.

Rest assured I do not think I was a perfect parent and my own style of raising them has many flaws. I am perfectly aware of that and it's doubly irrelevant as my kids actually are adults.

I don’t think I’m the perfect parent either. I think I did what I thought was best.

How would you deal with the situation you posted above?

Suzi888 · 17/10/2022 09:29

FluffyFluffMonster · 16/10/2022 12:39

But there are a lot of adults with trauma? Granted not all because they have been smacked but smacking and hitting a defenceless child is wrong.
My mother actually works in a school and as far as I can tell it's the bullying between staff that is the problem rather than naughty children throwing things and hitting adults. This is just her school and I don't know a lot about teaching except what she tells me however she does work in a really deprived area and she loves the children.

Well you seem intent on making a big hoo haa. Childhood trauma from one smacked butt? Honestly…..

Not really sure why you posted.

Personally I think people can lash out through fright and with a disproportionate reaction.

You do realise that children can and do die from being strangled by blinds? They can hang themselves.

Miffee · 17/10/2022 09:29

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 09:24

How is it a punishment though? It’s only a punishment if you think children should be allowed to do whatever they like at all times.

I didn’t say I had all the answers. I said punishments don’t work because they don’t. Why are you so reluctant to say how you punished your children?

Why are you so reluctant to say how you punished your children?

Because its irrelevant. The only reason you are asking is so you can build a strawman.

Rest assured I do not think I was a perfect parent and my own style of raising them has many flaws. I am perfectly aware of that and it's doubly irrelevant as my kids actually are adults.

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 09:25

Miffee · 17/10/2022 09:24

Then if they don't want to listen? If they want to carry on poking the cat/biting their sibling/smearing the cake. Do you wait until they have finished?

I never said I used the naughty step.

No, I keep asking them to stop. Or I distract them with something else.

What would you do in the exact same circumstance? What’s a better way to deal with it, in your opinion?

Miffee · 17/10/2022 09:24

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 09:20

Being forced to listen or forced to sit somewhere else. Both are unacceptable for me, an adult, in the context of an interpersonal relationship. You can disagree but you can't explain the material difference.

I don’t understand what you mean by this. You can’t force a kid to listen. You can force them (by lifting them up/holding them) to sit somewhere else.

Then if they don't want to listen? If they want to carry on poking the cat/biting their sibling/smearing the cake. Do you wait until they have finished?

I never said I used the naughty step.

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 09:24

Miffee · 17/10/2022 09:22

That it was punishment is what I inferred from your phrasing.

Why does it matter how I "punished" mine? I'm not the one adamantly claiming I have the answers. Indeed I am not sure what the answer is, I will happily admit that.

How is it a punishment though? It’s only a punishment if you think children should be allowed to do whatever they like at all times.

I didn’t say I had all the answers. I said punishments don’t work because they don’t. Why are you so reluctant to say how you punished your children?

Miffee · 17/10/2022 09:22

Pumperthepumper · 17/10/2022 09:17

Why would talking to them be a punishment? No, I still spoke to them when they became teenagers.

How did you punish your children?

That it was punishment is what I inferred from your phrasing.

Why does it matter how I "punished" mine? I'm not the one adamantly claiming I have the answers. Indeed I am not sure what the answer is, I will happily admit that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread