Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are people that want zero immigration racist?

682 replies

equalstime · 15/10/2022 22:31

People that moan about migrants coming to this county - taking our jobs - taking our houses - draining the medical system - not settling in the first country they reach for asylum- they're racist right?

There will always be an element of migration and when you take account of UK born people that leave and non Uk people that enter our country, the net figure is no doubt reasonable. They are often willing to work and contribute to our society and economy - so why the hostility?

Why not accept as a country that we have en element of migration and embrace that, if not because your views are racist?

OP posts:
Usou · 20/02/2023 07:30

No.

The country has been absorbing huge numbers of immigrants for decades now, with consequent negative impacts on housing - availability and prices, service provision etc.

Many are from countries with far lower population densities and without any particular problems such as wars.

WinterFoxes · 20/02/2023 07:20

halfsiesonapotnoodle · 15/10/2022 22:37

I doubt it's anything to do with actual race but more to do with the fact we are a tiny island, whose population has grown massively since the 50s and is actually causing many services to be at breaking point. We have too many people.

Are people who hold that view OK with all other countries having similar rules, so no Brits should be allowed to migrate to Canada, USA, Australia, Europe, Dubai etc in search of a better life?

Should no one be allowed to marry and settle here if they fell in love with a non-Brit? Where should a Brit live if maaried to a Jordanian or a Norwegian? What if those countries didn't allow a UK citizen to settle there?

We may be a small island but we are part of a big planet.

Kabalagala · 20/02/2023 07:13

Felicitythecat · 20/02/2023 06:55

My ancestors were Saxon farmers living in Yorkshire, maybe I should put a claim in to the French because the Normans stole our lands and murdered many of our people?
( I've just got to decide if I want the compensation paid in Euros or £s ) 🤔

Yeah because the colonies were all ancient history weren't they? It's totally not true that many only got independence within our (or our parents) lifetimes.
Not remotely a good comparison.

Felicitythecat · 20/02/2023 06:55

BrokenBonesStixStones · 18/02/2023 22:38

Considering the colonisation and plundering Britain done over the centuries it’s now time to pay the piper

My ancestors were Saxon farmers living in Yorkshire, maybe I should put a claim in to the French because the Normans stole our lands and murdered many of our people?
( I've just got to decide if I want the compensation paid in Euros or £s ) 🤔

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 20/02/2023 06:52

Icecreamandapplepie · 15/10/2022 22:40

Zero immigration? That would be madness, not sure anyone would argue for that 🤔

Sone people do argue for this ridiculous position...

We NEED talented migrants.

Local hospitals have cancelled operation lists /closed wards as they have lost so many staff post brexit.

Felicitythecat · 20/02/2023 06:49

Mycatsgoldtooth · 18/02/2023 22:01

My grandfather was hit by a car on purpose and called an outsider when he was living abroad in the 60’s. Being unwelcoming to immigrants is hardly a defining British trait. We have mass immigration and we absorb it and any disquiet about its social or economic effects are labelled racist. Sorry but the grooming gangs apologists on this thread show. I think looking at what has happened in Sweden shows that no matter how tolerant a country is there will be issues if you do not maintain controls over the people that move to a country.

You are correct.

If we don't do something about stemming the tide of extra people then we will have civil disobedience.
It is already starting in some areas - thelincolnite.co.uk/2023/02/veterans-before-illegals-protestors-to-march-through-skegness/

Chicca1970 · 20/02/2023 03:07

The dissatisfaction within the Care sector around wages does not, it might surprise you, come from UK workers alone - non UK nationals employed by agencies and Care companies are all impacted by the cost of living and Care is becoming increasingly unionised.

In the meantime, I am welcoming colleagues that plug a huge gap that will never be filled by UK workers (even if our wages significantly went up). For a lot of Brits, the job is too physically and emotionally demanding. Brits do not look after themselves - fact - IDGAF whether people slate me or not for this. I work with some fantastic English people but there is too much whining, bitching and avoidance of work as well - I am fed up with covering shifts for people who have a shit ton of relationship issues, cocaine habits, drink habits, don’t eat properly, can’t be arsed etc etc - sorry to rant.

I am a Labour voter btw.

Justanotherlurker · 19/02/2023 23:23

If you are going to play the GDP line goes up rhetoric you should at least understand the annual income you need to be a net beneficent to make improve the GDP line, for one it is about 10K more than the wage you have implied with no children, and that is including the hidden VAT that some like to state, that is before we introduce supply and demand on housing/gp access etc.

The vast majority are used as backfill low paid work or to flood the market to prevent wage inflation, whilst the majority of immigration is a good thing (and I am an immigrant myself) some people need to understand they are championing thatcher free market/neolib policies cloaked under e left leaning umbrella.

Chicca1970 · 19/02/2023 22:52

It’s more bloody ignorance than racism. I work in the Care sector and the company I work for has just recruited a whole bunch of amazing people from Zimbabwe - They have worked in equivalent healthcare jobs mostly in Harare. We have been hideously short staffed for months and finally have the help we need. They are courteous, hard working, have excellent English and are incredibly valuable to our sector. They are all individually renting rooms at £500-£600 per month on salaries of £26k - they are employed on 3 year contracts and have husbands and kids who may join them - their husbands’ jobs range from accountant to Médecins sans Frontières nurse - when their families join them, their kids will excel at school and as family units they will not be living in social housing or claiming shed loads of benefits.

The point is the vast majority of immigrants are a huge asset to our economy and society and people need to get their heads out of their arses.

Saschka · 19/02/2023 19:34

Aphrathestorm · 19/02/2023 09:00

NRFT but Japan afaik has a (almost?) zero immigration policy.

I think brits can go there for a year to teach English but can never become permanent residents (unless through marriage?)

But they are feeling the negative effects of this policy.

They have social cohesion but an elderly care crisis and perilously low birth rate.

No one seems to accuse them of being racist though?

People definitely accuse them of being racist! Japanese society is shockingly so, I don’t think many people would seriously argue otherwise.

poetryandwine · 19/02/2023 18:58

I am a white immigrant from a socially acceptable EU country settled here by marriage. Also my heritage is part British. Even though I still speak English with an accent, when discussing immigration I get the same reaction as the other white professional PPs: ‘I didn’t mean you’.

The NHS and social services are gasping because of years of underfunding, not an exploding population.

I agree with those who say that much of the anti-immigrant sentiment is really disguised xenophobia and racism. The NHS and the social care, farming, academic and STEM sectors need immigrants! Jobs are not being properly filled from the home population.

justasking111 · 19/02/2023 18:42

Both my friends sons are planning to go to Australia as doctors. Leaving behind broken hearts. BUT parents understand why.

ReformedWaywardTeen · 19/02/2023 18:21

SerendipityJane · 19/02/2023 16:28

The argument over the need for NHS staff would be solved far easier if it wasn't impossible for so many to go to university.

What ? And go against 40 years of government policy ?

My nephew trained as a Doctor and qualified in 2021, it cost over 50k to do so and he now has that debt for however long it takes, rather than qualifying and being able to own a home he is sharing a rental with 3 other NQ doctors.

If he took the Western Australian governments offer up, he wouldn't have to repay it ...

Thankfully, he doesn't want to go abroad due to family. He said it is tempting though as he works bloody hard and gets little appreciation.

Not from patients, although he's had a few get gobby, but he puts that down to wait times and people having unrealistic ideas of wait times and waiting lists in general. He also said he mostly excuses it because he can tell they or their family member is frustrated, often anxious, and it comes out in anger from time to time.

And I agree about 40 years of flagrant ignorance of low skilled jobs being the only thing available, hence why so many are unemployed or in sectors that don't cover bills and rent.

SerendipityJane · 19/02/2023 16:28

The argument over the need for NHS staff would be solved far easier if it wasn't impossible for so many to go to university.

What ? And go against 40 years of government policy ?

My nephew trained as a Doctor and qualified in 2021, it cost over 50k to do so and he now has that debt for however long it takes, rather than qualifying and being able to own a home he is sharing a rental with 3 other NQ doctors.

If he took the Western Australian governments offer up, he wouldn't have to repay it ...

TigeToo · 19/02/2023 13:30

Mycatsgoldtooth · 19/02/2023 10:41

@Aphrathestorm English people are the only people in the world who are not allowed to have any concerns about who lives in their country and how their tax money is spent. If you even think about this you are racist. Other countries are allowed as they have cultures. Apparently our culture doesn’t exist so there is no reason for us to care who lives here and the affect this has on the nation.

Anyone moving to the uk is a vital health care worker. To notice this is not true is racist.

Every other country is a paradise of integration where all immigrants are welcomed and there is no racism. Only in the uk are people made to feel unwelcome.

Crimes committed by people moving to this country don’t matter because we deserve it anyway because hundreds of years ago we had an empire. Because we are all still racist because of history. Other countries empires don’t matter because they are not England. Even Scotland’s colonialism is ok. Only English people are guilty of empire crimes and we deserve to pay. Doesn’t matter if your ancestors were peasant farmers dying at 30 they were still privileged so you should, by that rational, accept Albanian refugees, who are not refugees but their country is not as rich as England.

If people come from a country worth less wealth we have a moral duty to give them some of ours, with no question of if we can afford it, if it is beneficial to the people who already live here. Or you are racist.

It is never the fault of other countries leaders and citizens for the problems in their countries. Only English people are responsible for all the worlds ills. Say otherwise and you are racist.

These are the mumsnet rules.

Excellent post, spot on

justasking111 · 19/02/2023 13:05

We're in a tourism and retirement area. Sell up in the North West buy in North Wales eventually health declines. So you need carers. The Eastern Europeans I know are more caring and nicer than the retirees offspring back in the north west who can't be bothered to care but are paranoid about losing any inheritance.

Hospitality. Reception, housekeeping, restaurant, kitchen. They're hard working and reliable.

God only knows what they think of us.

ReformedWaywardTeen · 19/02/2023 12:59

The argument over the need for NHS staff would be solved far easier if it wasn't impossible for so many to go to university.

My nephew trained as a Doctor and qualified in 2021, it cost over 50k to do so and he now has that debt for however long it takes, rather than qualifying and being able to own a home he is sharing a rental with 3 other NQ doctors.

Nurses do now get a bursary but it's not enough of an incentive.

Even those who do manage aren't respected, and we will inevitably lose them to Australia and New Zealand. Nephew has already been headhunted by the US.

When so many nurses are having to supplement their income with UC, itself a soul destroying and anxiety fuelling hellscape, why would anyone bother?

And that goes for teachers, police, you name a key worker and they get paid shit and treated like shit.

Imagine getting into so much debt only to be treated like dirt!

All these issues link up.

So many are leaving school now, only GCSEs or A'levels, can't afford uni so skilled careers that could last a lifetime are out of reach. There's no retail industry on a level with when I left school, you have so many zero hours rip off jobs which doesn't offer secure pay. So then it's topped up with UC. They can't buy homes or get a mortgage, fuelling a social housing crisis. They can't afford anything but the basics of food, so no cars, no holidays, no retail therapy as they have to watch every penny for rent and utilities. So no VAT going back into the country.

So open up education past 18 as means tested, offer careers for those who want academic careers. And bring back stuff like teaching car mechanics, plumbing and building to those who aren't so fussed on uni.

It just seems so obvious to me. But instead we rely too heavily on workers from abroad. Which puts kids already here at a disadvantage.

boabitybowster · 19/02/2023 12:47

On the other hand, I'd have serious reservations about people moving here from other locations (eastern Europe), with whom we have very little share history.

@ScreamingBees I agree with your broader point but not this, and find it bizarre you don't recognise many Brits have a shared history with eastern Europeans - whether through present family or heritage, and also global historical "events", but at least you acknowledge your bias or lack of perspective as it were.

woodhill · 19/02/2023 12:44

Benefit from the wealth

woodhill · 19/02/2023 12:44

BrokenBonesStixStones · 18/02/2023 22:38

Considering the colonisation and plundering Britain done over the centuries it’s now time to pay the piper

Haven't we done this already by allowing the people in those countries to come to Britain and be edit from that wealth.

The common people of the time had no say in policy or a vote a

woodhill · 19/02/2023 12:37

Mycatsgoldtooth · 19/02/2023 10:41

@Aphrathestorm English people are the only people in the world who are not allowed to have any concerns about who lives in their country and how their tax money is spent. If you even think about this you are racist. Other countries are allowed as they have cultures. Apparently our culture doesn’t exist so there is no reason for us to care who lives here and the affect this has on the nation.

Anyone moving to the uk is a vital health care worker. To notice this is not true is racist.

Every other country is a paradise of integration where all immigrants are welcomed and there is no racism. Only in the uk are people made to feel unwelcome.

Crimes committed by people moving to this country don’t matter because we deserve it anyway because hundreds of years ago we had an empire. Because we are all still racist because of history. Other countries empires don’t matter because they are not England. Even Scotland’s colonialism is ok. Only English people are guilty of empire crimes and we deserve to pay. Doesn’t matter if your ancestors were peasant farmers dying at 30 they were still privileged so you should, by that rational, accept Albanian refugees, who are not refugees but their country is not as rich as England.

If people come from a country worth less wealth we have a moral duty to give them some of ours, with no question of if we can afford it, if it is beneficial to the people who already live here. Or you are racist.

It is never the fault of other countries leaders and citizens for the problems in their countries. Only English people are responsible for all the worlds ills. Say otherwise and you are racist.

These are the mumsnet rules.

You sum it up so well

ScreamingBees · 19/02/2023 12:15

I'll also state, working in the software industry, that we really don't educate enough good quality local talent, and there is no sign that will will change. Encouraging people from abroad, with relevant qualifications, is critical for tech industry here. The US are very effective in taking the best/brightest/most educated i the tech area, without having the cost of training them in the first place!

ScreamingBees · 19/02/2023 12:12

Given our family history, I've possibly a different perspective. Our family moved back to England in early 70s (from Southern Rhodesia). Since that time, we've known many people who've here, including children of families that worked with us. Lots of Zimbabweans moved here during the 90s especially. Personally, I think the door should be (mostly) open to people from former colonies, protectorates, etc. with whom we have a shared history.

On the other hand, I'd have serious reservations about people moving here from other locations (eastern Europe), with whom we have very little share history.

Florenz · 19/02/2023 12:05

The Brexit vote was nearly 7 years ago. There's no excuse for a lack of trained staff anymore, except from professions where it takes more than 7 years training to do the job.

Xenia · 19/02/2023 11:54

It is a new time in 2023 with global warming and much else. Most popular Western nations are going to have to decide how many new people they want to move in to their countries. No one is saying it is an easy issue but the UK has taken far many more people than many countries. Eg Canada is much much better than the UK with much more space and yet has about half the number of people we have in the UK., In 2022 the Uk had its highest net immigration ever at about 500,000 (about 1m immigration) (which if this is really going to lead to more tax generated and better better lives for British people I have yet to see the evidennce)