Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are people that want zero immigration racist?

682 replies

equalstime · 15/10/2022 22:31

People that moan about migrants coming to this county - taking our jobs - taking our houses - draining the medical system - not settling in the first country they reach for asylum- they're racist right?

There will always be an element of migration and when you take account of UK born people that leave and non Uk people that enter our country, the net figure is no doubt reasonable. They are often willing to work and contribute to our society and economy - so why the hostility?

Why not accept as a country that we have en element of migration and embrace that, if not because your views are racist?

OP posts:
FixItUpChappie · 19/02/2023 04:40

Not necessarily that should say

FixItUpChappie · 19/02/2023 04:40

Maybe but not necessary. They might be lots of things.....selfish, greedy, self-centred, unaware of the benefits of immigration, worried about jobs, worried about resources, worried about taxes, they might be uneducated - that does not necessarily mean they have a problem with people because of the colour of their skin. Just a lazy sweeping generalization IMO.

Captiancorrellistuba · 19/02/2023 03:35

hoardod · 18/02/2023 20:49

We have an ageing population, without immigration our "natural" population would be declining. We actually need more immigrants or we face a lot higher taxes.

We certainly need more workers whether they be 'home grown' or immigrants.
However, we need people with skills not a continual stream of anonymous people who we can't evaluate coming over the Channel every day.

Unless this government gets a grip on the situation we risk becoming a dumping ground for criminals that the rest of Europe don't want.

Bicyclethief · 19/02/2023 00:42

Rodneyisaplonker · 18/02/2023 21:36

Op, my grandparents were immigrants and horrifically abused,one of my grandfathers was brutally assaulted due to it. We are of Italian descent. “Dirty itI” was the term Brits like to shout at them. They were shunned.

they became wealthy, very respected in their community, now no one abuses you as you’re Italian descent.if anything it’s seen as cool. That’s what close to a century and the eu does,

Britain will always have a fear of immigrants, it’s nothing new.it’s being going on best part of a century now, it appalls and saddens me, but no way round the fact it’s an inbred reaction some have. This is nothing new. As said, best part of a century ago, the same racist shit was happening. The only thing that changed is the nationalities Of rhe immigrants.

but make no mistake, British people have always been guilty of this.

I doubt it's just the British. It's human condition. I'm also of Italian descent we also suffered discrimination but the vast majority of British people are welcoming and fair. Our grandparents left their countries because they wanted a better life, they worked hard and were not entitled . The Uk gave them that better life and here we are, assimilated and proud to be Anglo Italian.

Florenz · 18/02/2023 23:54

We don't need more houses, we need fewer people. Building more houses just kicks the can down the road for a few years, the houses fill up and there's a shortage again. We can't build an infinite number of houses, we are a country with finite space and resources.

Justanotherlurker · 18/02/2023 23:31

hoardod · 18/02/2023 22:25

The world has had an productivity problem for decades, it isn't just a UK issue,

who said it was only a UK problem? nonetheless it's a problem here.

the neolib mantra is to make sure the GDP line keeps going up, (eg: house prices keep increasing in price),

house price growth above all else has fucked the economy so I'm not sure why people would want more of that.

the 'doctors and engineers' meme that we require via immigration means that you are ok with brain drain from countries that would need them to build there own economy. It is nothing more than a modern day serfdom.

Of course it's brain drain just like Australia trying to entice doctors from here over there. However I'm ok with it when it means I see a GP or get my operation.

The conversation will shift over the next few years as Labour take power and actually be in control instead of shouting from the side-lines with retroactive knee jerk responses such as we should adopt Keynesian economics instead of austerity despite Brown running openly stating the austerity is needed (and an EU mandate at the time).

I hope labour will get into power but I don't see things shifting too much re immigration . Personally I favour a radical overhaul of the tax system & would introduce some form of wealth tax, no one will vote for that though!

who said it was only a UK problem? nonetheless it's a problem here.

It was you that inniated the problem whilst ignore the globalised economy.

house price growth above all else has fucked the economy so I'm not sure why people would want more of that.

Well on top of introducing working tax credits which led to an increase in zero hour contracts for the magic hours that has contributed to the gig economy, good luck thinking that any government wants to be in charge when house prices crash, MN flipped on a coin during the last election, fully pro corbyn 1000 posts deep until he proposed those earning above ~80k as to pay higher taxes, despite the MN meme at that time of 'openly want to pay higher taxes to fund services' was suddenly inundated with how 80k isn't that a great wage,.

Of course it's brain drain just like Australia trying to entice doctors from here over there. However I'm ok with it when it means I see a GP or get my operation.

Perfect neolib response, I wish many of the FBPE crowd would be so open.

I hope labour will get into power but I don't see things shifting too much re immigration . Personally I favour a radical overhaul of the tax system & would introduce some form of wealth tax, no one will vote for that though!

It will, nordic countries who we was compared against as being inferior during the 2015 migrant crisis has shifted, it is no longer xenophobic/racist by default and ironically some countries are looking at a Rwanda situation, the fact Labour are going to be in power when we follow means the online narrative will change.

As for wealth tax, there are many cosy middle class labour heartlands that are opposing house building on brown field sites, so even labour voters have an I'm alright attitude.

JocelynBurnell · 18/02/2023 23:03

woodhill · 18/02/2023 22:21

Japan doesn't have a great deal of immigration

Isn't it natural to want to be around people like yourself to some extent

Japan has been a test case in shrinkonomics as a result of an aging population and low immigration.

Unlike Britain, Japan has a tradition of strong family care for older people whereby adult children look after dependent elderly parents by taking them into their homes and providing for them and caring for them.

In Britain, what will happen the elderly when there aren't enough workers to pay pensions and provide care. Many in Britain are barely able to provide for themselves and their families and aren't in a position to take care of elderly relatives.

Justanotherlurker · 18/02/2023 22:58

BrokenBonesStixStones · 18/02/2023 22:38

Considering the colonisation and plundering Britain done over the centuries it’s now time to pay the piper

Imagine thinking this is the intelligent response to make and not just copied a twitter hot take.

even during MN peak Clique days, trolls would have a small amount of nuance and argument to troll, I would suggest you unblock a lot of the responses you have so you get a wider version of history, maybe use your RG degree and no doubt PHD/MSc to realise the reductive statement you are suggesting.

hoardod · 18/02/2023 22:50

@DemiColon I may be confusing you with another poster but I thought you were replying to my posts saying the left this, the right wing this etc.

I agree with you that immigration is a ponzi scheme but that's the model we currently have & we have a major demographic shift looming.
I don't know what a smaller economy looks like so was interested to hear your thoughts about that.

Justanotherlurker · 18/02/2023 22:45

Is it only British people though? I‘ve spent some time in Germany - same issues exist there too. From what I‘ve heard, Italian and Turkish workers who came to Germany in the 1960s were often treated badly by the locals.

No it isn't, you only have to look at recent european election results and general polling to see that what MN perceives as us being a backwater of inherent racism and going to the dogs it based on nothing more than myopic op-eds that feed a narrative.

The age old MN goto of nordic countries/germany are something we should emulate and are the grown ups when it suits are now being quietly ignored with regards to NHS reform and situations where the left are starting to have adult conversations around immigration, so much so that left leaning parties have come out as openly saying they want limits.

I have spent years in China with my white male colleague, we both experienced outright racism that would make MN blush, I've been fortunate enough to invited to corporate boxes for football across the globe and seen many high end derby's, I have never seen a whole stadium erupt in monkey chants apart from italy, I haven't seen british women shouting racist abuse at Turkish like I did watching a group of young German women verbally attack an older group of Turkish men.

Myself being a brown UK immigrant has faced more racist comments in Scotland .

MN isn't representative

DemiColon · 18/02/2023 22:43

BrokenBonesStixStones · 18/02/2023 22:38

Considering the colonisation and plundering Britain done over the centuries it’s now time to pay the piper

How does that pencil out?

DemiColon · 18/02/2023 22:40

hoardod · 18/02/2023 22:00

@DemiColon I'm not the OP though & i'm
unsure why you replied to my posts and assumed you knew my political leanings. I didn't state anything that was based on opinion just fact.

Other options might include things like better supporting training, increasing productivity through research, possibly increasing mothers in the workforce, or actually biting the bullet and looking at how to slowly make an economy smaller. This is a very difficult solution, and new ground. But probably will have to be faced in the end anyhow.

The UK has had a productivity issue for decades. How do we make the economy smaller? what does that actually look like?

I know that you are not the OP and I have no ideas about your political leanings. I'm not sure why you think I did?

Many people have asked what a smaller economy might look like. I don't know but I think we will find out.

But that really wasn't the point of the post. I was talking about the fact that many people in the left now seem to be entirely unaware that movement of labour has always been a concern of the left, because of its affects on workers. And they accuse those who are concerned about it now of being far right or alt-right, or more often, racists.

What this means is those who promote policies like free movement, for their own nefarious purposes, can do so without having the ethical issues pointed out.

It's been a huge coup for global capitalists.

BrokenBonesStixStones · 18/02/2023 22:38

Considering the colonisation and plundering Britain done over the centuries it’s now time to pay the piper

hoardod · 18/02/2023 22:34

Japan doesn't have a great deal of immigration

Yes but Japan has at least planned for their ageing population. They introduced an insurance model to help cope over 20 yrs ago.

hoardod · 18/02/2023 22:31

The whole world needs to work on reducing the population by incentivising not having children or having one child instead of two or more.

Now I think that is a little racist.

Much of the west have birth rates below replacement level. even so one dc born here has a larger carbon footprint than the dc born in the sub Sahara where birth rates are high.

jcyclops · 18/02/2023 22:28

justasking111 · 18/02/2023 19:36

www.news.com.au/national/western-australia/western-australia-plans-to-steal-31000-british-workers-to-fill-job-vacancies/news-story/81293d04bdea50a8a3d028173b1b0578?amp

Next month Australian representatives are coming to the UK to recruit 31k employees, doctors, nurses, police officer etc. The UK government have objected. But there's nothing to stop them recruiting from abroad.

The UK government can complain as much as they want. They will be ignored, just as the complaints from Ghana are being ignored by the UK government following the revelation that more Ghanaian medical professionals work for the NHS than work in the whole of Ghana.

"A 2021 report from the House of Commons in the United Kingdom has revealed that there are more health professionals of Ghanaian origin working for the National Health Service (NHS-UK) than in Ghana. According to the report, a total of 3,395 healthcare workers from Ghana are working in the UK. This is against a total of 3,236 Ghanaians working in Ghana as of 2021. This development has been described by the Ghana Medical Association as disturbing."

Florenz · 18/02/2023 22:26

Increasing immigration is a guaranteed vote loser. Even most immigrants don't want more immigration.

hoardod · 18/02/2023 22:25

The world has had an productivity problem for decades, it isn't just a UK issue,

who said it was only a UK problem? nonetheless it's a problem here.

the neolib mantra is to make sure the GDP line keeps going up, (eg: house prices keep increasing in price),

house price growth above all else has fucked the economy so I'm not sure why people would want more of that.

the 'doctors and engineers' meme that we require via immigration means that you are ok with brain drain from countries that would need them to build there own economy. It is nothing more than a modern day serfdom.

Of course it's brain drain just like Australia trying to entice doctors from here over there. However I'm ok with it when it means I see a GP or get my operation.

The conversation will shift over the next few years as Labour take power and actually be in control instead of shouting from the side-lines with retroactive knee jerk responses such as we should adopt Keynesian economics instead of austerity despite Brown running openly stating the austerity is needed (and an EU mandate at the time).

I hope labour will get into power but I don't see things shifting too much re immigration . Personally I favour a radical overhaul of the tax system & would introduce some form of wealth tax, no one will vote for that though!

Florenz · 18/02/2023 22:23

The whole world needs to work on reducing the population by incentivising not having children or having one child instead of two or more. Companies are going to have to get used to not having a ready supply of workers, by investing in training, taking on school leavers and training them up in-house, and also in automation, look at the caring robot bears in Japan.

woodhill · 18/02/2023 22:21

Japan doesn't have a great deal of immigration

Isn't it natural to want to be around people like yourself to some extent

Fifi00 · 18/02/2023 22:21

Yes it's racist to want zero immigration. I only want skilled and jobs we need though.

Mira28 · 18/02/2023 22:18

Rodneyisaplonker · 18/02/2023 21:36

Op, my grandparents were immigrants and horrifically abused,one of my grandfathers was brutally assaulted due to it. We are of Italian descent. “Dirty itI” was the term Brits like to shout at them. They were shunned.

they became wealthy, very respected in their community, now no one abuses you as you’re Italian descent.if anything it’s seen as cool. That’s what close to a century and the eu does,

Britain will always have a fear of immigrants, it’s nothing new.it’s being going on best part of a century now, it appalls and saddens me, but no way round the fact it’s an inbred reaction some have. This is nothing new. As said, best part of a century ago, the same racist shit was happening. The only thing that changed is the nationalities Of rhe immigrants.

but make no mistake, British people have always been guilty of this.

Is it only British people though? I‘ve spent some time in Germany - same issues exist there too. From what I‘ve heard, Italian and Turkish workers who came to Germany in the 1960s were often treated badly by the locals.
It wasn’t right of course and luckily things have changed since then (although xenophobia of course still exists), but I think attitudes like exist in most countries.

Justanotherlurker · 18/02/2023 22:15

The UK has had a productivity issue for decades. How do we make the economy smaller? what does that actually look like?

The world has had an productivity problem for decades, it isn't just a UK issue, the neolib mantra is to make sure the GDP line keeps going up, (eg: house prices keep increasing in price), the 'doctors and engineers' meme that we require via immigration means that you are ok with brain drain from countries that would need them to build there own economy. It is nothing more than a modern day serfdom.

The conversation will shift over the next few years as Labour take power and actually be in control instead of shouting from the side-lines with retroactive knee jerk responses such as we should adopt Keynesian economics instead of austerity despite Brown running openly stating the austerity is needed (and an EU mandate at the time).

The issues are multi faceted and there is no simple solution, but you can guarantee that another Rwanda solution will be provided under a Labour government, and those championing an ever increasing GDP line goes up will have to admit they are not traditionally left wing.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 18/02/2023 22:01

My grandfather was hit by a car on purpose and called an outsider when he was living abroad in the 60’s. Being unwelcoming to immigrants is hardly a defining British trait. We have mass immigration and we absorb it and any disquiet about its social or economic effects are labelled racist. Sorry but the grooming gangs apologists on this thread show. I think looking at what has happened in Sweden shows that no matter how tolerant a country is there will be issues if you do not maintain controls over the people that move to a country.

hoardod · 18/02/2023 22:00

@DemiColon I'm not the OP though & i'm
unsure why you replied to my posts and assumed you knew my political leanings. I didn't state anything that was based on opinion just fact.

Other options might include things like better supporting training, increasing productivity through research, possibly increasing mothers in the workforce, or actually biting the bullet and looking at how to slowly make an economy smaller. This is a very difficult solution, and new ground. But probably will have to be faced in the end anyhow.

The UK has had a productivity issue for decades. How do we make the economy smaller? what does that actually look like?