Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are people that want zero immigration racist?

682 replies

equalstime · 15/10/2022 22:31

People that moan about migrants coming to this county - taking our jobs - taking our houses - draining the medical system - not settling in the first country they reach for asylum- they're racist right?

There will always be an element of migration and when you take account of UK born people that leave and non Uk people that enter our country, the net figure is no doubt reasonable. They are often willing to work and contribute to our society and economy - so why the hostility?

Why not accept as a country that we have en element of migration and embrace that, if not because your views are racist?

OP posts:
DancingDaughter50 · 19/02/2023 11:34

The way you phrased it op, yes. Eg immigrants coming here taking our money etc.

However what happened to us as a country a decade ago has unfortunately skewed what normal immigration is because Tony Blair didn't properly due due diligence on potential immigration figures.

The level and volume of immigration we had In a very short space of time was extraordinary and I don't blame anyone for being deeply concerned about that.

Overall of course properly controlled immigration and migration is something that enriches any country.

lollipoprainbow · 19/02/2023 11:34

Mycatsgoldtooth · 19/02/2023 10:41

@Aphrathestorm English people are the only people in the world who are not allowed to have any concerns about who lives in their country and how their tax money is spent. If you even think about this you are racist. Other countries are allowed as they have cultures. Apparently our culture doesn’t exist so there is no reason for us to care who lives here and the affect this has on the nation.

Anyone moving to the uk is a vital health care worker. To notice this is not true is racist.

Every other country is a paradise of integration where all immigrants are welcomed and there is no racism. Only in the uk are people made to feel unwelcome.

Crimes committed by people moving to this country don’t matter because we deserve it anyway because hundreds of years ago we had an empire. Because we are all still racist because of history. Other countries empires don’t matter because they are not England. Even Scotland’s colonialism is ok. Only English people are guilty of empire crimes and we deserve to pay. Doesn’t matter if your ancestors were peasant farmers dying at 30 they were still privileged so you should, by that rational, accept Albanian refugees, who are not refugees but their country is not as rich as England.

If people come from a country worth less wealth we have a moral duty to give them some of ours, with no question of if we can afford it, if it is beneficial to the people who already live here. Or you are racist.

It is never the fault of other countries leaders and citizens for the problems in their countries. Only English people are responsible for all the worlds ills. Say otherwise and you are racist.

These are the mumsnet rules.

👏👏👏👏👏

frustratednomad · 19/02/2023 10:51

@Mycatsgoldtooth spot on.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 19/02/2023 10:41

@Aphrathestorm English people are the only people in the world who are not allowed to have any concerns about who lives in their country and how their tax money is spent. If you even think about this you are racist. Other countries are allowed as they have cultures. Apparently our culture doesn’t exist so there is no reason for us to care who lives here and the affect this has on the nation.

Anyone moving to the uk is a vital health care worker. To notice this is not true is racist.

Every other country is a paradise of integration where all immigrants are welcomed and there is no racism. Only in the uk are people made to feel unwelcome.

Crimes committed by people moving to this country don’t matter because we deserve it anyway because hundreds of years ago we had an empire. Because we are all still racist because of history. Other countries empires don’t matter because they are not England. Even Scotland’s colonialism is ok. Only English people are guilty of empire crimes and we deserve to pay. Doesn’t matter if your ancestors were peasant farmers dying at 30 they were still privileged so you should, by that rational, accept Albanian refugees, who are not refugees but their country is not as rich as England.

If people come from a country worth less wealth we have a moral duty to give them some of ours, with no question of if we can afford it, if it is beneficial to the people who already live here. Or you are racist.

It is never the fault of other countries leaders and citizens for the problems in their countries. Only English people are responsible for all the worlds ills. Say otherwise and you are racist.

These are the mumsnet rules.

Aphrathestorm · 19/02/2023 09:00

NRFT but Japan afaik has a (almost?) zero immigration policy.

I think brits can go there for a year to teach English but can never become permanent residents (unless through marriage?)

But they are feeling the negative effects of this policy.

They have social cohesion but an elderly care crisis and perilously low birth rate.

No one seems to accuse them of being racist though?

hoardod · 19/02/2023 08:53

There is (imo) no arbitrary standard. But, as with all choices in life - there are consequences.

I’ve been an immigrant elsewhere and was stunned when I returned to the uk to see just how much “stuff” the British have. Consumerism is not “standards”.

But there is huge inequality in the UK at least compared to many European countries. The reality is living standards will decline most for the have nots who often have limited choices. The haves are mostly insulated from the consequences.

hoardod · 19/02/2023 08:51

But it leads me on to my next point (environmentalism) - I’d rather keep my petrol fiesta on the road than have the blood of African children mining for battery components on my hands.

How have you avoided it for your phone?

FatSealSmugSoup · 19/02/2023 08:32

@hoardod (and others) - I’m delighted to read of new medical schools.

“oung people have already seen a decline in standards of living & are facing increased retirement ages despite no increase in healthy life expectancy. How low should standards of living be?”

There is (imo) no arbitrary standard. But, as with all choices in life - there are consequences.

I’ve been an immigrant elsewhere and was stunned when I returned to the uk to see just how much “stuff” the British have. Consumerism is not “standards”.

But it leads me on to my next point (environmentalism) - I’d rather keep my petrol fiesta on the road than have the blood of African children mining for battery components on my hands.

Each and every one of us makes choices which are best for us and our families. You need only take a glance at the property board to see that (current thread Blackheath/Eltham). Doesn’t mean we can’t acknowledge the consequences even if we don’t like them spoken out loud.

life isn’t black and white- and successive governments have kicked this can down the road for generations - and well, the gig is nearly up.

hoardod · 19/02/2023 07:40

yes which was my point we don't have enough workers currently & I'm not convinced we won't ever not need overseas workers.

Captiancorrellistuba · 19/02/2023 07:33

We are also increasing our own training of medics, although the results will take a while to show

www.themedicportal.com/application-guide/medical-school-interview/nhs-hot-topics/the-five-new-medical-schools/

Captiancorrellistuba · 19/02/2023 07:21

hoardod · 19/02/2023 07:19

but i'm confused why you responded to my post? Have the NHS stopped recruiting abroad?

Not at all.

www.england.nhs.uk/london/2022/06/22/the-capitals-nhs-supports-refugees-to-become-doctors-with-medical-support-worker-role/

hoardod · 19/02/2023 07:20

is

hoardod · 19/02/2023 07:20

There apparently 190k vacancies.

Captiancorrellistuba · 19/02/2023 07:19

Here is another initiative to increase NHS staffing levels;

www.gov.uk/government/news/action-to-bolster-nhs-workforce-and-retain-senior-doctors

hoardod · 19/02/2023 07:19

but i'm confused why you responded to my post? Have the NHS stopped recruiting abroad?

Captiancorrellistuba · 19/02/2023 07:12

hoardod · 19/02/2023 07:05

@Captiancorrellistuba are you just agreeing with me then? I'm not sure why you replied to my point about huge numbers of NHS staff in London being 1st or 2nd gen immigrants & we don't have the workforce to replace them?

It was a general response addressing falling NHS numbers across the board, not just NHS workers in London.

hoardod · 19/02/2023 07:10

The article quotes "Health and Social Care Secretary Steve Barclay said: “Boosting domestic and international recruitment is vital for our efforts to prepare the NHS "

Then it quotes Ridwan "I come from Nigeria"

I'm not sure why you think the status quo has changed?

Not to mention that 35k jobs is a drop in the ocean when you look at social care & NHS vacancies plus we all know there is retention issue.

hoardod · 19/02/2023 07:05

@Captiancorrellistuba are you just agreeing with me then? I'm not sure why you replied to my point about huge numbers of NHS staff in London being 1st or 2nd gen immigrants & we don't have the workforce to replace them?

Captiancorrellistuba · 19/02/2023 06:50

hoardod · 19/02/2023 06:40

@Captiancorrellistuba have you actually read the article you have linked?

Yes.

I don't get your point?

hoardod · 19/02/2023 06:40

@Captiancorrellistuba have you actually read the article you have linked?

Captiancorrellistuba · 19/02/2023 06:32

@hoardod

"If you live in London a huge number of the NHS are 1st or 2nd gen immigrants. Why do you think we have the workers to replace them?"

Well according to this the NHS is doing just that -

www.england.nhs.uk/2022/08/tens-of-thousands-of-people-sign-up-to-careers-in-the-nhs/

hoardod · 19/02/2023 06:31

and I firmly believe we need to fix from within. We need to train our own medics - not steal from countries who so desperately need them themselves.

It's a great soundbjte but unfortunately saying something doesn't make it happen. The above requires money & investment.

we need to accept a lower standard of living - rather than engage in Ponzi-style population growth which fucks over our descendants.

young people have already seen a decline in standards of living & are facing increased retirement ages despite no increase in healthy life expectancy. How low should standards of living be?

hoardod · 19/02/2023 06:25

good luck thinking that any government wants to be in charge when house prices crash,

I don't think any government wants that. I don't understand why people want ever increasing house prices, it's a major reason for our low productivity. That's a reason why things won't change, we haven't invested in young people & now it's too late to change, which is my point.

Perfect neolib response, I wish many of the FBPE crowd would be so open.

I'm not a neoliberal I'm just realistic. And it's exactly what my parents did, why would I have an issue with it? If you live in London a huge number of the NHS are 1st or 2nd gen immigrants. Why do you think we have the workers to replace them?

FatSealSmugSoup · 19/02/2023 04:58

Yes! Let’s make up for “centuries of plundering the colonies” by stealing medical staff. 🤦‍♀️ I’m disappointed (although not shocked) by that Ghana report - and I say disappointed because I’ve had similar suspicions for years and I’m not ok with it.

Ironically someone on this thread said she “didn’t care” (about Ghana et al) as long as she herself can get a medic - oh yeh, she’s all for immigration.

ALL western economies are in decline - and I firmly believe we need to fix from within. We need to train our own medics - not steal from countries who so desperately need them themselves.

we need to accept a lower standard of living - rather than engage in Ponzi-style population growth which fucks over our descendants.

“wah wah wah there’s nothing on the shelves in Waitrose”. Well toots, you wanted the farmland built on.

Anyway, my point is - I will NEVER be ok taking medical staff from women (I honestly care less about men) in Ghana just so I can pat myself on the back and claim the “right side of history”. Happy to be on the wrong side and content with my morality.