Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disruptive protests clampdown.

85 replies

malificent7 · 16/10/2022 08:39

I am torn. I am worried that this will erode our rights to peaceful protest but don't agree with blocking ambulances.

I think this government will use this as an excuse to clamp don on civil unrest that THEY have caused.

What do you think?

OP posts:
Feelinglikeachange22 · 18/10/2022 16:32

It's an erosion of democracy full stop.

Fizbosshoes · 18/10/2022 16:31

Because they're attempting to bring about major changes on a nationwide scale to reduce energy use for the indefinite future, which far outstrip a few hours' worth of increased emissions caused by a blocked road.

But what do they want/expect to happen as a direct result of their action? No single action is going to have any sort of instant immediate effect on climate change. There are long term plans to reduce carbon emissions/bring in low emissions zones etc but none of these, even if implemented tomorrow, is going yo have an instant impact.
And I think anyone affected by the protest on the Dartford bridge will tell you that's more than "a few hours" of extra emissions.

user1471465329 · 18/10/2022 16:11

bellac11 · 16/10/2022 18:36

It was political argument that won the day overall. Not just the protests.

And while its not a competition as such, the suffragettes were arguing for their own rights, not arguing about something that someone is buying/eating.

The political argument was considered immoral/a big joke until they took direct action.

I suppose the protesters believe everyone will benefit from preventing the destruction of the ecosystem, including themselves and their children and grandchildren.

user1471465329 · 18/10/2022 16:08

Fizbosshoes · 16/10/2022 20:24

I'm often confused at climate protesters who disrupt traffic/block bus lanes/glue themselves to trains etc. The result of this (apart from inconveniencing people) is that traffic will take longer to get from a to b = more pollution, bus lane blocked or trains not running = people would likely use a taxi/uber = less environmentally friendly than their original mode of transport. Traffic waiting while being blocked = lots of emissions in one place. Glueing themselves to a road/throwing paint at buildings or roads = more chemicals etc being used to unglued them/clear up mess. How is this helping their cause?

Because they're attempting to bring about major changes on a nationwide scale to reduce energy use for the indefinite future, which far outstrip a few hours' worth of increased emissions caused by a blocked road.

Fizbosshoes · 16/10/2022 20:24

I'm often confused at climate protesters who disrupt traffic/block bus lanes/glue themselves to trains etc. The result of this (apart from inconveniencing people) is that traffic will take longer to get from a to b = more pollution, bus lane blocked or trains not running = people would likely use a taxi/uber = less environmentally friendly than their original mode of transport. Traffic waiting while being blocked = lots of emissions in one place. Glueing themselves to a road/throwing paint at buildings or roads = more chemicals etc being used to unglued them/clear up mess. How is this helping their cause?

bellac11 · 16/10/2022 18:36

user1471465329 · 16/10/2022 18:27

I wonder if people against disruptive protests know what the Suffragettes did to win women the right to vote.

It was political argument that won the day overall. Not just the protests.

And while its not a competition as such, the suffragettes were arguing for their own rights, not arguing about something that someone is buying/eating.

MarshaBradyo · 16/10/2022 18:32

Iirc they do get arrested for damage - so damaging property is not legal ie frame of painting

The protests where there is disruption but no damage is glueing self to road or milk I don’t know it’s a hard one

user1471465329 · 16/10/2022 18:27

I wonder if people against disruptive protests know what the Suffragettes did to win women the right to vote.

paintitallover · 16/10/2022 18:16

I'm not sure at all it's a good idea. I can see everything being recategorised as disruptive.

Anydaynowonewouldhope · 16/10/2022 16:48

@PurpleParrotfish inkmagine there are lots of ways to get people to listen which don’t include stopping ambulances getting to hospital

these people are zealots - they’d be the first to arrive at public hangings

Getofftheladder · 16/10/2022 16:08

wb3 · 16/10/2022 10:44

Should people have the right to peacefully protest outside abortions clinics?

Basically yes. But there’s a world of difference between a protest standing there with a placard saying something like “life begins at conception” or protesters actually trying to stop women getting through, or showing grim images or whatever.

peaceful protest should be protected by law in my opinion. And by that I mean no damage done and nobody hurt.

BorgQueen · 16/10/2022 16:08

Oh, and if any of these twonks had to sacrifice their phones/gadgets, bottled water, Starbucks with highly eco-unfriendly almond milk or regular holidays by plane, you wouldn’t see them for dust. That’s what makes me so angry, they are massive hypocrites who revel in disrupting the lives of normal working people.

BorgQueen · 16/10/2022 16:03

Some protests are more equal than others. The police stand by and let the eco-nutters do what they like.
When military veterans were planning to protest in Westminster, they were threatened with immediate arrest and there was a total news blackout.
I know one thing though, if XR try and mess up Remembrance Sunday in London, there will be hell to pay. It won’t end well for them.

Funny how they don’t protest outside major oil producing countries Embassies and they never, ever protest against halal meat cruelty.

If someone dies because an ambulance can’t get through, the lot of them should be charged with manslaughter. I don’t know why they think this level of selfish spite will get the public onside.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 16/10/2022 15:22

They have now attacked Aston Martin branch

As with fox hunting, I guess this is just another example of it being less about "the cause" and more about sticking it to those perceived to be privileged - although suggest that protesters give up their environmentally damaging £1000 phones and the reaction tends to be different

And yes of course they could protest peacefully with banners, slogans and all the rest, but looking at the satisfied expressions when they get carted away I'd say it's not as much fun as being hauled off by the police and being able to plaster it all over social media

LeMoo · 16/10/2022 15:21

Just because I don't agree with the way a protest has been carried out doesn't mean I believe there should be even more police state laws denying our rights to protest.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 16/10/2022 15:16

I agree about stopping wilful disruption, but I also agree with your worry about selectivity, OP. We already have light touch enforcement (and sometimes none at all) in some areas, and while sensitivity's very important one difficulty can all too easily lead to others

Certainly we can draw a line and decide that some things will not be tolerated, but then we'd have to decide what to do about those who'll claim special exemptions - and it would need a better mind than mine to square that circle

PurpleParrotfish · 16/10/2022 15:14

ChocFrog · 16/10/2022 11:10

Why can’t they protest peacefully by walking about holding placades, and chanting slogans?

Why do they have to disrupt traffic and vandalise art? That ain’t protest that’s egotistical attention seeking by idiots.

A huge of the problem is the media. Two thousand people can hold a rally about an important issue and the bbc won’t cover the story, but one person throws oil at a Van Gogh and it’s on the front page.

Very mad at XR and Insulate Britain for handing this government an excuse to increase police powers. This won’t end well. I remember when the police were given extra powers to fight terrorists and they used those laws to remove an old man from a political party conference where he was peacefully protesting.

Unfortunately, even twenty thousand people on a peaceful demo won’t get any media attention. The media only pay attention to controversial protests so young people who are genuinely frightened about our current trajectory towards making large parts of the planet uninhabitable feel that’s what they have to do to get any attention.
I think these protests do risk alienating the public. But at the same time, what can we do to make people realise that once we’ve broken it, we can’t fix it? Once the ice sheets have melted, the sea level rise will happen. Our whole civilisation depends on the weather patterns that sustain agriculture, now changing.. And yet the government wants to ban solar farms and drill for more fossil fuels in the North Sea. They really don’t give a toss about the consequences.
Of course people who understand what’s at stake are feeling desperate. Even climate scientists are now going out and taking part in direct action.
By the way, someone suggested responding to policy consultations as an alternative. I responded to a lot of these in a previous job, and the idea that responses influence government is just… hahaha <hollow laugh>

Hawkins001 · 16/10/2022 15:03

They have now attacked Aston Martin branch

Anydaynowonewouldhope · 16/10/2022 14:49

And people should have the right to protest abortion legislation - which is very different to harassing individuals going into or working at abortion clinics

Anydaynowonewouldhope · 16/10/2022 14:47

Blocking ambulances and fire trucks is awful.

they’re just militants - they could just have easily been fascists if their circumstances were different. They are entirely removed from the real concerns of what they protest.

their protests clearly alienate people but they don’t care - becaue they don’t really care about the outcome.

i can guarantee if you told them it would be really helpful to put together some useful responses to a policy consultation on practical change they’d get bored and leave after 5 minutes

Thelnebriati · 16/10/2022 14:47

Should people have the right to peacefully protest outside abortions clinics?

No. No one should have the right to harass users or staff. Find a different way to protest.

Bunnycat101 · 16/10/2022 14:47

The stunt protests are ridiculous. The road blocking is dangerous especially when people can’t get through to the hospital. Those ones make my blood boil (and are counterproductive as all the standing traffic will be spraying out fumes).

the ones where they’re damaging things are equally annoying as clearly they will be using resources to clean up and rectify the damage.

bellac11 · 16/10/2022 14:44

Im not prone to conspiracy theories but perhaps this is all calculated to ensure the Government takes action to restrict the right to protest

And no you shouldnt have the right to 'protest' outside an abortion clinic any more than you should have the right to protest outside a children's hospital that the staff are doing harm etc

Its harrassment.

Lizannecarling · 16/10/2022 14:41

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines. Previously banned poster.

PBSam · 16/10/2022 14:38

wb3 · 16/10/2022 10:44

Should people have the right to peacefully protest outside abortions clinics?

Yes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread