Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are people that want zero immigration racist?

682 replies

equalstime · 15/10/2022 22:31

People that moan about migrants coming to this county - taking our jobs - taking our houses - draining the medical system - not settling in the first country they reach for asylum- they're racist right?

There will always be an element of migration and when you take account of UK born people that leave and non Uk people that enter our country, the net figure is no doubt reasonable. They are often willing to work and contribute to our society and economy - so why the hostility?

Why not accept as a country that we have en element of migration and embrace that, if not because your views are racist?

OP posts:
MooseBreath · 16/10/2022 07:54

The thing is, "unskilled" labour in the UK is needed. As an immigrant, I am "unskilled" (despite having a University degree and being a fully capable human being) and the only reason why I was eligible to come was because my DH is highly paid.

Since coming to the UK, I have worked as a teacher in both nursery and primary, an office, and now as a self-employed dance teacher (though on maternity, for which I receive no government assistance). I am eligible for no benefits whatsoever as a stipulation on my visa.

What is wrong with people like me coming to the UK? I pay taxes. I don't claim benefits. If I want to retrain at a University, I still need to pay exorbitant international fees. I need to pay £1000 per year in NHS surcharges just to live here in top of my visa fees. I contribute far more to society than I take, but based on the opinions of many in this thread, I shouldn't be here.

A competent government would mandate and fund better services along with the new housing being built, rather than focusing on lining their own pockets and privatising public services. "Low skilled" immigration isn't the problem. This greedy, capitalist, self-serving government is the problem.

120go · 16/10/2022 07:54

As another poster mentioned, it's all about who is coming.

Skilled worker in shortage occupation with good moral values? Positive contribution to society.

Poor uneducated person with a backwards view on many things? Negative contribution to society.

We've let in a lot of the latter hence as a country we are now relatively poorer than before and less safe.

Relative living standards will continue to decline in this country unless we crack down hard on "bad" immigration.

Of course the other school of thought is that we are all human beings and so all immigration is good because it is improving the lives of a lot of people (who are equal no matter where they were born).

All comes down to your views on countries/borders etc.

MintyFreshOne · 16/10/2022 07:50

HappyHappyHermit · 16/10/2022 07:33

@MintyFreshOne As I have now said twice, I very clearly understand that.

I don’t mean to attack you, I’m just so tired of hearing stuff like this from very comfortable expats.

UnderCoverFieldAgent · 16/10/2022 07:46

They’re not racist, they’re realists. This country is
on its knees and can barely support the people we’ve already got (I include both British born and the immigrants already here in that statement) However, we’re bringing more over daily. Why is that and who’s funding it? Oh yes, the tax payer. The very people who are using candles to light their houses as they’re terrified to run on the lights, skipping meals so they can feed their kids and missing mortgage and rent payments. We just can’t afford more people, we only have limited resources, why does the racist card have to be pulled?

PBSam · 16/10/2022 07:41

Is the Australian immigration model racist?

HappyHappyHermit · 16/10/2022 07:33

@MintyFreshOne As I have now said twice, I very clearly understand that.

MintyFreshOne · 16/10/2022 07:31

HappyHappyHermit · 16/10/2022 07:11

@MintyFreshOne I have lived in five different countries on 3 different continents! We all managed to get on everywhere we were even with differing cultures and beliefs.

Then you should understand that different societies have very different belief systems and cultural mores and that borders are the way we deal with that in the modern world.

And expats willingly live in countries that execute gay people or small-time drug users and still spout crap like this because it’s very convenient for them. It’s not far off saying you ‘don’t see colour’

HappyHappyHermit · 16/10/2022 07:14

I did also say I realised it wouldn't happen. I just think it isn't right that some people have safety and others don't purely due to where they are born. Why are those born in a safe place the only ones entitled to it.

Yubgftr · 16/10/2022 07:13

Yes they're racist, ignorant or afraid of anyone who is 'different '. Migration is a part of life. Deal with it.

They are also people who often believe everything in the right wing press. But the right wing press is so good at making out it's all the immigrants or the EU's fault to distract us from the fact that 9 times out of 10 it's the Tory government's fault.

We have issues with housing/ health service due to years and years of under investment and trashing of public services. Nothing to do with immigrants, that's the government's fault.

HappyHappyHermit · 16/10/2022 07:11

@MintyFreshOne I have lived in five different countries on 3 different continents! We all managed to get on everywhere we were even with differing cultures and beliefs.

MintyFreshOne · 16/10/2022 07:07

HappyHappyHermit · 16/10/2022 06:53

In fact I'm going to further my previous post. Why do we still have countries? Surely by now we should be mature enough to understand we are all born on the same planet, regardless of which piece of land we all share the Earth and are equally responsible for it. Land borders and countries are established based on Levens from long ago, in reality they have little relevance to now. One world with properly shared resources would surely be better for all than how hings are now. I realise, by the way, that this would never happen for a great number of reasons.

Wow, have you not lived in another country? Human beings have very different cultures and belief systems, some of which are very incompatible. Boundaries draw a line so while we can criticise other countries, we do not have to constantly fight them to preserve our way of life (or force our ways on others, which has worked out so well in the Middle East 🤦‍♀️).

anotherdayanotherpathlesstravelled · 16/10/2022 06:58

I just don't agree with unskilled unlikely to ever contribute to anything culturally or economically illegal jump On a boat at Calais not fleeing war or persecution immigration

WonkasBooboofixer · 16/10/2022 06:55

Not racist but able to see that small island w. limited resources (housing, school places, doctors, dentists, beds in maternity units etc) can only support x no of people before the systems are under strain.

HappyHappyHermit · 16/10/2022 06:53

In fact I'm going to further my previous post. Why do we still have countries? Surely by now we should be mature enough to understand we are all born on the same planet, regardless of which piece of land we all share the Earth and are equally responsible for it. Land borders and countries are established based on Levens from long ago, in reality they have little relevance to now. One world with properly shared resources would surely be better for all than how hings are now. I realise, by the way, that this would never happen for a great number of reasons.

equalstime · 16/10/2022 06:19

Some really very sensible responses that pick up on the issues we face as a country with the high number of migrants to this country but without actually coming across as racist and/or xenophobic.

It's given me a new perspective that perhaps there is a conversation to be had about the controls and how maybe we could manage that better.

I also think the government cuts have probably accelerated a lot of the issues which is also a factor in the schools - hospital waiting lists etc.

OP posts:
equalstime · 16/10/2022 06:16

HairyMcLarie · 16/10/2022 04:10

It's interesting that here in NZ immigration is very tightly restricted only to those who can achieve the stringent education, income and experience criteria that is set by a very left wing labour government who want to limit it to protect the cultural capital and low income populations here. The criteria massively favour western white applicants.

It's the right wing opposition who want to throw open the borders for commercial and capitalist reasons.

No one is calling Jacinda and her government racist for doing so.

Is that because they believe and trust the correct policy is in place, or because they are racist?

OP posts:
EdgeOfACoin · 16/10/2022 06:11

I think it was 'net 0' migration, not '0 migration'. I.e. if 25,000 people permanently leave the country each year, 25,000 people may stay permanently.

Question for those who fully support all immigration without question: do you think it is just a question of building more to keep up with the numbers of people coming in? Do you think there is ever a point when we might need to control for numbers? E.g. when the UK population hits 80 million? 100 million? 200 million?

iloveeverykindofcat · 16/10/2022 06:05

No one wants zero immigration. People who say that are just parroting a soundbite and have zero understanding.

AloysiusBear · 16/10/2022 06:01

I only dislike unskilled migration.

If you have a pool of essentially unlimited unskilled labour, it supresses wages at the bottom and distorts the market. A young migrant with no family from a poorer country will accept poor living conditions (cramped overcrowded houseshares etc) for a few years because the remittances or money they can save is worth so much more in their home country. They can effectively undercut the local workforce who need wages that are high enough to support living he long term, in decent conditions for families etc.

I have no issues with migrants who fill skilled labour shortages, come here through the right channels with visas etc.

MintyFreshOne · 16/10/2022 05:54

American or a German coming and taking jobs

Probably the American or German will go back home at some point unless they marry in. Expats tend to do that.

AllyCatTown · 16/10/2022 05:51

I think the OP about zero migration is silly, but there are issues with migration that should be discussed and examined in a mature adult way but unfortunately it just tends to go with extremes. For example people say bringing up culture is racism in disguise but it surely stands to reason that if you have mass migration into an area then culture will change. It can have issues on social cohesion in society.

MintyFreshOne · 16/10/2022 05:47

SwordToFlamethrower · 15/10/2022 22:55

My dad voted brexit, hates brown/black people and used to be in the BNP.

His dream was to "send them all back where they came from".

Thankfully he is locked up in a high security dementia home now. With brown and black women caring for him.

I hope they spit in his tea!

Be careful what you wish for. It will happen to you too

HappyHappyHermit · 16/10/2022 05:29

Not sure if always racist or just ignorant. I think more people should remember that it is pure chance that you are or aren't born into a safe country. We are all just molecules etc.

DogsDinner · 16/10/2022 05:05

I would like to see net immigration reduced close to zero. I don’t think my reasons are racist or xenophobic. It would still mean hundreds of thousands of people immigrating to the U.K. each year to balance the hundreds of thousands leaving.

England, which is where most immigrants settle, is already very densely populated compared to most countries. In Europe, I think we tie with the Netherlands for top place.

For over twenty years net immigration has increased the U.K. population by a million every 3 to 5 years. Do we just carry on like this for the rest of the century until we reach 100 million people? That’s a lot of land to be built on.

We already rely on other countries to feed us. We are in danger of losing some of our land If sea levels rise as predicted. Surely we should be trying to increase our self sufficiency, not be covering farmland with buildings?

We criticise other countries for destroying their countryside and the habitats of their native species. Is it okay for us to do it because hedges and meadows and bats and bees and hedgehogs aren’t as majestic?

Nimbys get a bad press, but often they are just trying to protect beautiful areas of our country from developers.

There have been a number of threads this week on the insanity that is U.K. house prices, NHS waiting lists, school places. If we stabilised the population for a decade or two, it would enable the infrastructure to catch up.

Importing more people to deal with our ageing population is just putting off dealing with the problem. Immigrants also get old! They also put demands on services, even while easing those demands.

I do have some ideas as to how we could deal with the ageing population, but I won’t bore on. I do genuinely welcome people coming to the U.K., and the opportunity for us to emigrate, I just think it should be balanced.

HairyMcLarie · 16/10/2022 04:10

It's interesting that here in NZ immigration is very tightly restricted only to those who can achieve the stringent education, income and experience criteria that is set by a very left wing labour government who want to limit it to protect the cultural capital and low income populations here. The criteria massively favour western white applicants.

It's the right wing opposition who want to throw open the borders for commercial and capitalist reasons.

No one is calling Jacinda and her government racist for doing so.

Swipe left for the next trending thread