Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are people that want zero immigration racist?

682 replies

equalstime · 15/10/2022 22:31

People that moan about migrants coming to this county - taking our jobs - taking our houses - draining the medical system - not settling in the first country they reach for asylum- they're racist right?

There will always be an element of migration and when you take account of UK born people that leave and non Uk people that enter our country, the net figure is no doubt reasonable. They are often willing to work and contribute to our society and economy - so why the hostility?

Why not accept as a country that we have en element of migration and embrace that, if not because your views are racist?

OP posts:
bloodyplanes · 16/10/2022 17:19

IndigoC · 16/10/2022 00:42

This country needs young working people. It needs immigrants. There are 70,000+ vacancies for nurses right now that can’t be filled.

Or we could stop expecting nurses to pay for their training and qualify thousands of pounds in debt. We could also not treat them like shit and pay them awfully when they do qualify! We could also sort out the massive bullying culture within the NHS 🤷‍♀️

Dontevenstart · 16/10/2022 17:18

No, not all people who want zero
immigration are racists.
However, all racists seemingly want zero immigration.
To want one is to associate with the other, and will be used, by those with whom you may not wish to be associated, to make a point with which you may not agree.

In short, be careful with whom you’re agreeing. And zero immigration is bullshit.

VladmirsPoutine · 16/10/2022 17:15

I thought we were all so proud of the British Empire? This is a natural consequence of conquering half the world. Or is anyone a bit unhappy about all these immigrants?

FreddyHG · 16/10/2022 17:14

Gwenhwyfar · 16/10/2022 13:57

"Is importing young people "keeping the country young"? How long can it work? Everyone ages......."

Yes, but people from more traditional countries have more children (at least for a generation or two in the new country) so there will also be more young people.

Sounds like a Ponzi scheme to me requiring ever expanding population.

JocelynBurnell · 16/10/2022 17:13

Those who want zero immigration rarely want to live with the consequences of zero immigration:

  • Reduced state pensions and benefits - due to aging demographics and declining workforce
  • Reduced health service - fewer healthcare professionals available, reduced funding due to contracting economy
  • Significantly reduced care facilities - few care workers available, families forced to look after elderly relatives, carer's allowance significantly reduced
SerendipityJane · 16/10/2022 17:13

Nation of immigrants argue about immigration. It's so fucking hilarious.

Stars71 · 16/10/2022 17:11

VladmirsPoutine · 16/10/2022 16:38

It's a fantasy. All Brexit will do is to swap immigration from countries culturally similar and with reasonably similar economics to those from countries which are further away, with very different ideas about social attitudes.

It'd be much easier for you to say you prefer white people to come over instead of Black and Brown. You're not alone in this thinking - racism in the UK is a bit like fish in the sea - everywhere Smile

Race baiting. It would be much easier for you to say you love it. A bit like Diane Abbott.

Stars71 · 16/10/2022 17:06

bloodyplanes · 16/10/2022 12:31

@Stars71 I completely agree! The irony is that they literally can't see that its attitudes like theirs that got Labour absolutely trounced in the last election!

Absolutely 👍

MarshaBradyo · 16/10/2022 16:55

WatchoRulo · 16/10/2022 16:38

Hilarious, as if the EU is some kind of multicultural paradise full of like-minded people. You have the supreme irony of criticising Brexit on the basis it will lead to an influx of brown people with cultures you don't like.

It is a bizarre stance I agree

WatchoRulo · 16/10/2022 16:46

VoiceOfCommonSense · 16/10/2022 16:02

100% a points system like we have in Australia should be implemented in the UK. It lets you set which skilled workers you want. We also turn back any boats with illegals. Anyone who arrives by boat illegally will never be allowed to permanently settle in Australia. This has been very effective against people smugglers.

Turning back boats isn't so easy for us as there's no international waters between us and France. It's also almost certainly against international law.

Abhannmor · 16/10/2022 16:46

People often say Britain is a tiny island bursting at the seams that can't feed itself. But it's surprising how empty it is outside the conurbations.

Holland is more densely populated and much smaller. Yet I often see Dutch grown fruit and veg here in Ireland. I imagine the same is true of the UK. Some countries are better organised I reckon.

drpet49 · 16/10/2022 16:40

Cw112 · 15/10/2022 22:47

Let's be honest most people who complain about immigration tend to be complaining based on the country of origin and the colour of the person's skin. We never really hear people complaining of an American or a German coming and taking jobs do we? So I do think it's fundamentally racist at least in part.

I agree with this

WatchoRulo · 16/10/2022 16:38

LexMitior · 16/10/2022 16:32

It's a fantasy. All Brexit will do is to swap immigration from countries culturally similar and with reasonably similar economics to those from countries which are further away, with very different ideas about social attitudes.

Moronic. I don't think the UK should be opening its doors to competition for the world that is illiberal and hasn't got the slightest idea about us. We had enough of that in 1960s and 70s.

Hilarious, as if the EU is some kind of multicultural paradise full of like-minded people. You have the supreme irony of criticising Brexit on the basis it will lead to an influx of brown people with cultures you don't like.

VladmirsPoutine · 16/10/2022 16:38

It's a fantasy. All Brexit will do is to swap immigration from countries culturally similar and with reasonably similar economics to those from countries which are further away, with very different ideas about social attitudes.

It'd be much easier for you to say you prefer white people to come over instead of Black and Brown. You're not alone in this thinking - racism in the UK is a bit like fish in the sea - everywhere Smile

WatchoRulo · 16/10/2022 16:32

Gwenhwyfar · 16/10/2022 13:57

"Is importing young people "keeping the country young"? How long can it work? Everyone ages......."

Yes, but people from more traditional countries have more children (at least for a generation or two in the new country) so there will also be more young people.

So you admit it's a ponzi scheme, but like most Ponzi schemes, it will be a while before it collapses.

LexMitior · 16/10/2022 16:32

It's a fantasy. All Brexit will do is to swap immigration from countries culturally similar and with reasonably similar economics to those from countries which are further away, with very different ideas about social attitudes.

Moronic. I don't think the UK should be opening its doors to competition for the world that is illiberal and hasn't got the slightest idea about us. We had enough of that in 1960s and 70s.

WatchoRulo · 16/10/2022 16:31

IndigoC · 16/10/2022 00:42

This country needs young working people. It needs immigrants. There are 70,000+ vacancies for nurses right now that can’t be filled.

What do we do with these young immigrants when they get old?

Quisquam · 16/10/2022 16:03

Anyone who wants 0 migration is inherently racist imo.

How do you work that out? This is a very densely populated country. We have among the least wildlife of countries in the world. We despair whenever, we see green countryside being built on - all the insects and animals, that lived there, have lost their homes. Where are they supposed to go, when their habitat is shrinking all the time? Even our national parks are not wilderness - they are managed land for the benefit of agriculture, the game lobby, the forestry commission (all those rows of conifers)….

I don’t see why wanting to leave green belt to give wildlife a home, makes me racist? We firmly believe mankind will destroy itself by 2040 through climate change and loss of biodiversity - making immigration an irrelevance!

VoiceOfCommonSense · 16/10/2022 16:02

MarshaBradyo · 16/10/2022 08:28

As someone who grew up with it it became normal to me there. I still strongly wanted remain but since that is now not an option I now think of the Aus point system as an example of how it could work.

100% a points system like we have in Australia should be implemented in the UK. It lets you set which skilled workers you want. We also turn back any boats with illegals. Anyone who arrives by boat illegally will never be allowed to permanently settle in Australia. This has been very effective against people smugglers.

beastlyslumber · 16/10/2022 15:38

So do you want to replace British people with immigrants then? I think it would be sad if Britain became a place where there was no native culture or language. I guess it would be interesting, too. But how would it work? Can a nation really function without some kind of cohesive national identity?

Goatling · 16/10/2022 15:28

Yes, but people from more traditional countries have more children (at least for a generation or two in the new country) so there will also be more young people until they become old people.

Gwenhwyfar · 16/10/2022 13:57

"Is importing young people "keeping the country young"? How long can it work? Everyone ages......."

Yes, but people from more traditional countries have more children (at least for a generation or two in the new country) so there will also be more young people.

bloodyplanes · 16/10/2022 13:45

Kabalagala · 16/10/2022 13:29

Anyone who wants 0 migration is inherently racist imo.
Most people have no real clue what the immigration system is really like. No idea how difficult it is to navigate, no idea the complex reasons people choose to come here.
We can't complain about asylum seekers on one hand, while opening our homes for Ukrainian refugees. What is that if not racism? What is so different about Ukraine that they get a whole new migration pathway created for them? Politics and racism.
And anyone moaning about building and overpopulation, I hope you have no children and have no extra bedrooms. Otherwise shut up

Again absolute rubbish! The ukrainians are genuine asylum seekers who have every intention of going home as soon as they can! Many Many of the " asylum seekers" who turn up on boats on the south coast are in fact economic migrants! People are sick of it, and no matter what " the left " say people are entitled to be concerned when the demographic of their area has become unrecognisable within a decade, when they can't get their children into their local school because its oversubscribed, when the doctors/ hospitals are struggling ( admittedly not just because of population increase). I live within an area of high immigration and it's completely unrecognisable from 10 years ago. Its absolutely nothing to do with colour either its to do with a clash of culture, lifestyle, expectations etc.

WatchoRulo · 16/10/2022 13:37

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Is importing young people "keeping the country young"? How long can it work? Everyone ages.......

Kabalagala · 16/10/2022 13:29

Anyone who wants 0 migration is inherently racist imo.
Most people have no real clue what the immigration system is really like. No idea how difficult it is to navigate, no idea the complex reasons people choose to come here.
We can't complain about asylum seekers on one hand, while opening our homes for Ukrainian refugees. What is that if not racism? What is so different about Ukraine that they get a whole new migration pathway created for them? Politics and racism.
And anyone moaning about building and overpopulation, I hope you have no children and have no extra bedrooms. Otherwise shut up