Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are people that want zero immigration racist?

682 replies

equalstime · 15/10/2022 22:31

People that moan about migrants coming to this county - taking our jobs - taking our houses - draining the medical system - not settling in the first country they reach for asylum- they're racist right?

There will always be an element of migration and when you take account of UK born people that leave and non Uk people that enter our country, the net figure is no doubt reasonable. They are often willing to work and contribute to our society and economy - so why the hostility?

Why not accept as a country that we have en element of migration and embrace that, if not because your views are racist?

OP posts:
Sometimeswinning · 16/10/2022 20:37

Kendodd · 16/10/2022 19:55

If you want to get angry because you can't get a GP appointment, I would suggest you get angry with the government who have just cut medical school places by 25%.
Or you cut just continue blame immigrants, who just happen to also make up , what was it, 20% of our doctors?

www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-62594141

Or just blame the mass building of houses and no extra doctors surgery's, schools, leisure areas. That's what we should be asking for. It's not racist. It's just people are seeing a decline in services.

orbitalcrisis · 16/10/2022 20:17

My immigrant mother has gone off on anti-immigrant rants to me. I put it down to the Daily Mail, selfishness and not being very clever.

marmaladepop · 16/10/2022 20:03

Suetwo · 15/10/2022 23:20

Many people do want to preserve a sense of racial and cultural identity. However, I think what really worries them is overcrowding. This country is unbearably crowded - certainly where I live. The roads are a nightmare, and horrible new build rabbit hutches keep being jammed onto every available scrap of land.

Another thing that really worries people (and they are right to be worried) is who we let in. If you let in an Indian surgeon or a Canadian professor, they are likely to be intelligent, civilized people who will enrich your country. If you let in a violent pimp, or a drug dealer, they are going to make your country worse. It's as simple as 1+1. The left seem to think every immigrant at Calais is a poor frightened refugee. I'm sure some of them are. I don't doubt that there ARE genuine refugees. I'm also sure some are not. The vast majority of people who cross the channel are young men. Where are their wives and children and parents? Do they have any? Have they abandoned them? These undocumented migrants are an unknown quantity. We have no idea who they are or why they left their country of origin. I'm sure human rights groups teach them what to say to get through the asylum system, but the real reason they left may be more sinister. Maybe they are wanted for rape in their home country and that is why they left. Or maybe they are criminals who see the UK as easy pickings.

Let me add that I'm aware WE can make awful immigrants. I have a lot of sympathy for Spanish people who resent Brits moving to Spanish coastal towns, getting drunk, urinating in the streets, not bothering to learn the language, etc.

This. Well articulated.

Kendodd · 16/10/2022 19:55

If you want to get angry because you can't get a GP appointment, I would suggest you get angry with the government who have just cut medical school places by 25%.
Or you cut just continue blame immigrants, who just happen to also make up , what was it, 20% of our doctors?

www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-62594141

PetraBP · 16/10/2022 19:54

No, they’re not necessarily racist if their concern is about that he numbers of people using finite resources such as housing, hospitals, healthcare etc.

What they are is ignorant of economics.

The settled populations are getting older and there’s a labour shortage so we need young immigrants to come and fill the jobs and pay the taxes.

WatchoRulo · 16/10/2022 19:48

LexMitior · 16/10/2022 19:24

I don't say that - and of course, I was careful to say Western Europe.

However, whatever antediluvian attitudes some Eastern Europeans may have brought after joining the EU and then brought to the UK, that was temporary, was it not? They retained their nationalities and returned in most cases. Why? Because that was the legal agreement in place. That has been the story after Brexit. They have left.

My point was that this was not what happened for migration in the 1960s and 1970s. We are doing the same now. We will offer migration routes to countries with economic differences and social attitudes which are very different. Is that a good idea?

What you want to ask yourself is why no Tory government, despite saying they will, actually changes it.

The truth is they are fine with it. If a government doesn't bother changing it for 12 years then it is because it suits them: expect migration up, not down.

You seem to be making a lot of assumptions -

"They have left." Is that true? I'd need to see the details on that to be sure.

I agree with your analysis of Tory Governments' attitudes - it's yet another thing on which they face both ways - they maintain they wish to reduce immigration and even set targets (which they never hit), whilst at the same time taking no effective action at all.

Wisper10 · 16/10/2022 19:37

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

So what do we do with these old white people? Do we need a cull based on colour (seemingly only one though) and age? We have the people we need, the problem is that they all work in McDonalds with Media Studies, Performing Arts type degrees because the country looks down on people who do manual type jobs.

LexMitior · 16/10/2022 19:24

I don't say that - and of course, I was careful to say Western Europe.

However, whatever antediluvian attitudes some Eastern Europeans may have brought after joining the EU and then brought to the UK, that was temporary, was it not? They retained their nationalities and returned in most cases. Why? Because that was the legal agreement in place. That has been the story after Brexit. They have left.

My point was that this was not what happened for migration in the 1960s and 1970s. We are doing the same now. We will offer migration routes to countries with economic differences and social attitudes which are very different. Is that a good idea?

What you want to ask yourself is why no Tory government, despite saying they will, actually changes it.

The truth is they are fine with it. If a government doesn't bother changing it for 12 years then it is because it suits them: expect migration up, not down.

WatchoRulo · 16/10/2022 19:08

LexMitior · 16/10/2022 18:50

. In the 1960s and 1970s, the country underwent vast social change. The death penalty was scrapped. The university system was opened up. Abortion was legalized and homosexual men were finally given some dignity. Later on, women secured rights for equal pay. The Church of England crumbled as a source of authority. Corporal punishment ended in schools.

All of that in my view was a very good thing. It meant ordinary people could, with support of the state, build better lives for their children. They did not have to be very rich. They had good healthcare and resources. They did not have to cringe in front of priests or adhere to Christian morality . And this process was to a greater or lesser extent across Western Europe.

At the same time, we also had migration from countries where religion still had great power, women were considered second class citizens, homosexuality met with the death penalty , and with social attitudes that the UK had left behind. I think there was some sort of belief that people would just fit in and get those attitudes. There has been mixed success on that.

Now the UK will have a different sort of migration. The two biggest nationalities entering the UK now are Indian and China. What attitudes do they bring?

I think you are conveniently ignoring the social and religious norms of some of the Eastern European nations who formed significant parts of the large scale immigration from the EU. If your argument is that we shouldn't import people from countries where, for example same-sex marriage is forbidden by the constitution and confirmed by referendum, then that would apply to places where significant numbers of EU citizens who came here originated - see also attitudes to abortion. You seem to be saying all europeans share the same liberal views which is plainly not the case.

MintyFreshOne · 16/10/2022 19:04

Also, everyone is an immigrant, by descent. A world with no boundaries should be the dream. Unite, not divide

You need a world with boundaries. Instead of endlessly fighting over everything from economic resources to women’s rights, we instead decide to allow countries to do pretty much as they please within their own borders. It is a more peaceful world this way.

The world is actually far more diverse than you think—and someone who thinks borders should disappear really has not experienced enough of it

Domino20 · 16/10/2022 18:58

halfsiesonapotnoodle · 15/10/2022 22:37

I doubt it's anything to do with actual race but more to do with the fact we are a tiny island, whose population has grown massively since the 50s and is actually causing many services to be at breaking point. We have too many people.

No, it's government failure to invest in infrastructure for a growing population that has these negative outcomes, not migration. Migrants are usually economically more active than the home population and migration provides a net financial benefit to the UK.
This is the economic reality, it's not migrants fault that the government haven't invested the £ they generated into services. Tbh, your reasoning is often used by racists, has no basis in fact and I'm pretty fed up of hearing it. Migration is a fundamental human impulse and the basis of the story of humankind.

LexMitior · 16/10/2022 18:50

. In the 1960s and 1970s, the country underwent vast social change. The death penalty was scrapped. The university system was opened up. Abortion was legalized and homosexual men were finally given some dignity. Later on, women secured rights for equal pay. The Church of England crumbled as a source of authority. Corporal punishment ended in schools.

All of that in my view was a very good thing. It meant ordinary people could, with support of the state, build better lives for their children. They did not have to be very rich. They had good healthcare and resources. They did not have to cringe in front of priests or adhere to Christian morality . And this process was to a greater or lesser extent across Western Europe.

At the same time, we also had migration from countries where religion still had great power, women were considered second class citizens, homosexuality met with the death penalty , and with social attitudes that the UK had left behind. I think there was some sort of belief that people would just fit in and get those attitudes. There has been mixed success on that.

Now the UK will have a different sort of migration. The two biggest nationalities entering the UK now are Indian and China. What attitudes do they bring?

Kendodd · 16/10/2022 18:17

Lemonlady22 · 16/10/2022 18:07

Too many old white people, are you for real ? As an over 60 person with 40 years working in healthcare, I think your comment is ageist. I’ve given plenty to this country and it will soon be time for me to take back a little of what I’ve paid in tax & NI during that time. Stupid comment!

Actually aging populations is a really serious issue for many countries across the world, it needs to be talked about and planned for. The poster above wasn't the most tactful, but it named the challenge. I think immigration alone won't be enough, I think some sort of automation to care for people needs developing as well.

OneTC · 16/10/2022 18:11

In general yes, people opposed to immigration are normally racist.

Including lots of people who say that they definitely aren't racist.

Lemonlady22 · 16/10/2022 18:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Too many old white people, are you for real ? As an over 60 person with 40 years working in healthcare, I think your comment is ageist. I’ve given plenty to this country and it will soon be time for me to take back a little of what I’ve paid in tax & NI during that time. Stupid comment!

WatchoRulo · 16/10/2022 17:57

the campaign would have been laughable if it wasn't so goddam depressing how many people bought unreliable statistics and financial estimations.
Agreed, on both sides.

wordler · 16/10/2022 17:45

Race plays a huge part in conversations about immigration - it's not just the UK it happens in most white majority countries. I get the 'we don't mean you' comments if I remind people in the USA complaining about immigrants that I am one.

But it's such a complex issue 'immigrants' is too broad a term for the reason people come and the reason we need them to come.

  • filling key employment needs - this is always changing and needs good government oversight and policies to keep a good balance and get the right people to the right areas at the right time
  • economic migrants - people with skills who want to come to the UK for their own economic reasons - they overlap with the category above, and there's room for people with specialist skill and generalist skill to contribute and make life better for the country as well as themselves
  • family reunification - UK citizens who marry someone from another country - are zero immigration advocates saying you can never fall in love with a non British person and have them come and live with you? We are already much more restricted on how other family members can come to the UK compared to other countries who have more pathways for sibilings etc
  • refugees/asylum seekers - we have global responsibilities to help in times of crisis, and humanitarian responsibilies to help people in need. This is the category which I think causes the most problems in terms of public perception. And that's possibly because it's been so badly managed by governments. But also the nature of a crisis means big visible groups of people in need - whereas we don't notice the quiet entry of the economic migrants.
Cw112 · 16/10/2022 17:45

FreddyHG · 16/10/2022 08:23

Did you miss the Brexit campaign where white immigration was a big issue? For me we are a tiny island which can't feed or energy resource itself that is becoming increasingly overcrowded with failing infrastructure. So I would argue against immigration and steps to reduce the birth rate.

No I didn't miss the brexit campaign- as a community worker my job is directly under threat as a result of the brexit campaign and most charities in my sector are now running into reserves which will undoubtedly have knock on impact on housing/ health and education provision. But big thanks to the powers that be for "protecting" my job from the immigrants.... the campaign would have been laughable if it wasn't so goddam depressing how many people bought unreliable statistics and financial estimations.

IcedPurple · 16/10/2022 17:37

HappyHappyHermit · 16/10/2022 06:53

In fact I'm going to further my previous post. Why do we still have countries? Surely by now we should be mature enough to understand we are all born on the same planet, regardless of which piece of land we all share the Earth and are equally responsible for it. Land borders and countries are established based on Levens from long ago, in reality they have little relevance to now. One world with properly shared resources would surely be better for all than how hings are now. I realise, by the way, that this would never happen for a great number of reasons.

The nation state is the entity which guarantees rule of law, governance, taxation, policing and the infrastructure which makes civilised life possible. The reason so many flee their own countries to live in more prosperous Western nations is precisely because their own states have failed and other states offer them a better life. That's evidence right there that countries matter.

The nation state is not without its flaws, but can you think of a better way to ensure good governance and management of resources?

JocelynBurnell · 16/10/2022 17:35

FreddyHG · 16/10/2022 17:26

And all wokies like immigration. Perhaps those mumsnetters concerned about modern wokeness around be kind and tw need to look at who they associate with.

Those who demand a zero-immigration policy can be very adept at name-calling.

Logical, coherent policies are an entirely different matter.

Dontevenstart · 16/10/2022 17:33

FreddyHG · 16/10/2022 17:26

And all wokies like immigration. Perhaps those mumsnetters concerned about modern wokeness around be kind and tw need to look at who they associate with.

What is a wokie? Is it a misspelled Star Wars character?

Also, everyone is an immigrant, by descent. A world with no boundaries should be the dream. Unite, not divide.

FreddyHG · 16/10/2022 17:27

SerendipityJane · 16/10/2022 17:23

Bonk for Britain !

Or just not increase population at all. Every mouth uses resources. Currently we aren't food or energy self sufficient ourselves.

FreddyHG · 16/10/2022 17:26

Dontevenstart · 16/10/2022 17:18

No, not all people who want zero
immigration are racists.
However, all racists seemingly want zero immigration.
To want one is to associate with the other, and will be used, by those with whom you may not wish to be associated, to make a point with which you may not agree.

In short, be careful with whom you’re agreeing. And zero immigration is bullshit.

And all wokies like immigration. Perhaps those mumsnetters concerned about modern wokeness around be kind and tw need to look at who they associate with.

SerendipityJane · 16/10/2022 17:23

FreddyHG · 16/10/2022 17:23

It's still not sustainable to have an exponentially increasing population. We need to make tough decisions and live sustainably that means not increasing our population through immigration.

Bonk for Britain !

FreddyHG · 16/10/2022 17:23

It's still not sustainable to have an exponentially increasing population. We need to make tough decisions and live sustainably that means not increasing our population through immigration.