Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you prefer to retire to the countryside or city centre?

218 replies

Faciadipasta · 15/10/2022 16:02

Inspired by another thread on here I'm just curious to see people's thoughts. I'm not due to retire for another 20 years or so but really hadn't considered doing so in the centre of London (or maybe another big city) but now after the other thread I'm thinking what a bloody brilliant idea!
I'd always just thought people tend to retire to the seaside or countryside before. So what do others think? City or countryside? And why?

OP posts:
Furries · 16/10/2022 03:41

Countryside for me. Can’t see me ever wanting to move back to a city. Not sure how that makes me selfish (according to one poster).

Added bonus of this nearby - can’t ever imagine swapping it for city life.

Would you prefer to retire to the countryside or city centre?
stuffnthings · 16/10/2022 01:06

Currently in the countryside and will remain so to be honest, I've always loved it, but I will be putting things in place to make sure I'm supported as much as poss, if and when I do retire. It's fab around here and can't imagine being anywhere else!

I'm only mid 40's but my plan is to make sure to see my wonderful DC in to adulthood, give them as much support as I can. But to be quite honest, once that is done as much as possible and in the event of ill health, I do not want to be a burden and will happily shift of this mortal coil of my own choosing.

Scrowy · 16/10/2022 00:38

5foot5 · 16/10/2022 00:03

@Scrowy Care to elaborate?

Yep! Just look two posts above yours

But selfish= only thinking of their own happiness and wishes and not about the impact a high influx of wealthy elderly retirees with no local family connections has on rua areas

Idiots = people completly clueless about the realities and limitations of moving to a rural area to retire and no plan for how they intend to manage with no car and no care.

Newcatbrowntail · 16/10/2022 00:18

Centre of a small functioning town with decent facilities like a pool and theatre and with a railway station would suit me,

2twotired · 16/10/2022 00:09

A small town or city at a push, I live in the countryside and as others have said its not the place to retire. I live in a rural area of the Highlands, its beautiful and lovely but it's not a great place for retirement, limited healthcare or traveling a long way to get it, no public transport amongst other things.

5foot5 · 16/10/2022 00:03

Scrowy · 15/10/2022 16:28

People who retire to the countryside are selfish idiots

@Scrowy Care to elaborate?

Kite22 · 15/10/2022 23:16

Sounds perfect @PuzzledObserver Smile

Scrowy · 15/10/2022 20:47

PylaSheight · 15/10/2022 20:15

Retiring to the country is a really bad idea, much as it seems idylic. In my job, pretty much every day I have to try and help patients who can't get to medical appointments because they no longer drive and the public transport is woefully inadequate. Or they are lonely and there are no social activities for them locally, and they can't get to the nearest place 5 miles away because of transport issues. Support services are few and far between, etc. You get the picture.

I've lived in the countryside and loved it, but it's no place for the elderly unless they have very supportive family, preferably who they live with. Retiring to a city or to the edge of a large town is much more sensible.

The rural areas also have to pick up the tab for the elderly retirees moving to their area, often pricing out local young families in the process.

even if they are wealthy and can pay for their own social care they don't pay towards the increased pressure on GP surgeries, district nursing teams, ambulances, occupational therapy services and hospitals. All of which are underfunded in rural areas because of the low density of the population, but that population is increasingly made up of older people.

there's no buses or taxis so as soon as you stop driving you are reliant on NHS transport or the over stretched GPs doing house calls. Delivery services are patchy at the best of times and in winter people can't get in or out to you easily if it snows. So it often requires mountain rescue to drop in.

in many areas over a certain age you don't even have to contribute fully to council tax.

once you lose access to a car you lose access to a social life in the country.

and the younger locals who are still there will do everything in their power to help out in these situations but it's a bit galling when the local village school has closed because most of the young families can live there any more due to wealthy city retirees taking up the housing.

user1497787065 · 15/10/2022 20:39

I live rurally. No amenities, no public transport. I think I would like to live in a town and be able to walk to buy a pint of milk etc but I'm not sure. I can't imagine traffic noise, people walking pst etc

Very tricky as I wouldn't want o love house and hate it.

shinynewapple22 · 15/10/2022 20:31

My ideal would be somewhere by the sea in a community large enough to have decent health services (GP, dentist, pharmacy) and a general store and pub in walking distance. With a cinema, leisure centre and large supermarket/shopping centre within 5 miles. Oh - and decent public transport. And a takeaway which does home delivery .

However - unless DS also planned to move there I will stay here in the middle of the country where my family and friends are, and where I have all the things above. I will prioritise my finances so that I get to go to the coast as much as possible though.

I wouldn't want to live in either a city or the countryside. I don't like cities and I hate the idea of having to travel miles to access basic services, especially when public transport is likely to be poor. No good as you get older .

For context we are late 50s and have had these discussions .

kerstina · 15/10/2022 20:18

Coastal. Ideally lots of green space but too.

PylaSheight · 15/10/2022 20:15

Retiring to the country is a really bad idea, much as it seems idylic. In my job, pretty much every day I have to try and help patients who can't get to medical appointments because they no longer drive and the public transport is woefully inadequate. Or they are lonely and there are no social activities for them locally, and they can't get to the nearest place 5 miles away because of transport issues. Support services are few and far between, etc. You get the picture.

I've lived in the countryside and loved it, but it's no place for the elderly unless they have very supportive family, preferably who they live with. Retiring to a city or to the edge of a large town is much more sensible.

bengalcat · 15/10/2022 19:57

I’ll be staying in London

Darbs76 · 15/10/2022 19:57

My dream would be to retire in the centre of london. I can just imagine lazy afternoons in St James Park, Afternoon tea’s, Theatre Matinee’s. I can’t imagine retiring in the countryside. I grew up in a small town in North Wales and now live outskirts of london, and I absolutely prefer the city.

EngTech · 15/10/2022 19:55

I can’t afford to retire 😳😳

AnotherEmma · 15/10/2022 19:53

PS Definitely NOT London (or Manchester, or Birmingham) or countryside, either!

AnotherEmma · 15/10/2022 19:52

Small city or large town. By the sea would be great but not a dealbreaker.

I like the small city I live in now and could see myself living here forever tbh!

nutbrownhare15 · 15/10/2022 19:50

In my 50s (I can dream) or 60s (oh yeah, I can dream that one too!) the countryside while I'm mobile and active. In my 70s and beyond city centre

LynetteScavo · 15/10/2022 19:46

Not the country. And not the city, unless it was London or Paris, although ideally I'd want some private outdoor space.

DH and I can't think of anywhere where we'd rather live than our own house, which is a nice problem to have.

lannistunut · 15/10/2022 19:32

'Live in the country, live in the car' was our experience too - was one of our main reasons for moving back into the city.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 15/10/2022 19:23

I use to think I’d love to retire to the country - but that was before many visits to friends in rural N Devon. They needed the car for everything, even to anywhere they could walk the dogs off the lead. At least a 10 minute drive even for emergency milk or bog roll.
Nice for a visit, but no thanks.
I don’t think I’d want city centre either, though - certainly not our local one, which is London. Too crowded, too much traffic, too many fumes.
Where we are now suits us fine.

PuzzledObserver · 15/10/2022 19:21

I was brought up in, and have pretty much always lived in, the suburbs of a city/large town. We retired a year ago and have moved to the very edge of a small town - population under 10,000 - but 15 minutes drive from the centre of a small city.

We are within a few minutes’ walk of a moderate-sized Tescos and the doctors’ surgery, less than 10 minutes walk from the station and 20 minutes to the town centre. That has a vibrant High Street composed mainly of independent shops, including a real butchers, greengrocers, 2 bakers, 3 (yes, 3) bookshops, a hardware store, a card/gift shop, deli, wine merchant, optician. There are 3 dentists and numerous coffee shops. There is a local arts and cultural scene which provides plenty to keep us busy, and if we want more (cinema/theatre/big shops, hospital) as mentioned the city is only 15 minutes away.

If/when we have to give up driving, as mentioned it is not far to the station, and there is a bus stop at the end of our road. Yet from our window, we can see open countryside, and evenings and weekends it is pretty quiet. It’s not that noisy the rest of the time, to be fair.

Redqueenheart · 15/10/2022 19:21

Something in between: small town with decent access to a bigger city by public transport.

I don't drive so rural/village life is not for me although I lived in a small village as a child/teen.

But at the same time I am fed up with the noise, pollution, anti-social behaviour and stress of London so I am retiring somewhere much quieter by the sea this year but still commutable.

lannistunut · 15/10/2022 19:20

City centre for me, not London but somewhere decent sized. Cardiff might suit me?

hellcatspangle · 15/10/2022 19:18

Seaside village with a couple of decent pubs and a shop, but with easy access to a good sized market town or small city.