Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to be independent although in-laws are well off and want to help

111 replies

NoWayJosèNotToday · 15/10/2022 21:21

Firstly, the people I'm talking about here, my in-laws, are really nice people. I do like them but I don't know why I feel so strongly about this. I want to know if it's me being weird or if it is reasonable.

In-laws are quite well off and want to spend their money on us (my husband is their only child so I get they want the best for him) like wanting to buy our flight tickets (business class), sponsoring holidays, buying things for our house like air conditioners etc. I obviously appreciate smaller gifts on birthdays, Christmas and some clothes for kids when they've been abroad but anytime else they spend money on us, it just drives me nuts because I feel like it controls me, and my family. Also, indirect things like bringing lots of snacks when coming to visit.

I get it that they have the money to spend but I want to raise my kids humbly (so learn to go without something until we can afford it) and I want us to be independent and not weighed down.

I don't want to ask them for anything as it feels like I will owe them or that I can't be upfront with them about things I don't like because I have to be grateful and keep my mouth shut. They bought us ACs for our house and it took me so long to feel like using it. It was so useful during the hot summer but the fact that they bought it for us makes me feel like I've to now "behave". I mean I am nice to them anyways and we get along fine but just feels like I am compelled to be extra nice.

I am a very opinionated person so if I don't like something I will say so. Like I have asked my MIL not to buy me things (she used to get me lots of things all the time and I was overwhelmed!). I also am particular about how I want to raise our kids so if something isn't right, I will say so for e.g. asking for consent before kissing my kids or giving them freedom (raising them montessori-way). But when they do us a favour or spend money on us, I feel like I lose the right to correct them or to hold anything against them or even have any negative thoughts about them at all! I feel guilty just writing this post as I'm thinking about all the things they've done for us (with/without us asking for it) and how I shouldn't be feeling this way. My husband is very comfortable just asking for help if needed so I feel really alone in this.

OP posts:
saraclara · 16/10/2022 08:57

Obki · 16/10/2022 08:35

But when they do us a favour

Stop asking them for favours then for a start.

You want to have your cake and eat it too.

She hasn't asked. She doesn't want their money so why would she ask for it?

cptartapp · 16/10/2022 08:54

PIL are very well off.
We had no wedding contribution or anything towards a house deposit (unlike SIL). The DC got £30 for their 18th birthday. Their money piles up with no one enjoying it, least of all them.
The gifts may not have strings now but wait until one is left alone, old and frail. You're already uncomfortable with it when both together, fit and well.
It's quite freeing to be beholden to no one.

Cantstandbullshit · 16/10/2022 08:48

Really, grandparents should ask your permission before they can kiss their grandchild??? So let me get this, they come to visit you and as child runs to grandma for a hug grandma says WAIT!!! I need permission, dear OP is it ok if I give her a kiss??

Then you say yes or maybe no depending on what, your mood? Then they say thank you your highness and give grandchild a kiss on the cheek?

Would they need to sign a waiver as well? You know to protect everyone involved?

Obki · 16/10/2022 08:35

But when they do us a favour

Stop asking them for favours then for a start.

You want to have your cake and eat it too.

pocketvenuss · 16/10/2022 08:27

Maybe they want to give what they can now to reduce inheritance tax when they die? Maybe your dh could talk to them about setting up a trust or bank account for their grandchildren

luckylavender · 16/10/2022 08:24

You sound quite hard work OP

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 16/10/2022 08:18

Delighted that you're teaching DC about consent.

It does sound like this might be more in your head than theirs. It doesn't sound as if those gifts have strings.

Is there a bone you could throw them? My first thought would be a trust fund for uni education. If your dc could go through uni with no loans that would make as massive difference to their future standing.

ThatsTheWayIHikeIt · 16/10/2022 07:26

I get what you're saying OP. My daughter has married into a family like this and her inlaws like to spend money on them, but there are lots of strings attached. It's infantalising and controlling - like "you can't possibly buy a new kitchen without our input" kind of thing. My daughter hates it.

I've seen threads like this before where most people have agreed it's inappropriate and controlling and how they'd hate feeling beholden too. MN is funny sometimes. if you'd posted this on a different day you would have got a very different response.

SuperCamp · 16/10/2022 07:26

OP, you feel as if their generosity controls you, and yet you seek to control their wish to share their wealth and to control their wish to give.

You haven’t said that they pull strings or exert pressure as a result of these gifts, so am assuming that their generosity is just about wanting to give and share.

Are you a control freak? If so, why? What else are you afraid of?

Its great you are raising your child on Montessori principles, but children live in a big wide world, not a pedagogical environment. They make their own individual relationships with different people they love. You can’t dictate each detail of how family members interact with your children, you live in a family, not a cult! (I am not saying Montessori is a cult, I am saying it is cult like if all family transactions have to be based on the same script). Do you ask permission to kiss your DH?

Have a think about why this level of control matters to you, where no discernible harm is being done.

MozzarellaMonster · 16/10/2022 07:21

I had an ex boyfriend whose Mother who got him or us anything held it over our heads and used it as a stick to beat us with... we ended up saying no to any help because of this.
When I met my now husband I was very nervous when his parents wanted to give gifts / help us with a deposit as I was worried that they would do what my ex's mother did but thankfully still to this day many years later they are lovely and generous and have never once held anything over our heads...
Is there a reason that you feel beholden, have they given you the impression that you owe them?
Unless they have I would say although hard try to change your frame of mind, I know with my own children I look forward to treating them like my PIL have treated us, pass the torch on and I won't feel they owe me anything either.
Trust and enjoy it unless they've given you a reason not to.

Donotgogentle · 16/10/2022 07:09

MintJulia · 16/10/2022 02:13

Have they ever tried to trade on their gifts, eg influence your dc's schooling by only paying certain fees?

Have you considered that they are trying to reduce their Inheritance tax liability.

You won't be able to stop it so why not try to direct it towards something that is useful long term like saving for house deposits or school fees or pensions.

I agree.

There’s the saying, “money can’t buy happiness but it keeps the children close”.

It’s naive to think generosity is never used to buy gratitude or compliance. Posters can’t know whether that is the dynamic here from what you’ve said op.

Suggesting all gifts from now on go into an ISA or pension for your dc is a good way to defuse that dynamic.

Oysterbabe · 16/10/2022 07:08

I'm in a similar situation but don't mind at all. Spending money on their child and grandchildren makes them happy so let them and just be grateful.
My inlaws have recently said they want to start giving away some of their money to their children so randomly drop cash into DH's account from time to time. We don't need it so it goes into savings.

GloriousGlory · 16/10/2022 07:00

So they enjoy seeing their DS and DGC enjoy their inheritance, but you want to wait until they die before you get the money?

I'm in the camp that I like to see my DSs and families enjoy what's going to be theirs. Rather that than the taxman gets it.

junebirthdaygirl · 16/10/2022 02:45

Or in getting them to involve the dc in donating food to food banks or some other charity stuff so they are learning about life.

junebirthdaygirl · 16/10/2022 02:44

I do understand when it's about buying stuff for your dc. If l was teaching my dc to save for something and their GPS just popped up and bought it l wouldn't be happy. I wouldn't have an issue with the holidays or even the air-conditioning but stopping the dc from learning about money would be an issue.
I would try and redirect their funds into college accounts for the dc.

Appleblum · 16/10/2022 02:28

They sound like really nice people. If there's no background of them being controlling, just accept their gifts with grace.

My parents do this all the time and my in laws also do this to a lesser extent. Giving is their way of expressing their love. It makes them happy and it doesn't make us any less independent. For DD's birthday recently our in laws wanted to treat the whole family (10 of us) to lunch at DD's favourite restaurant. We insisted on paying and so DD received a cash gift from them instead. It's all swings and roundabouts really.

Idyllicidealist · 16/10/2022 02:14

WalkingInTheAir13 · 16/10/2022 02:02

If my husband or I asked for permission to give our give our grandchildren a kiss, both our sons and daughters-in-laws would think we had truly lost our marbles!

Really?
I wouldn't kiss my 9 year old dgs without asking his permission first. It allows him to set boundaries which help to keep him safe.

MintJulia · 16/10/2022 02:13

Have they ever tried to trade on their gifts, eg influence your dc's schooling by only paying certain fees?

Have you considered that they are trying to reduce their Inheritance tax liability.

You won't be able to stop it so why not try to direct it towards something that is useful long term like saving for house deposits or school fees or pensions.

WalkingInTheAir13 · 16/10/2022 02:02

If my husband or I asked for permission to give our give our grandchildren a kiss, both our sons and daughters-in-laws would think we had truly lost our marbles!

5foot5 · 16/10/2022 00:24

Would it help to put yourself in their shoes?

Imagine yourself in 30 years time. You have everything you need and disposable income. Your children are grown up but they are still your children and you love them to bits and want to do everything you can to help them and their families.

It's surely not so hard to see it from their point of view is it?

Confusion101 · 16/10/2022 00:10

I voted YABU given that you have highlighted how nice your in laws are, the majority of threads on here are about families struggling to survive and you come hear complaining about "my lovely in laws want to give us too much"! Ffs....

Kitkatcatflap · 16/10/2022 00:02

You sound like hard work.

You post starts with saying they are nice people then you go on to list all the nice things they do. As a previous poster said - I wish I had your problem.

At no point do you say what makes them controlling or how their generosity is cloaked in control. They bought us an unsuitable holiday - a bare foot crocodile safari with two toddlers. They bought us AC for the house but only for their room when they visit. They gave us money for decorating but demanded it back when they didn't like the wallpaper.

You are married to their only son and they are well off and want their family to enjoy the spoils. I imagine they subscribe to the 'no pockets in a shroud'. Accepting their gifts, clothes and help does not interfer with you raising your children to be thoughtful, caring, grateful, kind and well mannered. Remember you married their son - didn't ruin him did it?

Just a wild guess but I imagine you struggle to accept a compliment too

saraclara · 15/10/2022 23:46

...so Yes, if their husbands got as aggressive about it as @MarieIVanArkleStinks and made it all abbot them, I'd be very distressed

saraclara · 15/10/2022 23:44

They want to support their son and his family, and see the benefits of their hard earned money in use when they are alive,

That. Everything that my mum and MIL (and their late husbands) had saved, plus the value of their houses, disappeared into care costs. All the plans they'd had to help their grandkids went to the wall.

I don't want that to happen to my hard earned savings and those of my late husband. Also, even if I don't ned care, my kids need that financial support now, but when they're nearly my age.

I world be heartbroken if everything I have went to a care home. What I give my DDs now, comes from what I see as their dad's half of what I have. We saved hard for both our retirements, but only I made it to retirement age. Their dad's share is theirs, not to fund my possible care, imo.

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 15/10/2022 23:42

But when they do us a favour or spend money on us, I feel like I lose the right to correct them or to hold anything against them or even have any negative thoughts about them at all!

Do they do or say stuff that makes you think that or is it all internal?

My inlaws are well off, they hand out money at the drop of a hat because they think it makes more sense for dh and his siblings to benefit financially now whilst we have young children. That doesn't mean we always agree or I can't say what I think. Partly because they're giving money to their child not to me directly (apart from birthdays and Christmas) but also because I don't see our relationship as transactional and neither do they. My mum hates it though because she does see all relationships as transactional and she can't compete so I don't tell her any more.

Fair enough to be upset if they pushback on your boundaries because they have given x or y, tainting the gift, but if not...might be worth examining why you feel like that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread