Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to be independent although in-laws are well off and want to help

111 replies

NoWayJosèNotToday · 15/10/2022 21:21

Firstly, the people I'm talking about here, my in-laws, are really nice people. I do like them but I don't know why I feel so strongly about this. I want to know if it's me being weird or if it is reasonable.

In-laws are quite well off and want to spend their money on us (my husband is their only child so I get they want the best for him) like wanting to buy our flight tickets (business class), sponsoring holidays, buying things for our house like air conditioners etc. I obviously appreciate smaller gifts on birthdays, Christmas and some clothes for kids when they've been abroad but anytime else they spend money on us, it just drives me nuts because I feel like it controls me, and my family. Also, indirect things like bringing lots of snacks when coming to visit.

I get it that they have the money to spend but I want to raise my kids humbly (so learn to go without something until we can afford it) and I want us to be independent and not weighed down.

I don't want to ask them for anything as it feels like I will owe them or that I can't be upfront with them about things I don't like because I have to be grateful and keep my mouth shut. They bought us ACs for our house and it took me so long to feel like using it. It was so useful during the hot summer but the fact that they bought it for us makes me feel like I've to now "behave". I mean I am nice to them anyways and we get along fine but just feels like I am compelled to be extra nice.

I am a very opinionated person so if I don't like something I will say so. Like I have asked my MIL not to buy me things (she used to get me lots of things all the time and I was overwhelmed!). I also am particular about how I want to raise our kids so if something isn't right, I will say so for e.g. asking for consent before kissing my kids or giving them freedom (raising them montessori-way). But when they do us a favour or spend money on us, I feel like I lose the right to correct them or to hold anything against them or even have any negative thoughts about them at all! I feel guilty just writing this post as I'm thinking about all the things they've done for us (with/without us asking for it) and how I shouldn't be feeling this way. My husband is very comfortable just asking for help if needed so I feel really alone in this.

OP posts:
saraclara · 15/10/2022 23:37

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 15/10/2022 23:28

Ah, the usual 'you are rude' responses to anyone who dares communicate in a direct manner. Seems passive aggression is often much more Mumsnet style, which is an underhand method of communication I find cowardly as well as rude.

OP you've made your views clear and they are continuing to override them. I am fiercely independent and would also not like this in the slightest. It does carry with it a certain degree of obligation and could later be thrown back against you in the mode of 'after all we've done for you....'

I would not in any circumstances want to hand anyone that degree of power. If I have a strong relationship with someone and feel affection for them, they don't need to buy me. If I don't, they are incapable of doing so.

YANBU.

What about her husband, their son? Is he not allowed to accept their kindness?

OP is perfectly able to say that she's not good at presents and though she appreciates their kindness, she'd rather they didn't give her big presents (one of my son in laws is like this. He doesn't really like birthdays or Christmas in that regard, so while I recognise both I keep his present small but personal and don't make a big deal of it). But she does not have the right to tell her husband to refuse the help that his loving parents want to give.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 15/10/2022 23:28

Ah, the usual 'you are rude' responses to anyone who dares communicate in a direct manner. Seems passive aggression is often much more Mumsnet style, which is an underhand method of communication I find cowardly as well as rude.

OP you've made your views clear and they are continuing to override them. I am fiercely independent and would also not like this in the slightest. It does carry with it a certain degree of obligation and could later be thrown back against you in the mode of 'after all we've done for you....'

I would not in any circumstances want to hand anyone that degree of power. If I have a strong relationship with someone and feel affection for them, they don't need to buy me. If I don't, they are incapable of doing so.

YANBU.

Triffid1 · 15/10/2022 23:25

You do.sound controlling. I mean, letting their grandparents kiss them shouldn't be a big deal.

The question is whether the in laws really do expect you to fall into line ad a result of their generosity or if its just in your head.

SD1978 · 15/10/2022 23:25

Would you prefer they spent it now or have you a lump sum when they die? Because bluntly, that's the reality of it. They want to support their son and his family, and see the benefits of their hard earned money in use when they are alive, and you have said they are nice and they expect nothing- so the issue here is your uncomfortableness, not them wanting to help their family when they can see it.

Luana1 · 15/10/2022 23:24

Life is generally quite hard and you have people that want to make things easier for your family. I can't understand your reluctance especially when there are no strings attached.

POLLYprosecco1 · 15/10/2022 23:21

OP - honestly, I think you are lucky. We have the opposite - in-laws who think nothing of having my husband pay for everything and take money off him at every opportunity. They also barely take interest in our children, preferring instead to indulge their daughter’s child with time, love, and plastic tat. They are the most useless in-laws I could have imagined. Yours sound wonderful in comparison. But maybe have a quiet word telling them how much you appreciate everything but would maybe rather they spent more money on themselves, or that you are more comfortable in paving your own way.

Miajk · 15/10/2022 23:20

cinnabongene · 15/10/2022 23:16

@Miajk if your generous in-laws offend you so much by wanting to treat you to a meal out, why do you go? Why not just go no contact with them? You keep going on about me needing to grow up, if I want to get on in the real world but it’s obvious you have a very narrow and culturally biased view. The majority on this thread also think the OP is being ridiculous

The majority doesn't always mean that they're viewpoint is correct, as you'd see by the recent outcomes of the British public voting for different things.

Why can't people just compromise? Respect each others differences? Why does it have to be only the way DHs family does things?

My view isn't narrow just because it doesn't align with yours. You think OP is selfish but it's ironic since you believe only one way of thinking is okay and OP is somehow problematic for feeling differently.

antipodeancanary · 15/10/2022 23:17

Well if it makes the kids and your DH happy, is it really fair that you try to put a stop to it?

ThatsAboutEnoughOfThat · 15/10/2022 23:16

My parents and my in-laws grew up poor, grinding, going to bed hungry poor.

Both DH and I benefited from being raised in the homes of people who worked hard to pull themselves and their familes out of that situation, but there wasn't a lot of spare cash to splash.

Our children are now amongst the very lucky. We are both university educated, in high paying jobs, we have lovely homes and our children want for nothing. And their grandparents NOW have the money spare to buy these children all of the things they could never have even dreamed of when they were young.

We don't need their money, the kids don't need their gifts, but this is part of how they express their love. Money can sometimes come with strings and sometimes someone just loves you/your kids and wants to do/give you nice things.

Chill out. You are overthinking this parenting gig.

cinnabongene · 15/10/2022 23:16

@Miajk if your generous in-laws offend you so much by wanting to treat you to a meal out, why do you go? Why not just go no contact with them? You keep going on about me needing to grow up, if I want to get on in the real world but it’s obvious you have a very narrow and culturally biased view. The majority on this thread also think the OP is being ridiculous

Createausernamehere · 15/10/2022 23:12

You sound really hard work if I’m honest.

your PIL sound generous and loving not controlling.

your attitude to your kids being humble is a bit bizarre and embarrassingly liberal

Miajk · 15/10/2022 23:10

cinnabongene · 15/10/2022 23:08

Yawn!

Are you always this ignorant and unwilling to accept that people in the world have different viewpoints, or is this just Mumsnet bravery? Either way... you might want to adjust that attitude if you're going to interact with other people in the world.

cinnabongene · 15/10/2022 23:08

Miajk · 15/10/2022 23:06

I'm not the OP I'm just someone who understands that it's not a normal family dynamic for one person to be expected to just adjust to the way one partner's family does things.

My in laws are like this. I'm more like OP. They never let us pay for a meal out, or anything. In my culture that's actually not polite.

But sure, go off - I guess only your opinion matters and people with other backgrounds can just suck it up. What a joy you are.

Yawn!

Miajk · 15/10/2022 23:06

cinnabongene · 15/10/2022 23:02

Are you the OP back with a different username because you aren’t getting the replies you thought you would?
It’s selfish because she is only thinking about how it makes her feel, not that it is her husband’s parents, who are doing a nice thing for their son and his family - apparently with no conditions attached. She didn’t have to marry into this wealthy family. She didn’t have to have children with a man who comes from a wealthy family - not if she doesn’t like the fact that his parents are, God forbid, generous. What a bunch of bastards!

I'm not the OP I'm just someone who understands that it's not a normal family dynamic for one person to be expected to just adjust to the way one partner's family does things.

My in laws are like this. I'm more like OP. They never let us pay for a meal out, or anything. In my culture that's actually not polite.

But sure, go off - I guess only your opinion matters and people with other backgrounds can just suck it up. What a joy you are.

twicebittenthriceshy · 15/10/2022 23:06

I do understand as I'm also independent and don't like to ask for help (and I'm stubborn too).

However, I also enjoy giving gifts, so perhaps your in laws are the same.

Despite being independent, I can get upset as my in laws don't buy our children anything for Christmas or birthdays!

cinnabongene · 15/10/2022 23:02

Miajk · 15/10/2022 22:57

How is it selfish?

Surely it's also selfish to assume you know what's best for someone and act in line with that, even though it actually makes them uncomfortable?

It's not about a high horse it's about having the emotional intelligence and maturity to understand different people/cultures approach money and financial dynamics differently and that doesn't mean your way is right so OP doesn't matter.

Are you the OP back with a different username because you aren’t getting the replies you thought you would?
It’s selfish because she is only thinking about how it makes her feel, not that it is her husband’s parents, who are doing a nice thing for their son and his family - apparently with no conditions attached. She didn’t have to marry into this wealthy family. She didn’t have to have children with a man who comes from a wealthy family - not if she doesn’t like the fact that his parents are, God forbid, generous. What a bunch of bastards!

Miajk · 15/10/2022 22:57

cinnabongene · 15/10/2022 22:55

It really isn’t thought is it? Only selfish idiots would see it like that. Climb down off your horse; it’s way too high for you

How is it selfish?

Surely it's also selfish to assume you know what's best for someone and act in line with that, even though it actually makes them uncomfortable?

It's not about a high horse it's about having the emotional intelligence and maturity to understand different people/cultures approach money and financial dynamics differently and that doesn't mean your way is right so OP doesn't matter.

cinnabongene · 15/10/2022 22:55

Miajk · 15/10/2022 22:30

What a rude and stupid comment.

Some people are independent and aren't comfortable with being given lots of stuff.

Not just for financial reasons but also because they don't want to overconsume or accumulate lots of things and just because OP's partner has a relationship like this with his parents doesn't mean that dynamic has to rule her house and family.

It really isn’t thought is it? Only selfish idiots would see it like that. Climb down off your horse; it’s way too high for you

saraclara · 15/10/2022 22:34

But when they do us a favour or spend money on us, I feel like I lose the right to correct them or to hold anything against them or even have any negative thoughts about them at all!

Is there some kind of back story in your life before you meet your husband, that explains why you feel this way?
I'd be horrified if either of my son's in law thought that about the help I've given. It wouldn't occur to me to expect anything back. Once I've given something I've given it. I don't dwell on the fact that I've done something for them or expect any kind of particular behaviour from then in return.

Given that your in-laws are nice people, I imagine that they'd be horrified too.

autienotnaughty · 15/10/2022 22:32

If you feel bad donate what they give or financial equivalent to charity

Miajk · 15/10/2022 22:30

cinnabongene · 15/10/2022 21:59

You sound like a pain in the arse. They are your husband’s parents, your children’s grandparents. It isn’t just about your thoughts and feelings.

What a rude and stupid comment.

Some people are independent and aren't comfortable with being given lots of stuff.

Not just for financial reasons but also because they don't want to overconsume or accumulate lots of things and just because OP's partner has a relationship like this with his parents doesn't mean that dynamic has to rule her house and family.

SophiaLaB · 15/10/2022 22:24

Just enjoy it. I imagine they genuinely want to just buy things for you and your family and don’t expect anything back. I recently bought a few things for DS girlfriend just because she needed them for a particular sport she is now doing with me (she and her family could easily afford these). I’m happy to do it and expect nothing in return. Just enjoy it and don’t question every purchase. If MIL was asking or expecting specific things in return that would be different, until then take it in the spirit it’s offered.

Floweryflora · 15/10/2022 22:15

I get it. Nothing worse than having diamond slippers that are too tight. Sad times op. Sad times.

saraclara · 15/10/2022 22:11

It's their way of showing love. If you've not grown up with that, or your experience of people giving you things has had a downside or been transactional, I imagine that it's hard for you to understand.

I love helping my kids out. They're not spoiled and we lived fairly frugally when they were children. But now I'm in a better financial position, and they're at a stage where every penny counts (especially now). I want their lives to be easier, and for them to feel more secure. So though I'm probably not as well off as your in-laws, I enjoy helping out. I'm also another who'd be sad if I was asked not to buy presents.
I love them and this is how I show it. On the other hand I'm not good at the sentimental side of things and sprinkling conversation with 'love you's and so on (though they know I do)

TheoriginalMrsDarcy · 15/10/2022 22:11

Given ur husband is their only child, they just want to spoil him and his family so u don't have to struggle. You should see this as an early inheritance and tax avoidance. Spend it on u all now, so there's not so much left at the end for Mr taxman. Enjoy your Inlaws and their kindness and generosity. Just be grateful they care enough. On the flip side, u could have uncaring in laws who spent every penny on themselves and totally ignore u all. You'd hate that and you'd be posting a completely different topic.

Swipe left for the next trending thread