Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to be independent although in-laws are well off and want to help

111 replies

NoWayJosèNotToday · 15/10/2022 21:21

Firstly, the people I'm talking about here, my in-laws, are really nice people. I do like them but I don't know why I feel so strongly about this. I want to know if it's me being weird or if it is reasonable.

In-laws are quite well off and want to spend their money on us (my husband is their only child so I get they want the best for him) like wanting to buy our flight tickets (business class), sponsoring holidays, buying things for our house like air conditioners etc. I obviously appreciate smaller gifts on birthdays, Christmas and some clothes for kids when they've been abroad but anytime else they spend money on us, it just drives me nuts because I feel like it controls me, and my family. Also, indirect things like bringing lots of snacks when coming to visit.

I get it that they have the money to spend but I want to raise my kids humbly (so learn to go without something until we can afford it) and I want us to be independent and not weighed down.

I don't want to ask them for anything as it feels like I will owe them or that I can't be upfront with them about things I don't like because I have to be grateful and keep my mouth shut. They bought us ACs for our house and it took me so long to feel like using it. It was so useful during the hot summer but the fact that they bought it for us makes me feel like I've to now "behave". I mean I am nice to them anyways and we get along fine but just feels like I am compelled to be extra nice.

I am a very opinionated person so if I don't like something I will say so. Like I have asked my MIL not to buy me things (she used to get me lots of things all the time and I was overwhelmed!). I also am particular about how I want to raise our kids so if something isn't right, I will say so for e.g. asking for consent before kissing my kids or giving them freedom (raising them montessori-way). But when they do us a favour or spend money on us, I feel like I lose the right to correct them or to hold anything against them or even have any negative thoughts about them at all! I feel guilty just writing this post as I'm thinking about all the things they've done for us (with/without us asking for it) and how I shouldn't be feeling this way. My husband is very comfortable just asking for help if needed so I feel really alone in this.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bluetree89 · 17/10/2022 13:54

I would take the help, it’s seems helping their family is something your PIL are more than happy to do. Stay opinionated, if your PIL really are helping to “keep you in line” you will soon find out when the assistance stops.

Calphurnia88 · 17/10/2022 13:47

I usually roll my eyes at the 'if this is all you have to worry about...' type responses on AIBU but on this occasion this is my gut reaction.

Unless you have strong reason to think that PIL are trying to control you financially, then I would consider yourself fortunate to have such generous relatives, especially during these difficult times.

If you're worried about your children being spoiled (which I do get) could you perhaps suggest that PIL put some money into a savings account for DC rather than lavishing them with gifts? You'll need to tread carefully with this though, as ultimately it's up to them how they choose to spend their money.

saraclara · 16/10/2022 23:32

cutthelawn · 16/10/2022 20:46

But it’s not, is it? It’s about a well off couple wanting to spend their money on their son and his family

yea because their son is allowing it, the status quo is now set and the well off couple feel they have to go along with it. It's the same concept as the threads that come up where 1 friend always feels she has to pay for the other friend and the other friend allows it to happen and never sets a boundary. The longer it goes on the harder it is to stop for the person paying and it leads to resentment and leads to an imbalance in the relationship.

That's ridiculous. I've helped my kids, they've not expected it, they don't remotely take it for granted, and it's entirely up to me whether I do it again.

Why on earth do you think that someone accepting help means that the giver is then tied into doing it forever, against their wishes? That makes no sense.

If my kids weren't appreciative, or took me for granted, then I wouldn't do it. It's as simple as that.

SnackSizeRaisin · 16/10/2022 22:26

JudgeJ · 16/10/2022 12:43

Then should my grandson seek my written permission in triplicate before he launches himself at me like he was on the rugby field? With parents like some on this site is there any wonder that so many children have problems'?

You don't seem over bright. The permission doesn't need to be written, obviously. The point is that you should not hug or kiss anyone who doesn't want it, even a child. A child also should only hug people who want to be hugged. If both parties want to hug, great. The problem is when children are forced into physical contact against their will by elderly family members. Less likely to be a problem the other way around

gogohmm · 16/10/2022 20:58

I would talk with your husband and decide on ways that your family could benefit from their generosity that also doesn't compromise bringing up your children. Not sure of the age of your children but how about them buying music lessons and the instruments needed, my dc benefitted so much from them, I highly recommend.

Direct gently their help with gratefulness

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 16/10/2022 20:52

OP seems to be long gone, which is a pity, but unsurprising considering the roasting she's been given on this thread. There have been few constructive suggestions as to how to tackle this effectively, but one good one is that of a 'college' style fund for the kids: a contribution which will be of real value to them as they get older.

Aside from this, an essential way forward is for both partners in this marriage to be on the same page, and to then present a united front and straightforward set of boundaries/compromises with his parents. Susan Forward is good for this: she suggests the unhappy partner sets out clearly why there are upset: 'when your family does A, it makes me feel B, C, and D. Then each party sets out what they are and are not willing to accept, and work out a solution from there.

Nothing the OP has posted in any way suggests she's a control freak, or an ingrate, or any of the other unpleasantries levelled at her on this board. She doesn't hate her in-laws. She has a practical problem and wanted a solution. But she also claims to be 'opinionated', which is probably what's hung her on this board in my estimation. It's not an attribute MN tends to encourage in a woman.

Blossomtoes · 16/10/2022 20:49

cutthelawn · 16/10/2022 20:46

But it’s not, is it? It’s about a well off couple wanting to spend their money on their son and his family

yea because their son is allowing it, the status quo is now set and the well off couple feel they have to go along with it. It's the same concept as the threads that come up where 1 friend always feels she has to pay for the other friend and the other friend allows it to happen and never sets a boundary. The longer it goes on the harder it is to stop for the person paying and it leads to resentment and leads to an imbalance in the relationship.

Complete bollocks. We spend money on our kids. It’s not expected and always appreciated. But, as I said, we’re selfish bastards.

hattie43 · 16/10/2022 20:48

You sound a nightmare

cutthelawn · 16/10/2022 20:46

But it’s not, is it? It’s about a well off couple wanting to spend their money on their son and his family

yea because their son is allowing it, the status quo is now set and the well off couple feel they have to go along with it. It's the same concept as the threads that come up where 1 friend always feels she has to pay for the other friend and the other friend allows it to happen and never sets a boundary. The longer it goes on the harder it is to stop for the person paying and it leads to resentment and leads to an imbalance in the relationship.

Blossomtoes · 16/10/2022 20:41

cutthelawn · 16/10/2022 20:32

Life isn’t just about what you need, it’s about things that make you more comfortable or things that make you happy. What a miserable existence otherwise

yea fine but if you want it go and buy it yourself and not relay on others to fund you and your family. If this thread was about a man allowing his gf/wife to fund his life he'd be hung.

But it’s not, is it? It’s about a well off couple wanting to spend their money on their son and his family.

cutthelawn · 16/10/2022 20:32

Life isn’t just about what you need, it’s about things that make you more comfortable or things that make you happy. What a miserable existence otherwise

yea fine but if you want it go and buy it yourself and not relay on others to fund you and your family. If this thread was about a man allowing his gf/wife to fund his life he'd be hung.

cutthelawn · 16/10/2022 20:30

However, as a previous poster said; read the room. People are in desperate times and most people are very envious of your position.
Lots of people are having to use food banks or work full time with no disposable income. Some feel that their lives are a prison sentence.
Enjoy the freedom you have, which ultimately what your financial position is giving you and consider your very fortunate position in society before complaining

i'd take mn views of ''desperate times'' with a pinch of salt. People have very odd views of money ,rich and poor on mn and appear to be totally detached from the real world.

Also I'd like to point out on this thread that people are very grabby here. I know a grandfather who was comfortable and was always buying excessive gifts for his 5 grand kids and giving hand outs to the parents (his son and dil).

The family always took out but never objected and it put pressure on him then to keep the status quo going or he'd feel he was letting them down. The truth was that he was retired, in his 70s with bad health but was taking on extra jobs on top of his large pension to fund their lives.

It was all stuff they didn't need-a 700 pound bike for his 13 yo grandson, a 1000 pound coat for the mum...

He was taking on so much that he collapsed 1 day on the way to their house with gifts for a birthday. The family never found out but they just assumed he had plenty of cash and enjoyed treating them and exploited him. It's a form of abuse and all you here saying it's fine should examine your principles. The parents in these situations can always set boundaries firmly but kindly.

Obki · 16/10/2022 20:24

saraclara · 16/10/2022 20:04

I have a very good one already.

While the phrase 'asking a favour' is very common, the definition of the noun 'favour' does not imply a request. It simply means:

an act performed out of good will, generosity, or mercy

Which is why I said ‘implies OP has asked for favours’ not that OP has asked for favours.

Why not clarify with OP before jumping down my throat?

Blossomtoes · 16/10/2022 20:22

cutthelawn · 16/10/2022 20:17

For all the people saying that the op should enjoy it because so many others are on poverty are missing the point. The op is pointing out how the gifts are excessive,materialistic and non essentials and ofcourse this is a bad message to send to kids. These aren't things that people need, it be totally different if the op was struggling and they were buying the essentials.

Life isn’t just about what you need, it’s about things that make you more comfortable or things that make you happy. What a miserable existence otherwise.

cutthelawn · 16/10/2022 20:21

MN is an oddly contradictory site at times

agreed but I think mn love a pile on too, people see the direction of the thread and jump in on the same boat. I too often feel that people know exactly in their heart the op is making is logical but will bash her and make her sound unhinged for having that view.

cutthelawn · 16/10/2022 20:17

For all the people saying that the op should enjoy it because so many others are on poverty are missing the point. The op is pointing out how the gifts are excessive,materialistic and non essentials and ofcourse this is a bad message to send to kids. These aren't things that people need, it be totally different if the op was struggling and they were buying the essentials.

Anyfeckinusername · 16/10/2022 20:16

Her gifting gifts and you having your independence are not mutually exclusive. You can have both offer, and remain unconnected. It is you connecting the two where there is no relation. It doesn't appear in any way like she is gifting your family in order to influence.

saraclara · 16/10/2022 20:04

Obki · 16/10/2022 19:42

Get an education.

I have a very good one already.

While the phrase 'asking a favour' is very common, the definition of the noun 'favour' does not imply a request. It simply means:

an act performed out of good will, generosity, or mercy

Obki · 16/10/2022 19:42

saraclara · 16/10/2022 18:13

No it doesn't.

Get an education.

LightDrizzle · 16/10/2022 19:36

I agree with PP in wondering whether for whatever reason, who have a transactional view of giving that you are projecting on to them.

In the absence of further information your post is all about how it makes you feel and what you fear it might imply, but nothing in your post suggests your in-laws themselves see their giving as giving them some kind of hold or say that encroaches on your independence.

Some people really do just loving giving, my late mother was one of them, it was never used as a power lever.

As long as their giving doesn’t come anywhere close to threatening their ability to enjoy a long, very comfortable retirement and they could cover top of the range care for either or both of them should ill health or dementia cloud their future, - I’d try to unclench and let them have their way.

Have a think about your own experiences and relationships in life to see if you can work out why this stresses you. You are not wrong that unfortunately some people do use money to create obligation and then exact compliance as a quid pro quo, but not everyone does.

Cozytoesandtoast00 · 16/10/2022 19:21

I can see your point OP. Especially about teaching the value of money.
However, as a previous poster said; read the room. People are in desperate times and most people are very envious of your position.
Lots of people are having to use food banks or work full time with no disposable income. Some feel that their lives are a prison sentence.
Enjoy the freedom you have, which ultimately what your financial position is giving you and consider your very fortunate position in society before complaining.

Confusion101 · 16/10/2022 18:41

It's awful to have that choice removed..for the first year of my youngests life I don't think I bought a single outfit. Great in theory, in practice....it felt like I was having the parenting role taken from me.

What was stopping you buying clothes if you wanted? Gifting the ones they bought or donating them to charity? The absolute cheek of grandparents buying their grandkids clothes! Cheeky fuckers!!!

JustFrustrated · 16/10/2022 18:39

I understand 100% OP.

In our case it WAS transactional, they bought X and as such expected Y.

It was hard to pull back, but now the kids are older it's changed a bit.

Something's have stayed, eg. They always buy their winter coat, but now I'm asked to suggest 3 and then she'll buy one of those..means the kids and I get a say.

It's awful to have that choice removed..for the first year of my youngests life I don't think I bought a single outfit. Great in theory, in practice....it felt like I was having the parenting role taken from me.

And fuck everyone saying you sound spoilt etc, it's really difficult to articulate how it feels to have that autonomy taken from you. Or that's how it felt to me at the time

Now we've had a few big arguments, unrelated but still, and our relationship is more equal, I can receive the gifts with good grace and also, can gift to her with love. Because that status quo is now us as equals, instead of her trying to buy us.

Blossomtoes · 16/10/2022 18:25

Confusion101 · 16/10/2022 18:12

Yes and they won't get to see their son and grandchildren enjoying their money then

This. We want to see our kids enjoy our money while we’re alive. We’re really selfish bastards like that.

Arnaquer · 16/10/2022 18:20

Read the room OP. There are a lot of people struggling right now and you are complaining about your generous in laws helping you out financially.
Give your head a wobble and be thankful to have people like this in your life.