Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Did anyone else do NOTHING with the £250 Child Trust Fund

357 replies

WarblingEttie · 16/10/2022 08:56

I just left it where it was and need to find out where it is as DS turns 18 on December 🤔

What did everyone else do?

OP posts:
TheHouseonHauntedHill · 17/10/2022 08:26

@Ziegfeld
" Widened inequality because the wealthy turned 250 into 30k"

Yes but that's because the wealthy seem to know and understand abuse investing.

It's clear that some people on here don't even understand the difference between a stocks and shares investment, and a bank giving basic interest rates.

Among my closet friends I've gently tried to encourage them ( one a sahm with no savings) to start a sipp at least

TheHouseonHauntedHill · 17/10/2022 08:15

@Itsokay2020

I don't know what forssester is or what it's invested in

However with our index funds which are mainly vanguard and mainly invested in a little of everything, we are buying now.

They are on sale.

Dollar cost averaging. You buy more for your money when the markets are low.
Definitely don't cash in or move it and loose it whilst market is low!
This is what they do and they always bounce back higher!

TheHouseonHauntedHill · 17/10/2022 07:45

@Ziegfeld

I agree.

We didn't have any spare money to add to dd1 when we got the initial 250.

Df invested it and I vaguely remember it going below 250 because it was fhe thick of the crash and fhen it jumped to over £800!

We couldn't contribute then moved it to a jisa where some inheritance went.

Dd2 didn't get anything from the government so we put the same in for her and they both have juniors ISAs stock and share with a platform.

I'm really trying to teach them both about money now!
I definitely won't just leave them until 18 and just wonder what they will do.

I'm showing them investments even the 9 year old understand the pitfalls of investing in one company only.

They have a stock ISA but also a small amount in a cash one ( which has performed dismally) but I'm expecting the cash ISA to go on a car, lesson's etc.and the large sum to their life capital to invest/flat.

It will be spoken of as for that purpose.

I think the problem is that 1000 isn't that much to an 18 year old even one without money. It's small enough to splurge.

Whereas 8 grand they can spend a bit and save or do something with it.

I certainly won't be passive however on money front and I'm trying to train them with their own bank cards and account now.

There is a clear difference between those who had it in cash ISAs and also those who invested it.

WarblingEttie · 17/10/2022 07:38

That's interesting @Ziegfeld - who knew we had a nudge unit!

Interestingly, in the 2010 election Labour wanted the scheme to continue as was, the LibDems wanted to scrap it, and the Tories wanted it to focus only on the poorest one third of families and those with disabled children

That's probably one of the few times I think the Tories were right!

OP posts:
TheHouseonHauntedHill · 17/10/2022 07:07

@BoogieBoogieWoogie

But how much time is left to go?
You can be proactive and move it? Perhaps into stocks and shares ISA if you are happy to leave it , why not take a punt if there are a few year's left to go?
I am in no way financial advisor but I would move it to jisa and buy Scottish mortgage with it.
It's on sale at the moment.

Even if you don't do that you can move it and put it into a steady index trackers?
Why be passive?

MrsDThomas · 17/10/2022 05:54

Nothing here. DD wad 18 at the start of the year and got just under £700.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 16/10/2022 23:49

Must be if its over a certain amount. Ds rang about his on the Friday and the money was in his account by the Monday

I have 2 younger dc who didn't get anything so I should really look into something for them but don't know where to start

Maverickess · 16/10/2022 23:03

It has literally been the only responsibility that DDs dad took for her in her 19 years, and even then I'm convinced he somehow thought he'd have control over it.

I checked it was invested but then forgot about it, he gave her the paperwork on her 18th birthday and she had just over £900, still does actually, saving it for topping up driving lessons if it's needed/another test or towards a first car.

TowerblocksAndSunflowers · 16/10/2022 22:59

Never added a penny to it and to be honest had forgotten all about it until I read this thread; surprised they don't often seem to contact us about it. But I do still have the paperwork, and we haven't moved house, so it shouldn't be too much of an issue to sort it out.
Whatever she gets, it'll be something for her to look forward to for next summer and might buy hopefully her a plane ticket or some other contribution for her year out.

Ziegfeld · 16/10/2022 22:53

WarblingEttie · 16/10/2022 21:08

The big winners over 18 years are those who moved into a stocks and shares CTF early on

So why didn't Gordon put the money straight into S&S for the kids instead of leaving it up to parents who might not understand?

Good question. I think these days, if the Govt introduced this policy, the default would be in S&S and if you didn’t want that, you’d have to opt out - a classic nudge in the direction of doing the right thing. Back in 2001 I think the view was that parents should decide their own risk level, starting from zero risk (ie cash) as default.

Remember also in 2001 nobody knew about nudges in government. Thaler and Sunstein’s classic book Nudge wasn’t written until 2008, and the UK Government nudge unit, one of the first in the world, wasn’t set up until 2010. So in 2001, CTFs weren’t seen as a nudge so much as a straightforward way of redistributing wealth (sort of similar to the thinking behind a universal basic income) to families who had not historically been able to accumulate any.

Interestingly, in the 2010 election Labour wanted the scheme to continue as was, the LibDems wanted to scrap it, and the Tories wanted it to focus only on the poorest one third of families and those with disabled children. If it were done today, I suspect Labour would probably take the same line as the Tories did in 2010 - better to focus the help on those who most need it. You could actually argue the old CTF scheme widened inequality rather than narrowed it, because wealthier families were more likely to take the £250 and turn it into £30k.

WarblingEttie · 16/10/2022 21:08

The big winners over 18 years are those who moved into a stocks and shares CTF early on

So why didn't Gordon put the money straight into S&S for the kids instead of leaving it up to parents who might not understand?

OP posts:
WarblingEttie · 16/10/2022 20:52

as it is a big enough sum to make a difference towards purchasing a home, I don't think they will touch it as opposed to a few thousand where it is too small to make a difference

Oh the privilege of some on MN ...

OP posts:
blueshoes · 16/10/2022 17:44

MissingNashville · 16/10/2022 17:20

Some kids are oblivious. I’d mentioned it to my son once when he was about 14, when he was next to me as I was opening post and there was a letter about it. When he got the letter at 18, he’d forgotten about it, as had me and his dad. Definitely not discussed with friends and he’s yet to do whatever needs doing to get the money many months later.

I think how it is meant to work is that the parent shows the child when they are old enough how their pot is growing from regular contributions so that the child sees a correlation between putting a small sum in regularly and ending up with an ever growing lump sum.

You can get that from cash deposits through interest over time but I think the lesson often lost (even on parents) is that the investment grows much more over the medium to long term (18 years) if you invest in stocks and shares. Not enough people in the UK know this. It seems to be either cash (safe but very low returns) or property (generally higher returns) but no in between. S&S is actually a great in-between investment because you don't need huge amounts of capital like property and there are almost no holding costs (unlike property which you have to maintain) and it comes with dividend income. If you chose a bog standard index-linked fund and put in a small sum every month over the last 18 years, you'd be laughing.

The more the CTF nudges parents into dipping into investing in S&S, the better.

Itisour · 16/10/2022 17:40

minidancer · 16/10/2022 14:32

I put my sons into a stocks and shares ISA and paid in £50 a month. The year before he turned 18 it was with £39k but he turned 18 during Covid and it had dropped to £22k 🤦🏼‍♀️ still a good amount but disappointing as I had really struggled to save for him. He's took 5k out for a car deposit and he is saving the rest

That's still really good - we saved £100/mth into our son's and due to the fairly poor performance of the HSBS S&S CTF it was worth £31.5K when he transferred it out at 18 - so I think £22K from £50/mth is still good going in comparison. Our Covid drop wasn't as dramatic - your son's was amazing before that!

imnotwhoyouthinkiam · 16/10/2022 17:25

I did nothing with DCs. Can't even remember where they were invested. DS1 was 18 this year. He applied to find it, got the money within a week and bought a VR headset.

MissingNashville · 16/10/2022 17:20

sashagabadon · 16/10/2022 16:39

And I disagree child are oblivious until their parents tell them about it. They all discuss it from about 16 ime. My dd knows exactly what all her friends got as they told each other! Not much parents can do about that which is why trying to hide it from a parent pov is utterly pointless!

Some kids are oblivious. I’d mentioned it to my son once when he was about 14, when he was next to me as I was opening post and there was a letter about it. When he got the letter at 18, he’d forgotten about it, as had me and his dad. Definitely not discussed with friends and he’s yet to do whatever needs doing to get the money many months later.

Ziegfeld · 16/10/2022 17:06

sashagabadon · 16/10/2022 16:39

And I disagree child are oblivious until their parents tell them about it. They all discuss it from about 16 ime. My dd knows exactly what all her friends got as they told each other! Not much parents can do about that which is why trying to hide it from a parent pov is utterly pointless!

Maybe oblivious was the wrong choice of words… I guess my point was really that it was supposed to encourage young people to get into good savings habits early yet (if this thread is anything to go by) it seems like it’s the parents doing all the saving/contributing - and the young people either don’t know about it or are just planning what they are going to spend it on.

PhotoDad · 16/10/2022 16:46

@sashagabadon Snap, about the investing vs saving, and needing a 'nudge' to start the S&S process.

Not only do they talk about it, but when a child turns 18 their provider writes them a letter. Opening your DC's post is a whole different level of CFery, right?

A PP mentioned that it takes ages to withdraw the funds. This was DD's experience; identity checks, and then they sent a cheque (remember those?) as an additional safeguard that parents aren't taking the money.

sashagabadon · 16/10/2022 16:39

And I disagree child are oblivious until their parents tell them about it. They all discuss it from about 16 ime. My dd knows exactly what all her friends got as they told each other! Not much parents can do about that which is why trying to hide it from a parent pov is utterly pointless!

sashagabadon · 16/10/2022 16:36

Ziegfeld · 16/10/2022 11:50

This is a fascinating thread! There seem to be two main groups of people on here:

  1. left the money where it was, didn’t add to it.
    Now it has increased 3-4x in nominal terms (ie is now £750-1000) although over 18 years there has been inflation so in real terms (what you can buy with the money at today’s prices) it’s more like 2x. Enough to buy a phone but probably not the latest iPhone, or a couple of weeks of uni tuition fees.

  2. added to it over the years, now worth between £10-30k depending on timing/how much contributed - close to flat deposit territory. This group seem most likely to describe it as a “super scheme” although their own contributions have dwarfed the original £250.

It would be really interesting to see how much savings behaviour has changed since 2011 when the “free money” CTFs were abolished and JISAs started. In theory there’s no good reason why the second group couldn’t start a JISA with £50 of their own money and make the same contributions to that instead - but did they?

The other interesting question is to what extent the scheme achieved one of its objectives which was teaching children good savings behaviour.

My impression from this thread is that most children seem oblivious of their CTFs until they approach 18 and their parent/s ask them what they want to do with the money….

I’m someone in group 2 and have contributed diligently for 18 years between £50 and £100 for pcm. I got yearly statements and some years the investment grew by double my contribution, some years it grew by less than my contribution. I invested initially with childrens mutual invesco perpetual income fund ( as that was recommended in the Sunday times the year my dd was born) and then switched to a foresters fund. I can categorically say I would not have opened a S&S for my dd without the CTF cheque. I would have opened a normal cash saving account ( and did anyway for birthday money) so for me it was a fantastic idea and opened up the world of investing over saving.
and yes parents could easily have opened a jisa for any kids born outside the years the scheme ran and contributed in the exact same way.

blueshoes · 16/10/2022 15:50

Ziegfeld · 16/10/2022 15:39

The whole point of keeping going with monthly contributions is that you balance out market movements.

Look at it this way: up until recently you have been buying expensive shares in companies. Now they are much cheaper - so effectively with the same contribution you will get more for your money every month.

When the market eventually recovers, the increase in value in the cheap shares you buy now will help balance out any loss in value of the expensive shares you bought last year.

If you can afford it, I would keep going.

This.

The big winners over 18 years are those who moved into a stocks and shares CTF early on and, even better if they could have afforded it, those who continued to contribute into the stocks and shares CTFs over the years.

That is how you can relatively easily end up with CTF pots worth tens of thousands at 18.

Although there is currently a blip, over those last 18 years, most bog standard index linked funds would have gone up massively. It is comparable to investing in UK property.

Ziegfeld · 16/10/2022 15:39

Itsokay2020 · 16/10/2022 13:57

My DD’s CTF is with Foresters Financial and I currently pay £23 pcm into it, which is index linked. It’s worth £3,400 and has another 4 years until she reaches 18. Over the past year I have paid in £279, but it’s only increased in value by £71. I am now thinking of reducing the direct debit and buying £20 in Premium Bonds each month whilst the markets are taking a hit. Is anyone else looking at doing similar?

The whole point of keeping going with monthly contributions is that you balance out market movements.

Look at it this way: up until recently you have been buying expensive shares in companies. Now they are much cheaper - so effectively with the same contribution you will get more for your money every month.

When the market eventually recovers, the increase in value in the cheap shares you buy now will help balance out any loss in value of the expensive shares you bought last year.

If you can afford it, I would keep going.

MissAmbrosia · 16/10/2022 15:24

We moved abroad when dd was 2 so weren't eligible for ISAs. I left it where it was and now she's 18 it's worth about £800. She's glad of as she's just started Uni but we need to sit down and work out how to extricate it as she doesn't have a UK account. We saved money separately for her and she has quite a large sum in her local savings account - which became fully hers at 18. I was a bit nervous about that, but doing anything else would have had tax implications. Luckily she is very tight with her own money and doesn't fritter it. She has her eye on a flat deposit.

bridgetjonesmassivepants · 16/10/2022 15:16

We added about £4000 over the first five years or so but then circumstances changed and we didn't add any more. Last time we checked it was up to £18,000 so we are very happy with that! Hopefully with that and our own money we'll be able to cover living expenses at Uni so he'll only need to get loans for the fees.

Fleetheart · 16/10/2022 15:16

I did nothing; Ds got around £500, he got it out as soon as he could and spent it on the naffest track suit and an armani rucksack. complete waste of everyone’s money in his case