Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Milk pouring protest

133 replies

snowballer · 15/10/2022 17:40

What the fuck is wrong with these idiots?

https://twitter.com/rebelsanimal/status/1581251694444564486?s=46&t=rCJ8ncsUW4dOKMKpSOjI5w

So in a cost of living crisis what they've achieved is a) the waste of perfectly good milk and food (other shops they've poured milk over cheese and other dairy products that will now have to be chucked) and b) forcing underpaid and overworked retail staff to clear up their mess.

The entitlement from these absolute fuckwits is unbelievable.

Would be interested to know if dairy-free MNers agree with these particular protests?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Fluffymule · 16/10/2022 22:07

I find it somewhat amusing that a poster is getting on a moral high horse with a ‘WTAF’ squeal about an imaginary consequence, suggested for myopic privilege driven actual ‘WTAF’ activity like criminal damage and vandalism by the trustafarian blue haired brigade.

I mean, you want to obstruct, steal, damage, vandalise and waste, along with forcing the little people to clean up your mess. They imagine stuffing a burger down your throat as a suitable response. Who can say which is worse/better to be fair?

cesspoolclowncar · 16/10/2022 21:49

Kellie45 · 16/10/2022 17:35

Oh for goodness sake cows have been milked for hundreds of years. Our ancestors did it and we do it. There is probably more caretaking of animals than ever there was

You managed to type that comment on the internet. A hundred years ago we didn't have that capability. We also didn't have the knowledge we have available at our disposal today. Tradition is a terrible reason to continue doing something.

As to your last point, what cuckoo land are you living in? Because as nice as your fantasy is, this is the era of intensive factory farming of a scale never seen before by "our ancestors".

This might clue you in to the level of caretaking currently being enjoyed by animals: animalclock.org/uk/

Maverickess · 16/10/2022 21:13

I have my own thoughts that have changed as I've got older towards animals that are used for human food or entertainment in it's various forms and it's definitely something I'm interested in learning about further, but not from a bunch of spoilt brats who want to make a big scene and be the centre of attention, wasting something without a thought that some people cannot afford at the moment - never mind the alternatives or plant based versions - during a cost of living crisis and then being so entitled to expect someone else to clean up after them as they pat each other on the back.

Absolutely appalling behaviour and will not get any support from me.

orangeisthenewpuce · 16/10/2022 20:57

@nobodysdaughter Obviously in a shop in a more affluent location will.The aim behind this protest almost certainly isn't, as many of you believe, to convert the general public to veganism overnight. It is to highlight the cause and get people talking about alternatives. And the way to do that is some crazy stunt, in the most deliberately provocative manner possible.
Whether you think they have a point, or wish to force feed the protestors steaks ( I mean what the actual FUCK?) you can't we are talking about it.

I disagree. It would definitely get publicity. And the videos of them getting beaten up would be viral in minutes.

VinoDino · 16/10/2022 19:56

@CentaureaCyanus exactly.

CentaureaCyanus · 16/10/2022 19:53

It's certainly created a discussion about the hyper privileged attitudes the protestors revealed with their wasteful antics in waitrose and harrods where they could be quite sure the biggest threat they faced was a bit of tutting. Alternatives to dairy not so much.

VinoDino · 16/10/2022 19:38

@nobodysdaughter you are making out they have achieved their so called aims. They haven't.

If they pulled that stunt in a 'hard' area, which they would never due to being sheltered middle class twat idiots, it would've made the news as they would've had their arses handed to them. They didn't want 'that' publicity.

They haven't achieved people taking about 'the cause' and the alternatives out there. All people are talking about is that they are cunts. End of. I'm not interested now in their cause, nor is anyone else I've spoken to about it.

It came on the radio in work today and no one decided to talk about the dairy industry in general. It didn't spark off that discussion. It was all about how absolutely ridiculous the twats were, the waste, the cost of living, the privilege, the poor prior having to clean up the mess, the supply and demand of what they have done.

It has the opposite effect on what you and they think it will achieve.

nobodysdaughter · 16/10/2022 19:04

"I'd love them to try doing that in my local asda which is in a very rough area. They'd quite rightly get the shit kicked out of them. Which is why they do it in places like Waitrose"

No doing it your "rough area" or indeed down the coop in my working class area would get NO MEDIA attention at all.

Obviously in a shop in a more affluent location will.

The aim behind this protest almost certainly isn't, as many of you believe, to convert the general public to veganism overnight.

It is to highlight the cause and get people talking about alternatives. And the way to do that is some crazy stunt, in the most deliberately provocative manner possible.

Whether you think they have a point, or wish to force feed the protestors steaks ( I mean what the actual FUCK?) you can't we are talking about it.

RhubarbAndMustard · 16/10/2022 17:59

MolkosTeenageAngst · 16/10/2022 13:14

Protests like this don’t make sense, people who want to buy milk will still buy milk. Their protest just means a large amount of milk has gone to waste and even more will need to be purchased to meet demand.

A better course of action would be to buy plant-based milks and stand in the milk aisle giving them out for free as an alternative for the people who are there to buy milk. Thats more likely to change somebody’s habit than pouring milk everywhere, inconveniencing and alienating the people you want to convert.

100% this.

PBSam · 16/10/2022 17:53

Kellie45 · 16/10/2022 17:35

Oh for goodness sake cows have been milked for hundreds of years. Our ancestors did it and we do it. There is probably more caretaking of animals than ever there was

No there isn't 🤣

Suzi888 · 16/10/2022 17:46

@Kellie45 That’s a very uneducated comment. 🙄

Is this going to turn in to another vegan bashing thread .

donquixotedelamancha · 16/10/2022 17:45

Ha ha ha. How clever and witty and funny you are.

Thank you. Most kind :-)

HighlandPony · 16/10/2022 17:44

StatisticallyChallenged · 16/10/2022 13:20

I've found my people, clearly! I would also pay good money to see them try it...

Ha! Of course!

I’m back up in the north east now but I lived and worked on a riding yard as a teen near muirhouse (which will remain nameless because I’ve bitched about it in here but you’ll ken it) and drylaw westerhailes and west pilton we’re three places we’d only go in pairs at night

orangeisthenewpuce · 16/10/2022 17:36

MrsDThomas
Of course being a vegan is a choice. But by heck dont bang on about it.

i dont bang one about eating steak and drinking milk,

what I would love to do it stuff a raw beef burger down the throat of these dickheads whist super glued to a butchers shop.

Excellent idea

Kellie45 · 16/10/2022 17:35

Suzi888 · 16/10/2022 17:32

I’m vegan.

The dairy industry is cruel- however I don’t agree with wasting milk/ cheese that animals have suffered immensely to produce for human consumption, to just be thrown around and wasted.

I don’t they’re terrorists. Let’s not be overly dramatic… 🙄

Oh for goodness sake cows have been milked for hundreds of years. Our ancestors did it and we do it. There is probably more caretaking of animals than ever there was

Kellie45 · 16/10/2022 17:34

midsomermurderess · 16/10/2022 16:45

I work with a vegan. It was about the first thing she said about herself. I found that a little odd, to make an announcement about what you eat. If we were going for a meal, of course it’s relevant, but to insert it first and foremost?

For some of these people it is a cult which they adhere to and want everybody else to as well. It is a mark of their self righteousness and justification.

Suzi888 · 16/10/2022 17:32

I’m vegan.

The dairy industry is cruel- however I don’t agree with wasting milk/ cheese that animals have suffered immensely to produce for human consumption, to just be thrown around and wasted.

I don’t they’re terrorists. Let’s not be overly dramatic… 🙄

BigChesterDraws · 16/10/2022 17:25

What are they hoping to achieve? By ruining all the milk, the stores will have to order more to replace it which will increase demand for dairy products. Surely that’s counter-productive?

MistressoftheDarkSide · 16/10/2022 17:20

I think these sorts of protests and activism do very little for the causes they are prompted by. It just makes me roll my eyes …..

Obviously there are dozens of environmental impacts from modern life and we’ve recognised that since the 60s. Some things have improved and some haven’t, mainly because growth and profit has eclipsed everything since the 80s.

TPTB are invested in lining their and their cronies pockets and bugger the populace in general and the disparity is escalating at an astonishing rate.

If you listen to the WEF and other think tanks there are lots of ideas about reducing consumption but very little in the way of explanation of how we should sustain ourselves in the current economic structure. It requires radical change from the top down and some ideas have more than a whiff of communist ideals about them.

Trouble is, humans are conditioned now to always strive for more, better, new and shiny - so even if they tried to level the playing field, corruption would occur and the greedy would make damn sure they didn’t lose out, no matter who suffers in the process.

I’m no expert but as far as I can see the problem with farming and animals etc is due to the industrialisation of it - we evolved with animals as part of our diet, and eliminating them at this stage requires other intensive farming options that deplete soil and cause a whole bunch of other problems. Unless you fancy lab grown meat and bugs which are being touted as good alternatives.

Everything is a big mess - for every apparent solution to a problem, up pop several new issues to address.

Back to these protests - interesting that someone mentions agents provocateurs earlier - ie paid actors. It’s been done before - you only have to look at the undercover cops scandal. The FBI in the US have set up those with alleged extremist views and given them the rope to hang themselves by providing weapons and then stopping an alleged terrorist plot. They have openly admitted it.

The instability in the world right now is unlike anything I’ve encountered in my 53 years and I’m definitely a keep calm and carry on type, but it’s getting more difficult to be optimistic as the media and our governments behave like school yard rivals and the bread and circuses theme is used to keep us all distracted and at each other’s throats.

No, I don’t have any answers and right now even voting seems like pissing in the wind.

I just try not to be part of the problem as much as possible - but apparently human existence is the whole problem so wtf are we supposed to do about that?

It is actually maddening in the true sense of the word.

PickAChew · 16/10/2022 17:09

MrsDThomas · 16/10/2022 16:34

Of course being a vegan is a choice. But by heck dont bang on about it.

i dont bang one about eating steak and drinking milk,

what I would love to do it stuff a raw beef burger down the throat of these dickheads whist super glued to a butchers shop.

That seems to be a rather unnecessarily violent inclination that you have.

orangeisthenewpuce · 16/10/2022 17:09

I'd love them to try doing that in my local asda which is in a very rough area. They'd quite rightly get the shit kicked out of them. Which is why they do it in places like Waitrose.

midsomermurderess · 16/10/2022 16:45

I work with a vegan. It was about the first thing she said about herself. I found that a little odd, to make an announcement about what you eat. If we were going for a meal, of course it’s relevant, but to insert it first and foremost?

MrsDThomas · 16/10/2022 16:34

Of course being a vegan is a choice. But by heck dont bang on about it.

i dont bang one about eating steak and drinking milk,

what I would love to do it stuff a raw beef burger down the throat of these dickheads whist super glued to a butchers shop.

nobodysdaughter · 16/10/2022 16:29

@Hobbesmanc lots of activists DO focus on those places, but it doesn't get nearly as much media attention.

That's what activism is designed to do, get the issue in the media. Even amongst the blistering anger on this thread, there's been discussion about dairy and its alternatives. (I doubt it's dramatically changed anyones position on dairy though)

In a load of long winded planning meetings, it was probably even discussed how much people would hate the waste of the milk and argue about on social media!

Kanaloa · 16/10/2022 15:48

donquixotedelamancha · 16/10/2022 13:07

If anything a better protest (imo) would be something like what Jaden Smith does. He has a vegan food truck which provides free food to the homeless/those unable to pay.

What a bastard. What did the poor homeless people do to him?

Ha ha ha. How clever and witty and funny you are.

Realistically it’s a much better way to promote a vegan lifestyle than pouring milk all over a shop.