Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are people that want zero immigration racist?

682 replies

equalstime · 15/10/2022 22:31

People that moan about migrants coming to this county - taking our jobs - taking our houses - draining the medical system - not settling in the first country they reach for asylum- they're racist right?

There will always be an element of migration and when you take account of UK born people that leave and non Uk people that enter our country, the net figure is no doubt reasonable. They are often willing to work and contribute to our society and economy - so why the hostility?

Why not accept as a country that we have en element of migration and embrace that, if not because your views are racist?

OP posts:
Qwertyfudge · 18/02/2023 07:43

Yes they are racist, the too many people argument doesn’t hold up. We don’t have enough working age people in this country to support the economy. We have too many old people, can’t imagine those screaming we’re full are going to start campaigning for a ship them out programme for the elderly. Maybe they could be sent to nice hotels with swimming pools in Rwanda?

EllieRosesMammy · 18/02/2023 07:35

Yeah they're racist. No one is "taking our jobs, taking our houses etc" all of these jobs and houses are open and available to British Nationals, but a lot of people in this country seem to think they're too good for certain jobs and houses, so they end up being filled by people who do actually want them.

OR the jobs that people are moaning about immigrants "stealing" are positions like doctors aka a position that you have to work really hard for, you can't just come over and steal 🤦‍♀️

ilikepinknblue · 18/02/2023 07:31

dreamingbohemian · 15/10/2022 22:52

Absolutely. I'm an American immigrant, I can't tell you how many times British people have expressed anti-immigrant views to me. I remind them I'm an immigrant, 'oh I don't mean you'

Americans could be preferred because they are known to come via proper channel and don't need accommodation provided by tax payer money.
Also, EU membership would have provided white workers, whereas Brexiters preferred Indians workers coming on visa, so how is skin colour important?

Mascia · 21/10/2022 15:36

Theroad · 15/10/2022 23:02

Only an idiot could expect zero migration. That's just completely unreasonable. However, I think it's quite natural and human to be concerned about mass migration. Humans are tribal creatures. I hate how anyone who voices concern about immigration is labelled a racist. I think that attitude actually creates division and racism as people are pushed to the margins et viola you end up with brexit.

I'm not British but I travelled over there for work for many years and was initially completely shocked by the levels of diversity you have there. In some of the areas I visited it appeared to be completely segregated by race. I wouldn't like that where I live. It's not good for social cohesion, erodes shared values and while I don't think it leads to more crime (?) I imagine it raises suspicions/hostilities which could lead to this. The numbers are too great for any sort of assimilation to be possible. I thought it was sad to see to be honest.

Fully agree with this. And I‘m an immigrant myself, currently living in the UK.

I used to see this issue as much more black-and-white, used to think that those who voted for Brexit did it because they disliked foreigners.

I now live in a place with high levels of diversity, but integration and social cohesion are definitely lacking.

Some people are openly complaining about it, but they are often called racist as a result. Others just quietly move away - while in principle supporting diversity, they don’t seem to appreciate the type we get around here.

It‘s a very complex issue, but there needs to be a discussion about it.

Seymour5 · 17/10/2022 16:38

And yet Senior Care workers can apply for jobs at less than £7 an hour. Occ code 6146
www.gov.uk/government/publications/skilled-worker-visa-shortage-occupations/skilled-worker-visa-shortage-occupations

MooseBreath · 17/10/2022 10:27

Seymour5 · 17/10/2022 08:33

The rules seem to say that if you secure a teaching job, at the lowest end of the national pay scales or above, then you could be eligible for a visa to come here. Similar for a care worker.

www.gov.uk/government/publications/teach-in-england-if-you-qualified-outside-the-uk/teach-in-england-if-you-qualified-outside-the-uk

Laughing at the thought of a care worker being offered a job before securing a visa with a salary of over £25,600/annum as a Health or Care worker. Same with a teacher from abroad being offered above the lowest band (QTS often doesn't transfer over, so a qualified teacher may have to go with Unqualified, therefore not meeting the lowest requirements) before securing a visa.

www.gov.uk/health-care-worker-visa/different-salary-requirements

Lykia · 17/10/2022 10:08

TightDiamondShoes · 17/10/2022 06:57

Lykia- you’re right - it’s VERY complex and I wish your post could be pinned.

I still shake my head at the Pakistani surgeons though. Doesn’t Pakistan need surgeons? See all the while we have (usually there left) saying immigration is wonderful/you’re gammon - or equivalent.

yet when you steal surgeons away from impoverished areas - who’s going to help that woman in rural Pakistan with a ruptured ovary?

“I’m alright Jack”

I want people to stop overlooking the fact we (the UK) are stealing medical staff from countries who will in turn suffer from this loss.

globalisation is complex.

I wholeheartedly agree with your post. We are stealing skilled staff from impoverished countries.

Those countries have trained them and probably paid for their training too and as soon as they're qualified they're off. Lured to the UK - where the streets are paved with gold.

However when they arrive they find it's a completely different story. Such as where am I going to live. No room at the inn re: the scarceness of rental property.

Seymour5 · 17/10/2022 08:33

MooseBreath · 17/10/2022 07:34

@Whippetlovely I understand that. I was under the impression though, that benefits could only be claimed for a small amount of time before the EU member had to leave the UK. I am not sure of this though, it is purely hearsay.

I am not from the EU. I have followed intense visa protocols and scrutiny to be able to live in the UK, like millions of other immigrants. My argument is that in a low wage economy like the UK, many of the jobs desperately needed (teachers, nurses, carers, etc.) are not paid highly enough to meet the financial threshold for immigrants wanting to come to the UK on a Work Visa.

The rules seem to say that if you secure a teaching job, at the lowest end of the national pay scales or above, then you could be eligible for a visa to come here. Similar for a care worker.

www.gov.uk/government/publications/teach-in-england-if-you-qualified-outside-the-uk/teach-in-england-if-you-qualified-outside-the-uk

Autumnisclose · 17/10/2022 08:32

I think many people are afraid to say what they think for fear of being accused of being racist. I also think most people in the UK welcome immigrants who add to society. I meet alot of immigrants through my work. Most are a benefit to to the UK and work hard and bring much needed skills. However there is also a significant proportion who sit with their hand out for years. Never working, never contributing or learning English, living off benefits. We need a more selective immigration system to prevent this. We also need to know who is coming into our country.

TomPinch · 17/10/2022 07:58

The 'it's too crowded' argument.

Fine- just spare a thought for the crowded, poor countries elsewhere getting the brunt of climate change due to fossil fuel burning by this rich countries like this one.

newsaint · 17/10/2022 07:52

A person is racist if they judge another persons worth based on the colour of their skin.

Their views on immigration do not really come into it.

The fact that the two issues are linked at all is down to left wing politics which - being intellectually vacuous - can offer nothing but defamatory accusations against those who disagree with them.

MooseBreath · 17/10/2022 07:34

@Whippetlovely I understand that. I was under the impression though, that benefits could only be claimed for a small amount of time before the EU member had to leave the UK. I am not sure of this though, it is purely hearsay.

I am not from the EU. I have followed intense visa protocols and scrutiny to be able to live in the UK, like millions of other immigrants. My argument is that in a low wage economy like the UK, many of the jobs desperately needed (teachers, nurses, carers, etc.) are not paid highly enough to meet the financial threshold for immigrants wanting to come to the UK on a Work Visa.

Galaktoboureko · 17/10/2022 07:30

But unless that rural village in Pakistan pays as well of they're going to come here.

TightDiamondShoes · 17/10/2022 06:57

Lykia- you’re right - it’s VERY complex and I wish your post could be pinned.

I still shake my head at the Pakistani surgeons though. Doesn’t Pakistan need surgeons? See all the while we have (usually there left) saying immigration is wonderful/you’re gammon - or equivalent.

yet when you steal surgeons away from impoverished areas - who’s going to help that woman in rural Pakistan with a ruptured ovary?

“I’m alright Jack”

I want people to stop overlooking the fact we (the UK) are stealing medical staff from countries who will in turn suffer from this loss.

globalisation is complex.

puddingandsun · 16/10/2022 23:05

What is this... The Tories are going down the polls and there's a desperate need to rekindle the immigration topic?
It's always a winner for them that one, isn't it.

Stars71 · 16/10/2022 23:05

Lemonlady22 · 16/10/2022 18:07

Too many old white people, are you for real ? As an over 60 person with 40 years working in healthcare, I think your comment is ageist. I’ve given plenty to this country and it will soon be time for me to take back a little of what I’ve paid in tax & NI during that time. Stupid comment!

Their comment is both ageist and racist. Quite disgusting, but as they are being derogatory towards white people, they have no shame. White people are now the battering ram.

Stars71 · 16/10/2022 22:52

OneTC · 16/10/2022 18:11

In general yes, people opposed to immigration are normally racist.

Including lots of people who say that they definitely aren't racist.

My goodness, what a well thought out post. Saying something and nothing, at the same time.

LexMitior · 16/10/2022 22:40

There's an interesting issue with diversity as it appears that more diverse countries, and the richer ones, have generally less happy populations.

So if you are a western nation, it looks like your population like a more homogeneous country than a diverse one.

The more diverse a country, the less social cohesion and the less wellbeing. This issue is not much discussed because economically, migration is pretty good for business and regulating wages. This is why absolutely nada has been done about the Tories. They like it, despite the dog whistle stuff about limiting it.

Galaktoboureko · 16/10/2022 22:36

We have the people we need, the problem is that they all work in McDonalds with Media Studies, Performing Arts type degrees because the country looks down on people who do manual type jobs.

Which is ironic when you consider that the average salary for a tradesman has been £10k higher than that of a graduate for the past decade (£45k vs £35k).

Florenz · 16/10/2022 22:03

Blair didn't miscalculate anything, He knew full well that far more people would come here than his "official figures" stated. He wanted it to happen, to, and I quote, "rub the rights noses in diversity".

Immigration should be restricted to the absolute highest skilled people, in very low numbers (double figures). There is absolutely no need for mass unskilled immigration. Let employers pay wages that British people will do the job for. You can't keep increasing the population ad infinitum, we are a small island and eventually there will be no more room. Increasing immigration is just kicking the can down the road for future generations to deal with.

TheHouseonHauntedHill · 16/10/2022 21:57

I don't recall immigration ever being such a toxic or hot issue prior to Blair's immigration policy when he /whoever massively miscalculated how many people would want to come here from Eastern Europe?

How it happened, i'e so suddenly and in such huge numbers caused many areas of our infrastructure unbelievably strain.

It's a shame because it tainted the whole discussion.
Proper controlled immigration benefits everyone including the migrants.

Lykia · 16/10/2022 21:48

Sorry for the typos
add
100%

To clarify I was/ am annoyed the govt. hasn't provided any housing help for the newly arrived social care/hideously workers. They desperately need homes for their families but they are very scarce on the ground. If the UK is going to invite workers here we need to have accommodation for them. It's a basic need.

Whippetlovely · 16/10/2022 21:43

@MooseBreath the thing is being in the EU meant anyone unskilled could come here and have a low paid job and top up with benefits. That meant millions of people came in a relatively short space of time.There will be many that had high skilled jobs that were needed but many more that were low skilled. That’s what a lot of people objected to. Many could come here take a low paid job and claim benefits after being here 5 minutes and not paying in. If you come from outside the EU you go through the correct channels of having a visa ect. That is the correct system and how you get in only the people needed. That’s what most countries do.

Lykia · 16/10/2022 21:43

Not all immigrants are equal. I am a dad of an immigrant and am not white. As a landlord I'm currently renting out a property to a married couple of newly arrived surgeons from Pakistan. I am 109% certain they did not arrive on a boat from Calais.

When advertising another vacant property I had over 75 applicants and many of them were newly arrived from Nigeria/Ghana working here in social care. I was really annoyed that the Govt. had invited them over here, I suspect filling the vacancies left by the E Europeans, however they were not informed about the difficulties in renting property in the SE. They had jobs but were sleeping on friends sofas as they couldn't find anywhere to live.

I am sure you agree the above mentioned are welcomed here with open arms.

Then there are the boat people from Calais, a lot from Albania, so not all brown as many people think.

Incidentally a friend of mine went to help out at a refugee camp in Greece a few years ago when war in Syria broke out. She was surprised to find that it was mainly Moroccans there and not Syrians. She wanted to help fleeing Syrians but instead was helping Moroccan men.

Then there are people from the EU, ex tenants of mine from Poland and Romania worked their butts off and took advantage of every job opportunity available and have gone on the buy their own homes in London outskirts. Good on them I say.

And then there are the Roma families who live near me and drink alcohol on the bench in the streets during the day and don't appear to work.

Immigration is very complex. I'm all for people coming here to take advantage of the opportunities that their home country can't give them. But as for the ones who come and milk it just for benefits. Well... however would I do the same if I were them?

Btw I also volunteer with Ukrainian refugees helping them with their English. I see a lot of immigration in my day to day life. Most of it positive.

Goatling · 16/10/2022 21:31

So it's just old WHITE people that are a burden? Better kill me then.