Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect people to stop their dog jumping up at me?

228 replies

NevertooearlyforGin · 15/10/2022 14:19

I enjoy walking at our local beauty spot which is a very large forest and heath area, it’s very popular with dog walkers. The problem is I really don’t like large dogs running up to me and jumping up at me which seems to happen most times I go, usually the dog owner is some distance behind so they can’t see their dog jumping up at me.

This happened again today, and a large dog and two smaller ones ran up to me and jumped up, the big ones paws reached my armpits. For context I was attacked by an Alsatian at the age of 9 in our local park, I don’t assume all dogs are aggressive but I am nervous around large dogs.

Today I plucked up the courage to say something to the owner, I asked him to stop his dog jumping up at me because I am scared of large dogs. He was very arrogant and laughed at me and said then I’d ‘come to the wrong place.’ As if the countryside exists for dog owners and nobody else and I was being ridiculous expecting him to control his pets.

The area is managed through grazing by the local forestry commission (usually hardy breeds of ponies, sheep and cows), there are frequent incidents of animals being worried and often mauled by dogs, I’ve seen this happen and there are signs saying that animals that don’t have a string recall should be kept on leads.

AIBU?

OP posts:
FromWalesAndBackAgain · 17/10/2022 11:43

@Piglet89 oh there definitely would be - there are definitely bad dog owners out there - and there are dangerous dogs - I don’t deny this. I just get frustrated by the generalisation and inflammatory comments (not saying yours is inflammatory- it is not, but there are many on here) - it dilutes the actual point. For example, if you made your comment as an OP there would be 20 people who agreed with you (prob both those who owned a dog and those who didn’t) and one comment where someone didn’t agree with you, and that one comment would give credence to many posts bashing all dogs and dog owners - which then alienates most dog owners even though they’d have agreed with your original post.

Piglet89 · 17/10/2022 11:35

@FromWalesAndBackAgain fair enough; my complaint about a dog was not about it jumping up, which was the question in the OP.

As an aside, is interesting that, had I posted as an OP about my issue, there would be at least one dog owner (@GloriousGlory in this case) who would disagree with my approach and be on the dog/dog owner’s “side”. I think it’s insidious attitudes like this that pit dog owners against people who don’t, TBH.

FromWalesAndBackAgain · 17/10/2022 11:30

@Piglet89 Ah I see. I agree with you in that it is not okay for someone to leave their dog barking in the yard, it’s not fair on the dog or the neighbours - and the resolution should not be on you to buy noise cancelling headphones.

However, I think the majority of dog owners on this forum have actually said I own a dog and think jumping up/not controlling your dog is unacceptable. I think this kind of comment reflects why some dog owners feel frustrated by this post, one bad experience with a dog/dog owner does not reflect all dogs and dog owners. I know many on here would say it is not one bad experience, however, I don’t even own a dog, I do have a small child, we often go walking in a massive public park and a nature reserve right by our house, we see multiple dog walkers every day and have never had an issue. Maybe we are lucky and I’m sure some areas are worse than others but I do feel like some comments on here have been massively blown up in terms of how it impacts their day to day life (more so than any comments condoning any bad behaviour from dogs/dog owners). I think if people had responded going “yes it’s unacceptable for a dog to jump up on strangers, and yes dog owners should ensure they have good recall before letting their dogs off the lead in public places” no one, or most reasonable people and the majority of dog owners, would agree with this. However it moved to inflammatory comments against all dogs and dog owners, and frankly - it’s boring and stops any dog owner taking these comments seriously as they just feel attacked.

Wow, essay over 😅

Piglet89 · 17/10/2022 11:25

@GloriousGlory your insistent focus on a small point in my post, in which I mused whether it had been left at home (but going to knock in the hope it had not, so that I might get the owner to control his animal to stop it disturbing others) kind of typifies the dog apologist attitude. As does that owner’s response - he obviously didn’t give a fuck either about how distressed his dog was or how much noise it was making. Never apologise, never explain, eh?

The world does not revolve around people’s dogs - despite what many owners seem to think.

Givenuptotally · 17/10/2022 11:21

Mine jumps up. He loves you even though he’s never met you. So I keep him on a lead when we’re out walking. I really don’t understand why dog owners can’t get this.

GloriousGlory · 17/10/2022 11:21

Piglet89 · 17/10/2022 11:05

Fair enough @FromWalesAndBackAgain - I’ll rephrase.

There are some serious dog apologists on the thread. Like @GloriousGlory , for example - my exchange with her about a different dog issue, where she suggested the solution to an inconsiderate neighbour causing nuisance noise by allowing their dog to bark for over an hour, disturbing everyone’s peace (and my concentration while I tried to work from home), was for me to buy noise cancelling headphones - not actually complain. Completely ridiculous.

Almost as ridiculous as knocking on a door when the dogs barking and you think it's alone 😂!

Did you think it would answer and apologise?

The world does not revolve around you working from home.

Goldbar · 17/10/2022 11:16

There should be fines for allowing your dog essentially to assault other people. If I pushed over a 3 year old, for instance, that would be an assault. Why is it OK for a dog to be allowed to do this? Dogs jumping up at people isn't just unpleasant, they can cause scratches, falls and other injuries.

serenghetti2011 · 17/10/2022 11:11

Thing is the people who wouldn’t allow this are not the problem and people who allow their dogs to run wild leaping all over people just don’t care what you think or feel op sadly it then reflects on dog owners who do take responsibility, train their dogs etc. I have a bouncy retriever, who absolutely would jump all over someone, however he is always on lead in public places.

he gets lovely long walks in the countryside and free runs on private dog field’s whilst we train his recall and sort out the jumping up. They have to learn but to learn you do have to exit the house, but that does not mean they can just be allowed to jump on someone. He’s a big dog, and could easily knock someone over. I get there are people who don’t like dogs and don’t want them near but that doesn’t mean my on lead controlled dog isn’t allowed out for a walk. Mind games are great we use them if it’s pouring down or just for fun but they don’t replace physical exercise and the right to be allowed to walk our dogs wherever we like. Blame inconsiderate dog owners don’t lump us all in together.

Yupbutnobut · 17/10/2022 11:08

YellowTreeHouse · 15/10/2022 14:25

YANBU but dog owners are entitled and rude and think everyone loves their mutt.

This

Piglet89 · 17/10/2022 11:05

Fair enough @FromWalesAndBackAgain - I’ll rephrase.

There are some serious dog apologists on the thread. Like @GloriousGlory , for example - my exchange with her about a different dog issue, where she suggested the solution to an inconsiderate neighbour causing nuisance noise by allowing their dog to bark for over an hour, disturbing everyone’s peace (and my concentration while I tried to work from home), was for me to buy noise cancelling headphones - not actually complain. Completely ridiculous.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 17/10/2022 11:04

Piglet89 · 17/10/2022 10:32

Quite a few entitled dog owners on this thread, aptly demonstrating exactly the very problem about which the rest of us are complaining.

We do not care how “friendly” your dog is: we do not want it to jump up on us. It’s an invasion of our space, often results in dirtied or damaged clothes and this desire is entirely reasonably!

Where are they then? Whose said it's ok for a dog to jump up someone? I must've missed that post

FromWalesAndBackAgain · 17/10/2022 11:02

Piglet89 · 17/10/2022 10:32

Quite a few entitled dog owners on this thread, aptly demonstrating exactly the very problem about which the rest of us are complaining.

We do not care how “friendly” your dog is: we do not want it to jump up on us. It’s an invasion of our space, often results in dirtied or damaged clothes and this desire is entirely reasonably!

I don’t think one dog owner has said it’s okay to have their dog jump up on you? From what I’ve read on this forum they have all said it’s not okay and they have trained their dog not to do this or put them on the lead when people approach? I’m really confused by your post

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 17/10/2022 10:46

threegoodthings · 17/10/2022 10:44

That's lovely. But just because your dog has never as much as looked in the direction of a human doesn't negate the fact that in general, dogs off lead are at best an irritation and at worst a danger. This thread isn't just about you and your dog

And I've said it is where exactly?

threegoodthings · 17/10/2022 10:44

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 17/10/2022 07:33

I am every so sorry. But if me and my dog are nowhere near anyone and all parties are minding their own business, it literally isn't my problem. He's not. We normally play ball. He goes on his lead on the way to the fields and back.

That's lovely. But just because your dog has never as much as looked in the direction of a human doesn't negate the fact that in general, dogs off lead are at best an irritation and at worst a danger. This thread isn't just about you and your dog

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 17/10/2022 10:38

ShouldIdo · 17/10/2022 10:34

Not all dogs have cocks, your answers are flawed.

Well, kick it in the tits then I dunno.

Would love to know what the right reaction is to make it get down immediately and not do it again.

ShouldIdo · 17/10/2022 10:34

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 16/10/2022 23:19

Dog People: If some great big twat of a dog jumps up at me and puts his sharp claws on my skin and covers me in mud, what should I actually do to make it fuck off ?

a) Kick it in the cock
b) Punch it on the nose
c) Hang it by the collar on a branch
d) Something else ?

Not all dogs have cocks, your answers are flawed.

Piglet89 · 17/10/2022 10:32

Quite a few entitled dog owners on this thread, aptly demonstrating exactly the very problem about which the rest of us are complaining.

We do not care how “friendly” your dog is: we do not want it to jump up on us. It’s an invasion of our space, often results in dirtied or damaged clothes and this desire is entirely reasonably!

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 17/10/2022 07:33

threegoodthings · 16/10/2022 23:29

If your dog is off lead then there's no way it will never have bothered anybody. It may not be jumping up and attacking people but its off lead presence will bother people. If it's just trotting along beside you then why not just have it on a lead? Because it's not trotting along beside you is it.

I am every so sorry. But if me and my dog are nowhere near anyone and all parties are minding their own business, it literally isn't my problem. He's not. We normally play ball. He goes on his lead on the way to the fields and back.

Anon778833 · 16/10/2022 23:30

YANBU. He’ll be laughing on the other side of his face if his dog bites someone!

threegoodthings · 16/10/2022 23:29

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 16/10/2022 21:33

Brilliant. So my dog, who has never ever bothered anyone in his life, who enjoys his walks needs to stop them and play some mind games at home instead? Why exactly? I don't understand why I am 'sodding' anyone. What have I done?

If your dog is off lead then there's no way it will never have bothered anybody. It may not be jumping up and attacking people but its off lead presence will bother people. If it's just trotting along beside you then why not just have it on a lead? Because it's not trotting along beside you is it.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 16/10/2022 23:19

Dog People: If some great big twat of a dog jumps up at me and puts his sharp claws on my skin and covers me in mud, what should I actually do to make it fuck off ?

a) Kick it in the cock
b) Punch it on the nose
c) Hang it by the collar on a branch
d) Something else ?

LightDrizzle · 16/10/2022 22:50

It’s a nightmare. A former recent dog owner and current dog lover here. Even before the lockdown explosion of first-time owners I reckon I was chased every run by at least one off-lead dog with an inattentive or arrogant owner with no control over it, on the urban waterside promenade where we lived. A promenade where people take their unsteady toddlers because there is no motorised vehicle access and the rest of the area is busy streets with lots of junctions and traffic.
My last dog had very poor recall, I got her at two years old with none and made little progress. She was soft as butter, short on brains and not a jumper, but she was a bulldog so looked scary to a lot of people and many dogs don’t react well to them and she might have trotted up to them. I walked her there every day and she was always on the lead. There was a grassy rectangle off the promenade at one point and I would let her off there for a run if no one was around
I have no problem myself with off-lead dogs with total recall or owners who slip the lead on when they see other dogs on lead approaching, toddlers, or small children on scooters or livestock. The numbers of hopeless owners is horrendous though and the aggression if they are politely asked to recall their dog! If you are lucky you get told they are friendly, if it’s a man, as it often seems to be, you’ve a high chance of getting told to fuck off.
People walking their dogs with their eyes glued to their phones don’t help either. So sad too, not interacting with their dog. I loved walked my, all very different, dogs and chatting to them, stopping for smells, playing games with them etc. enjoying the views.

If things don’t change we could go the way of Portugal where I live now. By law dogs must be on a lead in public areas and highways. In some public areas they may be off-lead if muzzled as long as they aren’t a breed categorised as Dangerous or Potentially Dangerous. Now this is so widely ignored that you would probably never guess it, more so in rural areas, particularly on roads and streets, but I’ve no doubt if it happened in the U.K. it would be much more strictly enforced, largely because of all the understandably irate elderly people, parents of small children and owners of reactive dogs or puppies in training who have been knocked flying, scratched and grazed or traumatised by out of control off-lead dogs. There will be photos taken on phones, Facebook appeals and reports to the police or dog warden.

Dogs with good manners and their well-mannered owners will suffer the loss of the chance to run and play off-lead because of lazy, fuckwit owners. My lovely Dalmation (penultimate dog) was a joy to behold doing great arcs to rejoin me along the rural river bank and neighbouring open grass l’d walk her to every evening. She had perfect recall. What a shame for her to be stuck on a lead outside her own garden.

I don’t see why some good dog owners get very defensive about these threads. Good dog owners and dog lovers have more to lose than non dog owners; surely very few haven’t experienced the very same problems that are being complained about. If they are lucky enough not to, do they really think everyone else is making it up?

Meili04 · 16/10/2022 22:21

YANBU I go for walks with patients behind a large MH trust I actually think it's trust property . For some reason people think it's acceptable to let dogs off lead, who then jump up. I've told lots of them to put their dogs on the lead if the dog ends up getting injured or the patient it would be horrendous. I don't know why people would be so brainless.

FromWalesAndBackAgain · 16/10/2022 22:16

Sorry my previous post was to @threegoodthings

FromWalesAndBackAgain · 16/10/2022 22:11

Can I ask how you are qualified to say dogs don’t need off the lead walks? Genuinely curious as to whether this is true.m, as it’s against everything I’ve seen before. Thanks

Swipe left for the next trending thread