Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are people that want zero immigration racist?

682 replies

equalstime · 15/10/2022 22:31

People that moan about migrants coming to this county - taking our jobs - taking our houses - draining the medical system - not settling in the first country they reach for asylum- they're racist right?

There will always be an element of migration and when you take account of UK born people that leave and non Uk people that enter our country, the net figure is no doubt reasonable. They are often willing to work and contribute to our society and economy - so why the hostility?

Why not accept as a country that we have en element of migration and embrace that, if not because your views are racist?

OP posts:
Mycatsgoldtooth · 20/02/2023 12:26

But it’s a straw man argument isn’t it. We must support mass immigration because there are people who support zero immigration. If you want any kind of controls on people moving to this country then you are in with the ‘send ‘em back’ brigade.

The majority of people across the world support jess immigration to their countries. In Italy it’s 71%, Germany 52%. But looking at the policies of governments you’d think not supporting mass immigration was a niche view. Do we honestly think that the millions people from we have from abroad are only having a positive effect on life in the U.K.? Many from cultures that are so different to ours and others who actively dislike our way of life and harbour resentments to our nation. Just look at the terrorist attacks over the last few years. Can you imagine an English person trying to bomb a maternity ward? There should be safeguards against people who harbour these feelings or have these beliefs living here. Visas, boarder controls, background checks…I just don’t see these things as controversial.

Cultural cohesion is the foundation of a high trust society in which welfare state policies and the rule of law flourish as you have high cultural buy in from the citizens. The more diverse a society, with groups not integrating, then unfortunately the less social harmony, lower levels of trust in the country. Different groups will then use politics as a means to compete for resources and power. Which will cause resentment and unrest. We are already seeing this in the very poor areas being expected to absorb high migration levels.

TiredArse · 20/02/2023 12:16

SerendipityJane · 20/02/2023 12:09

Have you read the Express comments section ? Not only do plenty of people support it, plenty more support negative immigration aka "send them back".

I was just coming to say the same.

GGMTJ · 20/02/2023 12:12

IcedPurple · 20/02/2023 12:04

But almost nboody actually supports "zero immigration".

This simply isn't true, I'm afraid.

SerendipityJane · 20/02/2023 12:09

IcedPurple · 20/02/2023 12:04

But almost nboody actually supports "zero immigration".

Have you read the Express comments section ? Not only do plenty of people support it, plenty more support negative immigration aka "send them back".

SerendipityJane · 20/02/2023 12:07

It isn’t racism to think that asylum seekers should claim asylum in the first safe country. That is what they are supposed to do. Travelling onward is no longer asylum seeking, it’s economic migration.

It may not be racist, but it certainly isn't Brexit. And since Brexit is the will of the people, I think it's a bit undemocratic to complain about it's effects unless you are a traitor.

IcedPurple · 20/02/2023 12:04

GGMTJ · 20/02/2023 12:02

No, they don't, and their citizens don't have an automatic right to come here. People who support zero immigration aren't just arguing that immigrants should meet certain requirements- that's already the case and our requirements are strict too- they're arguing for zero immigration.

But almost nboody actually supports "zero immigration".

GGMTJ · 20/02/2023 12:02

IcedPurple · 20/02/2023 11:36

British citizens do not have an automatic right to live in any of those countries.

In all cases, they would need to satisfy immigration requirements, which are pretty strict in at least some of the nations you mention.

No, they don't, and their citizens don't have an automatic right to come here. People who support zero immigration aren't just arguing that immigrants should meet certain requirements- that's already the case and our requirements are strict too- they're arguing for zero immigration.

Xenia · 20/02/2023 12:00

I don't see Japan as a country with big issues caused by lack of immigration. I think it is content with its elderly population and fewer people, even if that means less money.

IcedPurple · 20/02/2023 11:36

WinterFoxes · 20/02/2023 07:20

Are people who hold that view OK with all other countries having similar rules, so no Brits should be allowed to migrate to Canada, USA, Australia, Europe, Dubai etc in search of a better life?

Should no one be allowed to marry and settle here if they fell in love with a non-Brit? Where should a Brit live if maaried to a Jordanian or a Norwegian? What if those countries didn't allow a UK citizen to settle there?

We may be a small island but we are part of a big planet.

British citizens do not have an automatic right to live in any of those countries.

In all cases, they would need to satisfy immigration requirements, which are pretty strict in at least some of the nations you mention.

GGMTJ · 20/02/2023 10:04

Overthinkingnotdrinking · 20/02/2023 09:19

Yes do these mythical Peter Pan immigrants never get old or are they expected to bugger off once they have stopped being useful and need care themselves? These are people that will need housing, need education, health care and will end up needing pensions too. All these things cost a great deal and unless they are making over 38k a year they will be costing the public purse more then they will be contributing in tax.

This is fine though if immigration brings in young working people who then get old, as long as the potential support ratio stays reasonably steady. At the moment there are 3.4 working age adults in the UK for every person 65+- that is, 3.4 working people to fund the healthcare, pension etc of each elderly person. Stop immigration without increasing the birth rate and you very quickly end up with a much lower number of workers to retired age. It's a huge problem- look at Japan.

OhMammaMia · 20/02/2023 09:28

ChocFrog · 15/10/2022 22:46

It isn’t racism to be concerned about immigration levels. England is massively overpopulated compared to most other countries and services are at breaking point. You say that the net figures are “no doubt reasonable” but the problem is, they aren’t.

It isn’t racism to think that asylum seekers should claim asylum in the first safe country. That is what they are supposed to do. Travelling onward is no longer asylum seeking, it’s economic migration.

I live in Kent, we’ve had 22,000 migrants delivered to Kent’s beaches so far this year by people smugglers - and that’s just the ones who were caught. All of them need housing and food. All of the support network is full so some unaccompanied children are being placed in hotels - from where many go missing. (Your guess is as good as mine who takes children that no one is watching.)

Labelling concerns about this racist is unhelpful and inaccurate.

I just hope you don't expect them to be moved from Kent. If that's where they reached the country, that's where they should stay.

Overthinkingnotdrinking · 20/02/2023 09:19

Yes do these mythical Peter Pan immigrants never get old or are they expected to bugger off once they have stopped being useful and need care themselves? These are people that will need housing, need education, health care and will end up needing pensions too. All these things cost a great deal and unless they are making over 38k a year they will be costing the public purse more then they will be contributing in tax.

lazycats · 20/02/2023 08:59

ChChChChangeName · 20/02/2023 08:56

The UK has an ageing population and a birthrate of 1.56. Non-immigration population growth has come from people living longer, not from having babies. It's a huge problem in the pipeline.

I'd be interested to know how supporters of zero immigration would suggest we deal with this.

They'll say it's chicken and egg: less immigration = more freed up public services. Doesn't actually solve the ageing crisis at all, but that'll be the logic.

ChChChChangeName · 20/02/2023 08:56

The UK has an ageing population and a birthrate of 1.56. Non-immigration population growth has come from people living longer, not from having babies. It's a huge problem in the pipeline.

I'd be interested to know how supporters of zero immigration would suggest we deal with this.

lightisnotwhite · 20/02/2023 08:43

TigeToo · 19/02/2023 13:30

Excellent post, spot on

Not read the thread so I expect there’s people disagreeing with it now. But yes this sums it up.

lazycats · 20/02/2023 08:27

If you want low immigration then you need to support schemes that result in much cheaper housing so british born citizens can actually start families and support the woefully ageing population. If you don't care about that and enjoy seeing your house go up in price exponentially then well done: you're part of the problem you complain about.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 20/02/2023 08:25

I think out interventionist policies in other countries are a massive problem. I don’t support the U.K. giving arms to Ukraine, think we should be less involved in Syria and other Arab nations and would never vote labour due to Afghanistan and Iraq. However, I do not support the mass immigration In this country. My sil is from a developing nation. Her and my brother spend thousands getting her visa. She now works as a nurse. A strong immigration policy for essential workers and visa’s is important. Support for refugees such as the Ukrainian scheme and the gong king scheme I support. But a free for all of low skilled people with no desire to interstate, or men from safe countries entering on boats, or people with hostile attitudes to this country should be stopped. We could end up with a Sweden situation in the next five years here if we are not careful.

Kabalagala · 20/02/2023 08:17

MarshaBradyo · 20/02/2023 07:59

What do you want to see in practice as a result? Eg numbers and passport / visas

I'm not suggesting open borders is a solution. But we shouldn't be surprised that people want to come here.
There's a lot more we could be doing to limit the ongoing damage that might reduce the numbers of people wanting to leave their home countries though.

Mira28 · 20/02/2023 08:16

WinterFoxes · 20/02/2023 07:20

Are people who hold that view OK with all other countries having similar rules, so no Brits should be allowed to migrate to Canada, USA, Australia, Europe, Dubai etc in search of a better life?

Should no one be allowed to marry and settle here if they fell in love with a non-Brit? Where should a Brit live if maaried to a Jordanian or a Norwegian? What if those countries didn't allow a UK citizen to settle there?

We may be a small island but we are part of a big planet.

Don’t most countries have similar rules? Can a Brit just rock up in Australia and settle there? A British friend of mine married an American woman - he still had to apply for the green card if I remember correctly.
Canada‘s immigration laws are also quite strict as far as I know.
Plus, for most people it’s not about X never being allowed to immigrate into country Y, it’s about controlled immigration.

MarshaBradyo · 20/02/2023 07:59

Kabalagala · 20/02/2023 07:44

Oh I got the satire. It's just not funny. Why shouldn't people expect us to make good on the shit show that was colonialism?

What do you want to see in practice as a result? Eg numbers and passport / visas

VeryUnstableGenius · 20/02/2023 07:57

WinterFoxes · 20/02/2023 07:20

Are people who hold that view OK with all other countries having similar rules, so no Brits should be allowed to migrate to Canada, USA, Australia, Europe, Dubai etc in search of a better life?

Should no one be allowed to marry and settle here if they fell in love with a non-Brit? Where should a Brit live if maaried to a Jordanian or a Norwegian? What if those countries didn't allow a UK citizen to settle there?

We may be a small island but we are part of a big planet.

I mean … you can’t just emigrate wherever you want as a Brit. And you can’t just go because it’s convenient for you — you have to prove you’ll be a net asset to the country, not a drain, to get a visa

Mycatsgoldtooth · 20/02/2023 07:47

@Kabalagala Four of my great great grandparents were from Ireland, left due to the situation there which were caused by the English rule. Should I get reparations? My husbands family left their home country due the nazis. Should he be payed repetitions? They are not Jewish but were politically persecuted. Where does it end. People have been displacing people and colonising them for the history of the human race. There are 1.4 billion people in India. Do they all now have a right to move to the U.K. due to an England landing in India in 1608?

Kabalagala · 20/02/2023 07:44

Felicitythecat · 20/02/2023 07:36

It wasn't posted as a comparison - it was posted tongue-in-cheek to show how spurious such arguments are.

I'm sorry you didn't get the satire.

Oh I got the satire. It's just not funny. Why shouldn't people expect us to make good on the shit show that was colonialism?

Felicitythecat · 20/02/2023 07:44

Usou · 20/02/2023 07:30

No.

The country has been absorbing huge numbers of immigrants for decades now, with consequent negative impacts on housing - availability and prices, service provision etc.

Many are from countries with far lower population densities and without any particular problems such as wars.

I agree it is just not sustainable.

The government expects about 300,000 people to come to the UK over five years on a new path to citizenship that will - from 31 January 2021 - be available to more than five million people in Hong Kong (nearly three-quarters of the territory’s population). This summarises the government’s methodology in making its estimates, which have a very broad range. The lower limit of their projection is 5,000 in five years and the upper limit is over a million people during that period. Another anecdotal and informal estimate suggests as many as two million people may come by 2026.

^ If that doesn't scare you, then it should.

Felicitythecat · 20/02/2023 07:36

Kabalagala · 20/02/2023 07:13

Yeah because the colonies were all ancient history weren't they? It's totally not true that many only got independence within our (or our parents) lifetimes.
Not remotely a good comparison.

It wasn't posted as a comparison - it was posted tongue-in-cheek to show how spurious such arguments are.

I'm sorry you didn't get the satire.

Swipe left for the next trending thread