Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if this is normal for a teenager?

108 replies

Grumpbump · 16/10/2022 06:47

I will start by saying I never had a very good relationship with my mum so I don’t really know what’s ‘normal’

I have a 13 year old daughter, I would say we are close, she tells me about boys friends difficult things and she expresses how she feels pretty well normally. Recently her attitude has been a bit of a problem but really we talk and I make it clear she can always talk to me no judgment.

I check her phone and I recently saw text messages to her best friend saying she can’t speak on the phone because I’m here. She also text saying it’s like my mum doesn’t understand me, I can never talk to her. Is this normal? She has her privacy, she sits on the phone to her friend in her room. Is this something I should speak to her, I feel quite sad she feels like she can’t talk to me

OP posts:
CarefreeMe · 16/10/2022 09:13

I am an adult and still moan about my mum to my sister or close friend. I think everyone does.

I remember reading a message from my DD telling her friend how much she hates me because I brought her tickets to a theme park (that she really wanted to go to).
She absolutely loved it once she got there and was sending photos to all her friends but I think it was because I surprised her with it and she was too overwhelmed at first.

Keep it in the back of your mind and be careful of how judgemental you are etc but don’t give it too much thought.

LabiaMinoraPissusFlapus · 16/10/2022 09:10

I certainly don't think it is appropriate to check teens' phones, unless there is cause for suspicion. They have to learn to be responsible and how to deal with things. There has to be trust, and checking phones does not nurture a trusting relationship but for them to just hide things further. Some adults seem overly involved in their teens' lives. I think you can educate them and encourage a trusting relationship, and hope they come to you with any problems. Of course they'll keep stuff from you! I did at that age even in the era without phones.

mansviewpoint · 16/10/2022 09:02

Did you want to disuss things with your parents at that age? Did you know how to start a conversation about annoying people in your class at school? Did you think talking to your parents would help you at all?
Or did you think that they have no clue, and they won't be able to help or they'll tell you off because you did something a bit silly and you've already realised it was silly.
Teenagers are teenagers, their brains are very much being controlled by hormones, and those hormones are telling them that they are old enough for things like keeping secrets and being interested in adult things, and when that wave of hormones has finished it's massive rush, they then because 9 year olds again and don't like that they kept a secret, but think they are in trouble all the time. It's a horrendous time, especially for them but also for parents who care.
In my own rather narrow opinion is give them the space to work out the issues, remind them they can talk to you, and make sure they don't fall out with their friends that you approve of.

PoundShopPrincess · 16/10/2022 09:00

The parents not checking their DC's phones are very naive. Adult groomers are adept at manipulating DCs so they think they are safe and heard. The recent inquiry into a teen's suicide illustrated how algorithms gradually increase the severity of posts social media show users including suicide ideation and self harm. Then there are the other teens sending abuse or being bullies. That's why the police and schools recommend monitoring.

OP your teen has to say you don't understand her. It's a right of passage. 🙂Don't take comments like that too personally. Keep the lines of communication open. As a PP said nowadays young teens are having lots of conversations about identity and sexuality. Also depending on friendship groups on self harm and suicide ideation. Our young teen found it all very stressful but we chatted a lot and worked through it.

DeadbeatYoda · 16/10/2022 08:44

WonkyCoffeeCup · 16/10/2022 08:15

I’m sure most would not have says it was ok to go into a teens room, locate their diary and read it 20-30 years ago and this is the same really. They use their phones to put their personal thoughts down

They know that parents check so are welcome to write down personal thoughts in a private diary not a phone that's connected to the internet with all the this entails.

It's not the same thing at all. There are no bullies or abusers lurking in a diary waiting for a vulnerable / naive child.

DeadbeatYoda · 16/10/2022 08:42

@dogsod it's astounding how many grim things my daughter tells me her friends have been sent / had people try and coerce them to do over their phones but they don't tell their parents and their parents never check. I think there are lots of parents out there thinking all is well and they are respecting their teen's privacy when actually they are just burying their head in the sand because it's easier. 13 year olds are not equipped to deal with the hatefulness of some people out there.

TravelorNot · 16/10/2022 08:35

Even if she thinks she has a great relationship with you and can tell you stuff and that you understand her, she will never in a million years say that to her friends at this age. It just wouldn't be the done thing to say that, if you know what I mean.

DeadbeatYoda · 16/10/2022 08:34

Also, teens have a habit of expressing their rollercoaster of feelings in a very self-focussed and exaggerated way ( naturally). This means that describing their parents as awful, unfeeling beings ( just because you said no to a sleepover on a school night ) is completely normal. They need you to represent the source of the emotional frustrations they feel, even if it is not your doing. It means they trust you to be the immovable object they need to bash against, it's quite normal.

DeadbeatYoda · 16/10/2022 08:29

Leaving a 13 year old girl free rein with the internet without spot checks is not a good idea. All the experts, all the child protection agencies, anyone with any professional interest will tell you that the internet can be a dangerous place for impressionable young people, it's nuts to expose them to that unchecked.

LikeTearsInRain · 16/10/2022 08:23

Sounds like this friend of hers is actually her girlfriend and they can’t speak on the phone because then you’ll figure it out

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 16/10/2022 08:23

If your DD knows you check her phone and doesn't mind and you say she tells you everything, have you actually asked her about the texts from her friend?

Surely if she actually does know and doesn't mind then she'll know you would read the messages and know you'll ask her about them

Maireas · 16/10/2022 08:22

Grumpbump · 16/10/2022 08:19

I’m not really here to get into the pros and cons of checking her phone. I don’t do it to pry I do it to ensure she’s safe. She has her privacy I don’t think I smother her I read her message by accident.

I just don’t want her to think she can’t talk to me. Thank you everyone for your views and advice I appreciate it, my mum never parented me so I don’t really have any experience to draw from

It sounds like you're doing everything right, just keep the lines of communication open.

Mummyoflittledragon · 16/10/2022 08:20

My dd is 14. I no longer check her phone. It isn’t any point as she’s moved to Snapchat and I only ever found inane stuff before that. The worst I found was her friend, who has learning difficulties getting upset and using some colourful language at dd for not waiting until Christmas Day to open her present from the girl when the girl was 11 and dd 12. Dd did show me some nasty messages in the past, which were dealt with but the kids seem to have mellowed and are less reactive a they mature a little.

Dd is very open about things so there really is no need and the Snapchats are their secret, online discussions, which I am confident are age appropriate. We’ve talked about cyber bullying, sending pics etc. She’s never had a boyfriend yet and tbh she and her friends seem far less ‘advanced’ and less worldly than dh and I were at this age. We were very much more left to our own devices and had far far more freedom. Our parents were clueless about what we got up to. My dd is just doing things like meeting friends in town, going somewhere with parents, to the odd friend’s party (with parents present) or going for the odd walk around or hike with a friend. All far less seedy and more wholesome than my experiences.

So much of their lives is online. I think this is a blessing and a curse. A confident and open teen will talk to their parents if anything untoward happens. It is the ones, who are more secretive, insular or don’t trust their parents, who are more worrying. My dd knows if she tells me something I’ll act. She knows if she tells her 2 best friends something requiring safeguarding, they’ll tell me. And she knows if she gets into any scrapes, she can talk to dh and me without judgment. If she really can’t, my friend is always on call and if dd doesn’t want to talk to her, she’s been told to talk to a trusted adult. Idc who that adult is, so long as they’re a safe person. And dd is sensible enough to know who that is.

Op, in essence, I think you need to talk to your dd and trust your intuition as to the level of input you require with her. She is allowed her own relationships. It is hard to let go. But butting in and expecting to know things, which are none of your business, will not help with your long term relationship. She is pulling away. It’s developmental and normal.

Grumpbump · 16/10/2022 08:19

I’m not really here to get into the pros and cons of checking her phone. I don’t do it to pry I do it to ensure she’s safe. She has her privacy I don’t think I smother her I read her message by accident.

I just don’t want her to think she can’t talk to me. Thank you everyone for your views and advice I appreciate it, my mum never parented me so I don’t really have any experience to draw from

OP posts:
WonkyCoffeeCup · 16/10/2022 08:16

almost neglectful

WonkyCoffeeCup · 16/10/2022 08:16

sorrynotathome · 16/10/2022 08:01

You lost me at “I check her phone”. Bizarre.

Bizarre and most neglectful to think that checking a young teen's phone is bizarre. Incredibly naive.

WonkyCoffeeCup · 16/10/2022 08:15

I’m sure most would not have says it was ok to go into a teens room, locate their diary and read it 20-30 years ago and this is the same really. They use their phones to put their personal thoughts down

They know that parents check so are welcome to write down personal thoughts in a private diary not a phone that's connected to the internet with all the this entails.

dogsod · 16/10/2022 08:09

sorrynotathome · 16/10/2022 08:01

You lost me at “I check her phone”. Bizarre.

At 13 we had a grown man (30+) sending explicit messages to our friendship group, he got our numbers from a form we filled in and tried to groom us all. It was hilarious at the time and we wouldn't have gone near him (all virgins hadn't even had our first kisses) but he lived and worked locally and we could have easily been preyed on and hurt by him. We obviously didn't tell our parents because we would be told off (probably not, we did nothing wrong he was a paedo not us) and we didn't know what to do because we knew him in a professional capacity and it was so fucking awkward.

IF our parents had checked our phones he probably would have gone to jail for grooming and no doubt abusing countless girls. mobile
phones were only just starting to come out then and there were no online safety seminars or letters home about it to our parents.

millymollymoomoo · 16/10/2022 08:04

I understand the challenges with grooming and so yak media etc but there’s a fine line in checking phones for me. I’m sure most would not have says it was ok to go into a teens room, locate their diary and read it 20-30 years ago and this is the same really. They use their phones to put their personal thoughts down

i don’t check my 14 year olds texts and messages. I watch for her behaviours and moods ( most grumpiness/stroppiness and Norns teens ) and will on occasion, unannounced check phone history to get a sense of sites being visited

as well as open lines of Unjudgemetal communication

sorrynotathome · 16/10/2022 08:01

You lost me at “I check her phone”. Bizarre.

GirlOrganised · 16/10/2022 07:59

Discovereads · 16/10/2022 07:46

It’s normal in the sense that some things only another teen can understand.

However, I do not agree with checking teens phones. I never did. I gave them privacy. Instead I taught my DC online safety and they always came to me whenever there was anything dodgy or distressing. There is more than one way to parent.

I found that my DCs teen friends whose parents did check their phones and cyber stalked them that these teens all had secret accounts or would use apps where the messages & images & videos auto-delete after being viewed. These same teens would then not in a million years tell their parents of anything dodgy or distressing because then they’d have to admit to the forbidden secret accounts and risk having their phones taken away from them.

And there are teens who understand that their parents check their phones and are happy to interact with their parents on SM.

The only options are not one extreme or the other. This DD is 13, not 16.

justusandmoo · 16/10/2022 07:57

I check my daughters phone and she's 13. When she started comp she was being quite badly bullied and wouldn't say anything. If I hadn't been checked I would never have know. Don't fall into the trap of not checking because it's against their privacy rights etc...rubbish. You have a responsibility as a parent at that age to keep an eye on things.

OP I wouldn't worry too much. Just because she says she can't talk to you doesn't mean it's true. She's probably just trying to keep up appearances with her mates x

HikingforScenery · 16/10/2022 07:56

OP, for some people, once DC reach teens, they pretty much treat them like adults. You don’t seem like that kind of parent ( neither am I). I’d say you’re doing parenting right.

She might just be saying it to fit in.

There was a post where a DD was telling her friends how difficult her home life is so she could fit in. Her friends had terrible ones.

I wouldn’t speak to her about her saying she can’t speak to you but continue reminding she can talk to you about anything, etc.

procrastinatingtree · 16/10/2022 07:56

Discovereads · 16/10/2022 07:46

It’s normal in the sense that some things only another teen can understand.

However, I do not agree with checking teens phones. I never did. I gave them privacy. Instead I taught my DC online safety and they always came to me whenever there was anything dodgy or distressing. There is more than one way to parent.

I found that my DCs teen friends whose parents did check their phones and cyber stalked them that these teens all had secret accounts or would use apps where the messages & images & videos auto-delete after being viewed. These same teens would then not in a million years tell their parents of anything dodgy or distressing because then they’d have to admit to the forbidden secret accounts and risk having their phones taken away from them.

Agree with this.

My kids know they can come to me and that I trust them to do that.

procrastinatingtree · 16/10/2022 07:54

I didn't check their texts. If I was concerned about them I might, perhaps a change in behaviour but otherwise no

Swipe left for the next trending thread