Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - school related

139 replies

Flothecat · 15/10/2022 11:49

I've only got one DD, just turned 5, at Reception. She is a very compliant child, very social, had made a few friends since starting school, is a little bit more advanced with Phonics and maths compared with what they are doing at school and generally very happy.

However, she likes being her behaviour or her 'work' being recognised. It's something I've only recently realised. For instance they do 'star of the day' thing at school and she was one of the last to get it. There were kids with challenging behaviours (we know them from nursery) who got it much earlier (because they weren't so bad on that particular day) and DD was always coming home telling me why she is not getting it as she thinks she's always good.

When she finally got it, teachers told me it was very well deserved as she's always 'pretty starry', their exact words. It motivated her so much, she couldn't wait to go back to school.

Now I see other kids with all sorts of stickers, 'head of the day', 'great job' and so on, again some of the kids who are actually quite disruptive and challenging. DD told me this morning she thinks she's not good enough and that the teachers never notice her when she does something good. I'm not happy that she feels this way.

I had parents evening meeting 2 days ago and the teacher told me how wonderful, kind and well behaved she is, she ways has a positive attitude about all the activities they are doing and could not tell me anything negative. I asked her if there is anything we need to work on and she said keep doing what are you doing as it's working.

AIBU to ask how are other schools with kids that are consistently good? Do they get any recognition? I understand that the school needs to bring everyone up but I feel like in this class the disruptive kids get a lot more attention.

OP posts:
LetsPlayShadowlands · 15/10/2022 20:18

Same issue here. DD was upset saying school don't think she's good enough. I tried explaining its because they're used to her being good, but that's hard for a young child to understand. Luckily she then got it twice in a row! But I will mention it at parents evening.

BellaCiao1 · 15/10/2022 20:16

Lolapusht · 15/10/2022 20:11

@BellaCiao1 I didn’t say undermine the teacher, I said “it” ie the system. I don’t need to come with classroom management systems.

I always support school/teachers even when they do things I don’t agree with. When my 5 year old is in floods of tears because they haven’t been given SOTD again when they’ve done everything they were asked yes, I will undermine the reward system. When I’m struggling to get my DC to engage with school without giving up in Reception because they aren’t being rewarded then yes, I will undermine the system.

In our school where there are very few behavioural issues, these systems really are redundant. I have very well behaved children who have not been brought up without rewards/punishments, they just do what they’re meant to. For what it’s worth, different teachers in the same school use SOTD in a genuinely arbitrary way and I’ve had no tears/complaints from either my DC or anyone else’s about how unfair it is.

I’m genuinely interested to know how you think these systems help the majority of pupils ie not the ones who’s behaviour isn’t ideal. Do you think attendance awards encourage children to go to school?

I don't agree with star of the day/week, think it's a load of shite and serves more harm than good.

I've said up thread I do a house point system and everyone gets points on merit. I think what parents need to realise is that not all children can be treated equally, some have additional or different needs and by virtue they have to have special measures in place to achieve what other children do.

I only asked you for ideas as so many disagree with reward systems in schools and if anyone had ideas for an alternative to classroom management I'd be all ears.

Rinoachicken · 15/10/2022 20:15

Maybe read her ‘you are special’ by Max Lucado - it has religious undertones but doesn’t mention God or anything so can be read by anyone. It’s a childrens book with beautiful artwork.

“Every day the small wooden people called Wemmicks do the same thing: stick gold stars or grey dots on one another.”

The ‘good’ Wemmicks get gold stars, the ‘bad’ get grey dots. Then there is one wemmick who has neither, none stick to her, because she doesn’t need anyone else to tell her how good or bad she is, she already knows for herself.

I think it’s a lovely story to teach about striving for self-validation, rather than seeking validation/accepting judgement from others.

Lolapusht · 15/10/2022 20:11

@BellaCiao1 I didn’t say undermine the teacher, I said “it” ie the system. I don’t need to come with classroom management systems.

I always support school/teachers even when they do things I don’t agree with. When my 5 year old is in floods of tears because they haven’t been given SOTD again when they’ve done everything they were asked yes, I will undermine the reward system. When I’m struggling to get my DC to engage with school without giving up in Reception because they aren’t being rewarded then yes, I will undermine the system.

In our school where there are very few behavioural issues, these systems really are redundant. I have very well behaved children who have not been brought up without rewards/punishments, they just do what they’re meant to. For what it’s worth, different teachers in the same school use SOTD in a genuinely arbitrary way and I’ve had no tears/complaints from either my DC or anyone else’s about how unfair it is.

I’m genuinely interested to know how you think these systems help the majority of pupils ie not the ones who’s behaviour isn’t ideal. Do you think attendance awards encourage children to go to school?

Buttons294749 · 15/10/2022 19:29

I think the way DS' teacher does it is best, lots of stickers for all, everday. Everyone gets motivated.

I have 1 very "clever" child, i can see the buzz she gets when she e.g. knows she's read a tricky word. DS has additional needs and he needs to put SO much energy into things he really needs the motivation to climb the proverbial mountain.

I dont think anyone should be left out (doesnt seem like your DD was,?) And at this age dolling out lots of stickers daily is the way to go!

Chocolatedip · 15/10/2022 19:27

Child with ASC, excels in reading. Is always polite and this was constantly said to me. Unfortunately the only award they got in the whole time at junior (yr3-6) school was for punctuality. Yay(!)

BellaCiao1 · 15/10/2022 19:18

Lolapusht · 15/10/2022 19:11

It is utter bollocks and they’re far too young to get the complexities of applauding Little Johnny for not beating the crap out of a classmate. Undermine it at every opportunity, buy your own teacher stickers (check which ones the teacher has and get something similar) and give her stickers for giggling/skipping/doing the monkey bars/not burping in class etc.

When mine started reception there was star of the day, behaviour rainbow, kindness elves and a marble jar. They couldn’t consistently tell me how it all worked so there was no way it could possibly work to control behaviour. No 5 year old is going to think “Hang on…I’d better not climb on the chair because I’ll have to take a marble out of the jar which will mean the treat the entire class is expecting in 4 weeks time will be delayed”.

These systems punish the compliant majority and foster a “why bother?” attitude. What is the actual point of working hard if you don’t get the reward? The chance of getting the reward is dangled in front of them every day then it’s given to someone else and yes, “someone” has to get it but the negative impact it has on those who don’t get it far outweighs the benefit to the individual. They’re 5. They don’t give a crap about fostering resilience or sympathy or empathy, they want to be Star of the Day or to get a sticker!

You may have guessed that I don’t agree with extrinsic reward systems! OP, out of interest where did you go to school and what did they do instead? How was unwanted behaviour dealt with?

"Undermine the teacher at every opportunity"

That's helpful advice.

Out of curiosity, what strategies would you implement to help with classroom management? Genuinely interested.

Jalepenojello · 15/10/2022 19:18

I think you will be better off speaking with your daughter that she won’t be number 1 all the time. Celebrate her achievements at home. School here seems to give everyone a shot as every kid has something to be celebrated, even those that struggle with regulating their behaviour or aren’t as advanced. There’s always positives to be found.

BellaCiao1 · 15/10/2022 19:14

Dentistlakes · 15/10/2022 18:58

This happens all the time unfortunately. If you have a child who is generally well behaved and performs well with little
input from the teacher, they don’t tend to get recognition. It’s almost as if they think it’s their normal state and takes no effort. DS was overlooked for a key role in his last year of primary after never having put a foot wrong for 6 years. The child who was given the role had a history of bad behaviour and in the end made no effort at all. DS made his contribution in a very significant way regardless (of his own volition), but it was extremely disappointing for him.

Not being a teacher I do find it unfair on the children who go the extra mile, but i understand it’s about rewarding a
change in behaviour or effort. If your child is already producing the goods then there is little benefit to the teacher to reward them for it.

FWIW

For some children with needs, going an afternoon without disrupting the class is them going the extra mile.

Lolapusht · 15/10/2022 19:11

It is utter bollocks and they’re far too young to get the complexities of applauding Little Johnny for not beating the crap out of a classmate. Undermine it at every opportunity, buy your own teacher stickers (check which ones the teacher has and get something similar) and give her stickers for giggling/skipping/doing the monkey bars/not burping in class etc.

When mine started reception there was star of the day, behaviour rainbow, kindness elves and a marble jar. They couldn’t consistently tell me how it all worked so there was no way it could possibly work to control behaviour. No 5 year old is going to think “Hang on…I’d better not climb on the chair because I’ll have to take a marble out of the jar which will mean the treat the entire class is expecting in 4 weeks time will be delayed”.

These systems punish the compliant majority and foster a “why bother?” attitude. What is the actual point of working hard if you don’t get the reward? The chance of getting the reward is dangled in front of them every day then it’s given to someone else and yes, “someone” has to get it but the negative impact it has on those who don’t get it far outweighs the benefit to the individual. They’re 5. They don’t give a crap about fostering resilience or sympathy or empathy, they want to be Star of the Day or to get a sticker!

You may have guessed that I don’t agree with extrinsic reward systems! OP, out of interest where did you go to school and what did they do instead? How was unwanted behaviour dealt with?

donttellmehesalive · 15/10/2022 19:11

I expect your child feels proud when she reads a story, draws a lovely picture, listens to the teacher and straight away understands what she is being asked to do.

I expect her work has lots of ticks and 'well done' comments, and she is sometimes chosen to take a message or hand the books out. I expect she gets lots of smiles and 'good job' from the teacher.

Im a teacher and I'm on the fence about rewards. They can work but I'm not daft enough to think that every teacher uses them well. What I do know is that the best kids, the lovely easygoing ones, the ones who are a pleasure to teach and know, really don't care about them. I have had children say 'can you give my sticker to X please, I think he'd like it more.' I always think that attitude reflects so well on the parents too because they have modelled and taught what is important. Demonstrate to your child that she can feel proud and try hard without a pat on the head, and she'll believe you.

Cotswoldmama · 15/10/2022 19:08

All the kids I'm my son's class in reception and year one used to come out with at least a sticker each! I think they found all children worked better with praise and so multiple stickers were given out. Every child got at least one and others had more but I think it worked as noone felt left out and all children felt proud of their work.

Dentistlakes · 15/10/2022 18:58

This happens all the time unfortunately. If you have a child who is generally well behaved and performs well with little
input from the teacher, they don’t tend to get recognition. It’s almost as if they think it’s their normal state and takes no effort. DS was overlooked for a key role in his last year of primary after never having put a foot wrong for 6 years. The child who was given the role had a history of bad behaviour and in the end made no effort at all. DS made his contribution in a very significant way regardless (of his own volition), but it was extremely disappointing for him.

Not being a teacher I do find it unfair on the children who go the extra mile, but i understand it’s about rewarding a
change in behaviour or effort. If your child is already producing the goods then there is little benefit to the teacher to reward them for it.

autienotnaughty · 15/10/2022 18:57

The children who are behind developmentally , have Sen or issues at home need more support/scaffold to get them to where they need to be. Whereas your child is already attaining. I'd work on your child's confidence to recognise her success for her self without needing outside praise. The other option would be private school with lower ratios your child would receive more attention or of course home schooling.

BellaCiao1 · 15/10/2022 18:44

lizziesiddal79 · 15/10/2022 18:04

Yep, my DD (Y2) was upset she never got to go ‘over the rainbow’ like the more challenging children (most of the class). I raised it at parents’ evening. The teacher apologised, said she didn’t realise my well-behaved DD ‘needed motivating’.

DD subsequently ‘went over’ twice the next week and finally got a prize 🙄

So you complained to the teacher that she never got 'over the rainbow', the teacher took what you said on board and acted accordingly and then you come on being sarcastic about it.

Teachers can never win.

lizziesiddal79 · 15/10/2022 18:04

Yep, my DD (Y2) was upset she never got to go ‘over the rainbow’ like the more challenging children (most of the class). I raised it at parents’ evening. The teacher apologised, said she didn’t realise my well-behaved DD ‘needed motivating’.

DD subsequently ‘went over’ twice the next week and finally got a prize 🙄

queenofthewild · 15/10/2022 17:40

This was DS too.

Now he's at secondary though he's finally able to shine. Good work is recognised for being good work. Children who work hard are rewarded with enrichment and extension activities.

DS found primary frustrating at times, but there were a lot of children at his school with additional needs or from difficult homes. We just kept encouraging him and letting him know we were proud of him at our end - something the children with the stars and stickers often didn't get.

lollipoprainbow · 15/10/2022 17:35

@Iknowforsure1 agreed, OP is very lucky. So many children struggle academically and socially my dd included, I really don't see what there is to get so het up about.

Iknowforsure1 · 15/10/2022 17:12

What are you unhappy about? Your daughter is doing well both socially and academically and the teacher recognises it. There are 30 children with different needs, yet you want a constant praise for your child. It’s impossible. I have a child like yours. I’m focusing on keeping him self motivated and to not rely to a permanent validation from outside.

Charmander6 · 15/10/2022 16:39

It's the way of school sadly. Ds6 is well behaved and always works hard, he's learned to be patient over star of the week because he is always one of the last to get it as he can be relied on to behave. He's even said that so and so got it because they were good for a whole day and the like and is quite relaxed about it. They have a system now where they get points for good things that they've done in school and he likes that better as you have to earn them instead of taking turns. It is really hard when they're little but they do work out the system fast.

Preg19 · 15/10/2022 16:04

BellaCiao1 · 15/10/2022 15:22

I do agree with this, however, how do people expect teachers to manage a class of 30 children with differing needs and behaviours?

This is before we teach the curriculum might I add.

i don’t expect teachers to have to adapt at all, I totally understand how this helps you with 30 odd children and wouldn’t expect you to change it at all. My point was what we can do at home for our children to help them. Please don’t think putting teachers down!

MeowMeowPowerRangers · 15/10/2022 15:51

My youngest school is the same. It's shit.

It's always the same kids getting rewarded even though they are pretty naughty kids. My son is really good, does his work happily and always get top marks yet no praise what so ever.

However when he does the tiniest thing wrong or naughty I get called into school immediately! 😤 no wonder he's playing up when he sees the same naughty kids constantly getting rewarded.

LuffleGro · 15/10/2022 15:48

It shouldn't be that way but unfortunately in a lot of schools, it is. To some extent, it can't be helped because those challenging children really do need that extra input to help them learn to behave better. There should be efforts made to make all the children feel recognised for their achievements though so it's not so obvious to them that the difficult children may be getting more. I do remember my DS aged 4 coming home and telling me he'd worked out that to be put on the gold cloud he needed to be naughty first and then good!

When I was TA in a class with a particularly challenging child that the other children perceived as being rewarded despite being bad, the teacher I thought explained it very well to them. She told them that some children need extra help with their maths, some need it for reading, some for writing or spelling and some children need extra help with their behaviour. Just as you wouldn't resent a child getting extra support in maths if they need it, you shouldn't resent a child getting extra support with their behaviour. The children understood and accepted that then.

The other thing to remember is that children don't behave badly in a vacuum. Behaviour is communication. They are behaving that way because they are struggling with something. It could be that they have a terrible home life, or it could be they have SEN (diagnosed or not), as a parent you just see the behaviour, and the staff will have a good understanding of why that behaviour is happening and why jumping on and rewarding any good thing they do is really important. If a child has a really difficult life already, repeatedly punishing them for behaviour they may not be able to help really isn't fair or helpful.

It's worth talking to your DD about it all, obviously in child-friendly terms, to help her understand why the teachers reward those children. It does sound like they could do more to reward the always-good children as well though.

courgettigreensadwater · 15/10/2022 15:33

Same. Two DS both now 14 and 17 and they were always excellent at school as people and academically. Always the awards were given to those that had behaved less badly. Always. Very frustrating.

zippygeorgebungle · 15/10/2022 15:31

This was DD too, she's head girl now so her time came. But in reception she once explained to me, rather perceptively, that star of the week was for the people who found it hard to be good but had managed it a bit better this week. She finally got it in the final week and the little certificate with it said she could have had it any week of the year and well done for being patient. It bothered DS more though when he started and it took him ages to be chosen. But I think it must be hard for teachers to find ways of motivating children with more challenges so I try remind myself it's a good problem to have.