Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are people that want zero immigration racist?

682 replies

equalstime · 15/10/2022 22:31

People that moan about migrants coming to this county - taking our jobs - taking our houses - draining the medical system - not settling in the first country they reach for asylum- they're racist right?

There will always be an element of migration and when you take account of UK born people that leave and non Uk people that enter our country, the net figure is no doubt reasonable. They are often willing to work and contribute to our society and economy - so why the hostility?

Why not accept as a country that we have en element of migration and embrace that, if not because your views are racist?

OP posts:
MrsSkylerWhite · 18/02/2023 12:38

In the main, yes.

Redebs · 18/02/2023 12:37

In my experience, immigration concern is intrinsically connected with racism.

mumda · 18/02/2023 12:34

Considering the threatened electricity shortages maybe we should look seriously at how many people are here and what levels of infrastructure we need.

MarshaBradyo · 18/02/2023 12:33

The idea western countries keep growing for taxes and aging has difficulty as those lifestyles tend to pollute more

lollipoprainbow · 18/02/2023 12:32

As for the channel asylum seekers - quite frankly if you've managed to travel here from half way across the globe from a war torn country, then good on you!! You are likely to be a very resourceful and dynamic person, which is exactly what the economy needs!“

Except most of them haven't 🙄

Florenz · 18/02/2023 12:31

All countries should be looking to reduce their population. It's by far he best way to reduce pollution and slow global warming.

MrsSkylerWhite · 18/02/2023 12:20

Beecham · 15/10/2022 23:04
We desperately need immigration to keep essential services running and to pay taxes. Falling birth rates combined with an ageing population is not good. All those state pensions, all that NHS healthcare, all that state funded elderly care - we need taxes to pay for all that. Who's going to pay if birth rates are falling?? We need loads and loads of young people from wherever we can get them.

As for the channel asylum seekers - quite frankly if you've managed to travel here from half way across the globe from a war torn country, then good on you!! You are likely to be a very resourceful and dynamic person, which is exactly what the economy needs!“

👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

JudgeJ · 18/02/2023 12:16

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

No black people over 60? Sorry, as a pinkish, no such thing as 'white', almost 75 year old shall I top myself to help your spurious statistics?

thecatsthecats · 18/02/2023 12:06

I now live in a place with high levels of diversity, but integration and social cohesion are definitely lacking.

Interesting, I feel the same.

I grew up in the Lakes, which is spectacularly non-diverse, but the main division is farming vs incomers. There's great cohesion between the incomers, if that makes sense?

Whereas I currently live in a very cohesive neighbourhood in Birmingham, but would say that the city as a whole is very diverse, but with very little integration and cohesion in some areas.

viques · 18/02/2023 11:56

Florenz · 18/02/2023 11:39

"And since we are like many other first world countries an aging population , with a falling birth rate , who are currently not training and retaining enough health professionals (at all levels) and teachers, let alone builders, electricians and plumbers who do you see being the care givers of the future, or the people who maintain the infrastructure, build the houses, the hospitals etc."

The answer to this is that the government and companies need to invest more in training young people (and not so young people) so we have more health professionals (at all levels), teachers, builders, electricians and plumbers.

I agree, the government could be doing more to encourage training, and more importantly retention, in many jobs, but this doesn’t solve the issue of an ageing population and a falling birth rate. Look at the situation in Japan, where the population demographics are being skewed firstly by the tiny birth rate that isn’t even replacing the current population and exacerbated by the huge demands made on government finances by an ageing population. In twenty years time they simply won’t have enough people of working age to cover their needs as a country. Even huge financial incentives aren’t persuading Japanese families to have more children.

Florenz · 18/02/2023 11:39

"And since we are like many other first world countries an aging population , with a falling birth rate , who are currently not training and retaining enough health professionals (at all levels) and teachers, let alone builders, electricians and plumbers who do you see being the care givers of the future, or the people who maintain the infrastructure, build the houses, the hospitals etc."

The answer to this is that the government and companies need to invest more in training young people (and not so young people) so we have more health professionals (at all levels), teachers, builders, electricians and plumbers.

KarmaStar · 18/02/2023 11:34

No.It is because this island is too small for the thousands flooding in for free everything.
Yes thousands want to work but many more dont.
Doesn't matter what the skin colour is,it is the values the person has and many have none.every town has groups in the town centres smoking swearing ,brand new everything,aggressive to locals,sexually threatening to females,beach towns have huge areas barricaded off for their own personal use on the sand preventing anyone entering,constant begging and abuse hurled if not given money.It is not racist to state these facts .It is what is happening.
There are thousands of immigrants who are amazing.we are grateful to them.
We,and maybe they,are let down by the scroungers,no matter what colour they are or where they arrive from.

viques · 18/02/2023 11:31

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/10/2022 22:45

Sometimes, but I don’t think it’s a hard and fast rule.

We are a tiny Island that’s completely overpopulated and struggling economically. We are not a country fit for immigration and whilst I don’t want zero immigration, something has to be done to stop for a while and take care of people who are already here who desperately need help.

And since we are like many other first world countries an aging population , with a falling birth rate , who are currently not training and retaining enough health professionals (at all levels) and teachers, let alone builders, electricians and plumbers who do you see being the care givers of the future, or the people who maintain the infrastructure, build the houses, the hospitals etc.

And then there are the service industries and the farming industries both of which are heavily dependant on Labour which frankly isn’t forthcoming from the existing population.

Many of the people who want to come and live here have the skills and education to make a difference, if they are allowed to remain and work. And of those who don’t a lot have the energy and entrepreneurial push to make something of their life through hard work.

We are happy to accept without question the dregs of criminal lowlife from many Eastern block countries, the Middle East and elsewhere as long as they show they have a few million ( no questions asked as to provenance) to put in a bank account, even if it is clear that they have no interest in living in the UK and contributing to society.

Florenz · 18/02/2023 11:23

If we legalized murder it'd stop there being any murderers too...

magnifying · 18/02/2023 11:20

I think you have to draw a distinction between legal migration and illegal migration.

Personally I think we should lower the criteria for legal migration (we need skilled and unskilled workers for starters) and get tougher on illegal migration but making obvious exceptions for people who are genuinely seeking asylum.

I want to live in a country that is an amazing mix of cultures, ethnicities and people from all different walks of life - that to me is a healthy country. But I think problems occur when people attempt to enter illegally.

If we lowered the criteria for legal entry, we'd put the hideous people traffickers out of business too.

sendbobs · 18/02/2023 11:12

Basically, natural increase of the population doesn't solve an aging population it just means you have an even bigger ageing population in 40 years.

sendbobs · 18/02/2023 11:11

@Eleganz you haven't thought this one through, have you? You want to increase the birth rate to pay for more old people. Are those children never making it to retirement age themselves or what? Are you just going to keep bringing people in until nobody has any resources to live?

How does creating more children/flying people in solve your problem? Unless these people die as soon as they're economically inactive too

Florenz · 18/02/2023 11:11

We have more than enough people of working age in this country, employers just aren't prepared to pay decent wages. And there are some people who like having a servant class who will bring them coffee and food to their door for a pittance. It's the same people who would have been against the abolition of slavery in the US in the 1800s. "Because of the economy".

vivainsomnia · 18/02/2023 10:57

The problem is people who think that we could control it in a 100% veted way, so that we insure everyone we let in are bringing something to our economy, at least more than they take, but then we don't want to give them the good jobs that should only go to Brits. So ok to invite them to do what Brits don't want to do but noone else.

Of course it is racist! These people are just like us. They want to better their lives, not be slaves to jobs we are only want to give them just because they are not British. We want them to adjust to our culture, traditions, principles but don't want to have the same entitlements. We want to control them to our benefit solely. It doesn't get worse.

Eleganz · 18/02/2023 10:51

sendbobs · 18/02/2023 10:41

Too many old people you say? I think there's an irony here, did you miss it?

'Old people' don't just expire after they're done paying taxes. They have every right to rest and continue living and be looked after. One of my parents was an immigrant and the type some people don't like. And it's wrong the way some people treat immigrants, and even separate refugees into worthy and unworthy (Afghans vs Ukrainians). Still, people have every right to be concerned for issues like overpopulation and cultural erosion if that's what's happening in their area.

But who will pay for their rest? We have a massive demographic bulge of people at or above retirement age in this country. We have a dwindling working population who need to pay for a growing retired population and a dropping birth rate because people simply can't afford to have kids until they are much older or even not at all.

It is okay to get huffy about statements like 'too many old people' but it doesn't change the demographic and economic reality. We need more people working with higher wages to support a generation that has been promised protected pension benefits if they vote Tory. The government needs to solve this issue and make the country seem like a shit place to move to is not going to help that.

sendbobs · 18/02/2023 10:41

Qwertyfudge · 18/02/2023 07:43

Yes they are racist, the too many people argument doesn’t hold up. We don’t have enough working age people in this country to support the economy. We have too many old people, can’t imagine those screaming we’re full are going to start campaigning for a ship them out programme for the elderly. Maybe they could be sent to nice hotels with swimming pools in Rwanda?

Too many old people you say? I think there's an irony here, did you miss it?

'Old people' don't just expire after they're done paying taxes. They have every right to rest and continue living and be looked after. One of my parents was an immigrant and the type some people don't like. And it's wrong the way some people treat immigrants, and even separate refugees into worthy and unworthy (Afghans vs Ukrainians). Still, people have every right to be concerned for issues like overpopulation and cultural erosion if that's what's happening in their area.

Dotjones · 18/02/2023 10:38

Clearly the "zero immigration" argument is not racist in itself because it would treat people from all races equally, especially if all countries applied it.

I don't think all people who want to cut immigration are racist either, in my experience for the most part the people who want the most drastic cuts don't discriminate against particular countries or ethnicities, they just want all people to stop coming into the country.

It would probably be helpful if there were defined criteria for coming into the country that everyone understood and mostly agreed with. The only criteria that should be used is the test of how much benefit there would be to the country for letting someone in.

This is because people don't dislike immigration in itself, they dislike the negative impact immigration has on the country. It costs billions and many people born in this country are struggling. If immigrants had to pay to get into the country, had to work in jobs that we struggle to fill, were prohibited from sending any of their earnings overseas and would be deported once they were no longer useful, this would probably satisfy many anti-immigration exponents.

Qwertyfudge · 18/02/2023 10:32

@lollipoprainbow try reading my comment again. I’m suggesting the argument for the tiny island being full doesn’t hold up, considering we don’t have enough workforce to staff a functional health service or the hospitality industry. All the services we need to support our aging population relies on a young workforce, considering we don’t have our own, we’ll need to import one or our elderly will be left to an undignified end.
Asylum seekers are not allowed to work in this country despite many of them being skilled workers that could contribute to our economy, but don’t let that fact get in the way of your opinion

lollipoprainbow · 18/02/2023 10:19

Qwertyfudge · 18/02/2023 07:43

Yes they are racist, the too many people argument doesn’t hold up. We don’t have enough working age people in this country to support the economy. We have too many old people, can’t imagine those screaming we’re full are going to start campaigning for a ship them out programme for the elderly. Maybe they could be sent to nice hotels with swimming pools in Rwanda?

Yeah those annoying old people huh ? What a bloody disgusting comment. There are hotels full of immigrants just sitting around all day costing millions. Show me the jobs they are all supposed to be doing ??

Pricklyheath · 18/02/2023 07:48

A work colleague of mine who was a biochemist had just completed supervision and was about to start shift work was made to return to Barbados where laboratory jobs are few and far between as it’s a small island.
The argument used was that she didn’t earn enough and although the shift work would have put her in the correct income bracket the Home office refused to listen.
It happened about a year after Cameron got in and was definitely done to reduce immigration as it happened all over the country.
We lost a valuable member of staff, who had accommodation and a skilled job supporting herself, all to fulfil a political brief.