Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are people that want zero immigration racist?

682 replies

equalstime · 15/10/2022 22:31

People that moan about migrants coming to this county - taking our jobs - taking our houses - draining the medical system - not settling in the first country they reach for asylum- they're racist right?

There will always be an element of migration and when you take account of UK born people that leave and non Uk people that enter our country, the net figure is no doubt reasonable. They are often willing to work and contribute to our society and economy - so why the hostility?

Why not accept as a country that we have en element of migration and embrace that, if not because your views are racist?

OP posts:
Xenia · 20/02/2023 17:46

Like many who feel there has been too much immigration I voted Remain.

Volver,m the current Tories are very socialist, high spending, high immigration middle of the road party. Those of us who want less immigration have no main party for which to vote as both Labour and the Tories want and have achieved the highest immigration levels of British history ever including the latest figures 1m a year immigration (about 500k I believe net immigration figure).

For me it has never been about money. I would rather be worse off and have fewer people here. We have 18m more people in the Uk than when I was born and are very crowded.

booboo82 · 20/02/2023 17:33

No

Volver · 20/02/2023 17:31

@Mycatsgoldtooth Full disclosure
I’m an immigrant, by chance rather than design, as I married a Brit 31 years ago. Never intended to stay in GB, but stay I did because at the time I was happy and it made sense and for 40 years I did and that’s nearly all my working life.

We have grown up British born kids.
I’m writing from my house in Spain.
I’m a High Rate tax payer and have never taken a penny from the state, even though I’m many years shy of the shabby Estate pension age I already qualify with 38 years+ NI contributions. I even have private health care so when I’m back in GB in my own place I don’t need to rely on GP surgeries.
I feel most sorry for my kids who live there and I’m trying to persuade them to up sticks even though it’s their home country and their choice as young adults. I just don’t see a future for them there until people stop being so bloody stupid, and start voting responsibly instead of swallowing right wing propaganda.

I got so FED UP with the sheer audacity of brexiteers assuming I’m some kind of scrounger by virtue of my faint foreign accent that I have basically Given Up on GB. My heart broke when I realised half the population I came across in daily life had this low opinion of anyone foreign born.
I don’t have to put up with that shite so now the Spanish economy benefits from my taxes.

My solution would be go cap in hand to the EU and restore free trade and FOM but unfortunately on vastly less advantageous terms (like Norway) and get the economy moving again and highly skilled Europeans moving again to help with cultural cohesion and yes, give young Brits opportunities to study and work in Europe too.
Impose controls just like the rest of Europe has always done: The EU was never a “free for all” so people can look for a job but need to pay for healthcare the first year at least till they’re employed and contributing with their NI/taxes. No free social housing to anyone not working and contributing.

GB was really raking it in in prestige and economic growth as part of the EU.
Vote for a more socially conscious Govt that will invest in public services.

I do hope people realise Brexit was such a crazy foolish thing that at least restoring free trade will reverse the worst damage yet to come.
The immigration numbers from Europe would balance themselves quite fast as it’s the law of supply and demand. When there’s no work a lot of the young people simply leave.
Hell, even the long term ones with British passports like me have, so there’s nothing to fear.

  1. The vast majority of EU workers are young so not a strain on public services
  2. Culturally similar so less problems with language and integration into society
  3. They contribute more than they take out
  4. The ones that stay and settle for good will make a lasting contribution to society
  5. There’s a shortage of workers in GB: unless you force all the working age natives (and they number millions) to get off their arses and work you need the workforce to tend to the old, the sick, to contribute to Science, and yes to even pick crops from the fields…

The Asylum/Refugees question is separate and should be comprehensively addressed with offering safe routes to claim in collaboration with the UN and Europe.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 20/02/2023 16:56

So you think an extra 300 people a year is putting no strain on public services. As I’ve said you need to make 38k annually to be a net contributor in terms of adding more then you are taking. That’s a high wage. I’m not sure all 300k are on this. We are not a rich country, we have massive debt. We can not look after the people already here. As mass immigration has happened the gdp of the country has fallen. How can this be when they are contributing so much.

How many people would you ideally see move to the U.K.? Should there be any limit. I’m interested to know.

Volver · 20/02/2023 16:19

@Mycatsgoldtooth thank you for linking.
The report clearly recognises the value of Immigration to GB Society and the Economy.

You said upthread that this report identified a deficit of 4.6B annually due to Immigration. That figure refers to money Immigrants send back to their home countries (presumably to help their families) AFTER paying taxes, etc so instead of spending it in GB. Thus helping poor countries.
NOWHERE does it say that Immigrants cost more in public services than they contribute. Therefore they are NET contributors as the report also states on average they pay more than they take out, in fact on average they use less public services like the NHS.
Facts posted by your good self.
Thank you for proving my point.

Therefore anyone posting here stating that Immigration is causing problems with Public Services needs to give their head a big wobble. NO. They pay more into it than they use and thanks to them a lot of natives are not paying more.

If you need to blame someone go blame the useless Tories and not Immigration.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 20/02/2023 15:55

news.files.bbci.co.uk/include/newsspec/pdfs/bbc-briefing-immigration-newsspec-26148-v1.pdf

Pg 126 onwards for anyone interested. Some interesting stuff here about acceptance culturally of immigration. The U.K. top of the list of countries polled about positive attitudes towards. Immigration. So hardly the unwelcoming place it’s been made out to be on this thread.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 20/02/2023 15:46

I quoted from the bbc. Please feel free to google I have you the year and the name of the study.

However, the majority of the concerns I have raised are about the effect on culture. I am not too bothered about the ecconomics. If we invested in people already here, had affordable education training and housing we would not have to invest in the human neoliberal Ponzi scheme.

For those who are pro mass immigration do you think 300k net year on year will have no negative effect culturally on the social cohesion. How much immigration would be too much? A million a year? I’d like to know what people’s actual ideas of sustainable immigration are?

I am not a brexit voter. I think it was destabilising. But, if the country had dealt with immigration in a way that pleased most voters- Controlled, regulated etc then I don’t think brexit would have happened.

ConcordeOoter · 20/02/2023 15:46

Zero illegal immigration you presumably mean.

I suppose it depends - if you believe we are a country where people are relying on food banks, public service are collapsing or have collapsed, and wages have been dropping for years to the extent that inflation is quite soon going to kill a lot of people unless they can get food, heat or medical attention from the public purse, then no, it is not racist to shy away from the idea of adding an estimated million people per year in the coming years to eat from our food, take from our benefits system, drive wages down further and add strain to the NHS, policing, prison, social housing and social services without EVER having contributed a penny to them in their lives

If you believe we are a rich country where nobodt ever starves and the NHS is infinitely funded and responsive, food banks don't exist and everyone skips around tralalaland grabbing bunches of money from the money tree to burn in their fireplace because there's just too much money around, then yes it is probably racist to not want to add tens or hundreds of thousands, probably really millions of people to the country OUR CHILDREN live in and the services they rely on

FatSealSmugSoup · 20/02/2023 15:23

misscrabapple · 20/02/2023 15:16

@flawless29 You say it's "important to understand", so specifically what worries do you have about the "culture" and "society" that immigrants bring, for example? Just so I can understand this a bit better.

Well you could take a look at the feminism board at a woman working with psychiatric patients whose new colleague thinks FGM is brilliant and believes in witch medicine.

Volver · 20/02/2023 15:20

@flawless29 most of the arguments I’ve read in this thread against Immigration were economic concerns, quoting stretched public services and social housing.

As the stats clearly show Immigrants are NET contributors to the British economy, so that concern is not based on facts.

Culturally I would understand more as it’s true certain immigrant groups find it harder to integrate.
Unfortunately for those posters who think integration is the key Immigration worry, now post Brexit most immigration will come from Asia and Africa as GB has turned away from the nations that were culturally/ethnically closer to them, and so it’s something that will continue for the foreseeable future.
Brexiteers shot themselves in the foot spectacularly on that front.

misscrabapple · 20/02/2023 15:16

@flawless29 You say it's "important to understand", so specifically what worries do you have about the "culture" and "society" that immigrants bring, for example? Just so I can understand this a bit better.

Volver · 20/02/2023 15:09

@Mycatsgoldtooth you’re referring to a tiny % of foreign born people seeking Asylum.
That’s not the big picture on Immigration in GB. The big picture is that Immigration makes a net contribution to the HMRC coffers measured in billions more than they use in public services.

Stop confusing Refugees and Asylum seekers with Immigration. They’re totally different groups of foreign born people and since you can’t link to any stats to prove your points I conclude you’re speaking with prejudice and xenophobic sentiments rather than facts.

Regarding the small cohort of Asylum seekers/Refugees there ought to be safe routes to claim asylum and since there aren’t you get the people in small boats and the criminal gangs instead. It’s a problem created by the Government by not offering more processing facilities and safe routes in other locations that need it.

flawless29 · 20/02/2023 15:04

Sometimes people might want to limit or stop immigration for different reasons, such as worries about the economy, culture, society, or national security. It's important to understand that being worried about immigration doesn't necessarily mean that someone is racist

Mycatsgoldtooth · 20/02/2023 15:01

@Volver like selling drugs or human trafficking Albanian children, as those are the kids going missing from care? So many of the people crossing are from Albania it actually makes a mockery of the genuine people seeking asylum. Also - France is a safe country.

Volver · 20/02/2023 14:59

@angstridden2 I think that you and many others posters in this thread is confusing refugees/asylum seekers with Immigrant Labour and they’re totally different groups of people.

Regarding the specific concerns voiced by many on Refugees/Asylum seekers coming over the North Sea in small boats they’re a very small number of people, maybe many of them would already be making a useful contribution to society if they were allowed to work instead of languish for months in detention facilities.

Mira28 · 20/02/2023 14:47

Mycatsgoldtooth · 20/02/2023 12:26

But it’s a straw man argument isn’t it. We must support mass immigration because there are people who support zero immigration. If you want any kind of controls on people moving to this country then you are in with the ‘send ‘em back’ brigade.

The majority of people across the world support jess immigration to their countries. In Italy it’s 71%, Germany 52%. But looking at the policies of governments you’d think not supporting mass immigration was a niche view. Do we honestly think that the millions people from we have from abroad are only having a positive effect on life in the U.K.? Many from cultures that are so different to ours and others who actively dislike our way of life and harbour resentments to our nation. Just look at the terrorist attacks over the last few years. Can you imagine an English person trying to bomb a maternity ward? There should be safeguards against people who harbour these feelings or have these beliefs living here. Visas, boarder controls, background checks…I just don’t see these things as controversial.

Cultural cohesion is the foundation of a high trust society in which welfare state policies and the rule of law flourish as you have high cultural buy in from the citizens. The more diverse a society, with groups not integrating, then unfortunately the less social harmony, lower levels of trust in the country. Different groups will then use politics as a means to compete for resources and power. Which will cause resentment and unrest. We are already seeing this in the very poor areas being expected to absorb high migration levels.

Well said.

Aleaiactaest · 20/02/2023 14:11

@Lentilweaver - we need both types of economic migrants. Some very skilled ones and some unskilled but hardworking ones happy to do the more menial jobs as well.
@angstridden2 - many young males arrive first and then bring wives over and have children.
As long as everyone who comes works, it benefits the country. If we choose to incentive people to not work or not work as much as they could due to a dis functioning benefits system and too expensive childcare, then that is a systemic issue.

There are a lot of highly skilled & well off people arriving from Hong Kong right now which will benefit the UK. There are also quite a few skilled Europeans who paid a lot into the system leaving post Brexit. It will balance itself out.

Lentilweaver · 20/02/2023 14:01

So on this one thread we have:

(1) We need highly educated immigrants, like doctors or engineers, who can contribute.

(2) We can't take highly educated doctors and engineers from their home countries because it will be a brain drain.

Volver · 20/02/2023 13:58

Err @Mycatsgoldtooth please link?
The study I linked to is from MAC Oxford and it concludes that immigration in the last year they measured contributed net 20Billion to the Economy, so it’s exactly the same source you’re quoting…
otherwise you’re quoting on hearsay and I can’t take any of your posts seriously.

angstridden2 · 20/02/2023 13:51

Of course we need immigration, but like other countries we need to allow people with the skills required and who are likely to make a reasonably fast contribution to the economy. In all honesty I cannot see that many of the poorly educated young men with little or no English who make up the majority of illegal immigrants are going to become care workers or nurses. Why is it so controversial for the U.K to want to select who comes to live here

Aleaiactaest · 20/02/2023 13:45

It is not all about money though is it. If you have a falling birth rate you need young immigrants to come in, work and have children. If you have your own population retiring early and requiring the state to look after them via pensions and then care into their 90s you need the immigration - even if they are on low wages and paying low taxes. They are still contributing to essential services like refuse collection, transport, NHS, care work. Just because someone is paid a low wage and needs top ups that does not mean they are not adding huge value to a society.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 20/02/2023 13:40

The study quoted above, and the claim that migrants to the economy bring in more in net taxes is very controversial as it does not look at in work benefits. It is literally one of the only studies to conclude this. The fact that net migration to the U.K. is a steady 300k a year will not have an effect on public service and housing is pie in the sky. That’s a city the side of Portsmouth.

In January 2020 the BBC published an immigration briefing based on research that was published by the governments Migration Advisory Committee (MAC) and carried out for them by Oxford Economics.

This report concluded that in 2016/2017 migrants overall paid in £4.3 billion less than they took out. So okay maybe the claim that "every study" will tell you migrants pay more than they put in was a bit of hyperbole? You found a study by a neoliberal pro mass migration think tank.

And the question still stands, how much migration can a country as small as the U.K. absorb. Per capita we have population density in England (as that is where most migrants settle, not Wales or Scotland) comparable to Bangladesh or Tiawan. We have 430 people per square km.

MarshaBradyo · 20/02/2023 13:36

It is true people moving here add in taxes etc

It can be done through work visas though. Australia and other countries have systems which benefit and are strict.

If we’re going to have Brexit may as well have a system that matches skills to demand. And after Brexit net migration hasn’t gone down anyway

Volver · 20/02/2023 13:19

It seems to me that native born Brits are imploding through lack of public services resources brought on by their votes eg
Brexit
Successive Tory Governments
aided and abetted by the right wing media owned by the powerful who couldn’t give a stuff about the general population

It is racist and xenophobic to say it’s immigration causing the strain on public services like the NHS, education, housing, etc. Basically blaming and othering people in the minority, but who contribute more in net taxes to the well being of a nation than the native born population.
Yes there are always a minority of scroungers but in the vast majority immigrants contribute more per capita, and in many cases are better educated than the native population .

Read the Stats migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/resources/briefings/the-fiscal-impact-of-immigration-in-the-uk/

The other thing that makes me laugh is the very people who voted for Brexit have now shot themselves in the foot as EU nationals contributed more per capita to the economy than their non EU equivalents and culturally and due to historical ties had a huge amount more in common with Brits (including ethnicity which matters a lot to the racists who wanted Brexit) than immigrants from other parts of the globe.

They also voted to restrict their own freedom of movement to work and live in many lovely European countries.
Thats a direct result of ignorance and xenophobia. You couldn’t get more stupid if you tried.

Most of the comments on this thread blaming immigration for the mess GB is in are ignorant at best, racist and xenophobic in most cases too.

Lentilweaver · 20/02/2023 12:30

Placemarking as a first gen brown immigrant. Interesting reading.

Swipe left for the next trending thread