Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are people that want zero immigration racist?

682 replies

equalstime · 15/10/2022 22:31

People that moan about migrants coming to this county - taking our jobs - taking our houses - draining the medical system - not settling in the first country they reach for asylum- they're racist right?

There will always be an element of migration and when you take account of UK born people that leave and non Uk people that enter our country, the net figure is no doubt reasonable. They are often willing to work and contribute to our society and economy - so why the hostility?

Why not accept as a country that we have en element of migration and embrace that, if not because your views are racist?

OP posts:
Lndnmummy · 20/02/2023 21:07

Volver · 20/02/2023 13:19

It seems to me that native born Brits are imploding through lack of public services resources brought on by their votes eg
Brexit
Successive Tory Governments
aided and abetted by the right wing media owned by the powerful who couldn’t give a stuff about the general population

It is racist and xenophobic to say it’s immigration causing the strain on public services like the NHS, education, housing, etc. Basically blaming and othering people in the minority, but who contribute more in net taxes to the well being of a nation than the native born population.
Yes there are always a minority of scroungers but in the vast majority immigrants contribute more per capita, and in many cases are better educated than the native population .

Read the Stats migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/resources/briefings/the-fiscal-impact-of-immigration-in-the-uk/

The other thing that makes me laugh is the very people who voted for Brexit have now shot themselves in the foot as EU nationals contributed more per capita to the economy than their non EU equivalents and culturally and due to historical ties had a huge amount more in common with Brits (including ethnicity which matters a lot to the racists who wanted Brexit) than immigrants from other parts of the globe.

They also voted to restrict their own freedom of movement to work and live in many lovely European countries.
Thats a direct result of ignorance and xenophobia. You couldn’t get more stupid if you tried.

Most of the comments on this thread blaming immigration for the mess GB is in are ignorant at best, racist and xenophobic in most cases too.

I couldn't agree more

Florenz · 20/02/2023 21:02

Kabalagala · 20/02/2023 19:45

I'm not of the opinion that migration has anything to do with house prices. House prices have been propped up for decades, without migrants we'd just have built even fewer houses with the same outcome.

But there have been far more immigrants than there have been new houses built. Not to mention all the houses that previously would have housed one family being turned into "HMOs".

Mira28 · 20/02/2023 20:43

Volver · 20/02/2023 17:31

@Mycatsgoldtooth Full disclosure
I’m an immigrant, by chance rather than design, as I married a Brit 31 years ago. Never intended to stay in GB, but stay I did because at the time I was happy and it made sense and for 40 years I did and that’s nearly all my working life.

We have grown up British born kids.
I’m writing from my house in Spain.
I’m a High Rate tax payer and have never taken a penny from the state, even though I’m many years shy of the shabby Estate pension age I already qualify with 38 years+ NI contributions. I even have private health care so when I’m back in GB in my own place I don’t need to rely on GP surgeries.
I feel most sorry for my kids who live there and I’m trying to persuade them to up sticks even though it’s their home country and their choice as young adults. I just don’t see a future for them there until people stop being so bloody stupid, and start voting responsibly instead of swallowing right wing propaganda.

I got so FED UP with the sheer audacity of brexiteers assuming I’m some kind of scrounger by virtue of my faint foreign accent that I have basically Given Up on GB. My heart broke when I realised half the population I came across in daily life had this low opinion of anyone foreign born.
I don’t have to put up with that shite so now the Spanish economy benefits from my taxes.

My solution would be go cap in hand to the EU and restore free trade and FOM but unfortunately on vastly less advantageous terms (like Norway) and get the economy moving again and highly skilled Europeans moving again to help with cultural cohesion and yes, give young Brits opportunities to study and work in Europe too.
Impose controls just like the rest of Europe has always done: The EU was never a “free for all” so people can look for a job but need to pay for healthcare the first year at least till they’re employed and contributing with their NI/taxes. No free social housing to anyone not working and contributing.

GB was really raking it in in prestige and economic growth as part of the EU.
Vote for a more socially conscious Govt that will invest in public services.

I do hope people realise Brexit was such a crazy foolish thing that at least restoring free trade will reverse the worst damage yet to come.
The immigration numbers from Europe would balance themselves quite fast as it’s the law of supply and demand. When there’s no work a lot of the young people simply leave.
Hell, even the long term ones with British passports like me have, so there’s nothing to fear.

  1. The vast majority of EU workers are young so not a strain on public services
  2. Culturally similar so less problems with language and integration into society
  3. They contribute more than they take out
  4. The ones that stay and settle for good will make a lasting contribution to society
  5. There’s a shortage of workers in GB: unless you force all the working age natives (and they number millions) to get off their arses and work you need the workforce to tend to the old, the sick, to contribute to Science, and yes to even pick crops from the fields…

The Asylum/Refugees question is separate and should be comprehensively addressed with offering safe routes to claim in collaboration with the UN and Europe.

As a fellow EU immigrant in the UK I understand how you feel about the Brexit vote. At the same time, living where I currently live I can also understand those who wanted more control over immigration, including immigration from the EU.
Our town is very similar to how @Mycatsgoldtooth described the area where she lives - „lots of multiple occupancy housing, lots of crime and antisocial behaviour caused by the people living here who have arrived in the last five years“.
Sadly, all of this also applies to our town - unlike your statement about EU workers being culturally similar to the British and therefore having less problems with language and integration into the society. I‘m not saying your statement is generally untrue, I‘ve encountered plenty of people like that myself.
But it’s just not the case in our town - there are many EU immigrants here who seem to be living in a parallel world - many don‘t speak English, large groups of men gathering on street corners and in the town centre, blocking the pavements, and glaring if you want to pass, teenagers harassing passers-by, loads of shoplifting (I’m sure Brits shoplift to, but I know several business owners and they all have had issues with the „newcomers“ in the last five years or so).

Kabalagala · 20/02/2023 19:45

Florenz · 20/02/2023 19:33

Yes but the design includes high immigration which keeps house prices high. Where do you think all the immigrants who have come here in the last 20 years are living? And who would be living in those houses if there hadn't been such high immigration?

I'm not of the opinion that migration has anything to do with house prices. House prices have been propped up for decades, without migrants we'd just have built even fewer houses with the same outcome.

Valeriekat · 20/02/2023 19:44

PutYourShoesOnWereLate · 15/10/2022 22:50

If we are going to provide care then we need to encourage immigration. Our population is ageing and cannot care for itself.

So people come here with the sole intention of caring for our frail and elderly and earning minimum wage? Is that what you think?

That is racist and patronizing and so far isn't happening.

Florenz · 20/02/2023 19:33

Kabalagala · 20/02/2023 19:02

Thats not true though. The government keeps house prices high by design. They don't want cheaper housing.

Yes but the design includes high immigration which keeps house prices high. Where do you think all the immigrants who have come here in the last 20 years are living? And who would be living in those houses if there hadn't been such high immigration?

TreadLight · 20/02/2023 19:20

happyfishcoco · 15/10/2022 23:26

ask Boris Johnson where is the extra £350 million a week to spend on the NHS?

I thought I'd check this, just for laughs. The last year that Britain was in the EU was 2019/20, health spending in England was £137.4 billion.

2022/23 was forecast at £152.6 billion.

This is about £292 million a week, so not a million miles away from the £350 million Brexit dividend promised!

www.kingsfund.org.uk/projects/nhs-in-a-nutshell/nhs-budget

Volver · 20/02/2023 19:04

@MarshaBradyo yes I lived in an area that voted 75% Leave.

MarshaBradyo · 20/02/2023 19:03

I’m dual national. I can’t say it crossed my mind to leave due to Brexit. Maybe where you live has an impact. It’s diverse here and hasn’t changed from that.

Kabalagala · 20/02/2023 19:02

Florenz · 20/02/2023 18:56

Less immigration would mean less demand for housing which would make houses cheaper, not more expensive.

Thats not true though. The government keeps house prices high by design. They don't want cheaper housing.

Volver · 20/02/2023 19:01

@Mycatsgoldtooth i haven’t retired yet.
As far as I see it if people will hold fascist views on immigrants a lot of those who were making a useful contribution will not put up with it and leave.
I’m not alone, hundreds of thousands did too after seeing how they were viewed.

And I AM invested in GB. My kids live and work there: it’s their home country, they have British surnames, they grew up there and their father is as you like to put it “native born”. I want them to stay in their homeland IF they have a future. By your own admission there doesn’t seem to be a future for British people.

Honestly you’re blaming the wrong people for the mess a once great, thriving, inclusive country is in.

Florenz · 20/02/2023 18:56

Less immigration would mean less demand for housing which would make houses cheaper, not more expensive.

Lentilweaver · 20/02/2023 18:54

Darkstar4855 · 20/02/2023 18:37

Wow. I’m an A&E doctor. Three of us out of twenty are white British. Without immigration this country would be fucked. Of course it’s racist.

But those are 'good immigrants'. With skills. Not bus drivers or care workers or Deliveroo workers. And they have 'assimilated'.

Darkstar4855 · 20/02/2023 18:37

Wow. I’m an A&E doctor. Three of us out of twenty are white British. Without immigration this country would be fucked. Of course it’s racist.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 20/02/2023 18:36

@Volver but as you said you are a high rate tax payer who has left the U.K to retire early abroad. Quite elite compared to most people on low wages and no chance of a life in the sun. You don’t live here, you’re not invested in the future here. Like it or not you don’t really get a say as you’re not living daily with the effects of mass immigration and you encourage your kids to leave too. My point was that I don’t have that option, as I am not duel nationality so have a necessary investment in this country as it’s the only home I have. Not that I’m a ‘true Brit’. But, I am a native English person and I do think that gives me a right to care about this country more then someone who does not reside here and encourages their offspring to leave. Rat from a sinking ship comes to mind…

woodhill · 20/02/2023 18:29

lazycats · 20/02/2023 08:27

If you want low immigration then you need to support schemes that result in much cheaper housing so british born citizens can actually start families and support the woefully ageing population. If you don't care about that and enjoy seeing your house go up in price exponentially then well done: you're part of the problem you complain about.

Yes why haven't we done this in the first place

woodhill · 20/02/2023 18:28

Overthinkingnotdrinking · 20/02/2023 09:19

Yes do these mythical Peter Pan immigrants never get old or are they expected to bugger off once they have stopped being useful and need care themselves? These are people that will need housing, need education, health care and will end up needing pensions too. All these things cost a great deal and unless they are making over 38k a year they will be costing the public purse more then they will be contributing in tax.

Yes this is my argument

Can't we be honest and say that many of them need financial support

Volver · 20/02/2023 18:25

@Mycatsgoldtooth Elite person?!!
you’re having a laugh aren’t you.

The ONLY reason I left GB was Brexit, do you think someone who’s built their whole life for 40 years in a country ups sticks lightly?
I’ve worked hard all my life and thought my contribution was valued till I heard the xenophobic BS, till I started seeing how people behaved differently when they heard a foreign accent, when I heard of the xenophobic attacks on Europeans and it literally Broke my Heart.
The place I called Home viewed people like me as Aliens, scroungers.

That’s the only reason I left. Maybe I would have retired to Spain later in life, after stopping work like many of your compatriots do, but my decision was made as I didn’t want to live my life being viewed suspiciously by random strangers.

A little bit of my heart is always in GB, as my husband’s dear family are there, my children and many many good friends who don’t share the appalling views I’ve read here on Immigration that lack all basis on FACTS.

And I am also a (dual) British National though I do realise that to some native born like you I will never be a “true Brit”.
Thank you again for proving my point.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 20/02/2023 18:08

@Lentilweaver seejng my brother and sil jump through hoops, pay 7k in solicitors fees and other things for her to move here really opened my eyes to the playing of the system that goes on and the amount of people coming into the country with no checks, no ability to support themselves etc. Seems a joke that some people are vetted and some people not.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 20/02/2023 18:04

@Volver ah you’re an elite person with lots of money that does not live in the U.K who is a bit put out that the country voted brexit and you took it personally. All the while I’m in a poor area, on a street with lots of multiple occupancy housing, lots of crime and antisocial behaviour caused by the people living here who have arrived in the last five years. I work with deprived communities with a budget that now has to stretch to encompass the massive immigration into my area in the last five years.

You put no figure but it seems infinity immigrants is ok but.. doesn’t really effect you does it. You can move to Spain, I’m English so if this country suffers then it’s my life and my children’s that are worse off. You can just pay for yours to come to live with you out of the chaos. Classic, none English people, with no investment in our way of life or future thinking they have more rights to say who lives in this country then native born people.

Lentilweaver · 20/02/2023 18:01

I think some posters are confusing immigrants with refugees/ asylum. I can tell you that the first is very difficult and expensive.

Volver · 20/02/2023 17:58

@Xenia I understand
I do remember GB in the 80’s.

Its a problem with population numbers globally. Stop having babies??

According to last years Census for England and Wales in the last 10 years the population grew from 51million to 59 million (in round numbers) and accounting for deaths most of that population growth is births at over 6 million.
2 million is the net immigration over 10 years (2011 to 2021) so not sure where the 1 million in the last year you quote comes from but look:

If you don’t want immigration you’ll soon end up with a large portion of the population too old and not enough young working so if that’s the concern: limit all immigration and see how it goes??
I don’t know where the money will come from to support the ageing population but it’ll be an interesting experiment.

MarshaBradyo · 20/02/2023 17:57

Is the only direction to get more populous? Because how do people square that with climate change issues.

I think we’re in for a rough time and ideas around border control may well shift further as a result

DelphiniumBlue123 · 20/02/2023 17:56

equalstime · 15/10/2022 22:31

People that moan about migrants coming to this county - taking our jobs - taking our houses - draining the medical system - not settling in the first country they reach for asylum- they're racist right?

There will always be an element of migration and when you take account of UK born people that leave and non Uk people that enter our country, the net figure is no doubt reasonable. They are often willing to work and contribute to our society and economy - so why the hostility?

Why not accept as a country that we have en element of migration and embrace that, if not because your views are racist?

Well yes.

Volver · 20/02/2023 17:49

I meant the millions of working age Brits currently not working and living off benefits, to get off their arses if you don’t want further immigration.
Apologies for not making that clearer.