Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are people that want zero immigration racist?

682 replies

equalstime · 15/10/2022 22:31

People that moan about migrants coming to this county - taking our jobs - taking our houses - draining the medical system - not settling in the first country they reach for asylum- they're racist right?

There will always be an element of migration and when you take account of UK born people that leave and non Uk people that enter our country, the net figure is no doubt reasonable. They are often willing to work and contribute to our society and economy - so why the hostility?

Why not accept as a country that we have en element of migration and embrace that, if not because your views are racist?

OP posts:
Fromthedarkside · 16/10/2022 08:40

@Beecham As for the channel asylum seekers - quite frankly if you've managed to travel here from half way across the globe from a war torn country, then good on you!! You are likely to be a very resourceful and dynamic person, which is exactly what the economy needs!

Err no.
If you've passed through several safe countries on your way here, you're not a refugee, you're an economic migrant who's abusing the system.

The Refugee Convention is only meant to protect those coming directly from the place of persecution. Clearly those crossing from France (a safe and civilised country with a well-functioning asylum system) are not doing so.
As an MP on the influential House of Commons Home Affairs Committee has said: “Anybody coming across in a boat is potentially committing an unlawful act, as well as the people who are facilitating that, because they are not coming directly from a dangerous country”.

WilmaFlintstone1 · 16/10/2022 08:40

I have no issue with immigration, I work with people from across the world in the NHS.

What I do have a problem with is the lack of services for people who have nothing and have on too many occasions experienced torture. There are nowhere near enough support services to help them. I’m left floundering when I get someone referred to me who speaks little English (all hail language line and other interpretation services) has experienced torture and who needs urgent MH support which isn’t out there.

None of that is the fault of the person but of government.

Those coming in off the boats are being smuggled, many do not know where they will end up. Those that want to come here often do so because they can speak the language or they have family here already. They usually want to work but are not allowed to while their cases are being heard.

And a hotel room in England is far superior to a tent in France. They can lock the door and feel safe.

I gather there are specific arrangements for unaccompanied children. So no child should be disappearing out of a hotel room unless they have been smuggled in by a gang who have managed to say they are responsible for the child. Look at Mo Farah and what he experienced.

TightDiamondShoes · 16/10/2022 08:37

We need to be selective about migrants we welcome. Yes, we need more Doctors/nurses/scientists/engineers - but I doubt they’re the ones paying people smugglers.

I personally also feel it’s morally reprehensible to steal highly-skilled medical staff from the developing world.

It’s all well and good having “all the feels”, but don’t come crying when you can’t find anywhere to live/see a doctor/get a sibling place at a school.

CaronPoivre · 16/10/2022 08:36

We are quite densely populated but don’t top EU or many other nations when it comes to being crowded. The U.K. has an overall average of 265 people per square km. The UK is fourth on the list of countries in the European Union behind Malta, The Netherlands and Belgium. We aren’t terribly overcrowded.

We are underfunded and money is being diverted from public services to the pocket linings of the very wealthy. We perhaps need to support measures to make staying in your home nation more favourable instead of plundering highly qualified staff from poorer nations.
Perhaps our global energy crisis could be averted by investing in solar farms in places like Rwanda and Somalia? That would create wealth and employment in those nations.
Perhaps we could sponsor universities and vocation training colleges in some poorer nations to increase their wealth and status whilst also offering opportunities to our young people? Imagine the benefits for all if we sponsored 200 young plumbing and engineering apprentices to broaden their skills by learning as they extended clean water access to many areas of the world devastated by drought and enteric disease.
If we supported all to have better lives there would be a reduced need for economic migrancy and greater global security.

MooseBreath · 16/10/2022 08:31

I don't class myself as a "highly skilled worker". I class my DH as one, as a PhD educated person in specialised computer security. And if I had to leave the country due to being ineligible for a Visa, he would have come with me and taken his skillset with him. But I certainly wouldn't say that I am "unskilled" as a teacher...

PortiasBiscuit · 16/10/2022 08:30

It’s a tiny world, there are too many humans. Everyone is going to have to budge up and make room.
Why does being born in a certain place give you exclusive rights to that place? It’s a bit mad if you really think about it.

Jasmineblossom24 · 16/10/2022 08:30

We are struggling as it is with lack of housing, lack of schools, lack of proper public transport, the NHS is drowning… it’s not racism. It’s a very sad reality.

MarshaBradyo · 16/10/2022 08:28

PBSam · 16/10/2022 07:41

Is the Australian immigration model racist?

As someone who grew up with it it became normal to me there. I still strongly wanted remain but since that is now not an option I now think of the Aus point system as an example of how it could work.

FreddyHG · 16/10/2022 08:28

Plus immigration drives down wages an conditions. It's basic supply and demand of labour. Even Theresa yesterday said UK nurses will be replaced by foreign workers if they don't like the conditions and leave the NHS.

marvellousmaple · 16/10/2022 08:26

MooseBreath · 16/10/2022 08:23

@marvellousmaple My DH is British. I studied abroad at The University of Sheffield, met my DH, and moved here whilst he completed his PhD on a Youth Mobility Scheme visa. It expired around when DH was offered a very good job in computer security, so I was able to swap to a Spouse Visa. If DH hadn't been offered that job, we would've had to move to my home country and the UK would've lost a "highly skilled" worker in the process.

Yeah ok. I guess that makes sense if you think the UK doesn't have enough highly skilled workers ( as you class yourself).

FreddyHG · 16/10/2022 08:23

Cw112 · 15/10/2022 22:47

Let's be honest most people who complain about immigration tend to be complaining based on the country of origin and the colour of the person's skin. We never really hear people complaining of an American or a German coming and taking jobs do we? So I do think it's fundamentally racist at least in part.

Did you miss the Brexit campaign where white immigration was a big issue? For me we are a tiny island which can't feed or energy resource itself that is becoming increasingly overcrowded with failing infrastructure. So I would argue against immigration and steps to reduce the birth rate.

MooseBreath · 16/10/2022 08:23

@marvellousmaple My DH is British. I studied abroad at The University of Sheffield, met my DH, and moved here whilst he completed his PhD on a Youth Mobility Scheme visa. It expired around when DH was offered a very good job in computer security, so I was able to swap to a Spouse Visa. If DH hadn't been offered that job, we would've had to move to my home country and the UK would've lost a "highly skilled" worker in the process.

luckylavender · 16/10/2022 08:19

Cw112 · 15/10/2022 22:47

Let's be honest most people who complain about immigration tend to be complaining based on the country of origin and the colour of the person's skin. We never really hear people complaining of an American or a German coming and taking jobs do we? So I do think it's fundamentally racist at least in part.

And there was wide spread hospitality when it was Ukrainian refuges. Lots of Daily Mail views on this thread.

cimena · 16/10/2022 08:18

New Zealand and Australias policies are INCREDIBLY racist, and New Zealand’s is a lot of other ‘ists’ as well. It’s horrendous and it’s shameful.

A lot of people on this thread seem to think the UK just lets everyone in? It’s really, really hard work to settle here, costs thousands and takes years. And that’s if you’ve got resources!

Refugees and undocumented migrants are a different thing entirely and basically a direct result of colonialism, so I’m of the opinion that it’s the UKs responsibility to help, given the hand they had in causing the massive global imbalance in wealth and political instability that forces people to take unbelievable risks to try to come here.

marvellousmaple · 16/10/2022 08:18

Nobody ever seems to admit that their own country was shite - that's why they are emigrating. But the country they have moved to needs to be perfect , Fecking annoying really

Jessiesthedog · 16/10/2022 08:18

There are deals being signed at the moment in India which are going to absolutely open the floodgates. If you think its an issue now, brace yourself.

AntlerRose · 16/10/2022 08:17

You dont have to claim asylum in the first safe country you reach. I dont know why people think that.

Imagine the burden on some countries if that were the case, although to be fair turkey does have a massive chunk of the worlds refugees.

marvellousmaple · 16/10/2022 08:14

MooseBreath · 16/10/2022 07:54

The thing is, "unskilled" labour in the UK is needed. As an immigrant, I am "unskilled" (despite having a University degree and being a fully capable human being) and the only reason why I was eligible to come was because my DH is highly paid.

Since coming to the UK, I have worked as a teacher in both nursery and primary, an office, and now as a self-employed dance teacher (though on maternity, for which I receive no government assistance). I am eligible for no benefits whatsoever as a stipulation on my visa.

What is wrong with people like me coming to the UK? I pay taxes. I don't claim benefits. If I want to retrain at a University, I still need to pay exorbitant international fees. I need to pay £1000 per year in NHS surcharges just to live here in top of my visa fees. I contribute far more to society than I take, but based on the opinions of many in this thread, I shouldn't be here.

A competent government would mandate and fund better services along with the new housing being built, rather than focusing on lining their own pockets and privatising public services. "Low skilled" immigration isn't the problem. This greedy, capitalist, self-serving government is the problem.

Just wondering why you moved

A580Hojas · 16/10/2022 08:13

DogsDinner · 16/10/2022 05:05

I would like to see net immigration reduced close to zero. I don’t think my reasons are racist or xenophobic. It would still mean hundreds of thousands of people immigrating to the U.K. each year to balance the hundreds of thousands leaving.

England, which is where most immigrants settle, is already very densely populated compared to most countries. In Europe, I think we tie with the Netherlands for top place.

For over twenty years net immigration has increased the U.K. population by a million every 3 to 5 years. Do we just carry on like this for the rest of the century until we reach 100 million people? That’s a lot of land to be built on.

We already rely on other countries to feed us. We are in danger of losing some of our land If sea levels rise as predicted. Surely we should be trying to increase our self sufficiency, not be covering farmland with buildings?

We criticise other countries for destroying their countryside and the habitats of their native species. Is it okay for us to do it because hedges and meadows and bats and bees and hedgehogs aren’t as majestic?

Nimbys get a bad press, but often they are just trying to protect beautiful areas of our country from developers.

There have been a number of threads this week on the insanity that is U.K. house prices, NHS waiting lists, school places. If we stabilised the population for a decade or two, it would enable the infrastructure to catch up.

Importing more people to deal with our ageing population is just putting off dealing with the problem. Immigrants also get old! They also put demands on services, even while easing those demands.

I do have some ideas as to how we could deal with the ageing population, but I won’t bore on. I do genuinely welcome people coming to the U.K., and the opportunity for us to emigrate, I just think it should be balanced.

This aligns with how I feel. We have to balance compassion with practicality.

God the country is in a mess. Never known anything like it in all my 60 years Sad.

waffless · 16/10/2022 08:12

People calling for zero immigration are as morons as people to call for open borders.

Have a control immigration system and make sure public services are working for all. We have the right to select who comes in and the duty to provide the best for those immigrants in return for their hard work and their contribution to taxes.

Yes, racists want zero immigration but it does not mean the rest of us are happy to let all the developing countries problems and nutcases here. There is a reason why this was a civilised country. Now it is becoming scary to be here. Very often people from the left put up Sweden as the best example of socialism. See what is happening there politically. It is bound to get worse so may be think harder before making sweeping statements calling everyone racist and talking non sense OP.

Chicca1970 · 16/10/2022 08:08

@PutYourShoesOnWereLate Excellent comment - I have just come off a 60 hr week in Care. I am currently rostered with a lot of Nigerians. They are all fantastic - dynamic, enthusiastic, respectful to the residents and immensely hard working. Back home, they worked in finance, engineering, teaching … a month’s wage for these professions in Nigeria equates to one day’s earnings in the UK Care sector. I have to be honest, there are some excellent UK Carers but I would rather work alongside a large team of Africans & Eastern Europeans on a 12hr shift than a large team of Brits because there is less bitching, moaning and more initiative. Of course, there are a lot of superb UK workers.

Carers need a fairer wage, as do staff in the NHS - a lot of foreign workers are looking to go to places like Canada as the cost of living is relatively lower and lifestyle/opportunities better.

#ToriesOut :)

Meili04 · 16/10/2022 08:03

We definitely need some immigration, I work in healthcare and a good chunk of our staff are from abroad. It needs to be certain roles though and there should be caps, time limits on some roles. I like the Australian points system.

CaronPoivre · 16/10/2022 07:58

Much of the right wing, anti-immigration culture was stirred up by Farage and the media and (like the 350 million on the side of the bus and better trade deals, cheaper foods and having all the cards) has little basis in fact.

The U.K. has only 14% immigrant population (people born outside U.K.) People arriving by boats are the tiniest number compared to say, Polish workers who arrived legally under EU rules and Indians with visas. Most are entirely legal.

Poland is still the top country of citizenship of foreign citizens (696,000), accounting for 12% of non-UK citizens living in the UK. Who doesn’t want Polish bakers in the markets and Polish plumbers fixing their leaking taps when no U.K. born ones are available to work or are unaffordable?

Most people seeking asylum are granted it. Those few people (usually of working age, sometimes women and children) who cross the channel are firstly fellow humans and our equals. They have crossed the globe on an incredibly difficult journey for better, safer life for themselves and their families. Who would deny them that? (Apart from Tory’s reliant on popularist, far right policies to remain in their seats). Of those seeking asylum about 86% are granted refugee status. Another 6% are given humanitarian protection rights. They aren’t ‘illegals’ they are seeking asylum under international laws and arriving by the only means available to them.

ohfook · 16/10/2022 07:58

This is just my personal experience but there are some arguments against immigration that could be valid (lack of space, competition for jobs etc) but the people I know who use them, use them to prop up their racism so it becomes hard to separate the two.

Much in the same way I suppose that it's not at all racist to put a Union Jack in your garden or up in your window, yet anyone I know who does it in real life is actually fairly racist so the two become intertwined.

HappyHappyHermit · 16/10/2022 07:57

@MintyFreshOne If it makes you feel better I would never have classed myself as a very comfortable expat, I've very much lived in the thick of things, not in the protected expat pockets. All this did was strengthen my feeling that the way things are set up are not fair and safety should not rely on being born on a particular bit of soil. We can agree to disagree though, I realise my views are a far off ideal to me that would be a struggle to achieve. I just hate the unfairness.

Swipe left for the next trending thread