Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if this is normal for a teenager?

108 replies

Grumpbump · 16/10/2022 06:47

I will start by saying I never had a very good relationship with my mum so I don’t really know what’s ‘normal’

I have a 13 year old daughter, I would say we are close, she tells me about boys friends difficult things and she expresses how she feels pretty well normally. Recently her attitude has been a bit of a problem but really we talk and I make it clear she can always talk to me no judgment.

I check her phone and I recently saw text messages to her best friend saying she can’t speak on the phone because I’m here. She also text saying it’s like my mum doesn’t understand me, I can never talk to her. Is this normal? She has her privacy, she sits on the phone to her friend in her room. Is this something I should speak to her, I feel quite sad she feels like she can’t talk to me

OP posts:
mondaytosunday · 16/10/2022 11:26

Give her some privacy! What kid wants their mum listening in to their conversations, no matter how banal? Kids can't imagine you have ever experienced what they are feeling, and actually don't want you to know how they are feeling a lot if the time.
Just be there, be non judgmental, listen listen listen if she ever wants to talk (do NOT butt in with your own thoughts/experiences - do NOT analyse or try to explain to them what they are feeling, just listen and offer gentle advice IF asked).
I would not dream of reading my children's texts.

Darbs76 · 16/10/2022 11:14

Perfectly normal. I wouldn’t worry

NotDavidTennant · 16/10/2022 11:00

I think you're reading too much into it. Lots of teenagers like to play the "I'm so misunderstood by my parents" card in order to look cool to their friends. If you feel like you have a close and open relationship then that is probably a more accurate reflection of things than what your DD is telling her friends.

neverbeenskiing · 16/10/2022 10:45

I’m sure most would not have says it was ok to go into a teens room, locate their diary and read it 20-30 years ago and this is the same really.

It is not even remotely similar, let alone "the same". A diary doesn't talk back to you. A diary can't blackmail you into sending indecent images of yourself, or send unsolicited indecent images to you, it can't bully you, threaten you or give you tips on how to starve yourself without your parents noticing. A diary doesn't give you access to hard-core porn that normalises violent acts as part of a sexual relationship. A diary can't give you step by step instructions in various methods of suicide and show you images and videos normalising and even glamourising self-harm. A diary doesn't introduce you to older men claiming to be teenagers, who even have voice changer apps that make them sounds like kids. Last year many of our students saw a video of a man shooting himself in the head, they didn't go looking for it, it was hidden inside innocuous sounding Tik Toks claiming to be about cats, dancing or baking.

A diary doesn't have the potential to place kids at risk of harm and the online world does.

Maireas · 16/10/2022 10:43

OP, it may be worth raising with the Head of KS or year manager, just to check if her behaviour has changed at school or if teachers have any concerns.

Discovereads · 16/10/2022 10:34

Toddlerteaplease · 16/10/2022 10:27

Molly Russell is the reason
Parents of young teenagers should check their phones.

Sorry, but that didnt save Molly Russell
Her parents checked her phone, had access to her emails via the family computer and monitored her internet activity and SM accounts:

“I also looked briefly at Molly's YouTube account and saw a… pattern - many normal teenage 'likes' and 'follows', but a similar high number of disturbing posts concerning anxiety, depression, self harm and suicide.
"On the family computer I saw that Molly continued to receive emails after her death from another social media platform, Pinterest.
“I knew Molly had an Instagram account and a Twitter account as I also had accounts on these platforms and we 'followed' each other, as did other members of the family.
“Molly closed the Twitter account of hers that we were all following and it was only after her death that I found out she had opened another account on Twitter.”
www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-62981964

And there it is, the secret Twitter account that had her tweets for help and suicidal thoughts….

Theroad · 16/10/2022 10:31

It's perfectly normal, and if you aren't checking younger teens' phones, you aren't parenting them properly.

Quite. Scary that so many let their very young DC loose with their phones/internet access. Have you people seen the internet?! Bad, bad parenting.

Mummyoflittledragon · 16/10/2022 10:28

neverbeenskiing · 16/10/2022 10:12

However, I do not agree with checking teens phones. I never did. I gave them privacy. Instead I taught my DC online safety and they always came to me whenever there was anything dodgy or distressing.

School Safeguarding Lead here. If I had a pound for every time a parent had told me they don't need to check their child's phone because they've taught them online safety and they always come to them with anything dodgy or distressing, and then I've had to tell that parent something both dodgy and extremely distressing about their own DC that came as a massive shock to them, I'd be a very rich woman.

I know a family like this. A question of privacy apparently. I’m talking about 11 and 12 ffs. I gave up trying to persuade them and reporting stuff to them as it wasn’t dealt with properly.

Toddlerteaplease · 16/10/2022 10:27

Molly Russell is the reason
Parents of young teenagers should check their phones.

ElectedOnThursday · 16/10/2022 10:26

Of course you need to check her phone, she is a child. You would be negligent not to. And all these cries of intrusion saying “oh I check but I don’t read texts” well that’s pretty silly because texts are a huge part of what’s going on. That’s where you find out they’re self harming or skipping school or being bullied or whatever. It’s called parenting.

That said, teens go to their peers for help long before they confide in parents or other adults, always have, always will.

Yoir daughter is behaving normally and I think you are doing everything right.

She may need to hear you say that you will always love her and that you would be very happy if she finds love one day and that the gender is not an issue.

Liz1tummypain · 16/10/2022 10:22

That's how I was with my mum and that's how my daughters have been with me - to different extents. I don't see any reason to be concerned. Unless I've missed anything.

PoundShopPrincess · 16/10/2022 10:18

There's also a particular group targeting MN atm that is very invested in parents not checking their DCs' phones.

Our school has had lots of issues with DCs accessing age-inappropriate apps because their parents have adopted a very hands-off approach to phone use and monitoring.

Maireas · 16/10/2022 10:17

Indeed, @Discovereads - I've been a secondary school teacher for 40 years (yes, I'm very old) also Head of KS3 and KS4. Most parents are just trying to navigate the often painful route from childhood to adulthood with kindness, support and good humour.
Having weeping parents in my office asking where they went wrong because of what their child has been doing online is, as you can imagine, distressing.
Parents must judge how to do it, but it's increasingly hard for many,

neverbeenskiing · 16/10/2022 10:15

You cannot say you check her phone and simultaneously claim she has her privacy!

She has a level of privacy appropriate for her age.

neverbeenskiing · 16/10/2022 10:12

However, I do not agree with checking teens phones. I never did. I gave them privacy. Instead I taught my DC online safety and they always came to me whenever there was anything dodgy or distressing.

School Safeguarding Lead here. If I had a pound for every time a parent had told me they don't need to check their child's phone because they've taught them online safety and they always come to them with anything dodgy or distressing, and then I've had to tell that parent something both dodgy and extremely distressing about their own DC that came as a massive shock to them, I'd be a very rich woman.

Discovereads · 16/10/2022 10:12

Maireas · 16/10/2022 10:05

Ok. You've got me!
That comment came from a PowerPoint from a safeguarding course I was on.
You don't believe me, fine. You've obviously been a very successful parent with mature and sensible children and I genuinely applaud you for that.
There are, however, recent guidelines because of numerous damaging and dangerous incidents. I dealt with a particularly distressing one last week.

Ok. Thank you. I guess I am mostly reacting to the insults others (not you) are flinging around about being “foolish” “utterly naive” “neglectful” “not parenting properly” “nuts” “bizarre”

Theres more than one way to parent successfully and I’m glad you acknowledged that.

fUNNYfACE36 · 16/10/2022 10:08

You cannot say you check her phone and simultaneously claim she has her privacy!
I think it does huge damage to your relationship with your teen to randomly check their phone .You are telling them you don't trust them!

Maireas · 16/10/2022 10:05

Discovereads · 16/10/2022 09:53

No source for your statement that “talking to them and warning them doesn’t work for most children”

Ok. You've got me!
That comment came from a PowerPoint from a safeguarding course I was on.
You don't believe me, fine. You've obviously been a very successful parent with mature and sensible children and I genuinely applaud you for that.
There are, however, recent guidelines because of numerous damaging and dangerous incidents. I dealt with a particularly distressing one last week.

Crunchingleaf · 16/10/2022 10:04

Any parent that doesn’t check a young teens phone under the guise of privacy is either utterly naive or foolish. They are not yet adults and are still maturing both emotionally and mentally. My DC school said that now days the vast majority of the bullying they are dealing with is online. It often takes months and months after it starts before an adult aka a parent or teacher finds out. So yes I check my 13 year olds phone randomly. I know other mothers I have spoken to are doing the same.
The online world can destroy a young teens mental health even if there is no bullying going on and it’s relentless especially if they have phone access 24/7.
It’s totally normal for a teenager to complain about the parents. Developmentally it’s natural for them to turn away from their family unit and focus on the peer group. They are all massive conformers so even if they think their parents are pretty cool they would never admit it to their friends.

kilo · 16/10/2022 09:59

Yep, her attitude is definitely normal. I have a 13 year old DS and 13 year old niece and have a great, open, fun relationship with both but when they’re with friends they do all like to complain (exaggerate) about how ‘strict’ I am , it’s partly growing up and trying to differentiate between themselves and their parents and partly to fit in, some of their friends genuinely don’t talk to their parents and have a really tough time at home. It simply wouldn’t be cool to say ‘my mum’s great, she’d like my best friend!’ 😂 honestly don’t take it to heart, it sounds like you are doing a great job 😘
And personally I don’t think there’s anything wrong with randomly checking their phone from time to time, in fact I think it’s important, as long as your kids know that this is the deal. I wouldn’t be doing it at 16, but 13 is still pretty young and needs some guidance/ support with navigating the virtual world xxx

Discovereads · 16/10/2022 09:53

Maireas · 16/10/2022 09:46

Secondary School Safeguarding Leads for our Trust.
Advice from police liaison officer to parents.
Safeguarding updates to all parents in our trust.

No source for your statement that “talking to them and warning them doesn’t work for most children”

Schnooze · 16/10/2022 09:53

It’s normal to have secrets. That’s part of the great bond with friends.
It sounds as if she’d come to you if she really needs to.

Discovereads · 16/10/2022 09:52

@PoundShopPrincess
The recent inquiry into a teen's suicide illustrated how algorithms gradually increase the severity of posts social media show users including suicide ideation and self harm.

If this is a reference to Molly Russell, her parents were monitoring & checking her phone. They followed her SM accounts as a requirement for her to have them. They just didn’t know about her secret SM accounts with the suicide material on it. 🤷‍♀️

If you think checking your teen’s phone makes your teen safe, you’re naive.

Maireas · 16/10/2022 09:46

Discovereads · 16/10/2022 09:44

@Maireas
However, all the safeguarding advice now is to monitor usage, not just talk to them or give warnings because sadly it doesn't seem to work for most children.

Source please. I think you won’t find one that says my method doesn’t work for most children. I think you’ll find the cases where horrible things happen innwhivh the parents did not teach online safety, did not have good lines of communication and/or did not do any monitoring at all. As in they did nothing or they did too much invasion of privacy leading to the secret double life situation.

Secondary School Safeguarding Leads for our Trust.
Advice from police liaison officer to parents.
Safeguarding updates to all parents in our trust.

Discovereads · 16/10/2022 09:44

@Maireas
However, all the safeguarding advice now is to monitor usage, not just talk to them or give warnings because sadly it doesn't seem to work for most children.

Source please. I think you won’t find one that says my method doesn’t work for most children. I think you’ll find the cases where horrible things happen innwhivh the parents did not teach online safety, did not have good lines of communication and/or did not do any monitoring at all. As in they did nothing or they did too much invasion of privacy leading to the secret double life situation.