Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

. . . to withdraw from this "friendship"?

37 replies

SadAndConfused22 · 15/10/2022 15:09

I'm quite sad and upset just now. I've been close friends with two other women for about six years, and they've been friends longer, probably about ten years. We've been on weekends and family holidays together and supported each other through IVF and babies etc.

Things were great up until about four months ago. One of the women - Friend A - mentioned in the group chat that she and the other woman - Friend B - had met up for a coffee without me. I thought nothing of it, assumed they had things to chat about. Since that first time, they've had weekends away together and meet-ups that Friend A then mentions in the group chat afterwards, and each time I've felt a little excluded, but got a grip and told myself it didn't matter. When we do meet up, a big thing is made of how we're a threesome etc. and that reassures me.

I've just browsed Facebook and Friend A has put a photo on of her and Friend B drinking cocktails in town.

AIBU to feel a bit hurt and want to quietly withdraw from the friendship? It's clearly not the friendship I thought it was, and I have other lovely friends that I spend time with and enjoy their company. I'm just thinking that maybe I'm being subtly told that they don't really want me to be around them anymore?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Lucylock · 11/01/2023 05:26

I don't think A is as lovely as you think.

I would focus on other friends and step back from these two and see what happens. No need to speak to them (A knows what she is doing when she puts those messages on WhatsApp ) or cut them off completely. Friendships ebb and flow, this one may still be a friendship but in a different form.

I had a friend situation going on recently. Someone who I thought was a close friend who has been making less and less effort over several months, to the point that all contact was being initiated by me. It seemed that she was happy to chat via messages, but as soon as meeting up was mentioned the messages would be 'missed' or ignored. It was quite a change, i decided not to speak to her about it as I think in most cases no one will be truthful if you do that. I just thought that if I don't know what I may have done 'wrong'. then it can't be that big a reason. She was still going out with other people so I knew it was specific to me.

I knew I needed to move on as I would never have an answer. She obviously has her reasons, but also didn't seem bothered about the hurt she caused so clearly wasn't such a great friend.

I focussed on other friendships and working on my self esteem. I'm still friends with the person concerned , but she has a less important role in my life which is better. It's a way of taking back control in a situation you don't feel you have much say in..Funnily enough she instigates more contact now than before , which I am sure is because I stopped running about chasinf her!

hattie43 · 11/01/2023 05:18

They are mean and I would slip away . How on earth do they expect you to feel about this . What they are doing is very hurtful .

Catspyjamas17 · 11/01/2023 05:17

Perhaps in their way they are trying to make you feel included by mentioning it on the Whatsapp group, not realising it is having the opposite effect?

Nicecow · 11/01/2023 04:52

SadAndConfused22 · 16/10/2022 15:08

@BiscuitLover3678 maybe an occasional time, but recently there's been about three occasions where I've been available. And would have loved to join them, if I'd been asked.

The problem is, they're so NICE when we do meet up, I end up pushing the anxiety out of my mind.

Sorry, I've just read this and changed my mind. Don't worry about it OP, they obviously like you and just want to do things together sometimes too, and thats ok. It is dumb putting on the whatsapp though, but people can be dumb 🤷🏼‍♀️

Nicecow · 11/01/2023 04:50

I was friends in a threesome. Sometimes I did feel a bit miffed of they did something together, but then equally I would do something as a couple with each of them too. I think it's just adult friendships and sometimes it's nice to have 1:1 time too and theres nothing wrong with that. I think them mentioning it on your whatsapp group if its happening alot as it seems, is odd, I'd probably slowly withdraw, it all seems a bit childish

selfindulgentmoaner · 11/01/2023 03:58

I think you are being very generous about Friend A’s qualities.

Don’t bring it up with both of them. A is the problem- not B.

I’d gently broach the subject with B - ask if there’s a problem. If B is a good egg, then she’ll maybe twig that A is trying to manipulate things. If she and A are equally to blame for this situation, then you’ll soon find out.

I suspect that the reason they are both really nice to you when you meet is that Friend B likes you, and friend A is jealous. Friend A has to go along with the threesome because that’s what Friend B wants ( and she doesn’t want to look bitchy in front of her).

Cw112 · 16/10/2022 16:19

I don't think it's unreasonable to feel left out, it's a natural reaction however I wouldn't personally mind I would just get on with doing my own thing. I'd also consider how much effort I make, do I turn things down regularly, do I suggest meeting up as regularly as they do, is it easier for them to hang out last minute moreso than it would be for me. I would invest in other people as well so you don't feel like you need them so much and just enjoy when you do see them.

SadAndConfused22 · 16/10/2022 15:08

@BiscuitLover3678 maybe an occasional time, but recently there's been about three occasions where I've been available. And would have loved to join them, if I'd been asked.

The problem is, they're so NICE when we do meet up, I end up pushing the anxiety out of my mind.

OP posts:
hattie43 · 15/10/2022 19:44

That's hurtful of them . In your shoes I'd quietly withdraw , you have other friends so won't be lonely .
I don't get why people do this though it's obvious if you're a threesome not inviting one person to events is hurtful . How did they expect you to feel .

BiscuitLover3678 · 15/10/2022 19:43

Have you thought about meeting either of those two one on one also? Do they meet at times where you’re not available?

YankeeCat · 15/10/2022 19:40

If you think your friendship has any chance of being salvaged you are going to need to talk with them concerning how you are feeling. Although, the picture of how you painted A does not sound good. Just because someone may not be inherently a bad person does not mean that she values your friendship.

I thought I had good friend, and I still think our friendship was genuine at one time, but then it turned out that she was talking crap about me behind my back. It is a long story but the point is that really hurt me. At least with the "mean girls" you know they don't like you and will tell you to screw off, but a false friend or a friend who came to dislike you (but still wears a mask) is much worse. I still don't think she is a malicious person at heart but I keep my distance. We keep our distance.

If you don't want to talk with A you might want to at least speak with B.

Friendship is not supposed to make you feel miserable. If you want to walk away you don't have anything to justify and if neither are taking the time to want to reach out to you then you might have your answer on if it is for the best to walk away. But keep in mind that they are not mind readers and communication is important in any relationship you want to maintain.

RedHelenB · 15/10/2022 17:40

SadAndConfused22 · 15/10/2022 15:33

Yes, I do suggest meeting up; I've noticed that the last couple of times Friend A has cancelled at the last minute and we end up agreeing to rearrange.

Knock that on the head. Stick to the original plan and go with friend B still.

Prinnny · 15/10/2022 17:36

Hmm tricky because your still chatting and spending time together so your not excluded as such but I get it hurts. It’s hard when they have a long-standing friendship that predates yours, if you pull them up on it I imagine they’ll get all defensive and play it down.

If you want to continue the friendship id probably bring it up in a non confrontational way in person, such as ‘where was my invite last time’ etc and see what they have to say.

TestingTestingWonTooFree · 15/10/2022 17:01

I’m in a 3, sometimes 4, friendship group. I see them on their own, with one other, or all together. We’re busy, live apart and if we had to wait until all 4 of us were available, it would hardly ever happen. I’m also in another 3, where I have a regular arrangement with one of them (yoga weekly) and see the other on an ad hoc basis, with or without the other one. They see each other without me too.

Can you try and see just B? A sounds a bit mean.

WingsgivenbyRedBull · 15/10/2022 16:50

SadAndConfused22 · 15/10/2022 15:22

Thanks all . . . it's just so hurtful, I'm having flashbacks to the little cliques at school! And there's only so many times I can put in a brave face and tell myself it doesn't matter.

It also feels a little bit like Friend A is always really keen to tell me she spent time with Friend B without me - a few weekends ago she messaged me privately early in the morning out of the blue to say she had a hangover from being out with Friend B the night before. I thought it was a bit odd, like she was making a point of telling me . . .

I agree with you all - I'm just going to let the friendship slide. It's a shame because they are both lovely people, Friend B is an amazing human being, but I think a friendship should (on balance) make you feel happy and good, not sad and anxious!

Drop A and just hang out with B. It sounds like it might be A asking only B to do things.

Kissingfrogs25 · 15/10/2022 16:47

Threes rarely work in my experience, one is always left out. Clearly friend A is making damn sure it isn’t her.
That said they have been friends for longer.
So it’s complex.
Either way if you are feeling hurt and rejected regularly it’s probably not worth it op.
Are you closer to B? Maybe focus on a one to one friendship with her, but if she continues to cancel that is not a good sign either.

I would spend my time with friends that make me valued and enough op.

SadAndConfused22 · 15/10/2022 16:31

Hi @honeylulu - I think there might be a very watered-down version of that going on. I don't think Friend A is deliberately and consciously trying to engineer me out of the group. She really is a lovely person. But I do think that she can be a little possessive with B.

I don't want to play games or try to engineer anything or become closer to B - feels wrong. And exhausting. I'm too old for all that Grin

OP posts:
honeylulu · 15/10/2022 16:09

Sounds like A might feel she no longer wishes to share "her" friend B. Could she be worried that you and B were growing closer and was afraid she (A) might end up as the spare friend? So she's engineering ways to leave you out and making sure you know it.

I've experienced something similar though it was from a new friend who joined our group and wanted to monopolise two particular people and get rid of the other two of us. She took on a big organising role so that lots of events were at her house or started there and she'd "forget" to invite the unchosen ones or say to the others (untruthfully) that we'd indicated we couldn't come because of the baby/dog/work. It took a while for us all to work out what was going on. (She later left the group in a fit of pique after taking offence at something. Don't miss her one bit!)

Can you try investing in B and setting up some 121s.If B is still keen then you'll know the problem is A.

Ihaveamagicwand · 15/10/2022 15:51

I had this too. A three way friendship group which lasted years while I was useful for sharing lifts as one friend didn’t have a car. Then as soon as she got one, I was dropped more quickly than a hot cake.

It took me right back to the playground! But I made sure they looked like the immature ones not me. I tried to keep the moral high ground and be as polite and friendly as possible when necessary.

i know it hurts OP but chin up. Grey rock them and let them go. You’re worth more than the scraps they deign to throw for you. 💐

glasshole · 15/10/2022 15:50

I personality think friend A is the problem here. She is actively trying to make you feel bad by rubbing to tell you she is "suffering" due to the fun her and B had without you. She is also the most likely to cancel plans with the three of you and say to reschedule . I would reschedule, and if she cancels ask B to go ahead anyway. Three things could happen.

1-A suddenly managed to join you anyway.
2- You and B have a great time regardless
3- B says no so nobody goes out. Then you have a firmer idea of if the issue is mostly A, or if both A and B prefer each other's company.

I only say to do it this way as I've been in your shoes in the past. Turned out that my version of A was telling B that she didn't want to invite me due to me being so busy and having worries . The point being to make B believe that A was doing me a favour and knew there was a reason I couldn't go ( all bollocks). A wanted to look gracious in Bs eyes while cutting me out and trying to get closer to her. Me and B are still friends, we haven't seen or spoken to A for years. Once she knew the game was up she slowly faded out of our lives and moved onto another group to upset their dynamic.

TheHoover · 15/10/2022 15:43

YANBU.
Friend A may be a mean girl

SadAndConfused22 · 15/10/2022 15:41

@WrenNatsworthy no, definitely not mean or nasty. Both lovely people. Friend A can be a bit controlling and can sometimes be a bit passive-aggressive but overall she's a good person.

Totally fine with friends meeting up independently, it just feels like Friend A is very keen to make sure I know it happened and it feels a little odd.

I'm going to let it all roll off me; water off a ducks back.

OP posts:
IndianSummer78 · 15/10/2022 15:40

I'd drop out. Friend A doesn't appear to like you. Friend B likes you but you're second best, she won't go out if it's just the two of you, she'll cancel and wait until friend A can come too. But friend A is cancelling because you're coming, so the situation doesn't work.

Greyarea12 · 15/10/2022 15:38

Yeah I agree not to give them a reaction.

I also agree with you where friend A is trying to make it obvious to you that they are meeting up & not inviting you and therefore she seems quite nasty.

I would withdraw and concentrate on your other friends who don't make you feel shit.

WrenNatsworthy · 15/10/2022 15:37

It sounds like letting this friendship slide will make you unhappy.

I have a 'best friend' and even though we're in various friendship groups with other people sometimes we just want to see each other on our own. It doesn't mean we don't like the other people.

Enjoy their friendship for what it is, and your other friendships away from them. It doesn't sound like they are mean or nasty to you?