Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are people so adamant they can’t be wrong?

30 replies

Chatterbait · 15/10/2022 14:36

A couple of recent incidents have sparked this question, but I’ve noticed this a lot. People are genuinely baffled/horrified at the idea that they might be wrong about something; even when it’s a very simple mistake and not as if they’ve done something stupid/unacceptable. Examples:

At work the other day, I took a call on the general enquiries line. “Good afternoon, [company name]”, I say.

Caller (sounding confused): “What? Is that the John Lewis bed department?”
Me: “Sorry, you’ve got the wrong number”.
Her: “Are you sure?”
Me (wondering how she thinks I wouldn’t have noticed being surrounded by beds): “Yes, this is a printing company”.
Her (huffily): “Well that’s the number they gave me”.
Me: “Well then I’m afraid they either gave you the wrong number or you misdialled”.

She makes a humphing noise and hangs up.

Then last night I was out and went to get my things from the cloakroom as I was leaving. It’s one of those where they give you a raffle ticket for your hanger. I hand over my ticket, noticing it’s ticket 966. Attendant brings out a bag and coat that aren’t mine.

Me: “Sorry, that’s not my stuff”.
Him: “That’s what I’ve got for this number”.
Me: “Well, that isn’t mine. Maybe you’ve got it upside down”.
Him (looking again): “966?”
Me: “That’s right”.
Him: “Well that’s what I’ve got for 966”.
Me: “Well, maybe it is… but that doesn’t change that this isn’t my stuff. Can you check again please?”

He rolls his eyes and stomps off. Reappears with my things (hey presto) and says “This it?” I say “Yes, thank you”. He stomps off again without a word.

What is wrong with people like this? How can they be so convinced they are right that they will believe literally any other explanation than “Whoops, my mistake?” Wrong number woman thought it was more plausible that I can’t tell the difference between a print house and a bed department than the possibility that she pressed the wrong button. Cloakroom man thought, rather than him having had a ticket the wrong way up, I had either forgotten what my own bag and coat looked like, or simply fancied swapping it for whatever ticket holder 699 might have had.

If I dialled the wrong number, I’d simply say “Sorry, wrong number” and then try again. If I’d brought out the the wrong things, I’d have said “Let me check again” and apologised when I realised my mistake. That’s normal, right?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TimBoothseyes · 15/10/2022 19:10

ElevenOG · 15/10/2022 18:23

Ha I've had this too! My old house had the number listed for Zizzi's which had closed down years ago. I just gave up disagreeing with people in the end and would say "yep that's all booked for 7:30pm for you." I'd love to know how many people turn up for date night outside the WHSmiths that replaced it.

I did that once when a rather "irate" woman insisted I was wrong and she would be speaking to my manager and I'd never work in hospitality again once she'd finished. I mumbled an apology and "booked" her party of 8 in. Would have loved to have been a fly on the wall when she turned up especially as I'd given her a fake name and nobody working there was called that. Unless of course there was, in which case sorry VeraLynn.

ElevenOG · 15/10/2022 18:23

TimBoothseyes · 15/10/2022 15:44

I used to get that.
My old phone number was 1 number different to the pub/restaurant's just down the road. A typical call would go something like:

"hello is that xxxx?"
Me."No you have the wrong number"
"I'd like to book a table please"
Me " You have the wrong number this isn't xxx"
" Look can I book a table or not?"
Me "Once again this is not xxx, please hang up and dial xxxxx number"
"Yeah that's the number I dialled, can you do a table for x amount next saturday 7.30pm?"
It was usually at that point I hung up.

I no longer have that number.

Ha I've had this too! My old house had the number listed for Zizzi's which had closed down years ago. I just gave up disagreeing with people in the end and would say "yep that's all booked for 7:30pm for you." I'd love to know how many people turn up for date night outside the WHSmiths that replaced it.

ElevenOG · 15/10/2022 18:19

Every time I've called the council to apply for a wheelie bin I've been told repeatedly that no one by my name lives here, despite having lived here for 5 years. When I enquired if DP's name was registered here (bearing in mind we own the house) I was told that he's registered with the council but at an address on the other side of town. The woman on the phone literally told me that I can't possibly live here because her computer says so. I still don't have that fucking bin.

FlyingSquid · 15/10/2022 17:51

I had a very earnest teenage helper at an activity tell me that my daughter was 'over there with her sisters'.

When I said no, she did look a bit like them but she didn't have any sisters, Earnest Teen told me I was wrong.

Clearly my mistake. I am a bit forgetful that way.

aluminiumwaterbottle · 15/10/2022 17:18

I’ve just thought of another one, 2 incidents like this in one day. Was in the queue to check in at America’s busiest airport for a flight back to England, it was Christmas season and heaving, everybody was worried about missing their flights and the atmosphere was horrid. There were 2 flights to Heathrow a couple of hours apart, one going with American Airlines and one going with British Airways (my flight). It was clearly signposted that this was the BA queue, not the AA one.

After queing for hours, the man in front of me finally gets to the check-in desk. They can’t find him on the system. They ask to see his online reservation, and it is with American Airlines. They politely tell him he needs to check-in with them and he yells at them about how it’s terrible service by British Airways. And complains that he’s had to queue for 3 hours for nothing. The woman at the desk tries to get him to understand that she physically cannot check him in, as his flight is with a different company. He was holding everybody up screaming in the poor woman’s face and holiding everybody up, and we were already cutting it fine for the flight. Others in the queue started to shout at him, and he had to be escorted away by security.

Eventually it gets to boarding. A woman goes up to boarding desk and asks to upgrade to first class. They tell her there’s no space in first class, and she tantrums like a child that they HAVE to put her in first class and that there’s no possible way she’s flying economy all the way to London. She was a proper piece of work, and caused the flight to be delayed. She seemed to think the lack of space in first class was a personal thing against her. In the end, I believe she was moved onto the next flight that had a first class seat, but that was after much demanding they found her a seat on our flight.

It put me off flying for years.

Cruisebabe1 · 15/10/2022 16:07

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 15/10/2022 15:11

Is it that people lack self confidence? So if they admit they have made a mistake, it will somehow mean that they are utterly worthless, idiotic etc etc. I used to think that this was a very masculine trait ( apologising for sexism🫢) but I have noticed it increasing amongst women, too.

anyway here’s my contribution

me answering phone ‘01xxx xxxxxx’
old bloke ‘ I want to speak to Freddie’
me’ I’m afraid you have the wrong number
old bloke ‘ I tell you, I want to speak to Freddie’
me ‘ there is no Freddie here this ( repeats number)
short pause
’well, bugger off then’

‘I want to speak to Freddie’ is a shorthand for baffling or ridiculously unreasonable behaviour in our house now.

😂😂😂😂😂

ShahRukhKhan · 15/10/2022 15:44

@aluminiumwaterbottle I would get this working in university admissions. They would ring us and if we couldn't offer a space they would ask about the totally different X university down the road, and be baffled when I couldn't tell them if X uni had any places.

We also had one woman at an open day FURIOUS that none of the events on the timetable had been in the stated places and times. Total waste of her time! Etc etc. We pointed out that the timetable was actually for X uni down the road,not us. She'd either turned up at the wrong open day or printed the wrong timetable. She was still really angry with us, somehow!

TimBoothseyes · 15/10/2022 15:44

I used to get that.
My old phone number was 1 number different to the pub/restaurant's just down the road. A typical call would go something like:

"hello is that xxxx?"
Me."No you have the wrong number"
"I'd like to book a table please"
Me " You have the wrong number this isn't xxx"
" Look can I book a table or not?"
Me "Once again this is not xxx, please hang up and dial xxxxx number"
"Yeah that's the number I dialled, can you do a table for x amount next saturday 7.30pm?"
It was usually at that point I hung up.

I no longer have that number.

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 15/10/2022 15:40

One charmer got angry that I couldn’t book him a room at a hotel I had absolutely no affiliation with.

This reminds me of working for an online retailer many years ago, when someone got in a complete strop with me because I told him we wouldn’t refund a faulty item he’d bought from a completely different retailer. “But you stock it! I’ve seen it on your website!” Yes - and if you’d bought it from our website, we could help. Taking back other retailers’ faulty stock? Yeah, dream on.

newtb · 15/10/2022 15:34

I kept getting a lot of calls about electrical jobs on my mobile. I'm an accountant so not much use me trying to rewire someone's kitchen.
Eventually I found out that Coventry yellow pages had printed my number instead of the one submitted.
All I could think was how grateful I was that it wasn't on a business card in a phone box.
Was about 20 years ago, and got a few hundred in compensation.

AnnaTheMouse · 15/10/2022 15:31

I had someone from my current GP practice call me one day with a total, triumphant "gotcha" tone, as they'd noticed I was registered at a different address when I gave birth the year before. Silly woman thought I'd lied to register at the practice. I didn't say it, but wish I had, but my previous gp at my last address was so, so much better. If I was going to lie it would not have been to get a place at my dreadful GP

crowsfeet57 · 15/10/2022 15:30

The entire contact centre where I work is wfh. The company have closed the offices. One of our customers will not accept what I have told her and insists she will keep calling until she gets somebody working from the office who will know what they're talking about (as I don't.)

She has called hundreds of times and everyone tells her they are wfh, even when we try to explain that the very few staff who are still working from an office don't answer the phone, she still ends the call and rings straight back asking whoever answers the phone if they are in the office.

Redcrayons · 15/10/2022 15:26

JadeSeahorse · 15/10/2022 14:59

You'd have to go a long way to find anyone worse than the NHS for refusing to admit when they are wrong.🤬

I have DTs and somehow they were registered at different addresses at the GP. (Ie I live in James street, they has DT2 living in John Street)
I went in to get it corrected and had a whole conversation where they tried to make it my fault.
am I sure? Yes I know where my newborn children live
Did you register them at two different addresses - no, why would I
Have you moved? No and why would I just update one address
Do they live with their dad? yes in my house where we all live
Who lives in the other address? No idea, don’t even know where it is

And of course I didn’t have this conversation once, because, you know the system didn’t update/we didn’t change it on some other system/who the fuck knows what else.

aluminiumwaterbottle · 15/10/2022 15:19

When I worked in a very busy hotel in a tourist hotspot I’d get several phone calld asking if we had a room available for the night. Often we’d be sold out, or the person would recoil and change their minds after I quoted them the price.

Often, they would then ask for other hotel recommendations. I didn’t mind that. But sometimes they’d asking if these hotels had rooms available, or ask for a price quote. I could not provide answers to their questions, as I literally didn’t know. One charmer got angry that I couldn’t book him a room at a hotel I had absolutely no affiliation with.

Vulpine · 15/10/2022 15:17

Kellie45, I'm assuming you're right about it then

AnnaTheMouse · 15/10/2022 15:15

Yes, I used to get the same thing when I worked in the HR department of a local council. They were always convinced we were car insurance or breakdown cover. I think the area code was very similar to another area code, so they got it mixed up and then did act as if I'd lost my mind or was telling them lies when I explained 😄

I think when you dial a number in particular it can be weird when the 'wrong' person answers.

Cloak room guy sounds charming.

KittiesInsane · 15/10/2022 15:14

I had a call from the benefits agency asking to speak to Jake Widdington or something similar.

Said politely that nobody of that name lived here.
’Well, can you tell him that he needs to log into his portal urgently?’
No, I can’t, because I’ve no idea who he is.

Person on the other end repeated that it was urgent and was really quite grumpy at me for being so unhelpful.

Sorry Jake.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 15/10/2022 15:11

Is it that people lack self confidence? So if they admit they have made a mistake, it will somehow mean that they are utterly worthless, idiotic etc etc. I used to think that this was a very masculine trait ( apologising for sexism🫢) but I have noticed it increasing amongst women, too.

anyway here’s my contribution

me answering phone ‘01xxx xxxxxx’
old bloke ‘ I want to speak to Freddie’
me’ I’m afraid you have the wrong number
old bloke ‘ I tell you, I want to speak to Freddie’
me ‘ there is no Freddie here this ( repeats number)
short pause
’well, bugger off then’

‘I want to speak to Freddie’ is a shorthand for baffling or ridiculously unreasonable behaviour in our house now.

NumptiesIncorporated · 15/10/2022 15:11

My worst experience was

'hi, can I speak to your dad please?' (note: I was 38 at the time).

'no, he's dead'.

'hahahaha, very funny. Can you get him for me?'

'no, he's dead. He died two months ago'.

'now now, you've had your fun. I need to speak to him'

'well when you do, tell him I miss him'. Then I hung up.

Chatterbait · 15/10/2022 15:10

I get a shitty text saying how evil I was for not getting xyz and he’d be complaining about me (to who?I answered my own phone!)

This is brilliant 😆

OP posts:
TheWolves · 15/10/2022 15:08

It's not unusual with customers. You tend to get three groups of people. 1. People who realise they've made a mistake and admit it 2. People who immediately hang up and 3. People who double down on it and try to convince themselves and you that they are still right.

JadeSeahorse · 15/10/2022 15:06

@Subriquet and fgs don't dare complain for being messed around.

Instead of apologising to you - as any half decent person/organisation would - they will accuse YOU of being offensive/abusive.🤬

TheWolves · 15/10/2022 15:06

I've had someone get epically angry that they called the wrong company.

After about ten minutes of being screamed at, I said ok give me your reference number then, loudly typed it in and said wow what do you know, it didn't come up.

Soubriquet · 15/10/2022 15:03

JadeSeahorse · 15/10/2022 14:59

You'd have to go a long way to find anyone worse than the NHS for refusing to admit when they are wrong.🤬

Oh god the nhs.

I got given a number to ring. Wrong number. They transferred me to the “right” department. Nope. Still wrong place. Got transferred again anyway half an hour later of being transferred to various different departments, guess where I ended up? That’s right, the number I initially rang.

I hung up after that.

Kellie45 · 15/10/2022 15:01

You only have to look at these eco-warriors to see how people think they are always in the right no matter what inconvenience they cause other people