Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are people that want zero immigration racist?

682 replies

equalstime · 15/10/2022 22:31

People that moan about migrants coming to this county - taking our jobs - taking our houses - draining the medical system - not settling in the first country they reach for asylum- they're racist right?

There will always be an element of migration and when you take account of UK born people that leave and non Uk people that enter our country, the net figure is no doubt reasonable. They are often willing to work and contribute to our society and economy - so why the hostility?

Why not accept as a country that we have en element of migration and embrace that, if not because your views are racist?

OP posts:
Justanotherlurker · 18/02/2023 21:55

Rodneyisaplonker · 18/02/2023 21:36

Op, my grandparents were immigrants and horrifically abused,one of my grandfathers was brutally assaulted due to it. We are of Italian descent. “Dirty itI” was the term Brits like to shout at them. They were shunned.

they became wealthy, very respected in their community, now no one abuses you as you’re Italian descent.if anything it’s seen as cool. That’s what close to a century and the eu does,

Britain will always have a fear of immigrants, it’s nothing new.it’s being going on best part of a century now, it appalls and saddens me, but no way round the fact it’s an inbred reaction some have. This is nothing new. As said, best part of a century ago, the same racist shit was happening. The only thing that changed is the nationalities Of rhe immigrants.

but make no mistake, British people have always been guilty of this.

Quite ironic considering the issues that Italy are going through at the minute....

A second generation brit of Italian heritage insinuating that the British is deeply racist/xenophobic.

Meloni can make even make Farage wince, and that is only using the last year as as a bench mark

DemiColon · 18/02/2023 21:53

hoardod · 18/02/2023 21:34

@DemiColon I've never called anyone a fascist or a racist though. I think a major issue with Brexit was that debate was shut down with cries of racist. Of course one can have concerns re immigration without being a racist.

However I'm not sure why saying we have an ageing population & that our system is set up to use immigration to prop up the economic model is anything other than stating the facts?

The OP is calling people racists, and certainly isn't alone in that viewpoint.

Maybe I haven't been clear. It's true that immigration has been set up dodo as you say. However, it is also true that:

a) Part of the reason they have made that choice is because it suits those who want to keep social costs low and wages depressed. It is the easy cheap solution that makes things like effective union action difficult and depresses wages at the lowest level.

Other options might include things like better supporting training, increasing productivity through research, possibly increasing mothers in the workforce, or actually biting the bullet and looking at how to slowly make an economy smaller. This is a very difficult solution, and new ground. But probably will have to be faced in the end anyhow.

b) But what is more maddening is that these issues - movement of labour, protection of industry, unions - these are traditionally the things the left have embraced or recognized as important to protect workers. They have utterly abandoned them, and in fact claim that they are far-right ideas.

There are lots of people in the current "left" parties who really think that concerns about movement of labour are racist and fascist. Their thinking is - Racist supported Brexit - Brexit was concerned about movement of labour/housing/etc - therefore these concerns are racist. Or - Trump aid he would protect the auto industry - Trump is far right - therefore protection of industry is far right.

Both of these types of policies are traditionally hated by the economic libertarians, who have somehow succeeded in convincing progressives they should embrace them. Not pragmatically, but ideologically, and as if they have always been believed by the left.

SnipSnapMe · 18/02/2023 21:53

Looking ahead, as the climate changes and becomes unpredictable there will be countries in the world where it becomes impossible to live. People will be forced to leave their homes, millions of them. It won't be about choosing where's nicest, it'll just be about survival - for every one of us. It's a problem the whole world is going to have to face up to. 😥

hoardod · 18/02/2023 21:39

I'm a 2nd gen immigrants born & raised in London. I didn't know anyone who wasn't 2nd gen until I went to uni. My part of London has always been very diverse, I don't know anything else.

woodhill · 18/02/2023 21:39

Rodneyisaplonker · 18/02/2023 21:36

Op, my grandparents were immigrants and horrifically abused,one of my grandfathers was brutally assaulted due to it. We are of Italian descent. “Dirty itI” was the term Brits like to shout at them. They were shunned.

they became wealthy, very respected in their community, now no one abuses you as you’re Italian descent.if anything it’s seen as cool. That’s what close to a century and the eu does,

Britain will always have a fear of immigrants, it’s nothing new.it’s being going on best part of a century now, it appalls and saddens me, but no way round the fact it’s an inbred reaction some have. This is nothing new. As said, best part of a century ago, the same racist shit was happening. The only thing that changed is the nationalities Of rhe immigrants.

but make no mistake, British people have always been guilty of this.

Would it be any different in a another country in those times

Rodneyisaplonker · 18/02/2023 21:36

Op, my grandparents were immigrants and horrifically abused,one of my grandfathers was brutally assaulted due to it. We are of Italian descent. “Dirty itI” was the term Brits like to shout at them. They were shunned.

they became wealthy, very respected in their community, now no one abuses you as you’re Italian descent.if anything it’s seen as cool. That’s what close to a century and the eu does,

Britain will always have a fear of immigrants, it’s nothing new.it’s being going on best part of a century now, it appalls and saddens me, but no way round the fact it’s an inbred reaction some have. This is nothing new. As said, best part of a century ago, the same racist shit was happening. The only thing that changed is the nationalities Of rhe immigrants.

but make no mistake, British people have always been guilty of this.

TigeToo · 18/02/2023 21:35

IWishItWasChristmas · 18/02/2023 21:30

You just keep repeating insults and add nothing to the thread. You're dismissed and I shall not be responding to you further

Interesting that your posting history spans all of one day. Stop trying to stir up race hate

hoardod · 18/02/2023 21:34

@DemiColon I've never called anyone a fascist or a racist though. I think a major issue with Brexit was that debate was shut down with cries of racist. Of course one can have concerns re immigration without being a racist.

However I'm not sure why saying we have an ageing population & that our system is set up to use immigration to prop up the economic model is anything other than stating the facts?

IWishItWasChristmas · 18/02/2023 21:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You just keep repeating insults and add nothing to the thread. You're dismissed and I shall not be responding to you further

TigeToo · 18/02/2023 21:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

IWishItWasChristmas · 18/02/2023 21:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

boabitybowster · 18/02/2023 21:27

It’s interesting to me that settled immigrants are often the ones calling loudest for the borders to be controlled. Why do you think that is?

@RudsyFarmer If it's true then yes it's interesting, but what specific settled groups are often calling the loudest? I'm not doubting you (although I am surprised) but it's absolutely not what I'm seeing or hearing.

DemiColon · 18/02/2023 21:27

hoardod · 18/02/2023 21:18

Totally. The biggest gains of the libertarian right, in my opinion, have been that Brexit, and the Trump election in the US, somehow made the political "left" start shilling for neoliberal capitalist policies. And calling anyone who wanted something else a fascist!

Or perhaps people simply recognise the fact that the model we have is based on immigration propping up the population so if that system isn't working we dont currently have an alternative.

One can acknowledge the reality without actually believing it's the best solution...

No, I don't think that is the case. You don't call people racists and fascists because you are being pragmatic about the realities. You do it because you think they are espousing evil ideas.

And it's not just immigration. All kinds of policies that were normative on the left, like protection of industry, are now derided as "far right" because they are seen as connected to people like Trump. Trump says he will protect American industry, so suddenly these numpties think free trade is a leftist thing? They are idiots, and classist wankers, not pragmatists.

TigeToo · 18/02/2023 21:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Haha in your dreams. Thankfully these ridiculous ideas of yours will never see the light of day. Our government might be stupid, but they’re not that bloody stupid.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 18/02/2023 21:26

No a total end to immigration is silly and impractical. But, a limit. I live in a street with lots of recent immigration and it causes so many issues. There are eight English households on a street of 120 houses. The problem a complete disregard of cultural values. If you have more people from another culture in an area then there will be issues as their culture will dominate which will cause frictions. Keeping a balance is important.

frustratednomad · 18/02/2023 21:25

@IWishItWasChristmas I think you are a troll too, no immigrant I have ever met has your attitude.

TigeToo · 18/02/2023 21:25

frustratednomad · 18/02/2023 21:23

@IWishItWasChristmas you said we should move out of our houses to make way for families with children despite having worked and paid for our houses but you aren't prepared to give up your house that was given to you for free for another family with say six children? Entitled or what!

Oh is she talking about people who have actually bought their house?? Jesus H Christ that’s even worse. Got to be a troll.

Justanotherlurker · 18/02/2023 21:25

IWishItWasChristmas · 18/02/2023 21:14

It isn't about " newer or old immigrants". It's about needs of that specific immigrant

So the priority list now has caveats, is that specifically for immigrants only?

After all this is what you said:

I would support a family of immigrants particularly when children are involved to be prioritised over someone even if they were living here for 1000 years. The time someone has been here is irrelevant in assessing priority.

Following your logic, you have been here 8 years and recent immigrants with children are a priority over you?

MarshaBradyo · 18/02/2023 21:25

IWishItWasChristmas · 18/02/2023 21:17

Asylum

How did you find the process? Did you wait long before you could work etc

IWishItWasChristmas · 18/02/2023 21:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ReformedWaywardTeen · 18/02/2023 21:24

I think there is a huge difference between people wanting zero immigration and being concerned about how many we seem to welcome on an almost daily basis.

I have no issue with those who go via the proper channels and apply. After all, no one complains about Australia and their system where you are unlikely to get accepted without a trade, money or a sponsor.

However, I can't help but be concerned by Dover. I know many stories in the press are designed to sensationalise a situation, but it is uncontrolled. My concern isn't just for the numbers but how much we have paid France to attempt to stop it. France has basically banked it and laughed at us.

I also worry that it is mainly men. Whilst no one wants more women and children to drown, the amount of men is worrying. And are they really refugees or economic migrants? To my mind, refugees do indeed seek sanctuary in the first safe zone they reach.

As someone who lived near a very early hotel for migrants as a teen, who saw some of the behaviour these males engaged in, yes it worries me as I have a teen DD. There would be groups of 5 or 6, sitting on the wall outside and the things they used to say even to girls like me in school uniform was disgusting. They would think nothing of grabbing girls round the waist. And if you dared tell them to piss off the aggression was scary.

Not everyone is like that. But even a handful is unacceptable.

I also agree with someone who said our resources are at breaking point. The NHS is a big attraction and I saw an article this week about the money the NHS has lost due to health tourism, as they don't get paid by those who disappear after being treated.

I just think people would be less annoyed about it if we helped those on the streets already. Many are told they need to find their own private accomodation or that they are intentionally homeless. How must these people feel knowing that others get helped without question.

TigeToo · 18/02/2023 21:24

IWishItWasChristmas · 18/02/2023 21:23

and now the insults come out

I think you’ll find it’s you who is being insulting.

frustratednomad · 18/02/2023 21:23

@IWishItWasChristmas you said we should move out of our houses to make way for families with children despite having worked and paid for our houses but you aren't prepared to give up your house that was given to you for free for another family with say six children? Entitled or what!

IWishItWasChristmas · 18/02/2023 21:23

TigeToo · 18/02/2023 21:16

Of course you didn’t. Because you laughably believe that migrant families should be prioritised over British born families.

I think you’re a troll. I think you’re trying to provoke far right comments by posting provocatively in this manner. Nobody would be this selfish and entitled in real life.

and now the insults come out

TigeToo · 18/02/2023 21:21

IWishItWasChristmas · 18/02/2023 21:19

I think that is unlikely. I have 4 children. I'm not sure what point you are trying to make exactly?

new family has 5 children, get your bags packed!