Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to be independent although in-laws are well off and want to help

111 replies

NoWayJosèNotToday · 15/10/2022 21:21

Firstly, the people I'm talking about here, my in-laws, are really nice people. I do like them but I don't know why I feel so strongly about this. I want to know if it's me being weird or if it is reasonable.

In-laws are quite well off and want to spend their money on us (my husband is their only child so I get they want the best for him) like wanting to buy our flight tickets (business class), sponsoring holidays, buying things for our house like air conditioners etc. I obviously appreciate smaller gifts on birthdays, Christmas and some clothes for kids when they've been abroad but anytime else they spend money on us, it just drives me nuts because I feel like it controls me, and my family. Also, indirect things like bringing lots of snacks when coming to visit.

I get it that they have the money to spend but I want to raise my kids humbly (so learn to go without something until we can afford it) and I want us to be independent and not weighed down.

I don't want to ask them for anything as it feels like I will owe them or that I can't be upfront with them about things I don't like because I have to be grateful and keep my mouth shut. They bought us ACs for our house and it took me so long to feel like using it. It was so useful during the hot summer but the fact that they bought it for us makes me feel like I've to now "behave". I mean I am nice to them anyways and we get along fine but just feels like I am compelled to be extra nice.

I am a very opinionated person so if I don't like something I will say so. Like I have asked my MIL not to buy me things (she used to get me lots of things all the time and I was overwhelmed!). I also am particular about how I want to raise our kids so if something isn't right, I will say so for e.g. asking for consent before kissing my kids or giving them freedom (raising them montessori-way). But when they do us a favour or spend money on us, I feel like I lose the right to correct them or to hold anything against them or even have any negative thoughts about them at all! I feel guilty just writing this post as I'm thinking about all the things they've done for us (with/without us asking for it) and how I shouldn't be feeling this way. My husband is very comfortable just asking for help if needed so I feel really alone in this.

OP posts:
saraclara · 16/10/2022 18:13

Obki · 16/10/2022 17:20

‘Favour’ implies OP or her DH is asking them to do things for them.

No it doesn't.

Confusion101 · 16/10/2022 18:12

cutthelawn · 16/10/2022 17:04

Presumably you and your DH will inherit after they die? Will you refuse the inheritance

that is totally different because they will be dead.

Yes and they won't get to see their son and grandchildren enjoying their money then

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 16/10/2022 17:32

cutthelawn · 16/10/2022 17:00

You sound like a pain in the arse. They are your husband’s parents, your children’s grandparents. It isn’t just about your thoughts and feelings

I don't agree with this at all and I see where the op is coming from. The excessive buying/showering of gifts can be uncomfortable and make people receiving them feel indebted and under pressure. I'd feel the same because of how I was brought up but I know too many others who would totally take advantage of this and it doesn't sit well with me.

I also agree with the op that this sort of behaviour is a bad example for the kids in that it goes against her values she wants to teach them.

She wants to share with them that things must be earned and not just given, in other words we must work for them and not to be taking taking taking from others. And sometimes we just can't have the finer things because that's how life is.

I do believe this paves the way for children to become cfers and entitled-because the example from parents is to take take take or everything to be freely given.

Every word 💯

Perhaps it does relate to the ethics and morals we were raised with, but some people - many, I'd venture to say - are embarrassed and discomfited with taking. When someone is putting them in this position continually, it's easy to see why this should make them feel particularly uncomfortable, especially when they've expressly requested that this not happen.

The OP intimated that there are no discernible strings attached to these gifts. But even when someone's motives are entirely altruistic, even when they may not perhaps even be conscious of doing so, that unspoken weight of expectation is there. It's creating an imbalance in the relationship, which people who have been raised to be independent would likely struggle with. It's also modelling a system of ethics to the children which are against OP's style of parenting.

The word 'kindness' is entirely subjective in these circumstances. I'd see the OP's stance as principled. As for being 'controlling' over the way her in-laws spend their money, that's quite some reach. No one is telling them how to invest their funds, or frog marching them into John Lewis and demanding they buy the blush sofa rather than the blue one. But the rights of one person to do as they wish with their own funds end where these conflict with the wishes of the would-be recipients and the code of ethics they want to pass on to their own children.

There was a thread on a similar point in AIBU recently on which the consensus was that the gift-givers were the controllers, that the recipient had very right to assert her preferences, and if the relative continued to override these and send gifts to her property without asking her, those gifts should be refused or sent back.

MN is an oddly contradictory site at times.

Obki · 16/10/2022 17:20

saraclara · 16/10/2022 08:57

She hasn't asked. She doesn't want their money so why would she ask for it?

‘Favour’ implies OP or her DH is asking them to do things for them.

MintyGreenDreams · 16/10/2022 17:10

I'd love that.Mil is as tight as a gnats arse

cutthelawn · 16/10/2022 17:04

Presumably you and your DH will inherit after they die? Will you refuse the inheritance

that is totally different because they will be dead.

cutthelawn · 16/10/2022 17:00

You sound like a pain in the arse. They are your husband’s parents, your children’s grandparents. It isn’t just about your thoughts and feelings

I don't agree with this at all and I see where the op is coming from. The excessive buying/showering of gifts can be uncomfortable and make people receiving them feel indebted and under pressure. I'd feel the same because of how I was brought up but I know too many others who would totally take advantage of this and it doesn't sit well with me.

I also agree with the op that this sort of behaviour is a bad example for the kids in that it goes against her values she wants to teach them.

She wants to share with them that things must be earned and not just given, in other words we must work for them and not to be taking taking taking from others. And sometimes we just can't have the finer things because that's how life is.

I do believe this paves the way for children to become cfers and entitled-because the example from parents is to take take take or everything to be freely given.

FairyLightAddict · 16/10/2022 15:57

First world issues. Wish my wealthy parents were as generous

MintJulia · 16/10/2022 15:54

JudgeJ · 16/10/2022 12:43

Then should my grandson seek my written permission in triplicate before he launches himself at me like he was on the rugby field? With parents like some on this site is there any wonder that so many children have problems'?

You are being absurd. I loathed my grandmother trying to kiss me - she smelt horrible and was pretty unpleasant all round. I always made myself scarce when she was due to visit.

Children have every right to say no thanks to physical contact.

cptartapp · 16/10/2022 15:34

pocketvenuss there honestly isn't. Except maybe that the house she was buying was next door to them!
I know, it's unbelievable you would treat your DC so differently isn't it?

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 16/10/2022 13:06

Then should my grandson seek my written permission in triplicate before he launches himself at me like he was on the rugby field? With parents like some on this site is there any wonder that so many children have problems'?

I'll do you the courtesy of taking this post at face value, albeit it's pretty silly. If he's 'launching himself' at you he's clearly quite happy with the physical contact, since he's initiating it! Boys as a rule can be pretty affectionate. That there's no issue with that at all should be patently obvious. The material point is that like adults, children have the right to reject hugs, kisses and physical contact at any time, and for any reason, they want.

It shouldn't even need pointing out why teaching them any other message about maintaining their own bodily autonomy is potentially problematic. I'd go as far as to suggest claiming otherwise is intentionally disingenuous.

MooseAndSquirrelLoveFlannel · 16/10/2022 13:05

In-laws have never given us money, ever. And FIL says he will be donating it all to the Dogs Trust so we know where we stand 😂

MooseAndSquirrelLoveFlannel · 16/10/2022 13:04

What the feck is the montessori-way? Is it a rule book on how to act ungrateful?

My in-laws are millionaires, the profited very significantly from the housing boom and their parents also were extremely wealthy. And reading your post made me remember when FIL shower me his bank statement complaining that he was uncomfortable as his current account had dropped below £40k. Apparently he likes to keep £40k for "spending money". Its okay though, he has hundreds of thousands of pounds worth of gold bars, and a savings account in the millions but dropping the current account below £40k worried him.

Meanwhile we had two young kids, the housing crisis in 2008 had crippled us and our heating had broken so we had two toddlers in a freezing house and no money to repair it. In the end my Mum gave us her entire savings of £6k so we could sort the heating and bring it up to code. Meanwhile FIL bought more gold bars..

In other words, you're coming on MN which is currently awash with people worried how they will make ends meet and keep a roof over their head and you're complaining your diamond shoes are too tight.

JudgeJ · 16/10/2022 12:43

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 16/10/2022 12:25

No, it's the child's permission they should be asking. Children are people too. Their bodily autonomy is very important, and the earlier they learn this, the better.

Then should my grandson seek my written permission in triplicate before he launches himself at me like he was on the rugby field? With parents like some on this site is there any wonder that so many children have problems'?

JudgeJ · 16/10/2022 12:41

Idyllicidealist · 16/10/2022 02:14

Really?
I wouldn't kiss my 9 year old dgs without asking his permission first. It allows him to set boundaries which help to keep him safe.

Then your dog needs help!

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 16/10/2022 12:25

Cantstandbullshit · 16/10/2022 08:48

Really, grandparents should ask your permission before they can kiss their grandchild??? So let me get this, they come to visit you and as child runs to grandma for a hug grandma says WAIT!!! I need permission, dear OP is it ok if I give her a kiss??

Then you say yes or maybe no depending on what, your mood? Then they say thank you your highness and give grandchild a kiss on the cheek?

Would they need to sign a waiver as well? You know to protect everyone involved?

No, it's the child's permission they should be asking. Children are people too. Their bodily autonomy is very important, and the earlier they learn this, the better.

pocketvenuss · 16/10/2022 12:22

Cantstandbullshit · 16/10/2022 08:48

Really, grandparents should ask your permission before they can kiss their grandchild??? So let me get this, they come to visit you and as child runs to grandma for a hug grandma says WAIT!!! I need permission, dear OP is it ok if I give her a kiss??

Then you say yes or maybe no depending on what, your mood? Then they say thank you your highness and give grandchild a kiss on the cheek?

Would they need to sign a waiver as well? You know to protect everyone involved?

You describe a very creative interpretation of seeking consent. No one is suggesting anything like your crazy little story. Simply, you can't just launch yourself at anyone. Family or otherwise. Why would you think you could? Just ask. 'May Granny have a hug' and be an adult if the little one says no.

SuperCamp · 16/10/2022 12:22

My daughter has married into a family like this and her inlaws like to spend money on them, but there are lots of strings attached. It's infantalising and controlling

The strings is the crucial part of this, and we don’t actually know if the OP’s ILs are ‘like this’ because she hasn’t mentioned any strings being attached.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 16/10/2022 12:20

What about her husband, their son? Is he not allowed to accept their kindness?

Absolutely. But if it's on behalf of the children, then children have two parents, not just one. And if one parent is uncomfortable with a situation pertaining to their kids, they get the veto.

Men are not 'heads of the household' anymore who get to make decisions for everyone else. This is a situation where compromise is called for. And partnerships where one or both parties are unable to do this don't bode well for the future.

pocketvenuss · 16/10/2022 12:19

cptartapp · 16/10/2022 08:54

PIL are very well off.
We had no wedding contribution or anything towards a house deposit (unlike SIL). The DC got £30 for their 18th birthday. Their money piles up with no one enjoying it, least of all them.
The gifts may not have strings now but wait until one is left alone, old and frail. You're already uncomfortable with it when both together, fit and well.
It's quite freeing to be beholden to no one.

There must be a back story if SIL gets money and you don't

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 16/10/2022 12:15

saraclara · 15/10/2022 23:46

...so Yes, if their husbands got as aggressive about it as @MarieIVanArkleStinks and made it all abbot them, I'd be very distressed

Nothing I've said is in any way 'aggressive'.

JudgeJ · 16/10/2022 12:05

I also am particular about how I want to raise our kids

Is their father not allowed an opinion then, it's only your opinion that counts?
As an only child he will presumably come into an inheritance, will you instruct him to give it away to suit your views of being 'humble'?

billy1966 · 16/10/2022 09:44

They may mean well OP, but I understand.

You are an adult and as an adult you don't wish to be receiving unasked for gifts, however well meaning.

I would suggest a college fund for each of your children be set up and when they are trying to push stuff on you, tell them gifting the children for their future education who be a wonderful gift.

The AC sounds like a very thoughtful gift designed to improve the comfort of your home for the whole family, but I do understand how you feel.

Perhaps talk to your husband about a middle ground.

Miajk · 16/10/2022 09:24

Cantstandbullshit · 16/10/2022 08:48

Really, grandparents should ask your permission before they can kiss their grandchild??? So let me get this, they come to visit you and as child runs to grandma for a hug grandma says WAIT!!! I need permission, dear OP is it ok if I give her a kiss??

Then you say yes or maybe no depending on what, your mood? Then they say thank you your highness and give grandchild a kiss on the cheek?

Would they need to sign a waiver as well? You know to protect everyone involved?

God you sound mentally unstable. Why shouldn't kids have bodily autonomy? Selfish and nasty to assume you're entitled to touch and kiss people however and whenever you would like.

Teaching kids about consent helps prevent awful situations. I can't believe how ignorant your comment is.

Nocaloriesinchocolate · 16/10/2022 09:03

My DS is an only child and will inherit when DH and I die. When we offer money or to buy something expensive for him and DIL its always to him because he, as our DS,is able to ask us not to, or to say quite rightly that he’d have to consult DIL first. If we mentioned it to her, bless her, she’d say yes because she’s polite even if she didn’t want whatever it was on offer.

The way we look at it is that DS (and DIL as his wife of course) will get everything of ours when we’re gone but then we wont be in a position to watch them enjoy it so we’d rather them give things now so we could see them enjoy them.

If DIL felt as OP did, DS would - lovingly - tell us so.