Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are people that want zero immigration racist?

682 replies

equalstime · 15/10/2022 22:31

People that moan about migrants coming to this county - taking our jobs - taking our houses - draining the medical system - not settling in the first country they reach for asylum- they're racist right?

There will always be an element of migration and when you take account of UK born people that leave and non Uk people that enter our country, the net figure is no doubt reasonable. They are often willing to work and contribute to our society and economy - so why the hostility?

Why not accept as a country that we have en element of migration and embrace that, if not because your views are racist?

OP posts:
halfsiesonapotnoodle · 16/10/2022 03:58

OP starts thread and doesn't return??? Journalist? Hmm

Mfsf · 16/10/2022 02:17

No , just xenophobic . I can’t think of anything worse than a place with nil multiculturalism.

watcherintherye · 16/10/2022 01:59

Strictly speaking, in terms of services, we have too many old white people. Around 20% of the UK population are white people aged 60+, people who are less likely to be providing services and increasingly likely to be using them.

Ageist and insulting. You do know the current retirement age is 66, due to increase eventually to 68, don’t you? If people manage to get to 68 after the best part of half a century working, I think they’ve bloody well earned the right to use the services that they’ve paid for!

MintJulia · 16/10/2022 01:55

Not necessarily, just foolish.

Without at least some migration, there would be very little overseas trade, and life would be pretty grim if we existed only on home produced materials. And in the long term our culture is enriched by outside influences. It has been since the Romans invaded.

I can also see the argument from the point of view of a Brit who has spent 10 years on a housing waiting list and then someone who arrived last week takes a scarce house or flat. It's easy to see how resentment starts especially for single males who get shunted down the queue. That's not necessarily racist either, it's just desperate.

Sometimes people are too quick to call the racist card, without understanding the underlying reason.

funzeny · 16/10/2022 01:45

The lengths illegal immigrants take to get to a safe country is heartbreaking because it shows how awful their country is. I couldn't be tough and send them back but realistically we can't help everyone. There's whole countries full of people suffering but England is tiny compared to the world. There has to be a limit really otherwise we will sink. It's just having the right balance

Seymour5 · 16/10/2022 01:40

@Nat6999 I'd love those who support completely open borders to tell us what benefits the majority of Roma have brought? Low educational standards means they aren't doctors or nurses. Those in Sheffield that you mention are from Slovakia, around 5000.

One small point, they aren't PUT in a specific area of the city, the houses where most have settled are not great quality, private, fairly cheap lets. News gets out, and they follow those already here. There is a house that has recently been turned into a police station to try and keep a lid on the on street disturbances and violence.

LondonQueen · 16/10/2022 01:21

halfsiesonapotnoodle · 15/10/2022 22:37

I doubt it's anything to do with actual race but more to do with the fact we are a tiny island, whose population has grown massively since the 50s and is actually causing many services to be at breaking point. We have too many people.

This.

twicebittenthriceshy · 16/10/2022 01:19

halfsiesonapotnoodle · 15/10/2022 22:37

I doubt it's anything to do with actual race but more to do with the fact we are a tiny island, whose population has grown massively since the 50s and is actually causing many services to be at breaking point. We have too many people.

I think it's everything to do with race!

Look how differently refugees from Ukraine have been treated to refugees from Africa!

Danikm151 · 16/10/2022 01:11

I think the general consensus is that uncontrolled immigration should stop.

Yes there are immigrants that benefit our country immensely, but there are also those who illegally enter the country. (Asylum seekers are supposed to claim Asylum at the first country they enter)
Then there were the EU rules when we were part of it that said you could live in any country within the eu as long as you have an eu passport or identity card and live exactly the same as a citizen( benefits/housing/work/nhs). Some people hate the fact it was so easy to do so and blame the people who took the opportunity rather than the system that allowed it.

There are also those of the opinion that if you come to live in a country you should embrace the customs and social niceties of that country not act as though you are in the country that you came from.

JocelynBurnell · 16/10/2022 00:47

Yourhamsterisnonbinary · 16/10/2022 00:31

The main thing that needs to happen is that there are less births across all ethnicities. The world cannot support 8 billion people. Anyone having over replacement level - 2 - is making a morally dubious choice. Immigration is realistically neither here nor there.

A lower birth rate with little immigration means that hospitals won't have the staff to care for an increasingly elderly population increasingly in need of medical attention. Care homes will close as they won't have staff to look after the elderly.

There won't be enough people of working age paying tax to pay the pensions of those who are retired. Many people of working age won't be able to work as they will be caring for elderly relatives.

PeppaPigsBonnet · 16/10/2022 00:47

@IndigoC It needs immigrants. There are 70,000+ vacancies for nurses right now that can’t be filled.
Yes, but they won't be filled by people coming over the Channel by the boatload who can't speak English.

covilha · 16/10/2022 00:43

Why is wanting what’s best and right for communities and individuals- and that includes safe migration and acceptable level of support for all concerned, racist? Does it seem silly to you to be concerned that people should have these things? 💐

IndigoC · 16/10/2022 00:42

This country needs young working people. It needs immigrants. There are 70,000+ vacancies for nurses right now that can’t be filled.

PeppaPigsBonnet · 16/10/2022 00:38

Zero immigration is not possible or desirable, however, the present rate of immigration is untenable -

For example, Stoke-on-Trent MP Jonathan Gullis told the House of Commons in 2021: “The stark truth is that our city has now reached its limits…. people are looking for two-bedroom and three-bedroom homes and young families are struggling because we do not have one-bedroom sheltered accommodation for the elderly population to move into. Our schools are at absolute capacity, if not over capacity, and we have a public transport system that has, quite frankly, been well and truly left behind.” (see Hansard).

Stoke-on-Trent MP Jonathan Gullis told the House of Commons in 2021: “The stark truth is that our city has now reached its limits…. people are looking for two-bedroom and three-bedroom homes and young families are struggling because we do not have one-bedroom sheltered accommodation for the elderly population to move into. Our schools are at absolute capacity, if not over capacity, and we have a public transport system that has, quite frankly, been well and truly left behind.” (see Hansard).

And during the summer last year, Torbay Council leader Steve Darling raised concerns about the amount of local housing available. He said the city did not have an adequate support network for refugees arriving from Afghanistan, adding: “In Torbay this summer we have seen record numbers of homeless households in need of temporary accommodation, as well as seeing record numbers on our housing waiting list.”

Yourhamsterisnonbinary · 16/10/2022 00:31

The main thing that needs to happen is that there are less births across all ethnicities. The world cannot support 8 billion people. Anyone having over replacement level - 2 - is making a morally dubious choice. Immigration is realistically neither here nor there.

Sweettea89 · 16/10/2022 00:30

HannibalHeyes · 15/10/2022 22:52

Basically, it's the little Englanders and Brexshitteers that keep shouting for zero immigration. So, yes, they're racists, and should always be shouted down as such.

You know being a brexiteer means supporting leaving Europe and Europe is rather white.

nonono1 · 16/10/2022 00:29

IScreamMonday · 16/10/2022 00:22

Often the people coming in are propping up the infrastructure though e.g. about 24% of GPS are foreign-born because it has become unattractive as a medical profession in the UK. Migration isn't totally random, people often move where there is demand for their skills. So it's not migration creating demand but responding to it.

I see what you’re saying. But also, the more people who settle here to “prop up the infrastructure”, the more infrastructure, roads, housing, schools, hospitals and everything else we actually need.

VoiceOfCommonSense · 16/10/2022 00:25

ChocFrog · 15/10/2022 22:46

It isn’t racism to be concerned about immigration levels. England is massively overpopulated compared to most other countries and services are at breaking point. You say that the net figures are “no doubt reasonable” but the problem is, they aren’t.

It isn’t racism to think that asylum seekers should claim asylum in the first safe country. That is what they are supposed to do. Travelling onward is no longer asylum seeking, it’s economic migration.

I live in Kent, we’ve had 22,000 migrants delivered to Kent’s beaches so far this year by people smugglers - and that’s just the ones who were caught. All of them need housing and food. All of the support network is full so some unaccompanied children are being placed in hotels - from where many go missing. (Your guess is as good as mine who takes children that no one is watching.)

Labelling concerns about this racist is unhelpful and inaccurate.

Thank you. I’ve stated this before to be called racist or a Nazi.

nonono1 · 16/10/2022 00:23

GrumpyPanda · 16/10/2022 00:20

"Too many people", or rather egregiously underfunded public services? You can hardly blame the latter on immigrants.

See my post above. Providing enough public services, housing, infrastructure and everything else for an extra 4 million people in the space of 14 years is a huge ask (if not actually impossible!)

IScreamMonday · 16/10/2022 00:22

nonono1 · 16/10/2022 00:03

@IScreamMonday I agree to an extent, but if there’s a huge influx of people into a country in a short space of time then it’s not easy to quickly provide the infrastructure, doctors, nurses etcetera to match that.

The foreign-born population increased from about 5.3 million in 2004 to nearly 9.3 million in 2018.

Four million in 14 years - that’s an enormous increase.

Often the people coming in are propping up the infrastructure though e.g. about 24% of GPS are foreign-born because it has become unattractive as a medical profession in the UK. Migration isn't totally random, people often move where there is demand for their skills. So it's not migration creating demand but responding to it.

JocelynBurnell · 16/10/2022 00:21

miceonabranch · 15/10/2022 22:55

We're told that we need immigration. Okay, fine, but then we're having to deal with a housing crisis, inadequate health service, not enough GPs for the size of population, shortage of teachers etc.

I don't really understand how it should balance out. You can only increase a population if you have enough public services surely?

Immigrants are more likely to work in the NHS than UK-born residents. Around 20% of GPs trained outside the UK.

In the years following arrival to the UK, immigrants use inpatient hospital services around half as much as UK-born residents of the same age and gender.

The increasing number of returning UK expats, retired and often in poor physical health, is placing increased pressure on the NHS.

GrumpyPanda · 16/10/2022 00:20

halfsiesonapotnoodle · 15/10/2022 22:37

I doubt it's anything to do with actual race but more to do with the fact we are a tiny island, whose population has grown massively since the 50s and is actually causing many services to be at breaking point. We have too many people.

"Too many people", or rather egregiously underfunded public services? You can hardly blame the latter on immigrants.

DandyMandy · 16/10/2022 00:14

No it isn't racist. You're called a bigot nowadays if you feel protective over your people and your culture but that's only if you're white. Others are allowed to prioritise their own without being labelled racist. Also, many of these immigrants are white or at least white adjacent so it's more xenophobia than racism.

surreysarah · 16/10/2022 00:11

I’m not very well versed on these matters admittedly, but how come in the 1980s the UK economy was booming and yet we didn’t need enormous numbers of immigrants to prop it up? What has changed between then and now? Cheers all!

BMW6 · 16/10/2022 00:06

Well I voted for leaving the EU and I have never advocated zero immigration.

Should be a points system like Canada or Australia IMO.