Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are people that want zero immigration racist?

682 replies

equalstime · 15/10/2022 22:31

People that moan about migrants coming to this county - taking our jobs - taking our houses - draining the medical system - not settling in the first country they reach for asylum- they're racist right?

There will always be an element of migration and when you take account of UK born people that leave and non Uk people that enter our country, the net figure is no doubt reasonable. They are often willing to work and contribute to our society and economy - so why the hostility?

Why not accept as a country that we have en element of migration and embrace that, if not because your views are racist?

OP posts:
SummerWhisper · 16/10/2022 09:32

When people cite overpopulation, services at breaking point etc. do those people call for population control? If not, I suspect racism.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 16/10/2022 09:29

Ilovemycatalot · 16/10/2022 09:07

No I don’t want uncontrolled immigration. I’m living in the south east and we have a housing crisis. No council housing and low housing stock for anyone wishing to buy/rent. That’s even if you could ever afford to buy with the ridiculous house prices. My dd commented how busy everywhere is and it’s true because there are to many people. No gp appts and good luck if you need hospital care you will be waiting years. All in all it’s making the UK an undesirable place to live and it’s not racist to say that.
I guess if your living in your country dwelling in your nice unaffected bubble then of course your view on immigration will be different.
But if your living the reality it’s not so good.

This. It's not racist to not want that. I would like a system like Australia's. That's how I feel it would work better for the country.

BloodyHellKen · 16/10/2022 09:16

Based purely on the title of your thread OP, no, I don't think people who want zero immigration are racist as their idea of zero immigration isn't based on race.

Presumably they want no immigrants irrespective of their race and where they come from.

jetadore · 16/10/2022 09:16

You don’t have to be racist to want zero immigration, but it helps.

MooseBreath · 16/10/2022 09:16

@Seymour5 I stated that I was on a Youth Mobility Scheme visa, which is not a Student Visa (I had been on this prior to the YMS). But surely I'm not the only person who was living abroad when my personal situation changed?

I'm not saying that every foreign graduate should have the right to remain. I'm saying that the monetary threshold for Spousal visas is too high, and that people should be able to come in on work visas for "less skilled" professions than doctors. The fact that there is a teacher shortage and teachers are not deemed as "skilled" is ridiculous.

Ilovemycatalot · 16/10/2022 09:12

Also don’t want anymore of our disappearing green space turned into bloody flats! They are constantly building horrible tall tower blocks to accommodate the ever growing population and it just makes the whole place look like concrete city and very depressing. Not that their building anymore schools hospitals etc to accommodate all these extra people.

Seymour5 · 16/10/2022 09:10

MooseBreath · 16/10/2022 09:00

@Seymour5 If my DH had still been a student or was paid less, I would have applied for a working visa, which I wouldn't have qualified for because I am deemed "unskilled".

When you came on your student visa you would have known it was for a limited time. I imagine most international students plan to take their qualifications home and use them to find work there.

Your residency is because your husband is a UK citizen. Likewise he could move as a spouse to your country if you wished. It sounds as if you're suggesting every foreign graduate should have the right to remain here?

dottiedodah · 16/10/2022 09:09

Some immigration is inevitable though.people always seem to complain but if in hospital don't mind being tended to by excellent doctors and nurses! The whole point of getting people over was to do jobs with vacancies. The whole team barring the manager in mums care home were foreign .one lady sent all her wages back to her family 👪.!

Fromthedarkside · 16/10/2022 09:09

@waffless
If anything the government has done nothing to solve this situation with the smugglers. Why?

You are misinformed.

see p 36 of this document - assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/972517/CCS207_CCS0820091708-001_Sovereign_Borders_Web_Accessible.pdf

Ilovemycatalot · 16/10/2022 09:07

No I don’t want uncontrolled immigration. I’m living in the south east and we have a housing crisis. No council housing and low housing stock for anyone wishing to buy/rent. That’s even if you could ever afford to buy with the ridiculous house prices. My dd commented how busy everywhere is and it’s true because there are to many people. No gp appts and good luck if you need hospital care you will be waiting years. All in all it’s making the UK an undesirable place to live and it’s not racist to say that.
I guess if your living in your country dwelling in your nice unaffected bubble then of course your view on immigration will be different.
But if your living the reality it’s not so good.

MarshaBradyo · 16/10/2022 09:06

waffless · 16/10/2022 09:01

If anything the government has done nothing to solve this situation with the smugglers. Why?

What would you like to see them do? It’s a very difficult issue, what options do you see. Genuinely interested as maybe I’m missing what they can do

Things have to be really bad to dissuade people - look at Aus camps used they are harsh places

Redqueenheart · 16/10/2022 09:05

I immigrated from an EU country 30 years ago. My thoughts:

  • There are obvious issues about the fact that the infrastructure (housing, healthcare, schools) has not increased to match the demand. Immigrants tend to live in places that are already highly populated (London and the South East) so of course that places an incredible strain on services there and immigration needs to be managed better because of this
  • Most immigrants (and I say that as a Londoner) just want to live a peaceful life, do well and raise their children to do well. But I think it is also a fact that a minority have brought with them issues that led to increased anti-social behaviour and that there can be a refusal to integrate and adopt ''UK values'' (things like understanding you need to show equal respect for women and leave your homophobia at the door and so on).

I do think though that there is still an element of racism there too as people have mentioned already as white immigrants are often treated differently from people from other backgrounds. Although I must say as a white person I have still heard a few xenophobic comments over the decades...but in London it is rare that people are openly hostile as the population is so diverse.

I was very proud when I became a British citizen and I have done everything I could to learn about history and culture and integrate in society. If people have an issue with that, that's their problem, not mine.

Some level of immigration will always be needed to fill gaps in areas like healthcare, medical research, academia and engineering. Some people also choose to start businesses here that will employ local people and bring tax revenue and I don't see anything wrong with that.

waffless · 16/10/2022 09:01

If anything the government has done nothing to solve this situation with the smugglers. Why?

Seymour5 · 16/10/2022 09:01

@purpleleotard2 people from the UK visit Albania as holidaymakers. Why then are Albanians coming here in dinghies, purporting to be seeking asylum? What war are they fleeing?

Fromthedarkside · 16/10/2022 09:01

@purpleleotard2 Those escaping their war torn countries by crossing the channel by boat are wanting to come to the UK to work and build a new life

Since when has Europe been a 'war-torn country' ? Have I been asleep at the wheel?

One in six boat crossers already claimed asylum elsewhere
In March 2021, the Home Office revealed this eye-opening fact (relating to those who came in small boats during 2019) Thousands of those crossing on boats are failed asylum claimants who have already tried their luck and been rejected in other European countries, such as France, Germany, Greece, Denmark and Switzerland .
Some would have us forget this important context and receive everyone coming as a fresh claimant. This is patently absurd.

Anyone who wants to check this out can read it here - assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/972517/CCS207_CCS0820091708-001_Sovereign_Borders_Web_Accessible.pdf

So it seems that we are being overrun by other countries' rejects.

waffless · 16/10/2022 09:00

So how the reason that they come here because of the English language leave us? With that reason as valid yes many would come here and they therefore would have family already here. Do we have a problem then?

MooseBreath · 16/10/2022 09:00

@Seymour5 If my DH had still been a student or was paid less, I would have applied for a working visa, which I wouldn't have qualified for because I am deemed "unskilled".

beastlyslumber · 16/10/2022 08:59

Have been reading the thread with interest. I agree with pp there has to be a better balance - zero immigration is unreasonable, but net zero is a good idea.

I also think that there needs to be some kind of expectation of immigrants that they assimilate to British culture and language. There shouldn't be areas where women have to conform to Sharia law, for example. If you live in this country, you should conform to its laws and culture, e.g. LGB equality, women's rights etc.

Ayaan Hirsi Ali wrote a book called "Prey: Immigration, Islam, and the Erosion of Women's Rights," where she researches and discusses these issues in depth.

Seymour5 · 16/10/2022 08:58

MooseBreath · 16/10/2022 08:31

I don't class myself as a "highly skilled worker". I class my DH as one, as a PhD educated person in specialised computer security. And if I had to leave the country due to being ineligible for a Visa, he would have come with me and taken his skillset with him. But I certainly wouldn't say that I am "unskilled" as a teacher...

Spousal visas don't require applicants to be skilled. The expectation is on the existing UK resident, like your husband, to be able to support you.

Only those applying specifically to come here to work need to demonstrate skills.

Southwig22 · 16/10/2022 08:49

I completely agree.
The same lame old excuses as well e.g. "we are a small island and don't have the services to support ourselves etc etc" ... Wilfully ignoring the fact that it's because we don't have enough workers that we are suffering these service issues.

x2boys · 16/10/2022 08:49

I guess a lot of views are formed from where people live,it's all very well sitting in your nice four bedroom detached house in a middle class area ,with ample school places for your children in either private schools or nice leafy high achieving schools ,and you can afford private health care etc ,not think high levels of immigration are a problem
It's an entirely different scenario living in a deprived area ,with a high level of immigration, with an all ready over stretched health service , with schools bursting at the seems ,and not enough decent housing it might cloud your view somewhat.

purpleleotard2 · 16/10/2022 08:48

A different take to this question.
I don't think we are a 'small island', there are huge areas un inhabited. Only 1.4% of the UK landmass is used for housing
Services are stretched at some point because there are not the people to do the work.
We need the immigrants to keep our services, NHS, transport, Social services, Hospitality etc running.
The Covid virus killed about 207,000.
Those escaping their war torn countries by crossing the channel by boat are wanting to come to the UK to work and build a new life. Numbering about 27000 in 2021 and set for 40000 in 2022. They do not come close to replacing those lost to the virus. They live a very difficult life, denied work, until their situation is "regulated". Let them work. Let them contribute to the UK plc.

oiltrader · 16/10/2022 08:48

ChocFrog · 15/10/2022 22:46

It isn’t racism to be concerned about immigration levels. England is massively overpopulated compared to most other countries and services are at breaking point. You say that the net figures are “no doubt reasonable” but the problem is, they aren’t.

It isn’t racism to think that asylum seekers should claim asylum in the first safe country. That is what they are supposed to do. Travelling onward is no longer asylum seeking, it’s economic migration.

I live in Kent, we’ve had 22,000 migrants delivered to Kent’s beaches so far this year by people smugglers - and that’s just the ones who were caught. All of them need housing and food. All of the support network is full so some unaccompanied children are being placed in hotels - from where many go missing. (Your guess is as good as mine who takes children that no one is watching.)

Labelling concerns about this racist is unhelpful and inaccurate.

incorrect. they do not have to claim asylum in first country

Fromthedarkside · 16/10/2022 08:47

@Beenaboutabit “This little island is full” is UKIP propaganda.
Do a bit of research about country landmass and population density. It’s just not true.

Err actually it is. We are the second most densely populated country in Europe

unherd.com/2018/03/youll-never-guess-densely-populated-country-europe/

Ignorance is tiring.

No. Your ignorance is tiring

MarshaBradyo · 16/10/2022 08:45

imo things will only become more strained as climate change ramps up. How countries respond will depend in part on geography

Swipe left for the next trending thread