Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are people that want zero immigration racist?

682 replies

equalstime · 15/10/2022 22:31

People that moan about migrants coming to this county - taking our jobs - taking our houses - draining the medical system - not settling in the first country they reach for asylum- they're racist right?

There will always be an element of migration and when you take account of UK born people that leave and non Uk people that enter our country, the net figure is no doubt reasonable. They are often willing to work and contribute to our society and economy - so why the hostility?

Why not accept as a country that we have en element of migration and embrace that, if not because your views are racist?

OP posts:
Kendodd · 16/10/2022 11:28

MarshaBradyo · 16/10/2022 11:22

For a start, Ukraine is basically fighting a war against Putin for us, they are the first line of defence. Another is that the vast majority of Ukrainian refugees are women and children. Ukrainians are also expected to return, they're only given temporary shelter

I agree with this although I do see the need for getting Afghan people out who helped us.

I also remember the huge outcry at gov for taking too long wrt Ukrainian refugees so that was an added pressure

Absolutely. I remember have a stand up row with some women at work (well volunteering job) about it. It was the day after Kabul fell, she was saying how terrible it was but 'they can't come here, we're full up'. I was talking to a security guard about it immediately afterwards. He served in Afghanistan and in his words 'was as racist as they come' but even he agreed we should do everything we can to get people out.

Fromthedarkside · 16/10/2022 11:27

@FreddyHG Be very careful here Mumsnet censors citing talk guidelines stuff even when backed up with official statistics when it shows certain ethnic groups cause disproportionately issues to their population size.

Exactly.

Rochdale Grooming Gangs ( and others) were allowed to continue for as long as they did because it appeared Police were reluctant to act for fear of being called racist.

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/police-chief-we-ignored-sex-abuse-of-children-hgrhc358v

It seems this mindset continues in other organisations -

www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/grooming-gangs-iicsa-racist-fears-b2007649.html

news.sky.com/story/1-000-children-groomed-but-unease-about-race-meant-telford-sexual-exploitation-ignored-inquiry-finds-12650725

Lndnmummy · 16/10/2022 11:27

So WHY is this teeny tiny island "over populated"? Might it have something to do with your colonial past? Just a thought..,

red4321 · 16/10/2022 11:26

I wonder if the government knows the actual size of the population in the U.K.? I hadn't really thought of it until they made it clear that people didn't need an NHS number to be vaccinated.

In fairness, I don't know whether everyone living the U.K. is meant to have an NHS number if they're legally living here. But I've read articles suggesting that the population is 5-7 million higher than the official number. Which surely makes it hard to plan public services if you don't know the number and geographic location of your population?

MarshaBradyo · 16/10/2022 11:22

For a start, Ukraine is basically fighting a war against Putin for us, they are the first line of defence. Another is that the vast majority of Ukrainian refugees are women and children. Ukrainians are also expected to return, they're only given temporary shelter

I agree with this although I do see the need for getting Afghan people out who helped us.

I also remember the huge outcry at gov for taking too long wrt Ukrainian refugees so that was an added pressure

Kendodd · 16/10/2022 11:19

EugeneLevysEyebrow · 16/10/2022 10:56

The clearest sign I’ve seen recently that reveals how racist Britain is how one set of migrants (Ukrainian refugees) have been treated compared to other migrants from other countries who are in similar positions.

On the whole the government, media and population of the UK have been welcoming to Ukrainians fleeing the war. Not to mention the Ukrainians flags flying from every council building, and on your random relative’s Facebook page.

But similarly horrific wars and disasters are happening in so many other places - Afghanistan, Yemen, Haiti etc. But these horrific things are happening to non white, often non-Christian people. Afghans who actually worked for the Uk govt in Afghanistan and are at serious risk are put at the back of the queue behind blond Christian Ukrainians. That’s racism, pure and simple.

I don't disagree with you about the appalling way other refugees have been treated, especially Afghans who are only in danger BECAUSE they worked for western forces. I think equating the different treatment of Ukrainian refugees with racism is simplistic though. There are loads of reasons they've been treated differently (and racism may be one of them). For a start, Ukraine is basically fighting a war against Putin for us, they are the first line of defence. Another is that the vast majority of Ukrainian refugees are women and children. Ukrainians are also expected to return, they're only given temporary shelter, other refugees need permanent resettlement.

Galaktoboureko · 16/10/2022 11:14

FreddyHG · 16/10/2022 10:40

Be very careful here Mumsnet censors citing talk guidelines stuff even when backed up with official statistics when it shows certain ethnic groups cause disproportionately issues to their population size. Unless of course white males in which case crack on and blame them for everything.

I just don't understand the utter radio silence around it - even on this thread it's been totally ignored. You'd think feminists would be all over it!

Westernised/later generation ethnic minorities are not the issue at all, but it's pretty obvious that women are second class citizens in many ME/Asian/African cultures. We need to be giving the message that we will welcome cultural diversity but not tolerate women being brutalised. Turning a blind eye isn't the solution and doesn't set a good precedent for the ethnic youths who now make up the majority of under 20s in a growing number of our cities.

Changechangychange · 16/10/2022 11:10

marvellousmaple · 16/10/2022 08:26

Yeah ok. I guess that makes sense if you think the UK doesn't have enough highly skilled workers ( as you class yourself).

We do not have enough doctors, nurses or teachers, no. Have you seriously missed this?

There are also plenty of gaps in IT and other skilled professions.

stuckdownahole · 16/10/2022 11:03

HairyMcLarie · 16/10/2022 10:12

@gonutkin yes she's an immigrant. As I am in NZ. White western middle class people sometimes call themselves the ridiculous euphemism 'expats'.

I had to demonstrate a certain level of income (well above the national average), post grad degree and 10 years of experience in my field along with a clean bill of health to be given a visa. It still takes around 8 years to be considered a citizen. Any misdoing will have your visa cancelled and 'expatriated'. You also have to be under a certain age. 46 or something random.

We waited an extra 6 months for a decision because we had slightly high blood pressure... it's damn difficult to get into NZ and Aus yet this is barely questioned as being racist

I always call myself an immigrant in the hope of normalising the phrase.

I am a UK citizen who works abroad. I call myself an expat because the only reason I am in another country is for work purposes. I have no intention of permanently leaving the UK and settling elsewhere.

Adultchildofelderlyparents · 16/10/2022 11:01

To nip these comments in the bud: asylum seekers do not need to seek asylum in the first safe country they reach. They haven't needed to do that since the 1951 Refugee Convention.
If you were seeking asylum, wouldn't you want to go somewhere you might already have a relative or friend? If there was a European war, would you be happy for the population of France to come to the UK or would you expect some to go elsewhere? That said, a lot of asylum seekers do go to a neighbouring country. Turkey currently has the most. 38% of asylum seekers are in only five countries (the UK is not one of them).

It's important to note the difference between asylum seekers, displaced people, refugees, illegal immigrants and immigrants. I think a lot of people complain about immigrants, when what they actually have a problem with is illegal immigrants.

Over recent years, the number of people moving to the UK from overseas has been higher than the number who leave, but foreign-born people still only make up 9% of the UK population.

Are they taking our jobs? No, they are not "our" jobs to take. The best person for the job will get it, if that is someone moving from overseas then they bring something UK candidates cannot offer. You could argue that successive governments have failed the UK education system in that sense.

Are they taking medical attention? Again, since they only make up 9% of the population, no. I have to wait two weeks for a GP appointment, I waited 18 months for an operation. That, again, is the government historically and persistently underfunding the NHS. It's not because immigrants are clogging the system.

Are they taking our houses? There is a problem with foreign buyers in the housing market, but these tend to be non-UK resident buyers of expensive properties.

Where is the burden on resources and facilities coming from? The UK population as a whole has increased. We are healthier and wealthier, our children survive infancy and we live longer. In the old days babies died often, children too, average life expectancy was lower. Then the world wars killed a significant number. But then penicillin was introduced, water was cleaned to drink, the NHS was developed.
In 1950 the population was just over 50 million and its increased by around a million every 3-4 years averagely. Foreign migrants make up a tiny fraction of that total number.

To answer your first question, "are people who want zero immigration racist?" Some of those people, yes, will have racist motives. We saw clear demonstrations of those race and ethnicity prejudices around the brexit referendum in some people.
Others may not be racist but may not understand that the burden on our resources, infrastructures, services, is from ourselves, not from immigrants.

As a country, we could not manage on zero immigration, it's just not feasible.

newnamethanks · 16/10/2022 10:59

Wanting zero immigration is probably racist but is most certainly comprehensively stupid. Anyone with such an opinion should be forced to read a book. Or two. Ineffably dim.

Kendodd · 16/10/2022 10:58

Theroad · 16/10/2022 00:00

Thank you for proving the OP's point

I think you've proved my point if anything. Racism is hating/discriminating against people based on their skin colour. I explicitly stated it was sad to see people segregated by skin colour. I also said expecting zero migration was unreasonable.

I think controlled migration is good for a country. I was brought up in a predominantly homogeneous country and I see the downsides of this. However, there's a balance to be struck. It's a numbers game. Otherwise you tip over into division and, as I said, a breakdown in social cohesion. This is bourne out in the research. So perhaps get down off your reactive high horse for a breather!

No it isn't. Or at least that's not the UN definition of racism.

www.ohchr.org/en/instruments-mechanisms/instruments/international-convention-elimination-all-forms-racial

EugeneLevysEyebrow · 16/10/2022 10:56

The clearest sign I’ve seen recently that reveals how racist Britain is how one set of migrants (Ukrainian refugees) have been treated compared to other migrants from other countries who are in similar positions.

On the whole the government, media and population of the UK have been welcoming to Ukrainians fleeing the war. Not to mention the Ukrainians flags flying from every council building, and on your random relative’s Facebook page.

But similarly horrific wars and disasters are happening in so many other places - Afghanistan, Yemen, Haiti etc. But these horrific things are happening to non white, often non-Christian people. Afghans who actually worked for the Uk govt in Afghanistan and are at serious risk are put at the back of the queue behind blond Christian Ukrainians. That’s racism, pure and simple.

ManAboutTown · 16/10/2022 10:54

I should think most people (particularly in the cities) know immigrants as friends, work colleagues, their children's friends and so on and these are people they see in day to day life who are striving for a better life just like most of the rest of us.

What people also see though is the preponderance of immigrant groups in some crimes like people trafficking, child rape, terrorism and so forth

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 16/10/2022 10:47

I used to think they were racist, and I think shutting people down like that is part of the reason Brexit won. Some people are racist, but a great many more have been let down by successive governments not responding to changing needs of the population. If it was easier to see your GP, get appropriate healthcare, send your dc to a school with a smaller class size, get whatever help you need, or even park safely outside your dc school then immigration wouldn't be perceived as such a threat.

TinySaltLick · 16/10/2022 10:42

halfsiesonapotnoodle · 15/10/2022 22:37

I doubt it's anything to do with actual race but more to do with the fact we are a tiny island, whose population has grown massively since the 50s and is actually causing many services to be at breaking point. We have too many people.

The issue you describe is the services have failed to scale with population increase, it is a government issue.

Health care is such that life expectancy now means the population will always increase, until a limit is imposed on total children allowed. So rather than worry the country is full (when it is mostly green space) the question is how do we house and support a growing global population

FreddyHG · 16/10/2022 10:40

Galaktoboureko · 16/10/2022 10:33

I absolutely agree that there are a lot xenophobic/racist individuals about, but on the other side of the coin, I find it odd how people have a wilful tendency to ignore worrying trends when the perpetrators are of an ethnic minority. I can only assume it's due to a perhaps misguided desire to avoid racial profiling.

1200 sexual assaults in one night is perhaps the biggest inidividual instance in recent European history. Meanwhile, Germany’s Office of Police Crime Statistics (PCS) acknowledged that 'asylum-seekers represented an above-average share (9.7 percent) of all suspects in cases of “rape, sexual coercion, and sexual assault in particularly serious cases including those resulting in death', which is worrying when you consider they constitute approximately 1% of the total German population.

Be very careful here Mumsnet censors citing talk guidelines stuff even when backed up with official statistics when it shows certain ethnic groups cause disproportionately issues to their population size. Unless of course white males in which case crack on and blame them for everything.

FreddyHG · 16/10/2022 10:38

SummerWhisper · 16/10/2022 09:32

When people cite overpopulation, services at breaking point etc. do those people call for population control? If not, I suspect racism.

I suspect you don't understand because you are woke lefty. People are equally against white migration as seen to the reaction to seasonal workers here in East Anglia.

Sarahcoggles · 16/10/2022 10:36

halfsiesonapotnoodle · 15/10/2022 22:37

I doubt it's anything to do with actual race but more to do with the fact we are a tiny island, whose population has grown massively since the 50s and is actually causing many services to be at breaking point. We have too many people.

This.

It's not racism.

Galaktoboureko · 16/10/2022 10:33

I absolutely agree that there are a lot xenophobic/racist individuals about, but on the other side of the coin, I find it odd how people have a wilful tendency to ignore worrying trends when the perpetrators are of an ethnic minority. I can only assume it's due to a perhaps misguided desire to avoid racial profiling.

1200 sexual assaults in one night is perhaps the biggest inidividual instance in recent European history. Meanwhile, Germany’s Office of Police Crime Statistics (PCS) acknowledged that 'asylum-seekers represented an above-average share (9.7 percent) of all suspects in cases of “rape, sexual coercion, and sexual assault in particularly serious cases including those resulting in death', which is worrying when you consider they constitute approximately 1% of the total German population.

ManAboutTown · 16/10/2022 10:31

I don't know anybody who wants zero immigration so the premise of the thread is probably off.

What many people want though is controlled immigration - they see things like the daily shitshow in the channel and headline net immigration numbers and are concerned about overcrowding in inner cities and the effects of a rapidly rising population on the provision of public services such as housing, health, education and transport.

Nearly all western European countries have demographic problem with the "native" population not having children to meet replacement rate and immigration fills some of the gap. All also have aging populations.

Is wanting to restrict immigration racist - in a word no. Concerns tend to be over cultural issues and how well people can fit into society - we have all seen that some cultural issues (by no means all) have developed over the decades of increased immigration and one of society's challenges is how to address that without alienating or marginalising sections

PoundShopPrincess · 16/10/2022 10:29

Our immigration system isn't fit for purpose. That doesn't mean people want zero immigration.
You need to look at the system as a whole. People who make it to the UK spend too long waiting to find out if they can stay. Checks and balances on who people are and why they came, are patchy. Our shoddy system encourages people trafficking which funds organised crime, channels women and DCs into prostitution, and puts many people's lives at risk.
There is a global refugee crisis and it needs a global response.
Somewhere the UK fell into a trap of framing any conversations about refugees or immigration as racist - the result of that is that the system can't be discussed or reformed or improved.
The squeeze on infrastructure and resources is another issue although it sits alongside it for many people. Again, government policies have led to breakdowns in infrastructure and insufficient services.
When you have politicians who have no principles, change policy depending on polls and ultimately feel responsible to wealthy donors (not the electorate) you end up with systems that don't work.

sst1234 · 16/10/2022 10:28

To call those racist who wanted some controls on immigration is what enabled Brexit in the first place. The people to blame for Brexit are the enlightened ones who feel morally superior for thinking all immigration is good and that anyone questioning it must be racist. Congratulations, gun, foot, prefect shot.

I don’t think there are many people who believe in 0 immigration. Maybe only some extreme right wing nut jobs in small numbers. On the contrary, on the left it is a prevalent view that you must not question immigration at all, everyone coming on a boat is a genuine asylum seeker and many will not hear a word against mass migration, they simply want open borders. This is the attitude that is most harmful because it’s not on the fringes like the 0 immigration ones. It’s mainstream.

We need some low skilled migration and we need lots of high skilled workers. But the left have made it an impossible topic to talk about rationally by calling the opposing side racist.

bingbummy · 16/10/2022 10:26

Mycatsgoldtooth · 16/10/2022 10:21

@bingbummy tell me you’ve never had any dealings with the criminal justice system, without telling me you’ve never had any dealings with the criminal justice system

What?

MarshaBradyo · 16/10/2022 10:25

lollipoprainbow · 16/10/2022 10:02

Strictly speaking, in terms of services, we have too many old white people. Around 20% of the UK population are white people aged 60+, people who are less likely to be providing services and increasingly likely to be using them.

Disgusting comment, my over 60, white relative has just died so that's one less for you to worry about.

I’m not getting why the poster added white - if the proportion changed the issue would still exist

Swipe left for the next trending thread